Mark Mattingly 24003716TT.pdf

Mark W Mattingly, Petitioner V Township Of Grand Blanc, Respondent · 24-003716-TT

← View full record

Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.

Ey 

ns 

dal 

STATE OF MICHIGAN 

GRETCHEN WHITMER 

DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS 

MARLON i. BROWN, DPA 

GOVERNOR 

LANSING 

DIRECTOR 

MARK MATTINGLY 

, 

MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL 

Petitioner(s) 

v 

MTT Docket No. 24-003716-TT 

TOWNSHIP OF GRAND BLANC 

Respondent(s) 

PROOF OF SERVICE 

DULCEE RANTA 

states that on 12/12/2024 

he/she 

[Name of person serving/mailing petition] 

[date of service] 

served a copy of the RESPONDENT'S ANSWER relative to the above-captioned matter upon: 

[Provide name and address of the party/people being served] 

MARK MATTINGLY 

8476 WARWICK GROVES CT 

GRAND BLANC MI 48439 

Dey 

[IP gihe 

[Signature of person who is sefving/mailing copy] 

DULCEE RANTA 

[Print/type name of person serving/mailing copy]

P

Parcel Number: 

12-24-651-008 

Jurisdiction: 

GRAND BLANC TOWNSHIP 

County: 

GENESEE 

[Grantor 

Grantee 

| 

sale 

sale 

Inst. 

Terms 

of Sale 

Liber 

[ 

Price 

Date 

Type 

& Page 

[xaTTOULA, 

ADNAN 

MATTINGLY, 

MARK 

& EBRAHIM 

| 

300,000| 

08/12/2005 

|WD 

03-ARM'S 

LENGTH 

| 

| SERRA, 

JULIE 

KATTOULA, 

ADNAN 

| 

155,000| 

09/10/2002 

|WD 

03-ARM'S 

LENGTH 

| WARWICK GROVES DEVELOPMEN 

|SERRA, 

JOSEPH 

O 

& 

JULIE 

| 

90,000| 

01/16/1995 

[WD 

21-NOT USED/OTHER 

2563/108

| 

| 

| 

| 

| 

|Property Address 

Class: 

RESIDENTIAL-IMPRO |Zoning: 

R1 

Building 

Permit (s) 

Date 

| 

| 

| 

18476 WARWICK GROVES 

CT 

School: 

GRAND BLANC COMM SCHOOLS 

NEW HOUSE 

| 

06/13/20

| 

P.R.E. 

100% 01/06/2016 

| 

|Ownez's Name/Address 

A 

MATTINGLY, MARK 

& EBRAHIM, SHAYHANA 

[T2024 Bst TCV 1,556,496 TCV/TFA: 272.21 

8476 RARAICK, CROvEe or 

qd 

| 

[Vacant 

Tand Val 

timates 

ble 

SEMSD.2024 GG/

GRAND BLANC 

MI 

48439-7426 

| 

¥ [Improve 

[| 

| 

acan 

| 

Lani 

alue 

Estimy 

te 

for 

able 

SEMSD. 

G 

| 

Public 

| 

* Factors 

* 

| 

Improvements 

| Description 

Front 

Depth 

Rate 

[Tanpayer’s Name/Address 

TT Road 

| 2024 FRONT RE 

1.0000 0.0000 

773 

cravEl MBAd 

| 2024 PER ACRE 

: 

1.976 Acres 129,379 

MATTINGLY, 

MARK 

& EBRAHIM, 

SHAYHANA 

X 

|paved Road 

i 

that 

do not contribute 

to the to

fT Es Tie 

% 

|storm Sewer 

¢ Feet, 

1.98 Total Acres 

Total 

© 

B 

Sidewalk 

X 

|Water 

i 

{ 

%X 

Sewer 

r 

ert Cost Estimates 

omni) i 

3 rea 

big, concret 

10704 

[UNIT 

8 WARWICK GROVES CONDOMINIUM 

(95) 

X 

|Gas 

x 

ad 

: 

I 

Curb 

£k 

on Sand 

27.48 

|Comments/Influences 

| 

. 

|street Lights 

Total Estimated Land Improvements 

[6/10/16 REINSP-MR. 

MATTINGLY. 

SPOT MEAS. 

Standard Utilitie, 

|CORRECT WINDOW TYPE AND BED COUNT. 

ADD 

Underground Utils 

| 

Woy 

k Description 

for 

Permit 

PB140236, 

Issued 06/13

|paTIO BLOCKS, 

CPP, 

GENERATOR AND 

1 

FULL 

g 

| COMPLETE 

FOR 2016.MD 

BATH AS 

O/P 

FOR 2017. 

MD/TW 

. 

Topography 

of 

22-2014 

INSP,MEAS,30% COMPLETE 

FOR 2015.MD 

< 

Site 

i 

| 

Level 

X 

|Rolling 

Low 

High 

Land&aped 

| 

Swa 

Wood: 

Pond 

[ 

Waterf. 

Ravine 

Wetland 

— 

Flood Plain 

|Year 

Land 

Building 

Assessed 

X 

[WALKOUT 

| 

Value 

Value 

Value 

Who 

When 

What 

2024 

127,800 

650,400 

778,200 

TW 

06/10/2016 REINSP-HOM 

[2023 

52,500 

670,100 

722,600 

|The Equalizer. 

Copyright 

(c) 

1999 

- 2009.|MD 

12/28/2015 INSPECTED- 3522 

52,500 

612,600 

665,100 

|Licensed 

To: 

Township 

of Grand Blanc, 

MD 

09/22/2015 INSPECTED 

! 

|county of Genesee, 

Michigan 

|2021 

| 

52,500 

583,600 

636,100 

+%% 

Information herein deemed reliable 

but 

not guaranteed***

Residential Building 

1 

of 

1 

Parcel Number: 

12-24-651-008 

Pr

Building Type 

(3) 

Roof 

(cont.) 

(11) 

Heating/Cooling 

(15) 

Built-ins 

(15) 

Fireplaces 

(16) 

Por

X 

|Single Family 

X[Eavestrough 

X 

|Gas 

0il 

Elec. 

Appliance Allow. 

Interior 

1 Story 

|Area|Type

g! 

YP 

Mobile Home 

X|Insulation 

Wood 

Coal 

Steam 

Cook 

Top 

Interior 

2 

Story 

T6g/cop 

Town Home 

0|Front Overhang 

F 

3 SY 

75 

DuoE 

1 

|Dishwasher 

2nd/Same 

Stack 

24|cpp 

Duplex 

0|other Overhang 

eveed 

Lr 

w/o 

DUCtS 

| 

7 

garbage Disposal 

| 1 

[Two Sided 

Selopp 

A-Frame 

Sy Air w/ Ducts 

Bath Heater 

Exterior 

1 Story | gioil 

(4) 

Interior 

Sones 

Hot rakes 

Vent Fan 

Exterior 

2 Story 

one

X 

|Wood 

Frame 

E SE 

card 

Hot Tub 

Prefab 

1 Story 

X 

Drywall 

Plaster 

Elec. 

Ceil. ecient 

1 

|Unvented Hood 

2 

|Prefab 

2 Story 

Building Style: 

Paneled 

Wood T&G 

Rac ant fs cory 

Vented Hood 

1AND2 STY COMB 

: 

: 

io. Lal 

Re 

ea 

Intercom 

TEI 

Don, 

Space Heater 

Jacuzzi Tub 

Yr Built 

[Remodeled 

[= 

[¥[o=a 

[ 

[in 

Wall/Floor Furnace 

Jacuzzi repl.Tub 

2014 

0 

: 

X 

|Forced Heat 

& Cool 

oven 

Condition: 

Very 

Good Sizedoficlosets 

Heat 

Pump 

13 

Microwave 

[to [¥]o=d 

| 

[small 

No Heating/Cooling 

Standard Rangg 

Room List 

Doors| 

|Selid| 

[A.C 

centzal Air 

i 

TotafiBase New 

: 2,100,816 

sTEasenet 

ETT 

me 

Toa 

Depr Cost: 1,932,877 

9|1st Floor 

(12) 

Electric 

“U%&timated T.C.V: 

1,293,095 

52nd Floor 

Kircnen; 

Haz duood 

0famps Service 

Other: 

Carpete: 

5 

5|Bedzrooms 

Other: 

No./Qual. 

of Fixtures 

Bldg: 

1 

Single Family 

1AND2 S

(1) 

Exterior 

[Ex 

[X Joxd. 

[rin 

Ei 

: 

Forged Heat 

& Coo 

Wood/Shingle 

(6) 

Ceilings 

Gx: 

:= 

4010 

SF 

Floor Area 

= 

8 

SF. 

Aluminum/Vinyl 

No. 

of Elec. Outlets 

/Biac/Econ/Comb. 

$ Good=92/100/100/100/92

Brick 

X Drywall 

[Many [X [ave. 

[ 

[Few 

X |Brick/siding 

(13) 

Plumbing 

Exterior 

Foundation 

Size

lati 

Brick 

Basement 

1,102

AflEnsuiarion 

Average Fixturef#) 

B. 

k 

336

- 

= 

rs 

Shs 

ric. 

Basement 

(2) 

Windows 

(7) 

Excavation 

5 

3 Fixture 

Batl 

Brick 

Basement 

527

Many 

Large 

Basement: 

4010 

S.F. 

2 

|2 Fixture Bath 

Brick 

Basement 

337

X 

|Avg. 

X 

|Avg. 

Crawl: 

0 

S.F. 

Softener, 

Autg: 

Brick 

Basement 

- 

1,708

Few 

Small 

| Slab: 

0 

S.F. 

Softener 

Total:

+ 

Tieed Sash 

Height to Joists: 

0.0 

Solax 

Other Additions/Adjustments 

Metal 

Sash 

Basement Living Area 

3208

Vinyl Sash 

(8) 

Basement 

Basement, 

Outside Entrance, 

Below Grade 

Double Hung 

Conc. 

Block 

Plumbing 

Horiz. 

Slide 

10|Poured Conc. 

3 Fixture Bath 

x 

casement 

Stone 

2 Fixture Bath 

Double Glass 

Treated Wood 

Extra Sink 

Patio Doors 

X|Concrete Floor 

Separate Shower 

pe 

Porches 

Storms 

& Screens 

(9) 

Basement Finish 

GY) 

Water/Sewer 

cpp 

166

(3) 

Roof 

Recreation 

SF 

Public Free 

CPP 

3

Gable 

GambrelP208 

|Living 

SF 

irc Heoor 

cep 

2

X 

|Hip 

Mansard! 

2 

|Walkout Doors 

(B) 

Water Well 

Balcony 

Flat 

Shed 

No Floor 

SF 

1000 

Gal Septic 

Concrete Balcony 

506

i 

Walkout Doors 

(A) 

2000 

Gal 

neotic 

Garages 

X |Asphalt Shingle 

(10) 

Floor Support 

Pp 

Class: 

A Exterior: Brick Foundation: 

42 Inch 

(Fini

Tots: 

Lump Sum Items: 

Base Cost 

697

Chimney: 

hs 

Sted TERE 

Common Wall: 

1 Wall 

Fp FEs 

: 

<<<<< Calculations 

too long. 

See Valuation printou

*%* Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed***

“parcel Number: 

*%% 

Information herein 

deemed reliable 

but 

not guaranteed*** 

12-24-651-008, 

Generator 

5 

Sketch by Apex Sketch 

Residential Building 

1 

1s’ 

23% 

21 

20° 

ax 

a 

1-S/BSMT 

21" 

1102.0 SF 

13 

1° 

1 

14'| 

14' 

10 

10 

10" 

18 

18 

47 

Garage 

697.0 SF 

28° 

25 

3 

22 

11 

5 

7 

1-S/BSMT 

16' 

15 

21 

527.0 SF 

& 

iio 

oP 

13 

336. 

21’ | 21° 

20° 

14 

2014 

20° 

J 

2-S/BSMT 

5 E 2 

[B=1708.0) 3416.0 SF 

El 

16' 

(Base 1708 SF) 

Cu 

8 

LiLevel Walkout 

oo 

2 

—e 

eee 

| 

21 

10! 

13' 

1g 

1-SBSMT 

337.0 SF 

as’ 

ia) 

Garage 

29" 

25' 

697.0 SF 

Ee

199 

<="A3d ‘PIS 

[4374 

<=oney "ales 

002‘986°€$ 

000°TZ9'6$ 

000°TZ9'6$ 

 sierol 

00£'95T$ 

000T66$ 

 HLONITSWHYV-E0 

QM 0007T6€$ 

 12¢/0€/90 

10SA00MIOVTII

 00€°08T$ 

0006Zy$ ~~ HIONITSWHV-E0 

AM 000'S/¥$ 

 2e2/60/E0 

40 SAOOM 3OVT

008'v8Y$ 

000GZT‘T$ 

HIONITSWHV-E0 

QM 000°SZT‘T$ TC/ET/Z0 

1D SAOOMMOIMHEY

008°09T$ 

000°088$ 

~~ HLONITSIWYY-E0 

OM 000°08€§ 

22/80/60 

 THLSAOOMMNOIMH

008'88T$ 

000099 

 HLONITSIWYY-E0 

OM 000°099% 

22/8Z/T0 

 THLSAOOMMOIMUY

00T‘€70°T$ 

000009'2$ 

HLONITSWHY-E0 

QM 000°009$ Te/LL/TT 

~~ 

SMOQYAWAISI

00T‘S0v$ 

000'6/6$ 

 HIONITSWHV-E0 

QM 000°5/6$ 

 Te/6e/ZT 

SMOQVIWALSI

00T°zTES 

000°0T8¢ 

~~ HLONITSWYV-€0 

OM 000°0T8% 

 TZ/0E/¥0 

SMOQYIW ALS

006'86¢$ 

000°958¢ 

~~ HLONITSIWYV-E0 

OM 000°558% 

 22/L0/20 

TYLNIFHO HIIN

000°22e$ 

00000/$ 

 HIONITSWHY-E0 

QM 000°00L$ 

 Z2/9Z/L0 

LO AVMLI

000°662$ 

000009 

 HIONITSWHV-£0 

QM 000°009$ 

 T2/T0/0T 

QAT183L¥O NIA1

91es '[py/pSy 

 P10S Usym “psy 

$ 918s py 

9)eS JO swia] 

“nsuj 

9911d 91S 

21eQ 91ES 

SS2IppPY 192115

9M/HA/99 40 AW/AYMUIVA/99 ¥Z02 

asWas 

SNVH/E9 40 AW/AYMEIVA/99 7202 

aswas 

9NVHd/89 40 AW/AYMEIVA/99 7202 

aswas 

OM/HA/E9 40 AW/AYMHIY4/99 7202 

Tw 

aswas 

OM/HA/EO 40 AW/AVMHIVE/99 7202 

aswas 

S9MWHJ/E9 40 AW/AVMYIVH/99 20 

aswas 

Rt 

i 

ah 

te is 

OV UI 

Eo 

Os 

en 

Es 

= 

oo 

] 

OM/HA/89 

40 AW/AYMYIVA/99 7208 

oo 

 aswas 

OM/HA/89 40 QW/AYMYIVH/99 ¥202 

aswas 

9M/Hd/89 40 QW/AVMHIVA/99 7202 

aswas 

OM/Hd/G9 40 AW/AVMHIVA/D9 7202 

aswas 

$S90Jy 

 SONSHAIOBIBYD 81S 

9POD Asn 

a)qe] pueq 

9)eS UIS]92Jed 19Ul0 

B3ly 403

<="13d PIS 

<=oney ‘eles 

002°‘088‘€$ 

000°529'8$ 

000°629'8$ 

sje 

00T°Ev0'T$ 

000°009°C$ 

HIONT1SIWHV-€0 

QM 000°009C$ TZ/ZI/TT 

SMOQY3IW ALSI

001507 

000°G6$ 

HLIONITSWHY-€0 

OM 000°G/6$ 

 T2/6Z/ZT 

SMOQYIW ALSI

001°ZTE$ 

000°0T8% 

HLONT1SIWHYV-E0 

dM 000°0T8$ 

 T2/0S/¥0 

SMOQY3W ALSI

006°069% 

000°0SZT$ 

 HLONITSWHY 1304Vd ILTNW-6T 

dM 000°0SZ'T$ €2/02/T0 

103340 37AQY

006°868$ 

000'ss8$ 

HIONITSWHY-E0 

OM 000°GS8$ 

 22/L0/20 

TYLMIIUO YIINY

00T70V$ 

000°'5E8%$ 

HLONITSWHY T30UYd ILTNW-6T 

aM 000°GE8$ 

 TZ/82/70 

TYLY3IYO YIINV

000°22€$ 

000°00£$ 

HIONITSWHY-E0 

QM 000°00$ 

 22/9T/L0 

IOAVMLV

000°662$ 

000°009$ 

HLIONITSIWHY-€0 

dM 000°009$ 

 TZ/T0/0T 

QA183LYO NIAT0

plos uaym ‘psy 

 $ ares ‘py 

3)eS JO Sula) 

sul 

9dud des 

dled Aes 

SSaIppY 193.115

AdSW3S - J

1100'S 

<=3JUBMEA "dAY 

6490 

<="4'03 9y 

918E/0°0 

 <=UORBIASG ‘PIS 

6990 

<='4'03 

0£281$ 

20EVET TTS 

 TBOTTSLS 

620°c

g90IN 

 90T6T$ 

©60°TT 

 ¢S90 

828'G9CE$ 

 E85°061C$ 

 L9reord 

 1¢ge

g9aIN 

 80°TLI$ 

00.7 

9/90 

BEE'96TT$ 

 £8L'808% 

€IZ'99T$ 

 0vS'6

g9aIN 

 EV0LI$ 

Sse 

SL9°0 

 TIS'Se8$ 

SLTY09% 

5z8'socs 

 6vS'6

NIdOM 

 €6'6LT$ 

1989 

0090 

8SE'906T$ 

 TOSYYITS 

 GEV'SOT$ 

 S8T

HIND 

~~ TOTIZ 

16° 

ZeL0 

 180°TKTT$ 

 ¥IS‘Ges$ 

98r'6T$ 

 £v6'8

HIND 

OT'T6T$ 

651 

¥Z8'0 

 ¥87'596$ 

£20°'56L$ 

e/6'68$ 

 610°9

HIND 

ST ver$ 

TILE 

289°0 

 LOT'ZOOTS 

 6L€89% 

80T'9T$ 

 esL/

90109 

 €9°65T$ 

€6T°e 

2650 

 £69°098% 

£69'605$ 

L08'06$ 

 6TP'S

ealy 403 

'bs/$ 

Baly100]4 

"4°03 

 $°UBWISOQ 

 1enpisay ‘3pig 

 PieA+pue] 

jestes

dSW3S - A

Yv.688€9€°L 

/1 

ON 02.%9e$ 

AHOLS-OM

/1 

ON 

S8T‘cST$ 

AHOLS-OM

; 

FT 

ON SThzsT$ 

AHOLS-OM

~ 

090-209-+TTT 

/1 

ON Tee'se$ 

GINOD 

ALS ZANV

I! 

ON 

0% 

WOO 

ALS ZANV

I 

ON 

0$ 

GWOD 

ALS TANY

I 

oN 

0$ 

WOO 

ALS ZTANV

[1 

ON £08‘06$ 

gIWNOD

ALS TANV

aes ui s)3died JaylQ 

 aeq iddy 

*b3 Aq "addy 

ane pue] 

apod asn 

21/15 Suipjing 

AdSW3S -

€8 

T0Y 

ONV

8. 

TOV 

ONV

REN 

aT 

TR 

LL 

TOV 

i 

ONY

16 

TOY 

) 

) 

8L 

TOV 

6L 

0p 

3 

6L 

oy 

86 

TOY 

9N

suonomysay Auadold 

Jamas 

Addngialepy 

Ssa20y 

 sonsuaioeseyg 

aus 

 tidagsuipiing 

 ssejd Ausdold 

AdSW3S - A

S20uUaN)u|IuUoIBIEA\ 

 dIUSISUMQ JUOILIDIBA\ 

 SWENJUOLUAIBA 

 JUOILIBM MIIA ULM

13)0B1RYD WON0Y 

dSIW3S - A

£69'G06$ 

568°979% 

9TS'LTSS 

LeT'88E$ 

Lyv'eTes 

85.'852$ 

69076T$ 

6Le'6TT$ 

eLL$ 

000°5E2°Z$ 

000°5ETZ$ 

 sIej0l 

000°s26$ 

~ 

HIONTISWHV-E0 

AM 000'6/6$ 

 TZ/62/CT 

SMOQVIW ALS THv

000°52T$ 

HLONITSIWHY-E0 

AM 000°52T$ 

12/92/80 

10 AVM SHIHLIM SOE

000°05T$ 

HLONITSIWEY-€0 

AM 000°0ST$ 

22/02/50 

Hlvd 310148 §/T

000°05T$ 

HLONITSIWEY-€0 

DTW 000°0ST$ 

 Te/TZ/t0 

AVA SYIHLI

000°5€8$ 

HLONITSWHY 1308Vd ILTNW-6T 

GM 000°GE8$ 

 T2/8Z/¥0 

 THLYIIYO ¥IINVO STZ

$ aes “py 

3)eS JO sua) 

isu] 

9dud aes 

aed ales 

$S3IPPY 193.11S 

JOOHY0gHOIAN

0T'6LE6CT 

 <=31dy1aN Jad 

€LL$ 

<=d44 lad 

SGV 

agelany 

agelany 

z6°sy 

16% 

6% 

8'1€8 

000°sP¥$ 

929°2r9$ 

526°£90°2$ 

BEE 

CT 

16/2 

8%8T 

0$ 

$79°88$ 

S5€°988$ 

SSTY 

£80 

£80 

0eve 

0°51 

000°STT$ 

000°GTT$ 

185°rT$ 

00°9Y 

oz’ 

9z'T 

0°ErE 

 0°G9T 

000°STT$ 

000°05T$ 

000°6TT$ 

£e°8e 

LL0 

LLO 

096T 

0TLI 

000°GTT$ 

000°05T$ 

000°STT$ 

88g 

880 

880 

0°89 

0'9ST 

000°00T$ 

186'82T$ 

610°908$ 

or'8y 

Sa19Y 1830) 

$319Y 19N 

JU0J4 03) 

ameppue]-is3 jenpisay pue] 

jesieiddy 

ind 

 21eS[p

JOOHYOGHOIIN

£6°T$ 

0 

ONV18 ANVYO 40 SMOAVaW 

~ 

pI+3T0220C 

€9QIW 

 08'W8T 

TES 

6

0 

MOTIOH 3NId 40 SAOOM 

¥1+360120°C 

NIdOM 

00°GST 

Tees 

6

0 

MOTIOH 3NId 40 SOOM 

Y1+3£0220°C 

NIdOM 

00°G9T 

€L'C$ 

6

0 

MOTIOH 3NId 40 SAOOM 

YT+350220°C 

NIdOM 

00°T4T 

or v$ 

T

0 

S31V1SI MOTIOH 3NId 

¥T+350T20°C 

H3NId 

00°9ST 

oe'e$ 

c

a8ed/iaqrl 

 ealy4D3 

juoijjemdy 

idbs/sienoag 

a

19AR19 

a)1qe] pueq 

3]eS ul S)3dled Jayi0 

JOOHYO4GHOIIN

SonsLIaoRIRYD AUS 

cdnoigaey 

gdnoigaley 

31IS ¥YIN9I-HS 

31S HYINOTY-4S 

30S ¥YIN93H-4S 

O/M WYIdLS-MLS 

T dnoig arey 

Tov. 

107 

Tov 

zor 

107 

SSe)) 

9poYasn 

Addng Jie 

SS929Y 

JOOHYOEHOIAN

SI9UMQ JU0IIe 

QWEeN juoiyiaie\ 

JUOILI3IBAL 

MBIA JUOLIBIEM 

S9J0N uonoLsay 

suona

QOOHY0gGHOIIN

13)0BIRYD WONOG 

AOOHYOEHOIAN

← View full record