Disclosure - Docket #25-003597 - JARBO.pdf
Justin Jarbo, Tracy Jarbo, Petitioners V Township Of West Bloomfield, Respondent · 25-003597-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
* West WV Bloomfield VALUATION DISCLOSURE FOR PROCEEDINGS AT THE MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL MTT Docket No: ~~ 25-003597 Tax Parcel No: X 18-03-136-011 Petitioner: Justin & Tracy Jarbo 1677 Parkview West Bloomfield, MI 48324 Agent: Lina Asmar 24681 Northwestern Ste 4007 Southfield, MI 48075 Respondent: Charter Township of West Bloomfield 4550 Walnut Lake Road West Bloomfield, MI 48323 Appeal Year: December 31, 2024, for 2025 Tax Year December 31, 2025 for 2026 Tax Year Prepared by: Robert Scfiptre, Assessor Daniel L. Sears, Chief Appraiser Angela Skiver, Chief Appraiser Keith Hartman, Property Appraiser
Page 2
2 Table of Contents Cover Letter .............................................................................................. 1 Table of Contents ...................................................................................... 2 Master Letter ............................................................................................ 3 Township Map ........................................................................................... 4 Subject Photographs ............................................................................... 5-7 Subject Aerial Map ..................................................................................... 8 Subject Record Cards............................................................................ 9-12 Valuation Report..................................................................................13-16 Market Comparison Analysis .................................................................17-18 ECF and Land Analysis .........................................................................19-21 Subject and Comparable Map ...............................................................22-23 Subject Sketch ........................................................................................ 24 File Maintenance Records .....................................................................25-26 Scope of Work and Certification ................................................................ 27 Appraiser’s Qualifications .....................................................................28-31 Addendum .............................................................................................. 32 Pictures and Maps of Comparables .......................................................33-50 Listing ................................................................................................51-53 Contractors Bid....................................................................................54-61
Page 3
* est Bloomfield = September 23, 2026 Chief Clerk Michigan State Tax Tribunal P.O. Box 30232 Lansing, Michigan 48909 RE: Address: 1677 Parkview Tax Parcel No: X 18-03-136-011 MTT Docket No: #25-003597 Dear Sir/Madam: Please find enclosed the valuation disclosure for the subject property listed above. We set the Assessment utilizing Mass Appraisal. For appeal purposes, the property is valued on an individual basis with the Sales Comparison Approach, which focuses on the specifics of that home only. We used the Cost Approach, Land Analysis and the Sales Comparison Analysis in preparation for this disclosure. The ‘original’ Assessed Value, True Cash Value, and Taxable Value for the year at issue are: Tax Day Tax Year TCV Assessed Value Taxable Value 12/31/2024 2025 769,340 384,670 381,016 12/31/2025 2026 823,600 411,800 380,297 The Michigan Tax Tribunal makes an independent determination of value based on all the evidence available. This valuation disclosure concludes the following values: Tax Day Tax Year TCV Assessed Value Taxable Value 12/31/2024 2025 822,500 411,250 381,016 12/31/2025 2026 761,900 380,950 380,297 Sincerely, : | yh Robert Scripture, Assessor Daniel L. Sears, Chief Appraiser > NE 3 Sr ngela Skiver, Chief Appraiser Keith Hartman, Property Appraiser West Bloomfield Township Ea 4550 Walnut Lake Rd. ! wbtownship.org West Bloomfield, MI 48323 —_—— fax (248) 682-7851
Page 4
4
TOWNSHIP MAP
TOWNSHIP MAP
uo
>
>
3
re
E
[4
>
h
TITRE
11]
{hes
BEAT
{
™
|
—
"
}
-t
—
-—
-~
-
“ad
0
8
3
—
a
1
-
-
>
—
Hi
[
4]
y
+
>
»
|
4
hl
:
.
:
—
3
-
1
dl
|
4
»
>
is
PEt
"
77 3
Ye
i
4
:
fl
d
©
*
Lf
wi
=
"|
.
5
—~
a
ange
yl
pil eit
oa
imate
B
LakPage 5
5 Subject Property – Front Photograph Subject Property — Front Photograph
Page 6
6 Subject Property – Rear Photograph a Be: v & SEPed S200 08:20" — Rear Photograph Subject Prope
Page 7
7
Subject Property – Water Frontage Photograph
Subject Proper
— Water
ii rot age Photograph
A i
=
FT]
1
Ji fh
a
tt
5
i
[AY
Pa
J
JH
[|
i
A
aad
il
Of yi)
BOL 07 Ew
A
ES
Lis
J]
Ty)
|
N
i)
"Wit
|
Hh
1
KS
{
(i
EER)
BE
0)
1
/ ¥
14
i
fi
MY
(i)
I
if
[04
A
|
|
ha
th)
)
fi
{
{|
i
he!
oo]
Ai
i {h
IA
fe
LAR
i
Z
Wo
JHE
Wil
Jil
72
$5 A
$4
LR
7.2%
Or
1
i
hit
th
Ty
In
\
Il
il
il
2 »
IS
ol
\
HR
be
0A pl
wd
A
\§t
1
|
i il
A
\
Pee
5’
IR
|
i
|
#
~ 44
AhPage 8
8 Subject Property – Aerial Map Standard Detaled Hybrid More Change Password
Page 9
9 2025 Record Card – Page 1 2025 Record Card — Page 1 »+aP333UEITNG 10U ING STGRITSI PSWSSP UTSISY UOTIBWIOIUL mes 5098°L3T | 09L°8ZE 018706 [ose Lez zzoz| ES ———— a ‘pueTx=p 30 A3unop| ; B 7 7 TI0¥3D ‘PTSTIWOOTE 253M JO dTYSUMOL OL PISUSDTT ozEZ ‘9LT $OT% 850 |019 58 |ooceLe $202) aabutpTTng Z66T/€0/TT 6Z0|-g00z — 666T (2) 2ubTzAdon zTTenbz sur 5095 ‘698 095 °69¢ 098°s6 |ooL‘eLz $20Z| 3gBuTPTING 8661/81/50 6E6| o9t10°18E | HOLD ‘98E 0L3 “¥BE oLs‘0TT loos ‘see Szoz| 3=uM usyM ou snTEA T3U30 #aTASY |enTEp anTEp antes 388135-nIUI X sTqexel |/Teunqrir Jo pasog passassy ButprTng pus T=ax uTeTd POST TT iid a —— cad EE iia TER = PUETISM BuTARY AUOIIIIIEM puog Ppapooy dueng padeospuey 9bTE #07 SutTTOR Taa9T 2315 = Fo Zudeafodor g¥- -aTuzsd 2507 "PSYs pooM ¥ ‘ITH . -sTTan punozbrspun ‘5,401 peinsesy -sozoyd paaepdn 3 axa 955% = nTEA ysED enIl sausWEnoIdW] PUET PSITWTISI THIOL ssTaTrTan prspusag PaMeTASY “Wd 03 I00p UO OT EN £2/T1/6 0 6L T 000 suo) /udsy/Aemsatig 52ubTT 38815 gv- "prose 05 Ly 891 T6°TT II31IDUCDPSIA0D-10D qano paaepdn DUR OJUT SSTES PIMSTASY £2/9Z/6 ante ysed Poo9 § 32TS @aEy uotadraasag seg X Wd - §I4 ad out peaEpd] - £2/8/ZT (s)weaI sDETd UT aTuUR 1719573 X We - wzoz sbusys sweu/ssaIppE 091°¢ [24 10z SP EE “2uc)/WEIZ PooM T3M35 - 28d ssaxppe Suryrewm psaepdp - 52/52/27 EER Ly 8s ZL ot sX00Tg OTIEQ 1a/M/Q | 2328M S30uUSNTIuUI/S3usmIo) snTEp YsED Poog § SITS EE uotadraosag | ATEmspTS ERE) ssaswrasy 2505 auswssozduy pusT | BL 4 . Z00 % T00 BF LE-81-50 2 a 19 T 09 ‘6S SIOT HS MUVA ZAISTHVI poy peaNd) | X0z OL NOILIGQ¥ NOOS¥I £ DIS ‘6d ‘Nel 068 °L¥S = sys; puwy "35¥ [PA0L S9IJ¥ TFIOL 970 ‘399J IWOXI TENIDY SIT real X uoTadrIoseq XeL 06E°L¥S 307 ensTusd 0ST 6T5Z 0BLB 0 0000°T £796 00°S9T +195133 Fru ow), ante) uoseay “Cpysy @3ey wyadsg 43uozz yadsg asbeauozy uoradrassag sjuswaaczduW bral Sh Jy EXONS 1 § — | SE 7... SH ¥ITZ9 ST9El PUET Y¥ITZ3 STQEl PUES] I0J S3IEWTISF INTE) PUET ques | panoxdary | X €ZE8% IA QTIIIN0O0TE ISIM T v 3 0 1 TIVEL DVIINOA SO¥L 2 as: L - i _|T97¥3€ WAL/ADL LEE'E3L ADL LS ii id | ZIOWEL * NIISOP ‘ogEEr ST :ATUOLT S53IppY/sWEN 5,ISUND L = [ ; L — sw zwa ] | “ISTO TOOHDS UTSIJHOOTE ISEM :XTOOUdS METAMYG LLIT sn3Els Taqumy =3=q (s)3tmrsg burping IT -BUTUOZ OuaNI-TYIINZOISTE 5210 sss3ppy A3zsdozg [ | | 0-0 WEISNWEL AINZA0UA 1ISOUL 30 INO/OINI-T| ¥ild| $10Z/PT/S0 |T | 81 9NIATT § Xwwsr ‘doHSIS XW¥Er ‘dOHSIE joroot axa au| £202/1€/L0 |000°00% | WOAVT 'OFNNE| ¥I ONIATT § XWWEC ‘dOHSIE 0°00T | yaasNWMl AINEZA0UE| 4 ial £202/22/11 [000°0%) | KOWAL 3 NIIsOr ‘omMur| WHT “OFEEL -sueag ig sbeq 3 sdAy) s2Eg s0T1q -aunag paTITIaA z3qTT s1®s 30 suIsI) -asux s1ES a1=5 s33uEIn z03u=Ig 9202/22/60 uo pazutag QNYDIvO :A3unod PTSTIWOOTY 358M JO “dMl 1UOTIDTPSTINL TT0-9ET-€0-8T- X :Isqumy T=2I=g
Page 10
10
2025 Record Card – Page 2
+24P392URIENS 20U 3NQ STEITSI PSWSSD UTSISY UOTITWIOIUT mas
2025 Record Card — Page 2
T68°LTZ
ADL <= 00%°T
(¥IT23 STq=l 303) 0%
:s3308
sLz’ssT
ose ‘og
sTe301
swear wng dum
|
L83’'z
9TL’S
T
£7035
1 IOTISIUT
otadss TES 0002
hepato
stadss Te 000T
591
z5¢
T
Poo psausaug
ala
zeT
(1:14
T
Tesodstg sbeqaes
Tansg ‘Srranal
sur-atTng
:
0144
688
1s
z33us) FOTIE
SIEM DTIqRAl |
9L9-
BEF T-
T
TT=M 2/T :TT®M uowmo)
T3mM35/1938M ($1)
szp'zT
#9592
zis
sop seg
weg aus
(PSUSTUTFUQ) UDUI Zh TUOTIEPUNOZ DUTPTS SIOTISANT D ISSEID | snoory qn oTweIs)|
5958385 | surey aril oTwezsy|
1
LLB
598°1
6%
POOM P33BSIL
| 10073 TTL STWEIS)|
T
Lest
506°
S31
poo psazail
zomous saszedes|
I23q
JUTS BIIXF
ZET'T
6052
T
sured STIL dTWeIs)
3sTTOL ®IANT
#95
661°T
T
0012 STTL dTWeID
Butqunia oN
Bee’
SLE'Y
1
Ye 3INIXTI
©
283g I33EM IETOS
butquntd | renusy fo
|
53usIISTLPY/SUCTITPPY 9430
oany
‘zsusazos
£sE EET
osL'csz
Teor
yawg eImaxti
z|
ze
ETS
burps
£2035
T
uasg smaxti £|
z
zie
a=TS
Butpts
£2035
T|
(s)omaxza sbezeny]
9TL’T
ETS
12138
a
asop -adsg
MeN 350)
sz1g
uoTaEpUNO
20TISIXT
saTz035
___
buramia (eT)
seaxy BurprTng |
Med
|
"sag|x
| AueR|
|
L¥/00T/00T/00T/L¥=P00D
§ “quop/ucdg/ouni/Aud-qu/Aua
s3s7an0 ~99Ta 30 -ON|
“3S 011% = ®8Iy 20014
3S 0ITZ = 28I¢ PUnoIs
Teams] =a
|
938M 20H Ps0z03 -weasAs Butasey
(Tr) | "TAL
| "PIO X|
x3
3561 318
2
sp
£2035
1
ATTWe3 STOUTS
T BPTE "59W 307 -9s3 350) |
seamaxti Jo ~TEND/ ON
F008
we3sAs AarIndsg|
0TAISS
sdurg|
oz
sexy azodzsp|
168°LTz *A°D"I Peaswrasy
Bhi
ye
21132813 (21) |
005° T
X
6L2°5ST 3503 deg TE30L
{
I
Bl toetoc M hced E
08£‘08E
: MeN sseg Teor
be
try
0 30013 -uo) oN!
0
:®axy abexoag
0
poo)
§
¢ peysTuT
YOUI Zp SUOTIEPUNOZ
TEM Z/T :TTEM UOWMIOD!
0 :-usp suoag
1s Cusp YOTIE
ButpTs
:I0TISIXF
2 :sseTD
z :Zatoedey zmDl—
0LET :atTng I®ex)
sb=xEg
(LT)
3zZ0Z/2Z/60
POOM P33EIIL 6%
POOM P33EIIL 537
dir say
| | £7035
1 FOTISIUI| T
s32380/53yD30g 91)
li
uo pautg
0TT‘z :®a3y 10011
£5 sby "233%
5 amp)
[ #5 pegusp-a0s1Tq|
sa025 poop
YaIESH PIsTEY
I03BTNOIT) 3ESH
£20315
7 qE3e34)
|
A&z035
1 qezeag
£1015
7 IOTISIXT
&z035
1 zOTI®IXT
PSPTS oML
¥0E35 swes/puz
{ £7035
g IOTIIUL
ssoeTdeITs
(51)
1
sbuwy uEsI) IT3s
sbuey parepu®ag
3ABMOIDTH
usap
qnr-1dsz tzznoep
qnr Tzzaoep|
wodz33uUT|
POOH plus
POOH paausaun
T
qnl oH
uEg usp
1339Sy yaeg
Tesodstg sbsqIes
1
zsysEAYSTQ
dor 300)
-moTTY souerrddy
SUT-37INg (ST)
TTI0-9€T-£0-81-
X
ITY TEIauSD
Buttoop/butaEsy of
dumg 3=sg
100)
3 3wey peozod
sosuIng 200TI/TTEM
I3389y @0=ds
3E3E TTEM 2733237F
(700T3-uT) 3usTPEY
JuBTPEY -TT9D "991%
preogeseg DTIa08TH|
1938 20H peoI03|
X|
s1ong / ITY PsoIog
£3907 o/# ITY psdIog
T=00|
poo
|_TT0|
seg
X |
weg
-o97E|
SutToop/BuTiEsE (TT)
:Tsqumy Ts0IEd
Tdng- nea
|
ua paazoddnsupn
"D091
‘s0XZ
| t9)
szooq anoxTEM
as
20013
ON|
(g)
szooqg anoxTeM|
is
Butatr|
3s
uorasszosy
YsTUT3I Juswsseg
(6)
20073 33330u0D|
pooy peaeaxr|
suoas|
“oop paInog
x201g
"duo
quswaseg
(5)
:sastop 03 aubteH
“d's
011Z
-q°1S
3's
0 :TARID
‘a's
0 ausweseg
:sastop
|
sTbuTys. aTeydsy)
X
|
sI00g oTaEg|
sseT19 s1quog|
JuswssE)|
SPITS "ZTIOH X
Sung a1quog|
|
uses TAutp
|
yses TEISH| X
|
uoTIEABIXT
(L)
|
Tremfag) x
Pr
— x
|
busyzsap I3430|0
busyzsap uo
uotaETasuI| x
_ybnozasanez|
{"3u02) z00¥ (E)
131
he]
TAUTA/MUTENTY,
3
sBuTTT®)
(9) |
a1buTus/pooM
EE
—
|
z0TI33%F
(1)
psasdzsn :z3uag
swoozpag|e
STTI :usuoat
20013 Pug
sz0014
(5)
|
itd
.
ausweseq|
-5-8| x|prros| | sx00g
3577 wWooy
tres]
|
pao|x| 51]
|
s38501) 30 327s]
Liisi Medes Se
TT]
of
9561
uti
20,
|
[
[ exox[ =]
| potspousy
atweg 2x
uoraeaonag
3 ed
Em
931 pooM
|
parsueq
|
ews surerimg
zs3sETd]
|
TrEmAag
x
I
I0T292UT
()|
Bosca”
S88 oc |
3
J—
xsTdng)
swog usor|
SWORE STTAOH
ArTweg stbuts X
[
sdAy ButpTIng
BUTPTTNE TETIUSPTSSY
10Page 11
11
2026 Record Card – Page 1
2026 Record Card — Page 1
ozEZ 3LT
5095 ‘69€
013 °‘ss
098°s6
1
[ote “ese
|
0393 '63€
[ooc ez
looL‘sce
2910 “18
|WoLs ‘sae
0L3“¥8E
oL&‘0TT
loos sce
TIDYIDST3S LBET/IZ/S0 660
3gbuTPTINE ZE6T/E0/TT
620)
-
S20Z|
3gbuTPTINg 8661/81/50 6E6
»esP333uEIEnd 10U 3Nq STQETTSI PIWSSP UTSISY UOTIBWIOIUT mae
|
[
oLez’ose
|
sory
xsu0
stqexer
| /Teunqriz
|
l008 “118
[P——
30 prsog
LECCE
snren
ButpTIng
josbzre
|entep
|pus
sz0z,
ESD
-sTTan punozbaspup
Asna; ~~
Sum
al!
a@8I35-nIYL X
uTeETd POOT
puETasy
sutazy
auozzzsasy| X
puog
papooy
duemg
padeospus]
ubTH|
ROT)
ButTTod,
Sjeawy
F315
Fo Aydezbodoy
usbTyoTH ‘PueTAsQ Jo Aaunop|
‘pTaTIW00TE 359M JO dTYSUMOL OI PasusdTT
6007 — 6661
(2) aubrzfdop
-3szyrenbz sur
28x 203 5 -ausoes szwedde - EN SZ/0S/L
yy uado dssy
"UOTITPUCD
UO SYIIYD
LSLy
= SnTEA YSED SNIL 5IUSWSA0IW] PUB PSIEWTISE TEI0L
ssTaTTTan prEpuEas
TenuuE 103 S5nOY-uT usdp -UCTITPUNOT
[]
BL
T
00°0
ou) /udsy/Aemsatig
saybTT 29815
203 3UNODDE 03
306 ©3 $00T Wox3 poob sAuyd
961°T
9%
891
8¥°ST
TI31IDUCPRIBA0D-10D
gang
qe z8MO7 -BUTTTSD SY3 UT SYDEID SBIET —
snTep use)
Poo § 32TS
say
uotadrInseq
|
seg
x
s10073 Butdors -swoy 3noaybnorya 3uszedde
(s)wa31
32ET4 UT Arun
|
2TI309TE
X
S9NSST SUOTIEPUNOF
~IOTISIUT PITITIAN
ZIT’
9%
102
EER
Duo) /sweIs ie]
I8mBg
“0°H /n "3dde £q zsaur spew sz/e/s|
[334
9%
EE
z8°3T
sY00Tg OTIEg d/M/Q
|
Zea,
Geis
so
snTep use)
poos
§ 9215
sawy
uotadraosaq
|
Pre
SIO
AL Sr
seawuTasy 150) Juswsnczduy puet
|
uri
,_
Z00
* 100 ui LE-B1-50
|
aos
nancy
19
3 09
‘65 SIOT €NS MUVd FAISDIVI
1
EON. pean
X0Z OL NOILIOUY NOODYI
£ DIS ‘36d ‘NZL
860 °%23
= snrep pueq "25% TEA0L
seIoy TEA0L 9§°0 ‘399 IWOII TEMIDY SIT
|
Pe |
X
uotadtaossq wel
850923
307 ensTuad
0ST
ZLBZ
O0BLEO 0000°T 9€°36
00°S9T
+1°9P133
|
Peon axed)
snrEp
uoseay
-C(pys @3sy
uyadsg
3uozy
yadag
abwauocag
uotadriossq
sauswsaozduy
TIE) STE
E
a SFOITE
|
2T1and
¥I1Z9 ST4EL PUST ¥ITZ) STAEL PUST 103 Se3swTasy su[sp pusy|
auedsp|
|
psaozdwr
X
£2€8% IW QTEIIW00TE ISEM
T
EE)
RSE
| I
= 52s
gies yy
ne ry
TIVEL OVIINO
SO¥L
{E€°06E
*WAL/ADL S6S°5TB AJL a,
ADWSL 2 NIISOr ‘Om¥Er
ZA TOLT
E53IPPY/SWEN §,I3UMD
!
|
|
80
"Fwd
Sa
:
|
|
|
-IsI0 TOOHDS QTITIWCOTE ISIM :TOOWDS
MEINE LLIT
snaeag)
Taqumy
sas
(s)aTuzsg ButpTTg|
IT :BUTUOZ OuaNI-TYIINIUISTE SSID
seaxppy Aazadozg
|
[
070° ——
1SOUL 30 INO/OINI-T|
¥ia|
pT0Z/§T/S0
|T
BL ONIATT § Xedar 'dOHSIE
AW¥EC ‘dOHSIE
0-001
aqzzal
|
QENIAYSISQ 39 OI-E€
am| £202/1€/L0
|000°00%
WOT ‘OFC
WI ONIATT § AW¥Er ‘JOHSIS
07001
| wassnwal Aruzaond
|
UENTRYEI3q 39 OI-£€
waa £202/2Z/TT
[000°05%
ADVIL
3 NIISOC ‘OSC
WHY ‘Omar
-suEIl
ig|
beg
3/
adAy
338g
s0Tad
Ee ml
§
PSTFTISN|
Sar)
SI%5 JO RL)
casoy),
Megeg
315
bre)
oe a
3202/22/60
wo peautig
QN¥DI¥O :&3unon
PTSTFWOOTE 253M JO “del
TUOTIDTPETIND
TT0-9ET-E£0-8T- X
:Isqumy Ts0Ieg
11Page 12
12
2026 Record Card – Page 2
ovL‘¥ET
MDL <= TET
(¥ITZ3 S19el 303) 30%
s330N
980°€5T
979 ‘spe
:steaol
6EE°Z
6¥3°s
1
Az035 1 30TI93UT
sasoeTdsITs
¥rT
8¥E
1
Pooy ps3usaun
STT
LL
T
Tesodstq s6eqiEn
sur-atTng
BLE
z16
1s
Is8US) ¥2TIG
BLS-
LEE ‘T-
1
TT=M 2/1 STTEM uowmo)
5£9°0T
683 'sT
zLS
1509 sseg
(PRYSTUTIUN) YOUT zy UOTIEPUNOJ BUTPTS :IOTIIIXF D ISSETD
sabexey
ose
2181
6%
Pooy pa3EaIL
s't
S6L°E
891
Ppooy paaEaIl
3230
386
18E°‘Z
1
suTEM STTL STWEs)
525
69Z°T
1
20073 STTL STwWeze)
1002
EEB
1
YaEE SINIXTI
§
Butquntg
S2uswISn{pY/SUOTITRPY I3U30
0zz ‘vel
850 ‘008
:1E30L
z8
qETS
Butpts
£3038
T
z1E
qeTS
5utpTs
£z035
T
aTL'T
qETS
ATE
£035
T
3sop -adsg
meN 350)
sz15
uoTaspunog
20TIRIXT
ss1I035
s=sIy ButpTIng
5 15/001/00T/06/25=Po09
§ ~quoD/uoog/oung/Aud-qy/Aua
"35 0T1z = ®5IY I00Td
35 0ITZ = =IY Puno
1898M 20H padiog -weasks ButaEsH (TT)
|
_SSEbard DSI &2o9573 Arr efwss
3 fpr
“seq fod t9SEiamod
y
weasks Katinas
Edi
.
NR
umnoE) TEIUSD
:®s3¢ 3z0dI=)
OFPL
PET
-A°D"1 PIITWIIST
20338dmo;
SEL
bee
EE
980°EPT
350) deg TE3OL
2 at
Sacivicioiz Sacoc HR
919 ‘Spe
: MeN seg Teaol
|
2026 Record Card — Page 2
0 :I00T3 "SuO) ON
0
-®axy abeioag
0
*POo9
%
TLS waxy
0
:sI00Q -YISH
0
:s3oog -oany
¢ psystuty
YOUI Zp TUOTAEPUNOZ
TEM z/T TTEM uowmod
0 :-usp suoag
TS
- "USA ATI
BuTpTS
:20TIIIXT
0T1’z
-®33¢ 0013
9 psausp-30811q
saoag poop
YIIESH PISTEY
I03ETNOIT) IESE
£2035 7 qEzsid
&z035 1 qE38Id
£1025
7 I0TI33XT
| £2035
T TOTISIAXT|
PopPTS omr
¥5
-9by
"23333
o
:ss=1D
sbusy uEsT) ITS
sbuey paepueag
34BMOIDTR
asap
qnz-tdsz Tzznoep
qnr TzZnOEQ
WodIB3UT
Pooy paausp
POOR pajusaun
1
qnl 30H
ueg usp
233%5H Y3eg
Tesodstq abeqIen|
1
SuTEM STTL STWE:
10073 STIL STWEI
(s)sInaxty sbezany
l
+2aP333URIENS 20U INQ STEITSI PSWSSP UTSISY UOTISWIOIUI mas
:swa3l wns dung
oradss TES 0002
o1adss T=9 0001
TT I33EM
Iams 2TTANG
zs3ey oTTang)
|
T
T
zsmoyg saeIEdsg
2ESH IS1EM ITTOS
TEnuUEy
‘I3U3330S5
oany ‘sus:
y3eg 9In3IxXTI
y3eg aIn3xXTI
§|
z
Tdng-73un
:ua7 paazoddnsup
"27031
‘80XZ
:s3stor
azoddng z00TZ
(01)
:EsumtyD
sTButys aTEudsyY| X
{¥)
sz00Qq 3nojTEM|
as
20013 ON
(g)
szoog 3InoxTEM
as
Buta
45
UOT3IESIDSY
© 0013 saszouo)|
poo paaEaIl
suo
-ouoy parm
werd -Suoy
quswes=g
(g)
0-0 :sastop o3 3ubreH
“E's
0T1Z :q=TS
"d's
0 :TAEId
PSYs)
presuzy
Tezquey
Foo’ (8). |
susszos
3 swzoag| x
sz00q oTa®al
sseT9 sranog
SpTIS
Bung s1qnog
auswssE)
-zT30H|
uses TAuTa
uses 123K X
SMOpUTM
(2)
|
butquntd
(£1)
|
weg)
|
“8ay|
X
| AueR
|
|
TTEsiag x
sasTang -osTz 30 oN]
sButTTs)
(3)
uoTiETnSUT| X
ATI
X
TAuTp/EnUTIMTY|
=TBuTyS/PooH)
wm]
| 'pro|x|
x
ITY TEIIUSD|
Button /ButaTey ON
dumg 3®sy
100)
3 3E8H PaDIOF.
S0FUINg I0OTA/TTEM
z3389y =o=dg
9ESH TTEM 2TI3037F
(10073-UT) 3UETPEY
aueTpEy TT) "29T3
|
|
[
soEuUINg pooM
|
|
|
TAuTA 133430
peasdzes 1x3430
STIL USYDITH
_
sT001% (35)
5°
x|prros|
=
x
z01783x3
(1)
SWOOIPaY|
0013 PUZ|
©0013 35T|9
aususseg
3ST] Wood
POO9 TUOTITPUOD
0!
9561
PaTspowsy|
ITTRE IX
uoT3eI0DSQ
¥ WII]
Az035
T
931 PooM.
—
SL EB
23185814
TiEaiag)
¥
PpIsogeseg 21132973
|
I33=M 30H PI2I0F
X
10TI33UI
(5)
s3ong /m ITY PSDI0F
POO;
CELLESS
E301
o/m
IT
DIO,
J SSE)
oh a a
JyOE15 Swes/puz
IIYsemysTQg
edd
13 Sims
=
z =Eatoeden 1m)
| Zz03g
7 z0TIRILY|
dog Yoon
wesas|
|teon|
|poom
OLET :3TTNg IE8%
®dA1|®83¥
| £7035
1 zoTI®aUI|
T | -mOTTY sousTrddy
0813
170
se)
X
| s3o%a/5sw08 (97)
|
uo pajuTIg
saoe7deaTa
(5
say-atyng
(ST)
TT0-9€T-£0-8T-
X
SurToo)/butaEsE (IT)
:Isquny Ts0IEq
Busyzsap T8430
swe
PpooM
X
SwEIg-¥
xs1dng|
SWoR uMoL
SWORE STTAOH
Arrwsg stbuts|
¥
Fans) Foon ye]
sdip Sutprmg
1 30 1 BuTPTINg [ETIUSPTSSY
12Page 13
13 2025 Valuation Report – Page 1 2025 Valuation Report — Page 1 09/22/2026 09:03 AM Valuation Report 8: Wbt2025 X -18-03-136-011 Property Class: Map #: 15 401 Twp 2025 Est. T.C . of West Bloomfield WV. JARBO, JUSTIN & TRACY 1677 PARKVIEW WEST BLOOMFIELD, MI 48324-1290 Land Value Estimates for Land Table 621LA.Land Table 621LA * Factors * 2 sides canal Description Frontage Depth Front Depth Rate %Adj. Reason Value ££144.1+ 165.00 96.36 1.0000 0.8780 2519 150 penisula lot 547,390 165 Actual Front Feet, 0.36 Total Acres Total Est. Land Value = 547,390 Land Improvement Cost Estimates Description Rate size % Good Cash Value D/W/P: Patio Blocks 16.72 58 47 456 Wood Frame/Conc. 33.45 201 47 3,160 Unit in Place Item(s) Description Rate Size % Good Cash Value cCT-CoveredConcrTerr 11.91 168 47 940 Driveway/Asph/Conc. 0.00 1 79 0 Total Estimated Land Improvements True Cash Value 4,556 Cost Est. for Res. Bldg: 1 Single Family 1 Story cls ¢ Blt 1956 (11) Heating System: Forced Hot Water Ground Area = 2110 SF Floor Area = 2110 SF. Phy/Ab. Phy/Func/Econ/Comb. % Good=47/100/100/100/47 Building Areas Stories Exterior Foundation Size Cost New Depr. Cost 1 Story Brick slab 1,716 1 Story siding slab 312 1 Story siding slab 82 Total: 283,730 133,353 Other Additions/Adjustments Plumbing 3 Fixture Bath 1 4,975 2,338 Ceramic Tile Floor 1 1,199 564 Ceramic Tile Wains 1 2,409 1,132 Deck Treated Wood 165 3,909 1,837 Treated Wood 49 1,865 877 Garages Class: C Exterior: Siding Foundation: 42 Inch (Unfinished) Base Cost 572 26,444 12,429 Common Wall: 1/2 Wall 1 -1,438 -676 Brick Veneer 51 939 441 Built-Ins Garbage Disposal 1 280 132 Unvented Hood 1 352 165 Fireplaces Interior 1 Story 1 5,716 2,687 Totals: 330,380 155,279 Notes: ECF (ECF Table 621LA) 1.400 => TCV: 217,391 2025 Est. T.C.V. X -18-03-136-011 = 769,337 Est. TCV/Total Floor Area = 364.61, Most recent sale 11/22/2023 for 440,000 2024 Assessed MBOR S.E.V. Base for Cap IRM 369,560 369,560 369,560 369,560 3.10 2025 New Eq. Adjustment Loss Additions Tax Adjustment Losses 13
Page 14
14 2025 Valuation Report – Page 2 2025 Valuation Report — Page 2 09/22/2026 valuation Report 0 3 AM ~ Parcel Number: X 0 11,456 0 Capped ~~ ->Taxable<- 381,016 381,016 0 14
Page 15
15 2026 Valuation Report – Page 1 2026 Valuation Report — Page 1 09/22/2026 09:04 AM Valuation Report 8: Wbt2026 X -18-03-136-011 Property Class: Map #: 401 Twp 2026 Est. T.C . of West Bloomfield WV. JARBO, JUSTIN & TRACY 1677 PARKVIEW WEST BLOOMFIELD, MI 48324-1290 Land Value Estimates for Land Table 621LA.Land Table 621LA * Factors * 2 sides canal Description Frontage Depth Front Depth Rate %Adj. Reason Value ££144.1+ 165.00 96.36 1.0000 0.8780 2872 150 penisula lot 624,098 165 Actual Front Feet, 0.36 Total Acres Total Est. Land Value = 624,098 Land Improvement Cost Estimates Description Rate size % Good Cash Value D/W/P: Patio Blocks 16.82 58 46 449 Wood Frame/Conc. 33.66 201 46 3,112 Unit in Place Item(s) Description Rate Size % Good Cash Value cCT-CoveredConcrTerr 15.48 168 46 1,196 Driveway/Asph/Conc. 0.00 1 78 0 Total Estimated Land Improvements True Cash Value = 4,757 Cost Est. for Res. Bldg: 1 Single Family 1 Story cls ¢ Blt 1956 (11) Heating System: Forced Hot Water Ground Area = 2110 SF Floor Area = 2110 SF. Phy/Ab. Phy/Func/Econ/Comb. % Good=46/90/100/100/41.4 Building Areas Stories Exterior Foundation Size Cost New Depr. Cost 1 Story Brick slab 1,716 1 Story siding slab 312 1 Story siding slab 82 Total: 300,048 124,220 Other Additions/Adjustments Plumbing 3 Fixture Bath 1 4,833 2,001 Ceramic Tile Floor 1 1,269 525 Ceramic Tile Wains 1 2,381 986 Deck Treated Wood 165 3,795 1,571 Treated Wood 49 1,812 750 Garages Class: C Exterior: Siding Foundation: 42 Inch (Unfinished) Base Cost 572 25,689 10,635 Common Wall: 1/2 Wall 1 -1,397 -578 Brick Veneer 51 912 378 Built-Ins Garbage Disposal 1 277 115 Unvented Hood 1 348 144 Fireplaces Interior 1 Story 1 5,649 2,339 Totals: 345,616 143,086 Notes: ECF (ECF Table 621LA) 1.361 => TCV: 194,740 2026 Est. T.C.V. X -18-03-136-011 = 823,595 Est. TCV/Total Floor Area = 390.33, Most recent sale 11/22/2023 for 440,000 2025 Assessed MBOR S.E.V. Base for Cap IRM 384,670 384,670 384,670 381,016 2.70 2026 New Eq. Adjustment Loss Additions Tax Adjustment Losses 15
Page 16
16 2026 Valuation Report – Page 2 2026 Valuation Report — Page 2 Valuation Report 09/22/2026 09:04 AM Parcel Number: X 0 9,998 Capped ~~ ->Taxable<- 380,297 380,297 0 16
Page 17
17 2025 Sales Comparable Analysis 2025 Comparable Analysis for Subject Parcel X -18-03-136-011 Feature Subject Parcel Comparable #1 Comp. #1 Adjustment Comparable #2 Comp. #2 Adjustment Comparable #3 Comp. #3 Adjustment Parcel Number X -18-03-136-011 X -18-03-186-004 X -18-03-182-007 X -18-03-303-004 Address 1677 PARKVIEW 4495 LINWOOD 1855 WINDSIDE 4963 GRAND CT Neighborhood/Location Cass Lake / All-Sports Cass Lake / All-Sports 0 Cass Lake / All-Sports 0 Cass Lake /All-Sports 0 Appraisal/Sale Date 12/31/2024 12/5/2023 0 9/27/2024 0 10/1/2024 0 Time Adjustment 2024 + 10% 65,000 2024 + 2.5% 20,600 2024 + 1.5% Land Size (Summary Acreage) 0.365 0.274 0 0.253 0 0.154 100,000 Frontage 165' / 2 Canal Sides 75' 76' 52' Year Built / Addn / Alter 1956 1954 / 2003 0 1965 0 1935 / 2007 0 Quality / Construction Standard / Brick-Siding Standard / Brick 0 Standard / Brick-Siding 0 Standard / Brick-Siding 0 Style 1 Story Bungalow 0 2 Story 0 2 Story 0 Bedrooms 3 3 0 4 0 3 0 Full Baths 2 2 0 3 (3,000) 1 3,000 Half Baths 0 0 0 0 0 1 (2,000) Square Feet 2,110 1,400 21,300 2,780 (20,100) 1,692 12,540 Fireplaces 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 HVAC Type Forced Hot Water Forced Heat & Cool (2,500) Forced Hot Water 0 Forced Heat & Cool (2,500) Garage Capacity 2 Car Attached 2 Car Detached 0 2 Car Attached 0 1 Car Attached 10,000 Fin Basement Sq. Feet None None 0 None 0 Finish (10,000) Basement Walkout Doors No Walk-out No Walk-out 0 No Walk-out 0 Walk-out (10,000) Porches / Decks Decks, Concrete Porch Deck, Concrete Porch 0 Concrete Porches, Brt 0 Deck, Concrete Porch 0 Grantor KARCHO, BASHAR & HAIFA NADOLNY, MARVIN & BERNADINE O'NEIL, ROBERT Grantee JABRO, RYAN & ERICA TIKA, WASIM MANNINO, JEROME & TANYA Miscellaneous Actual Sale Price DOM: 53 650,000 DOM:103 825,000 DOM: 2 727,000 Net Adjustments 83,800 CONV Sale (2,500) Cash Sale 101,040 Net Adjustments % 12.89% 0.30% 13.90% Gross Adjustments 88,800 43,700 150,040 Gross Adjustments % 13.66% 5.30% 20.64% Adjusted Sale Price 733,800 822,500 828,040 ***MOST WEIGHT GIVEN TO COMPARABLE #2 (LEAST AMOUNT OF GROSS ADJUSTMENTS % )
Page 18
18 2026 Sales Comparable Analysis 2026 Comparable Analysis for Subject Parcel X -18-03-136-011 Feature Subject Parcel Comparable #1 Comp. #1 Adjustment Comparable #2 Comp. #2 Adjustment Comparable #3 Comp. #3 Adjustment Parcel Number X -18-03-136-011 X -18-03-182-007 X -18-03-303-004 X -18-04-430-018 Address 1677 PARKVIEW 1855 WINDSIDE 4963 GRAND CT 5149 LATIMER Neighborhood/Location Cass Lake / All-Sports Cass Lake / All-Sports 0 Cass Lake / All-Sports 0 Cass Lake / All-Sports 0 Appraisal/Sale Date 12/31/2025 9/27/2024 0 10/1/2024 0 P: 12/8/2025 C:1/9/2026 0 Time Adjustment 2024 + 2.5%, 2025 +5% 109,500 2024 +1.5%, 2025 +5% 47,800 Land Size (Summary Acreage) 0.365 0.253 0 0.154 100,000 0.235 0 Frontage 165' / 2 Canal Sides 75' 52' 51' Year Built / Addn / Alter 1956 1965 0 1935 / 2007 0 1950 / 1974 0 Quality / Construction Standard / Brick-Siding Standard / Brick-Siding 0 Standard / Brick-Siding 0 Standard / Siding 0 Style 1 Story 2 Story 0 2 Story 0 1 Story 0 Bedrooms 3 4 0 3 0 2 0 Full Baths 2 3 (3,000) 1 3,000 1 3,000 Half Baths 0 0 0 1 (2,000) 0 0 Square Feet 2,110 2,780 (20,100) 1,692 12,540 980 33,900 Fireplaces 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 HVAC Type Forced Hot Water Forced Hot Water 0 Forced Heat & Cool (2,500) Forced Air w/ Ducts 0 Garage Capacity 2 Car Attached 2 Car Attached 0 1 Car Attached 10,000 2 Car Detached 0 Fin Basement Sq. Feet None None 0 Finish (10,000) None 0 Basement Walkout Doors 0 0 0 Walk-out (10,000) 0 0 Porches / Decks Decks, Concrete Porch Concrete Porches, Brt 0 Deck, Concrete Porch 0 Concrete Porch 0 Grantor NADOLNY, MARVIN & BERNADINE O'NEIL, ROBERT HODGINS, MILTON T Grantee TIKA, WASIM MANNINO, JEROME & TANYA HANTZ, JOHN R TRUST Miscellaneous Actual Sale Price DOM: 103 825,000 DOM: 2 727,000 DOM: 493 725,000 Net Adjustments CONV Sale 86,400 Cash Sale 148,840 Cash Sale 36,900 Net Adjustments % 10.47% 20.47% 5.09% Gross Adjustments 132,600 197,840 36,900 Gross Adjustments % 16.07% 27.21% 5.09% Adjusted Sale Price 911,400 875,840 761,900 ***MOST WEIGHT GIVEN TO COMPARABLE #3 (LEAST AMOUNT OF GROSS ADJUSTMENTS )
Page 19
19 2025 ECF Analysis 2025 ECF Analysis HERTS [00000 SES VIA 0002S | HON SINWV-E0| Vid] 000ZLS [VEIN osE'sezs [oes'taes | oozes | Wiow3swuv-Eo| OM 000'szsS [12/2/60 |oeezuss | oo0'toozs | muon SWHV-E0] Vid] 00010078 [ve/21/20 295Evs'ZS $96VET'SS Looe GOETSS [609595 556015 VEZ BOT EBLESTS HISNTISWNY-€0 vid 0000995 22/80/60 ov 1ss 6u'v TEST SOSTLLS 1 A ‘1S WASNT) SWNYV-€0 OM 000'0SS'TS ZZ/92/S0 4Q WV V1129# pooyJoqusiaN / sishjeuy 433 S202 sz0e/12fe 19
Page 20
20 2026 ECF Analysis 2026 ECF Analysis 85°188 SYveTs ZigTets 89'c91S 60L°Z01S 960'5LTS 659'8028 EEE #9°C895 265'vL58 HIONT1S.WHY-E0 HLONT1SWHY-E0 HINLLYISSTS HILLY £625 £10-087-70-81-X| 500-087-40-81-X| sales Ape 98T ueipap <=IeA [0 1UBD1900 133UF <=oIURHEA ONY 3 VL <="aa PIS 68906750 ns En <=oey aes. L5Ly'E T98'98L'LS. 692'989'68 0£9'428'v$ _000'919'F1$ 000'9T9'TIS _siwioL £20-202-20-81-X| FET) 6s1z'E2E vitze vitze Tozes £64818 VIE6LS LeTveis £10'890'TS 10£°9218 65678018 £96'L28 0ZE'ESY'T$ £57798 TWOBIYS BLEOLETS £19788 LBL'TTSS 089'LvSS 0OE'6ZE'TS LbL'sRSS BOE'LELS 061'589%. 0£8'0928 09'v76%. 059'89€$. 000°005'T$ 000'059% "HIONI1S.Wav-€0 HIONT1S.WHV-E0 000°005'TS. 0000598 HQ VNOAIY 0ST GOOMNI 618 GOOMNIT 659% GOOMNIT S6vY 1TZ9# POOYI0qUSIaN / Sishieuy 303 9202 9202/12/16 20
Page 21
21 Land Analysis Land Analysis [mews I | I I i [ soz oj orn cabs ad THESIIT csoVNRd GSLs <eagnd ws =m ms agen tesony atesony wow <ceoney ares sess set ss oser evens csr os609z'cs __ooo'eve'es ooveye'ss sieiol 0008 EVLES E6Z'0E9'TS Ov0'9S 7o vo 00ET SPO 062'L96$ 0v9'68ES sTeY 008'8ELS 000'005'T$. HIONTISIWUY-E0 Vid 00000S'T$ SZHZ/E0 HOVNOAW POST £20-202-20-81-X| 56085 siTezses 1681S vT0 vo oer oor To9'9ze$ 920908 soe 0ZPOSZS 0000598 HIONTISWMYE0 Vid 000'089§ SZ/BTZ0 COOMNMGISY 500-908-€0-91-X| JOOMNI699% [10-£26-6091-X] GOOMNI SGP 100-981-60-91-X| 11294 PoousoqusiaN / siskieuy pue szoz 9202112I6 21
Page 22
22 2025 Subject and Comparable Map
Page 23
23 2026 Subject and Comparable Map
Page 24
24 Subject Property – Sketch Subject Property — Sketch SKETCH/AREA TABLE ADDENDUM File No.: Property Address: 1677 PARKVIE! SUBJECT INFO Parcel No.: X -18-03-136-011 wW City: WEST BLOOMFIELD County: OAKLAND State: MI ZipCode: 48324-1290 Owner: JARBO, JUSTIN & TRACY Client: 00000 Client Address: Appraiser Name: Inspection Date: SKETCH OO AL HE © Wood Deck ei 1essf Wood Deck 49 sf of 26' ~ Brick -4' x 9.8" - 1-S Fr 312.0 sf 12.2 62' 22 10 BE 1-SFR Brick -4' x 12.8" po 82.0 sf N Unfin Fr Gar 1-S Brk Q 1.3 P oN 11.3 HE © 572.0 sf ; ] ‘ = Brick -4' x 9.8' IN 35.7 CCT Brick +4' x 12.8" 167.8 sf 15° Brick -4' x 11" © iLOOKABOUT (US) Inc. dba Apex Software 24 Page 1
Page 25
25 Subject Property - File Maintenance Record – Page 1 Subject Property - File Maintenance Record — Page Parcel Number 09/22/2026 09:09 AM Comments Report Comment Type Comment X -18-03-136-011 General Comment 8/3/25 Made inter by appt. w/ H.O. Verified interior. Foundations issues apparent throughtout home. Sloping floors - large cracks in the ceiling. Lower ab phys good from 100% to 90% to account for foundation. Open in-house for annual checks on condition. Keep open kh 7/30/25 NH - appears vacant. LC for rec. appr. Reviewed ext. Home has severe deferred maintain from exterior. Updated pi kh 6/10/25 - Summer and Winter 2024 tax bills returned as "no such number" - EEL 6/10/25 - Assessment notice returned 2025 - RM 6/10/25 - Assessment notice returned from 2024 - RM 2/25/25 - Updated mailing address per address/name change form - RM 12/8/23 - Updated info per PTA - RM 9/26/23 Reviewed sales info and updated record. -AB 9/11/23 NH 1C on door for RA. Reviewed ext. & updated photos. Measured TDK's, BLT, & wood shed. Close permit. — AB 08/14/23 Updated information per Warranty Deed AS 11/29/22 - Updated info per PTA - EEL 25
Page 26
26 Subject Property - File Maintenance Record – Page 2 Subject Property - File Maintenance Record — Page 2 Comments Report Par Type Number Comment X -18-03-136-011 Assessor's Eyes Only C 10/14/25 Listed for sale orig $849 7/23/25 - New H/O called and propert: for $ 770,000 and she is mo She asked for 2026 taxes as principal residence, I aksed her again if she is going to live in it and she affi that they are moving in. I told her ba ,670, Millage rate for West Bloomfield scl .6262, approximate 2026 taxes = 14,600.00 - RM EE 12/8/23 - New h/o said they are demoli in 2024 - RM hing this property 26
Page 27
Scope of Work This Valuation Disclosure has been prepared due to a Statutory Duty of the Assessor defending an Ad Valorem property assessment. We may or may not have been granted access to the subject property for this disclosure, or for the original Ad Valorem assessment. In such cases where we have not had access to the subject property, the condition, quality and amenities may be based upon an estimate. We have taken reasonable steps to ensure that these estimates are reasonable and just. Market research includes a review of recorded sales, current listings of the subject's market area and/or competing market areas. Certification The undersigned certify that: To the best of our belief, all statements and information contained herein are true and correct, subject to the assumptions and limiting conditions as set forth in the valuation disclosure. We have no present or contemplated future interest in the property that is the subject of this valuation disclosure. We have no personal interest or bias with respect to the subject matter of this valuation disclosure or the parties involved. This assignment is a statutory requirement. This valuation disclosure was not contingent upon the value estimated, nor upon reporting a predetermined value. The Assessor's Department for the Charter Township of West Bloomfield completed this document for the Michigan Tax Tribunal proceedings. Michigan statute requires the annual assessment of property. This valuation disclosure has been prepared with accepted standards of assessment administration. The wages of the West Bloomfield Assessing Department personnel are not contingent in any outcome of the proceedings. pr dss, Robert Scripére, Assessor Daniel L. Sears, Chief Appraiser Cy Oy . rN Arofle Sher Chief Appraiser Keith Hartman, Property Appraiser 27
Page 28
28 Robert C. Scripture MMAO, Michigan Master Assessing Officer Certified Personal Property Examiner West Bloomfield Assessor Current Employment: Charter Township of West Bloomfield ~ Assessor 2016 – Present Previous Employment: Oakland County Equalization ~ Chief Assessor 2004 – 2016 Certifications: Michigan Masters Assessing Officer (MMAO) R-8560 2014 Michigan Certified Personal Property Examiner #1810 Formal Education: Baker College of Business, Auburn Hills Bachelor of Business Administration Oakland Community College Associates of Business Affiliations: IAAO – Member OCAAO – Trustee, Technology Committee MAA – District III Representative, Long-Term Planning Committee, Instructor, Author
Page 29
29 DANIEL L. SEARS, MAAO (3) CHIEF PROPERTY APPRAISER CERTIFIED PERSONAL PROPERTY EXAMINER CURRENT OCCUPATION: * Chief Property Appraiser, West Bloomfield Township 1990 - Current Appraisal Education: * Fundamentals of Real Estate * Property Value Assessment Administration, Business 280 * Property Tax Law Valuation Concepts, Business 281 * Commercial and Industrial Appraisals, Business 283 * Assessment, Equalization and Allocation, Business 284 * Advanced Income Approach to Value, Business 288 * State Assessors Board, Course I and II * IAAO Mass Appraisal of Residential Property * Personal Property, MAA * Michigan Tax Tribunal Procedures, MAA * Computer, MAA * Narrative Appraisal, MAA * Tax Law and Exemptions, MAA * Appraisal Standards and Ethics, MAA * Proposal A Implementation * Planning and Administering Finance * Introduction to ArcView GIS * Advanced Computers, MAA * Principles of Public Administration, MAA * How to Critique an Appraisal, MAA Formal Education: * Oakland University, Business Management Professional Appraiser Certifications: * MAAO #1992 State Certified Appraiser * State Certified Personal Property Examiner #949 Organizations: * Michigan Assessors Association * O.C.A.A.O. Licenses: • Real Estate License
Page 30
30 Angela Skiver, MAAO (3) Chief Property Appraiser Charter Township of West Bloomfield Current Occupation Chief Property Appraiser Charter Township of West Bloomfield Appraisal Education Personal Property Course Communications/Public Speaking Course Property Tax Law Course Michigan Tax Tribunal Procedures Course Computers/Financial Calculators Course Income Approach Course Principal Residence Exemption Course General Education Associate Degree Liberal Arts Oakland Community College Appraiser Certification Michigan Advanced Assessing Officer (Level III) #8959 Certified Personal Property Examiner Michigan State Tax Commission Organizations Oakland County Association of Assessing Officers Michigan Assessors Association
Page 31
31 Keith W. Hartman, MAAO (3) Property Appraiser Charter Township of West Bloomfield Current Occupation o Property Appraiser, Charter Township of West Bloomfield 2013 – 2019 2021-Current Appraiser Education/Courses o Basic Income o Principles of Appraising o Commercial and Industrial Appraising o Statistics o Valuation and Economic Concepts o Personal Property o Land Valuation & Economic Condition Factors o Property Tax Administration o Equalization and Data Collection General Education o Bachelor of Arts in Psychology - San Francisco State University o Pre-requisites for Graduate Studies – University of British Columbia, Vancouver Appraiser Certification o Michigan Advanced Assessing Officer certification (MAAO – Level III) o Michigan Certified Assessing Officer (MCAO - Level II) o Certified Personal Property Examiner Organizations: o Michigan Assessors Association o Appraisal Institute
Page 32
32 ADDENDUMS
Page 33
33 4495 Linwood – Comparable #1 (Front) 2025 4495 Linwood — Comparable #1 (Front) 2025 =<) It. - J \ 33
Page 34
34 4495 Linwood – Comparable #1 (Rear) 2025 4495 Linwood — Comparable #1 (Rear) 2025 34
Page 35
35 4495 Linwood – Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2025 4495 Linwood — Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2025 d § 2 E ES 3 | 3 B 35
Page 36
36 1855 Windside – Comparable #2 (Front) 2025 1855 Windside — Comparable #2 (Front) 2025 36
Page 37
37 1855 Windside – Comparable #2 (Rear) 2025 1855 Windside — Comparable #2 (Rear) 2025 37
Page 38
38 1855 Windside – Comparable #2 (Aerial Map) 2025 1855 Windside — Comparable #2 (Aerial Map) 2025 Standard Delaied Hybrid More
Page 39
39 4963 Grand Ct – Comparable #3 (Front) 2025 4963 Grand Ct — Comparable #3 (Front) 2025 39
Page 40
40 4963 Grand Ct – Comparable #3 (Rear) 2025 elias AT ITT TES TESTE STH. sr ELE AEULNES (EREaNNNNNEE ENE Esau ouneeaED IKE Comparable #3 (Rear) 4963 Grand Ct 40
Page 41
41 4963 Grand Ct – Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) 2025 4963 Grand Ct — Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) H i 3 26 i Ed 41
Page 42
42 1855 Windside – Comparable #1 (Front) 2026
Page 43
43 1855 Windside – Comparable #1 (Rear) 2026
Page 44
44 1855 Windside – Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2026 1855 Windside — Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2026 Standard Detaled Hybid More
Page 45
45 4963 Grand Ct – Comparable #2 (Front) 2026
Page 46
46 4963 Grand Ct – Comparable #2 (Rear) 2026
Page 47
47 4963 Grand Ct – Comparable #2 (Aerial Map) 2026 4963 Grand Ct — Comparable #2 (Aerial Map) $ ] 3 ES i a 3 § 5
Page 48
48 5149 Latimer – Comparable #3 (Front) 2026 5149 Latimer — Comparable #3 (Front) 2026 48
Page 49
49 5149 Latimer – Comparable #3 (Rear) 2026
Page 50
50 5149 Latimer – Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) 2026 5149 Latimer — Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) i i § z 2 3 i a 50
Page 51
51 Listing – Page 1 Listing — Page 1 Residential Full_w/Photos 5149 LATIMER Street, West Bloomfield Twp 48324-1548 MLS#: 20240050175 Area: 02181 - West Bloomfield Twp Short Sale: No LP: $775,500 PType: Residential DOM: N/493/493 Trans Type: Sale oP: $860,000 =) Status: Sold ERTS/FS SP: $725,000 Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 2.0 Acreage: 0.24 Township: rest Bloomfield ggg; 5 car Lot Dim: 51.00 x 201.00 Mailing City: ~~ West Bloomfield Grg Dim: Rd Front Ft: 51 Side of Str: Grg Feat: 2+ Assigned Spaces, Detached School Dist: West Bloomfield Location: Hiller and Greer Directions: From Hiller take Greer St East to Moorgate South to Latimer East. ware Footage Contact Information Sqft Source: Public Records 2 Name: CRAIG A WARD Est Fin Abv Gr: 980 1.0 Phone: (248) 217-1905 Est Fin Low 4 Est Tot Low Arch Sty: Ranch Est Tot Fin: Arch Lvl: 1 Story Price/SqF Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Wtrfrnt Name: Cass Lake Year Built: 1950 Water Facilities: Lake Front, Private Water Frontage Year Remod: Water Features: All Sports Lake, Dock Facilities Water Frt Feet: 50 Listing Information Listing Date: 07/12/2024 List Type/Level Of Service: Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service . Arrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, 07/12/2024 Srves Offered: C200 For Salter Pending Date: ~~ 12/08/2025 Off Mkt Date: ~~ 11/17/2025 BMK Date: Contingency Date: ABO Date: 11/17/2025 Land DWP: Land Int Rate: ~~ % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: ~~ 365 Restrictions: Exclusions: Possession: At Close Terms Offered; Cash, Conventional MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20240050175 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundatior Crawl, Slab Fndtn Material: Exterior: Aluminum, Block Cnstret Feat: Heat & Fuel: Electric, Wall Furnace Cooling: Wir Hir Fuel: Natural Gas. Road: Paved Water Source: Well (Existing) Sewe Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room ovel Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Flooring Bath - Full First/Entry 7x9 Linoleum Bedroom First/Entry 10x13 Carpet Bedroom First/Entry 11x12 Carpet Family Room First/Entry 12 x 20 Carpet Kitchen First/Entry 7 x 10 Linoleum Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 1804430018 Subdivision: ~~ CASS-DALE Ownershi Standard (Private) Occupant: Vacant Tax Summer: $6,685 Tax Winter: 52,168 Homestead: No Oth/Sp Asmnt: 292.00 SEV: $273,770 Taxable Value: ~~ $160,398 Existing Lease: No Home Warranty:No Legal Desc: T2N, R9E, SEC 4 CASS DALE LOT 129 Agent/Office Information List Office: Real Broker LLC List Office Ph: (517) 200-3245 List Agent: CRAIG A WARD J List Agent Ph: (248) 217-1905 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox LB Location: Front Door Remarks Public CASS LAKE Fi Remarks: s, kitchen, full bath and large family room with tons of light looking . ront to put dock Sodihra a Sieh aes. Garage is detached and is a 2 car garage. Excellent location on the lake. REALTOR® CASS LAKE Front on the North Side of the Lake. House needs a ton of TLC. Survey is in the documents as well. The property has a ton of Remarks: potential. BATVAL Buyer's Agent To Verify All Information. If you are going to make an offer send to cward@soldbytrue.com in 1 PDF and do not use Remind. Sold Information Sold Date: 01/09/26 Sold Price: $725,000 Short Sale: No SP/LP:93.49% 3rd Party Appr: No Finance Code: Cash Sale SP/SQFt Abv: $740 SP/OLP:84.30% Selling Office: ~~ Real Broker LLC Selling Office Ph: (855) 450-0442 Selling Agent: Craig A Ward Selling Agent Ph: (248) 217-1905 Co-Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agt Ph: Sell Concessions: Notices and Disclaimers 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (1) make offers of broker cor (i) disclose broker ; (i) repr services are free or available at no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be ; or (iv) make any. limited to or on the of or payment to another broker or representative, ANY "DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP If LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. 2. Broker commissions are mot set by iaw and are fully negotiable. 51
Page 52
52 Listing – Page 2 Listing — Page 2 of source, though deemed reliable, is not guaranteed or warranted. A independently verified. 3. The accuracy o Copyright® Real 52
Page 53
53 Listing – Page 3 Listing — Page 3 53
Page 54
54 Contractors Bid – Page 1 Contractors Bid — Page 1 Roohester Hills 2817 Bond St. Rochester Hills, MI 48309 /\\ FSM AGrowundworke Company CONTRACT Licensed Conractor Date 71172023 Customer Phone (Work or Home) Eric Eboling Moblle: (248) 805-5572 Project Location E-mail - : 1877 Parkview Avenue West Bloomfield Township, Mi 48324 eric@ericebeling.com PROPOSED PRODUCTS Qty SettleStop Helical Pier 18.0 SettleStop Helical Pier - Hand Held 5.0 Permit Package A 1.0 Engineering A 1.0 Site Work/Obstruction 5.0 SettleStop PolyRenewal - 800+ 1164.0 Subtotal $66,830.01 Discount $6,683.00 Fuel Surcharge $99.00 Contract Price $69,346.01 This Contract, along with the Terms and Conditions, the Warranties, the Notice of Cancellation, and the Payment Terms form the contract (the "Contract’) between the Customer and Foundation Systems of Michigan, LLC (the “Contractor’). Customer is responsible for removing all personal lems from the X ‘work area. Customer assumes responsibility for damages to hidden or X unmarked utiity fins. Stabilization is warrantied. Contractor can attempt to lift at X___ Customer's request. X, X, Afull perimeter drainage system with sump pump was recommended. Customer is aware of warranty and all addenda. Customer Is responsible for providing all necessary electrical X, outlets. Acceptance of Contract - The above prices, specifications, conditions, and separate warranty are satisfactory and hereby accepted. You are authorized to do work as specified. Paymont will be made as outlined above or in accordance with the attached addendum. Subject to the Terms and Conditions, Contractor shall endeavor to start work within one hundred fifty (150) days of the dato of the Contract and shall endeavor to complete the work within an estimated one hundred twenty (120) days of the start date of the work.. Customer Contractor X X X. Date 7/11/2023 Date 7111/2023 108 A Groundworks Company 54
Page 55
55 Contractors Bid – Page 2 Contractors Bid — Page 2 Supplemental Notes Foundation Systems of Michigan, LLC to: Product Specifications SettleStop Helloal Pier Install Foundation Helical Pier(s) to stabilize and protect foundation from further vertical settlement. Customer understands contractor guarantees permanent stabifization of the treated area, however contractor does not guarantee lift, exact levelness, or crack closure due to unforeseen environmental or structural factors that may prevent it. Contractor can attempt Lift at the customers request. Lift is not guaranteed, but stabilization is. Final locations subject to change or adjustment depending on job site conditions. Final location of the piers subject to change. Helical Piers come with a LIFETIME TRANSFERRABLE WARRANTY. See warranty section for full details. Any obstructions or vegetation are the responsibility of the customer unless otherwise specified in this contract. Contractor will take care to remove the 1 butis not ible for the life of the in the work area. Customer understands that if additional soil and/or seed Is required, this will be the responsibilly of the Customer. SettleStop Helloal Pler - Hand Held Install Foundation Helical Pler(s) to stabilize and protect foundation from further vertical settlement. Customer understands contractor guarantees permanent stabilization of the treated area, however contractor does not guarantee lift, oxact lovelness, or crack closure due to unforeseen environmental or structural factors that may prevent it. Contractor can attempt Lift at the customers request. Lift is not guaranteed, but stabilization is. Final locations subject to change or adjustment depending on job site conditions. Final location of the plers subject to change. Helical Piers come with a LIFETIME TRANSFERRABLE WARRANTY. See warranty section for full details, Any obstructions or vegetation are the responsibility of the customer unless otherwise specified In this contract. Contractor will take care to remove the vegetation but is not responsible for the life of the vegetation in the work area. Customer understands that if additional soil and/or seed Is required, this will be the responsibiliy of the Customer. Permit Package A Permit package includes all administration duties and permit fees associated with project. Engineering A " Engineering package includes all administration duties, engineering documentation and fees associated with project. Site Work/Obstruetion Site work and/or obstructions on project. SeftieStop PolyRenewal - 800+ + PolyRenewal is a two-part urethane polymer that expands into rigid, structural foam to fill voids, stabilize, and sometimes lift concrete. Small 3/8" holes are drilled in strategic locations in the slab. PolyRenewal is injected beneath the slab to fill voids and attempt lift. Holes are grouted and sealed but may not match the color of the existing flooring or concrete. Customer is aware that the concrete can crack during the lifting process. Contractor will repair cracks that are caused by the lift but will not replace any concrete. The concrete can sometimes be ground down to reduce tripping hazards. Customer is aware that the concrete may not be perfectly level. Contractor guarantees . all joints and pr cracks are recommended and can be added for an additional charge. Contractor Agrees to © Install 18 helical piers Install 5 hand held piers install a total of 1,184sqft Poly indoor Customer agrees to o Be present during any fift procedure. © Have brick work re-pointed, re-fucked or caulked as desired afer installation. © Make final payment to foreman after completion of work. © Home Owner Is aware during any fift procedure additional cracks could appear. Homeowner is responsible for repairs of these cracks if any result in lifting of the structure. Includes drywall, ile or other interior finishes, © Move all personal items at least 10 foot from the work area. © Ifasbestos Is found on work site It is to be removed by a certified spocialist and Is the responsiblity of the homeowner. o Customer understands changes made by local city / township / county requirements may result In added costs and/or work alterations In order for Contractor to meet code and/or permit requirements. 20i& A Groundworks Company 55
Page 56
56 Contractors Bid – Page 3 Contractors Bid — Page 3 Terms and Conditions 1. Services. Foundation Systems of Michigan, LLC dibfa Foundation Systems of Michigan, Is licensed by the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs, This Contract for tho services requested by Customer (the “Work') is based primarily upon Customer's description of the project and/or the related problem(s) and is nfonded to remediate those 2 assumes existing ion generally complies with the relevant building codes. Any drawing(s) attached to the Contract are intonded solely for illustration purposes, are not to scale, and do not create any additional representation, warranty, or commitment on the part of Contracior in connecion with the Work. Contractor is not responsible for products, services, or conditions not expressly reflected herein, not expressly included in the Contract, and not purchased ‘and paid for by Customer. Start dates and completion ceadiinos for the Work are approximate and may be affected by events beyond Contractor's control, such as weathor, permilting issues, access to the property, etc. Any delay caused by events beyond the control of Contractor shall not consitute abandonment and shall not be included in calculating timeframes for payment and performance. Contractor reserves the right to amon the scope of the Work in order to best address the project andor problams. Any changes to the scope of Work which change the cost, materials, work to be performed, or estimated completion date must be made in writing, signed by both parties, and paid for before the Work can be performed. Any deviation from the scope of Work set forth in the Contract that results in additonal costs, Including bul not limited to unforeseen site conditions, unusual building construction, changes needed after Contractor's engineering! management review of the signed Contract, and/or special requirements from the county/oity/agency, will become an extra chargo over and above the contract amount sot forth in the Contract. If Customer and Contraclor cannot agree on the amount of such additional costs and sign an amendment to the Contract, then Contractor has the option, at is sola discretion, of nol proceeding wih the Work and canceling the Contract for its convenience. Contractor reserves the right to substitute a product with an equivalent or superior product. The Work will bo completed in a workmanlike manner according to the standard practices of the industry, and Contractor will comply with local permitting, Inspection, and zoning requirements. 2 Acceptance of Contract. By signing the Contract, Customer acknoniedgos hat hlsho understands and accept al terms, the Toms and Gondions and the Warrants, and desires to enter Into a contract with Contractor for the completion of the Work. Customer's signature authorizes Contractor to perform the Work as specified In tho Contract. The Contract may be withdrawn by Contractor If it Is not accepted within thirty (30) days from the date of delivery. 3. Compensation. Customer agrees to pay Contractor compensation as sat forth in the Contract, Payment must bo mada in full upon complation of the Work, Failure b Customer to mae payments when duo shall constiute a breach of the Contract. A sarvica fee of $25 will be charged for oach returned check, and Interest at a rato of 7 por year shall be applied to any amounts owed by Customer fo Contractor if Customer falls to pay the amounts owed for the Work as agrood. 4. Insurance. Contractor represents and warrants that it maintains Insurance as sot forth In the Contractor's Certificate of Liabillly Insurance, which can be mado available upon request. 5. Dispute Resolution. Dispute Resolution. The Contract shall be governed by the law of the place where the project is located, excluding that jurisdiction's choloe of law rules. Except for instances of failure to pay the full amount of the Contract, any claim, dispute, or other matlor in controversy arising out of of related to this Conract or breach thereof shall bo solllod by arbitration administered by the American Arbitration Association (*AAA') in accordance wih its Conslruction Industry Arbitration Rules In the place where the project is located, unloss another location is mutually agreed upon, and J on the award by the single ‘appointed to decide such proceeding may be entered in accordance with applicable law in any court having jurisdiction thereof. The fee schedule Is listed on tho AAA website al hitp:/finfo.adr.org/constructionfeeschedulel. The arbitrator has the discretion and authority to award such remedies as may be available under applicable law. Each party shall be responsible for its own attomeys' foos for tho arbitration. If payment in full is not mado when due, Contractor is entitied to proceed with ligation and may recover all expenses of collection, including atiomeys' fees, court costs, cour reporter foes, and expert witness foes, in such amount as the court may adudgo reasonable. Contractor is also entitled to recover interest on tho unpald amount from the dato due until paid at the rate of 7% per year. EACH PARTY TO THIS CONTRACT FOR ITSELF, ITS SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS, WAIVES ALL RIGHTS TO TRIAL BY JURY FOR ANY CLAIM, DISPUTE, OR OTHER MATTER IN CONTROVERSY ARISING OUT OF OR RELATED TO THIS CONTRACT. Customer's Responsibility. a. Cosmetic Repalrs. Unless specifically noted in the Contract, Contractor s not responsible for any cosmetic repairs. Rather, Customer is responsible for any finished carpentry, painting, ropointi ical work, extonding lines, replacement of floor ties, carpeting, elo, that may be y afer C: has tad the Work, unless such ropalrs are specifically identified In the Contract. When trenching or excavation is required, Contractor will backfill and compact soil to the best of its ability: however, Customer may need to add more fopsoll at a lator dato if the oxcavated area sstties. Customer is also responsible for any landscaping, reseeding, and resoding that may be r y after Contractor has completed the Work. b. Utilities. Contractor will call the appropriate utility protection service or damage prevention authority (i.e., 811 or “Miss Utility’) to have all public underground utilities located. If Customer lives at a rural address, public lines will only be located to the pole or Customer's property line. Customer is responsible for marking any private lines. such as satelite dish cables, propane lines, low voltage lighting wires, sprinklor system lines, security system wires, services to outbuildings and swimming pools, etc. Customer assumes all responsibility for damage caused to hidden, buried, or unmarked fuelutiity/service/privats lines. Unless otherwisa noted, electrical work is not included In this Contract and problems with electrical connections are the responsibility of Customer. c. Water Seepage. Customer agrees to maintain positive drainage away from any wall(s) repaired by wall anchors, foundation piers, and/or carbon fiber strips/reinforcers, In the event of a wall anchor Installation, a Water Management System is recommended to reduce hydrostatic prossure (which increases at greater depths) on the wall(s) ‘and reduce the chance of waler seepage into the basement. Water seepage inlo any aroa of the basement is NOT covered by the altached Warranties. d. Access and Personal Property. Customer shall provide access to the areas where the Work is to be performed and shall fumish utiities of electric and water at no cost to Contractor, Customer shal prepare such areas so that Contractor can begin work, Including moving all ftems at least 10 fost away from areas where Work is to bo performed and adequately sealing off living space from work areas. Customer shall famove or protect personal property, inside and outside of the residenca, including but not limited to carpets, rugs, shrubs and plants, and Contractor shall not bo responsible for said items. In the event that the removals have not been completed by the scheduled start date for Work, Customer shall be assessed a trp fee of $250. Gonlractor may offer, but is not required, to assist in the preparation of te Work areas and/or (i) in the removal and replacement of drywall, paneling, flooring, finish carpentry, wall coverings, of landscaping at a rate of $40 per man hour. 6. Representations. Customer warrants that except as described in the roquost for service, ail electrical, plumbing, HVAC, restoration, and handyman services located on the property are in good repair and condition and agrees to indemnify Contractor for any defective conditions that exist prior to or that occur after performance of the Work through no fault of Contractor. Customer Is responsible for protecting the components that Contractor provides from future damage and shall follow all Instructions provided in maintaining and protecting such components. 7. On-Site Meetings. Customer shall meet with Contractor on-site bofor the Work begins and shall moet with Contractor on-site when the Work Is completed and ready for inspoction such that Contractor can expiain the Work and finalize payment by Customer. Customer shall be responsible for being present on-site during any attempts fo (it any part of the structure and/or concrete pavement. ; 8. Notice and Contractor's Right to Cure. Customer shall promptly report, in writing, any problems with the Work to Contractor. If the problem with the Work is atiributable to Contractor, Contractor will begin to repalr/correct the problem within fourteen (14) days of receipt of written notice and shall complete the repai/correction in a reasonable time. 9. Assignment. This Contract will be binding upon the parties horeto and thelr raspecive sucosssors and assigns. This Contract Is not assignable without the written consent of both parties. 10. Miscellaneous. This Contract consiitutes the entire agreement of the parties. All prior agreomonts, whether writen or oral, are merged heroin and shall be of no foros or effect. This Contract shall not be modified except in writing signed by both parties. The walvor by any party of a broach or tha failure to enforce any provision of this Coniract shal not operate as a continued waiver or agreement or be construed as any olor waiver or agreement. The validity, performance, and construction of this Contract shall be governed and Interpreted in accordance with the law of the plac where the project is located. If any form, condition, or provision of this Contract is found unenforcoablo by a court of law or equity, this Contract shall be construed as though that term, condition, or provision did not exist, and its unenforceability shall have no effect doer the rest of this Contract. 11. Signatures. This Contract may be executed in any number of counterparts, each of which shall, when executed, be deemed to be an original and all of which shall be deemed to be one and the same instrument. This Contract may be executed by facsimile or electronlo signature pages which shall have the same force and effect as original executed signature pages. The person signing below for Customer represents that he/she has authority to act an behalf of the owner(s) of the properly described in the Contract. ) 12. Limitation of Liability. IN NO EVENT SHALL CONTRACTOR BE RESPONSIBLE FOR INDIRECT, SPECIAL, PUNITIVE, INCIDENTAL, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, LOSS OF USE OF THE SUBJECT PROPERTY, DAMAGE TO ANY PROPERTY NOT FURNISHED BY CONTRACTOR, ATTORNEYS' FEES, EXPERT FEES AND/OR COSTS. 30i8 A Groundworks Company 56
Page 57
57 Contractors Bid – Page 4 Contractors Bid — Page 4 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Customer and Contractor have caused their duly authorized representatives to execute this Contract as of the date first written above, Customer Col F y: of Michi Le Name: X_ Name: X. By;_Eric Ebeling By:_Zach Powers 4ol§ A Groundworks Company 57
Page 58
58 Contractors Bid – Page 5 Contractors Bid — Page 5 Warranties These Warranties are in effect only after the Work is cor competed and Customer has paid in full. If payment is not received, these Warranties are null and void. These Warranties are made In Yieu of all other warranties, express or implied, and of all other obligations on the part of Contractor to Customer. There are no other oral or written warranties. There are no warranties which extend beyond the descriptions that appear below, including no warranties of express or implied merchantability and no warranties of express or implied fitness for a particutar purpose. These Warranties are transferable to future owners of the structure on which the Work is completed. Contractor shall charge a fee of $200 to complete a system inspection and new owner orientation. All warranty claims must be brought prior to the expiration of the Spells ‘warranty period in order to be valid. Contractor does not warrant products not mentioned herein. Some producls may be covered by a separate rer's and Customer Is responsible for compliance with any notice and claim procedure included in such warranties. 1. Definitions. The term “stabilize,” as used in these Warranties, shall mean to make unlikely to give way or feil. The term “horizontal movement,” as used In these Warranties shall mean bowing. The term “vertical movement,” as used in these Warranties shall mean settlement. 2. Wall Support Systems. Conlractor hersby warants thal wal support syslorns, Including wal anhrs, carbon for strips, and sol beam systoms, wil sto further invard horizontal movement of the wall(s) in the areas where they are Installed for the lifetime of the structure from the date of Installation. Wall support systems are warranted only to stabilize repaired walls(s), not straighten. Walls that do not have wall support systems installed by Contractor entirely from comer to comer are not warranted. Contractor racommends annual maintenance for wall support systoms. The cost of maintenance ls not included in this conlract, but maintenance ks available from Contractor at an addtional charge. For Carbon Fiber Strips, contraclor doos not warrant against: (1) any tipping of leaning at the top of the wall(s) repairod; (2) shearing or sliding at the bottom of the wali(s) repaired. In the rare Instance that the repairod wall(s) oxperiance leaning or shearing, steel brackets or other methods can ba installed by Contractor at an additional charge. 5, Fondation ish Per and Foundation Hala Pers, Cartracowiivants thai the loundtion push ters ed fouedton hf! vers wl aftizs th afin areas) against further vertical movement for the lifetime of the structure from the date of Installation. Contractor DOES NOT WARRANT TO LIFT ANY STRUCTURE, to close cracks, 0 onder doors and widows operational, oro movo wal back t thelr aril posiln, but wil do is bes 10 achieve posive results in ths regard, i it a requslod by Customer. Contractor is not responsible for any damages caused by a iting oporation on C ’s fou push plers n helical piers are sold ‘and nstaled without the benefit of tailed krowlecgo of the exisiing foundation consiructon or Subsurface condilons at tho sil. Berensot soservos ne right to conduct a more thorough subsurface nif . Such an I " may result in additional charges and delays. . Stoel C djustable Screw Jack Support. C variant that tho Intpliaks vil sabilzo tho afoctod aroa(s) aginst rar vertical movement fo a period of two (2) years from the date of Installation. This two (2) years warranty against furthor vertical movement ls separato and apart from the manufacturer's warranty of twenty-five (25) years on the producl(s). Contractor DOES NOT WARRANT TO LIFT ANY STRUCTURE, to close cracks, to render doors and windows operational, of to move walls back to thelr original position, but will do Its bost to achieve positive results in this rogard, if lft is requested by Customer. Contractor is not responsible for any damages causad by a Htng oparation on Customer's framing. Tha coniton of wood located n craw Spaces can bo Highly variable and oa rap deteriora or move as a result of changes in environmental conditions and/or changes in the bullding envelope conditions. Contractor is not responsible fo folst sistering, beam Teplacement, $l pate repat, cracking/movement in hardwood flooring or ties) Incdontal & changos In Gnvironmental conditions andlor changes in ihe building Srvelopo. conditions, Unless specifically noted In this Contract. Contractor warrants carpentry work for a period of one (1) year. Steel columns/adjustable screw jacks are sold and fall tio al of deleted knowin of the existing foundation construction or subsurface conditions at the site. Contractor reserves the right to conduct a more subsurface uch an may result in addtional charges and delays. 5. Slab Pers. Contraclor warrants od the pry a will stabilize the affected aroa(s) against further vertical movement for a period of ten (10) years from the date of installation. Contractors DOES NOT WARRANT TO LIFT the slab back to ts original position. 6. Water Management. Contractor warrants that if water from the walls or floor wall joint passes through the perimeter of the water management system and Into the basement floor, Contractor wil provide the addtional labor and materials to fix the leak at no additional charge to the Customer. This warranty applies to water management systems along the specific areas where the system is installed. This warranty will be In effect for the lifefime of the structure and may be transferred to future homeowners provided Contractor is notified within thirty (30) days of the real estate transfer. Annual maintenance Is strongly r d for all water but is not required for tho warranty fo bo in effect, Tho water managoment syslom shail not rust, rol, of corrode for the life of the structure. I the entire perimeter of the basement wats not treated, then acional work at an adional charge may bo necessary Lo exon th system or rea other areas or ther problems not addressed by this Work In addon, a pump or power failure is posible; therefore, this y is not a gu of a dry basement. This warranty shall not apply to condensation, or any system that has been altered in any way, water vapor » from capillary action, water squirting out of the walls over the system, window well flooding, plumbing Joaks, sxtace weiss loodlng, leaks from chimneys or garages, wall dampness, or efflorescence (white powder) on conorete, masonry or bricks. Contractor is not responsible for frozen discharge lines or water once it is pumped from the structure. Installation of a water management system does not include extending discharge lines more than five (5 eat fom th foundation or iecriol work, uness specified: Floor cracks are warranted againet ‘only with full perimeter water ment systems. Primary \C operated sump pumps and DC back-up pumps may be covered under a separate manufaclurer’s warranty. Y Systerns that drain to daylight cannot bo warranted by Contrciors system does not drain enough water, does not drain water from under the floor, clogs, or freezes. While drainage systems clogging or malfunctioning from iron ochre, iron get. or iron bacteria from the soil are rare, Contractor cannot bo responsible for these situations, or for a system that requires cleaning, flushing, o other service as necessary lo keep it functioning. . Crawl Space Encapsulation. A crawl space encapsulation system will isolate the home from the earth. The humidity level in the air will be lowered, reducing moisture; however, the encapsulation system does not claim to be a mold mitigation system end a dehumidification/air purfication system is highly recommended to further reduce mold growth. CrawiSeal has a transferable twenty-five (25) years warranty—there will be no charge for service cals on any tears or holes in the CrawiSeal finer (not causad by abuse or misuse), in the unlikely event this occurs. Wel crawl spaces require a drainage system and a sump pump system to remedy any problems with water below the liner. Thera will be no charge for Conlracior to repair tears or holes in the crawl space encapsulation liner, unless Contracior determines that the tearfhole was caused by abuse or misuse. Sump pumps and crawl space encapsulation systems may be covered under a soparate manufaciurer's warranty. Instaliation of a crawl space encapsidation syslem does not incude extending discharge nes mora than five () foe fom the foundation o elecical work. unless specified. Conlraciar 1 no responlblo for frozen discharge lines, water once itis pumped from the structure, or condensation. The condition of wood located in crawl spaces can be highly variable and can rapidly deteriorate or move as a result of changes In environmental conditions andlor changes In the bulding envelope conditions. Contractor is not responsible for the repair of pre- existing wood damage unless specifically noted In this Contract. 8, PolyRenewal and Expanding Polyurethane Structural Foam. Ce ts that structural foam will fill voids, but will not necossarlly lift Famer slab to meot any crilerla of levelness, Confractor recommends: ‘sealing all cracks and Joints, and Contractor can do so for an additional charge. Contractor rants that the area where the slab of concrete was stabllized will not settle more than % inch for a period of five (5) years from the date of installation. If it does, ‘Contractor will provide the labor and materials to re-inject the area at no additional charge to Customer. This Warranty doss not include pat or or oe between slabs. Customer |s aware that the concrete may not be perfectly level or may not lift at all. Contractor guarantees stabilization, NOT LIFT. Any personal the work area are to be remaved by the Customer prior fo the arrival of the Contractor's crew. This warranty Is void if Customer does not maintaln grade around slal ye and seal joints between slabs. 9. Exclusions. THIS WARRANTY DOES NOT COVER, AND CONTRACTOR SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS LIABILITY FOR: (a) any product or system that is altered in any way; (5) goror waloprooing, c) system damage cased by Cuslomar' nagijanco, miouse, abuse, o alteration; (0) damago, sus, and condiens ncidortal fo nstalaon, incluling dust andl dirt; (6) changes to wood framing syste: () damag to personal properly of any type: (g) unmarkes uty ine breakage: (h) pels ullios and lines (e.g., sprinkler, plumbing, discharge lines, elc.; () damage caused by unforeseen conditions such as mold, asbestos, or lead based paint; ) removal and/or disposal of any hazardous malerials; (k) falure or delay in porformance or damage caused by acts of God (flood, fire, storm, oarthquako, methane gas, etc.) acts of civil or miltary authority, any olher cause outside of Canvacors coir) damage beyond Caniracors conto caused by dy of, comosion, ami nestaton, and subsanderd consirclor; (m} damage dono curing a fing operation; (1) basement wale seepage, urlosa a ul porimolor drainage system hao been installed: (0) heave or any damago caused by it 5) damage caused by lloral movomnts and forces of lle cep 1nd Sing or Spina of oll of deep embarmerts, EXCEPT AS EXPRESSLY SET FORTH, ALL SERVICES, MATERIALS, PARTS AND COMPONENTS PROVIDED BY CONTRACTOR ARE PROVIDED *AS IS* WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, AND CONTRACTOR EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. IS ~ 50f8 A Groundworks Company 58
Page 59
59 Contractors Bid – Page 6 Contractors Bid — Page 6 NOTICE OF CANCELLATION T ion Date: You may cancel this transaction, without penalty or obligation, within 3 business days from the above date. If you cancel, any property traded in, any payments made by you under the Contract or sale, and any negotiable instrument executed by you will be returned within 10 business days following receipt by Contractor of your cancellation notice, and any sacurity interest arising out of the transaction will be canceled. If you cancel, you must make available to Contractor at your residence, in substantially as good condition as when received, any goods delivered to you under this Contract or sale; or you may if you wish, comply with the instructions of Contractor regarding the return shipment of the goods at Contractor's expense and risk. Ifyou do make the goods available to Gontractor and Contractor doos not pick up them up within 20 days of the dato of your notice of cancellation, you may retain or dispose of the goods without any further obligation. If you fail to make the goods available to Contractor or if you agree to return the goods to Contractor and fail to do so, then you remain liable for performance of all obligations under the Contract. To cancel this transaction, mail or deliver a signed and dated copy of this cancellation notice or any other written notice, or send a telegram, to: Foundation Systems of Michigan, LLC at 2817 Bond St., Rochester Hills, MI 48309 not later than midnight of X, . I hereby cancel this transaction. (Date) (Customer's signature) If after three business days the transaction has not been canceled, then the deposit will be non-refundable. fold A Groundworks Company 59
Page 60
60
Contractors Bid – Page 7
Pemits Hotline
Basement Wall Height
[Crawl Wall Height
Shore wall
Contractors Bid — Page 7
DRAWINGS
ay
| FSA
877-DRY-MICH
734-452-8125
734-838-0257
07/03/23
Yes
Sunroom-264 sgit. Indoor Poly
Living room/Kitchen-900 suiy. Indoor Poly
.
Pao
Total-1,164 syit.
ot
24
+
11"
Sunroom
Ns
63
FP
Bedroom
Bath
Poly{Indoor)
Garage
Approx; 30x30
|_|
Mud
TS
/
,
room
|
|
Eq
{
EL
Bodroom#2
i
Master
oa
Fore
5
Driveway
15
E23
= Bubbler Pot
Key for above Dlagram
[)
= Intellidack
= Aquastap & Wall Seal
I
—
Suni Dive argo
'
Furnace
Ll
@B
=
AquaStop Triple Sump Pump
H
SR iTatos
Fo
crawlbrain
2
Cravalspace Encapsulation
Ean
k
©
~Q
Setllesiop Ancor
Pi
mw
Tleetrieal Panel
i
Bl
= setestiop tiie
5
Me
Motor Can
5
Lxtnling Sump
[J
= SettlaStop Carbon Fiber Stray
Es
TS
= transfor Switch
0:2
;
"
AC
=
Air Conditioning
= Supplemental IntelliBrace
IM
= Load Mangement
Kil
1
= Toilet
= Pain Buam R&R
won
Sister Joist
W
= Helical Pior
Foundation Lino
[£6]
= cummins Generator
= Electric Service Meter
he
-Aquastop Als Syztam
riggs & Stratton Generator
Electrical
Linn
+ Existing Beam
lec
trical
Lin
Co
= Gas Lino
= Existing Stanchion
ni
=
151 Story Gutter
= 3rd Story Gutter
= 20d Stury
Gi
tor
Told
A Groundworks Compary
60Page 61
61 Contractors Bid – Page 8 Contractors Bid — Page 8 PAYMENT TERMS We propose y to the services in this Contract for the sum of: Contract Amount $69,346.01 Deposit $14,836.60 Due Upon Completion $44,609.61 Is the project financed? YES No (Financing must be sel up at the time of the signed contract) ApprovallAcoount #. X (initial) - C must be on final day of install and final walk-through is to be performed with the Job foreman. xX. (initial) - Balanoo to be pald In full to foreman on last day of install. (Unless financed) BUYER'S RIGHT TO CANCEL. If the Contract is solicited at Customer's residence, and Customer does not want the goods or servioes, Customer may aancal this transaction at any time prior to midnight of the third business day after the date of this transaction. Additionally, Contractor is prohibited from having an independent courier service or other third party plok up C v's payment at Ci 's residence before the end of the 3- business-day period In which Customer oan cancel the transaction. The notice must be mailed or to: sy of Mi Le at 2817 Bond St., Roohostor Hills, MI 48309. It Customer oanels a homo solioltation sale during the cancellation period listed in this paragraph of the Contract, Contractor must return any payments made by Customer. If Customer does not oanoel the transaction during the cancellation period listed in this paragraph of the Contract, the deposit will be non-refundable. See tho attached Notice of Cancellation form for further explanation of this oanaellation right. Customer Contractor X, X X. Date 7/11/2023 Date 7111/2023 Bald A Groundworks Company 61