26-000989.pdf
Loretta J Klebba Petitioner V Township Of Big Creek Respondent · 26-000989-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
RECEIVED Loretta J. Klebba, 47049 Lauren Court, Van Buren, Ml 48111 (734) 968-7586 OCT 15 2026 ljholstenmailbox@gmail.com MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL. Michigan Tax Tribunal P.0.,Box 30232 Lansing, MI 48909 October 8, 2026 To Whom It May Concern: RE: MTT Docket No. 26-000989 Please consider my position for the 136 Ray Road proposed 2026 taxable value as follows: » The property was was listed and purchased at the current market value of $90,000 in August 2025. ® According to the realtor's market analysis, the estimated Market Value was $85,000 to $95,000. (attached) e The property changed ownership in December 2024 before | purchased it in August 2025. For the previous owner, the taxable value for the 136 Ray Road property was $45,715 for 2025. This amount was an increase of $12,804 in the taxable value from the previous 2024 taxable amount of $32,911. e The 2026 tenative taxable amount for the 136 Ray Road property is $59,300. The increase from the 2025 taxable value to the proposed 2026 taxable value is an increase of $13,585 for the taxable value. ® The National increase in single family home prices has not risen high enough to support an increase of $13,585 for 2026. (see attached chart) In conclusion, | believe that the taxable value for the 136 Ray Road property should be no more than $45,000 for 2026 since the current market value of the property was $90,000. Thank you for your consideration. beta Holehtms oretta J. Klebba cc: James Randy Booth, Supervisor, Big Creek Township Attachments: (6) Realtor's Market Analysis
Page 2
Market Analysis prepared for Gerard A. Klebba and Loretta J. Klebba 47049 Lauren Court Van Buren, Mi 48111 For a property located at 136 W Ray Road Mio, Mi 48647 Prepared By Joseph Sykes State Wide Real Estate 989-826-3292 Cell 989-808-8592
Page 3
Property ID # 001-325-018-60 Legal Description T26N R2E SEC 25 - £14/2 OF $ 1/2 OF § 1/2 OF SW 1/4 OF SE 1/4. EXCW 225". 3.30 A. 3 bedrooms, 2 bath Address 136 Ray Road Mio, Mi 48647 Large Windows Barn, two Sheds Deck Wood Heater, and LP Gas pond Family Room Woodstave 1876 sq ft State Equalized Value (SEV) Current State Equalized Value = $57,500 x2 Total Value= $115,000 Sold Comparables Address List Price | Sold Square Price per Acreage Date Sold Price Feet Sq ft 100 N Galbraith Rd 99,900 91,000 1040 87.5 9 09/04/2024 2395 Park Road 64,900 42,400 1216 34.84 4 10/ 16/2024 450 S Reain Rd 110,000 100,000 1224 81.69 2 03/28/2025 Average 91,600 77,800 1160 68.01 5
Page 4
Oscoda County, Mi
Summary
Parcel Number
~~ 001-325-018:60
Property Address
136 W RAY ROAD
Legal Description
T26N R2E SEC 25- E 1/2 OF § 1/2 OF § 1/2QF SW 1/4 OF SE 1/4, EXC W 225, 3.30 A. M/L.
{Note: The Description ab:
if bg ba sed o
Tax District
001 BIG CREEK TOWNSHIP
Schoot District
68010 MIOAU SABLE SCHOOLS
Property Class
401 RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED
Net Acres
33
Total Acres
33
Homestead %
100
Homestead Date
5/10/1994 12:00:00 AM
Vigyz tdap
Owner
KLEBBA GERARD AG LORETTA J
47049 LAUREN COURY
VAN BUREN,
MI 48111
Date of Last Name Change 8/22/2025
Land
LotArea
3.30Acres
Residential
Floor Area
1,876 sqft
Garage Area
864 5qit
Faundation Size
1,876sqft
Year Built
[1]
Occupancy
Mobile Home
Effective Age
24yrs
Percent Complete
100%
ACw/Separate Ducts
No
Basement Rooms
1st Floor Rooms
2nd Floor Rooms
Bedrooms
Full Bathrooms
Haff Bathrooms
onooo
Valuation
+
Assessed! Building Value
+
Assessed Land Value
=
Assessed Value
Year
2025
2024
2023
2022
2021
Estimated TCV
Basement Area
Year Remodeled
Class
TricLevel
Heat
Wood Stove Add-on
Water
Sewer
Style
8C
Ne
Forced Airw/ Ducts
0
Water Well
Septic
MOBILE
Assessed Value Breakdowns
2025
$31,100
526400
“s57.500
_ Assessed Value
$57.500
$47,700
$38,200
$35,100
$30,900
2024
2023
$0
50
$47,700
$8200
$47,700
$38,200
Total Valuations
State Equalized Value
’
$57,500
$47,700
$38,200
$35,100
"$30,900
2021
Cs
$30,900
$30,900
Taxable Value
$45,745
$32,911
$31,344
$29,852
$28.899Page 5
Year
{click for detail)
.
Season
Total Amount
Total Paid
last
Total Due
W202
Summer
©
343567
$435.67
9/1412
£0.00
@oay
ter
}
$26229
som
N
$282.29
moan
)
or
Summer
N
$42656
$426.56
9/14/2021
$0.00
wu
ne
Winter
$278.73
$278.73
3/12021
$000
Won
BB
summer
$42085
42085
ona020
goo
© 20
)
Winter
$186.69
$186.69
24/2020
$000
a0
oo
CT
summer
$475.81
$4781
912/219
$000
@ os
ee
Winter
$219.56
21956
2/28/2019
$000
EE
’
"Summer
©
gs3952
$539.52
“o/1412018
$0.00
Sales
|
SaleDate
SolePrice
Instrument
_ Grantor
i}
i
Grantee
I
8/21/2025
WD
PALAZZOLO DEBORAHK
KLEBBA GERARD A & LORETTA J
12/14/2024
Tc
CT
BELLOW,
JR THEODORE B
PALAZZOLO DEBORAH K
No data available for the fofiowing modules: Commercial, Agricultural, Extra Features.
#8 SCHNEIDER
2
anoeraTiatPage 6
|Address: TUU N Galbraith Road , Mio, MI; 48647 ( ‘ ] ] ] ) MLS#: 201830812 Provided as a courtesy of : ce : List Price: $99,500 Joseph James Sykes Type: Residential Acreage State Wide Real Estate Mio Status: Closed 10g on rel Prop Type: Residential Mio, MI 48647 Bedrooms: 3 Office - (988) 826-3282 Bathrooms: 2 info@statewidemio.com Gar YIN: Yes Gar Type: Pole Barn Gar Stall: 4 Gar Size: 30x48 pole building Style: Ranch Waterfront: No County: Oscoda Lake/River Other: Construction: HUD Sectional Frontage: None Tax ID 004-035-017-00 #Acres: 9.00 Lot Dim: gl Above SqFt: 1040 Total SqFt: 1040 SqFt Source: County Records School District: Mio/Ausable Ownership Status Owner TownshipiCity/Village: Elmer Subdivision or TR: T27N R2E Realtor.com Type: Residential-Single Family Full Baths 2 Half Baths Q internet Access Cable Public Remarks: 8+/- Acre property with a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home and a large pole building. Mostly open lard surrounded by tall pines. Includes a garden area. Located just outsids of "Amish Country.” The home needs some updating but Is priced fo sell. Supplement Directions: 2 mites N of Mio lo Cherry Creek Rd, Turn left go 2 miles to Galbraith Rd. Turn right and go north fo property. Legal: - 8 330' OF N 1980' OF W 1/2 OF SW 1/4 EXC. § 165' OF W 264". PARC C. 9 A. Showing Instructions: Appointment Only; Showingtime Rooms: Living Room Size: 15x18; Living Room Level: 1st; Dining Room Foundation: Craw! Size: 7x8; Dining Room Level: 1st; Kitchen Size: 7x12; Kitchen Basement Specifics: None Lavel: 1st; Bedroom 1 Size: 9x15; Bedroom 1 Level: 1st; Bedroom 2 [taxes and Possession: Possession: immediate; Association Dues: No Size: 9x9; Bedroom 2 Level: 1st; Bedroom 3 Size: 9x9; Bedroom 3 |HeatinglAir: Forced Air; Propane Level: ist; Bath 1 Type: Full; Bath 1 Level: 1s}; Balh 1 Size: 6x9; Laundry: Main Level Bath 2 Type: Full; Bath 2 Level: 1st; Bath 2 Size: 4x9; Utility Root Water: Welt Size: 6x7 . " Interior Doorwall, Vaulted Ceilings po Sot Years Approx Features: NN N : Appliances Blinds; Gelling Fan; Refrigerator; Range/Oven Extonor Featuros: Don Fixer-Upper; Garden Area; Shed quipmt: Road: Dirt; Maintained Terms: Cash; Conventional Morigage Sigh: Sign: Yos Under Contract Date: ~~ 08/08/2024 Sold Date: 09/04/2024 Sold Price: $91,000 How Sold: Cash Ownership Status: Owner
Page 7
|Address: Z3Ud Fark Koad, Mio, MI; 48647
MLS#:
201831860
Provided as a courtesy of
List Price:
$64,900
Joseph James Sykes
Type:
Residential Acreage
State Wide Real Estate Mio
Status:
Closed
are
Prop Type:
Residential
Mio, Mi 48647
Bedrooms:
2
Office - (869) 826-3292
Bathrooms:
2
Info@@statewidemio.com
Gar YIN:
Yes
Gar Type:
Detached/UN
Gar Stall:
4
Style:
Ranch
Waterfront:
No
County:
Oscoda
Lake/River Other:
Construction:
HUD Sectional
Frontage:
None
Tax ID
001-320-063-00
#Acres:
4.00
Lot Dim:
4 ac
Above SqFt:
1216
Total SqFt;
1216
8qgFt Source:
County Records
School District:
MiofAusable
Ownership Status
Owner
Township/City/Village:
Big Creek
Subdivision or T/R:
T26N R2E
Realtor.com Type:
Residential-Single Family Full Baths
2
Half Baths
[1]
internet Access
Unknown
Public Remarks: MIO/LUZERNE area - Fixer Upper on a nicely wooded 4 acres with a large outbuilding. Great location on a maintained road just a few
minutes drive to the Au Sable river access and shopping in Mio, or supper at the famed Ma Deeters in Luzerne. Bring those handy skillz and add in some
tender loving care to make this a great up north getaway or year round dwelling. CASH AS-IS sale only, power is off, condition of rechanicals unknown.
Vehicle on premises is excluded.
Supplement
Directions: M-72 to south on Mapes Rd to left on Park Rd to properly about a 1/2 mile down on the right.
Legal: T26N R2E SEC 28 - E 1/4 OF N 1/2 OF NW 1/4 OF SW 1/4 Except E 12.5 RDS OF N 12.5 RDS.
Showing Instructions: Lock Box; Vacant; Showingtime
Rooms: Living Room Size: 14x14; Living Room Level: 1st; Dining Room Size:
Foundation:
Craw
combo; Dining Room Level; 1st; Kitchen Size: 14x12; Kitchen Level: 1st;
|Basement
None
Bedroom 1 Size: 12x12; Badroom 1 Level: 1st; Bedroom 2 Size: 12x12;
Specifics:
Bedroom 2 Leva: 1st; Bath 1 Type: Full; Bath 1 Level: 1st; Balh 1 Size:
{Schools:
Elementary School: Mio AuSable; High School: Mio AuSable
8x6; Bath 2 Type: Full; Bath 2 Level: 1st; Balh 2 Size: 6x5
Taxes and
Taxes: 1,019.00; Tax Year: 23/24; Possession: 0 DAYS;
Possession:
Association Dues: No
Heatlng/Alr:
Forced Alr
Laundry:
Main Level
Wator:
Well
Sewer:
Seplic
Age:
Unknown
Exterlor:
Vinyl
Exterior Features:
Fixer-Upper
Road:
Dirt; Maintained
Terms:
Cash
Under Contract Date:
09/26/2024
Sold Date:
10/16/2024
Sold Price:
$42,400
How Sold:
Cash
Ownership Status:
OwnerPage 8
Address: 450 8 Ream Road , Mio, MI ; 48647 MLS#: 201832798 Provided as a courtesy of List Price: $110,000 Joseph James Sykes Type: Residential Lot Stale Wide Real Estate Mio Status: Closed Te Bh Street Prop Type: Residential Mio, Mi 48647 Bedrooms: 4 Office - (989) 826-3202 Bathrooms: 2 info@statewidemio.com Gar YIN: Yes Gar Type: Pole Barn Gar Stall: 2 Style: 1+ Story Waterfront: No County: Oscoda Lake/River Other: Construction: Other Frontage: None Tax ID 001-301-329-00 #Acres: 2.00 Lot Dim: 264x330 Above SqFt: 1224 Total SqFt: 1224 SqFt Source: Old MLS School District: Mio/Ausable Ownership Status Owner Township/City/Village: Big Creek Subdivision or TIR: T26N R2E Realtor.com Type: Residential-Single Family Full Baths 2 Half Baths 0 Internet Access DSL Public Remarks: HOME ON 2 ACRES- Nicely landscaped 2 acres with 4 bedroom, 2 bath home close to the Mio Pond. Close to town yet In a secluded wooded setting. 2 garages gives this home great potential. Newer 34x36 pole bam built in 2022. Newer septic (2019), newer steel roof (2019), updated flooring. Home has lols of character and storage. Covered back deck, RV hook up and large yard. C-650 Supplement Directions: Mio Michigan 48647 Head west on E 8th St toward Morenci Ave £1 56 ft Turn right at the 1st cross sireet onto Morenci Ave © 0.5 mi Continue onto S Mount Tom Rd 17 0,2 mi Tur left toward Pond Dr 73 308 ff Continue onto Pond Dr 13 0.2 mi Tum right onto Ream Rd 1.0.4 mi 450 § Ream Rd Legal: T26N R2E SEC 01 - E 16 RDS OF W 32 RDS OF N 1/2 OF 8 1/2 OF SE 1/4 OF SE 1/4. Showing Instructions: Appointment Only; Call Listing Agent; Showingtime Rooms: Living Room Size: 18x11; Living Room Level: 1st; Dining Room Size: Foundation: Crawl; Stab 10x10; Dining Room Level: 1st; Family Room Size: 10x23; Family Basement Specifics: None Room Level; 1st; Kitchen Size: 10x16; Kitchen Level: 1st; Bedroom 1 Schools: Elementary School: Mio AuSable; High School: Mio Size: 16x10; Bedroom 1 Level; 1st; Bedroom 2 Size: 9x10; Bedroom 2 AuSable Level: 1st; Bedroom 3 Siza: 7x14; Bedroom 3 Level: 1st; Bedroom4 Itaxes and Possession: 30 Days; Association Dues: No Size: 10x16; Bedroom 4 Level: 1st; Bath 1 Type: Full; Bath 1 Level: sl ipgssession: Bath 1 Size: 6x7; Bath 2 Type: Full; Ball 2 Level: 1st; Bath 2 Size: 4x6 HeatingfAlr: Forced Alr; Natural Gas Othor Family Room Laundry: Main Level Rooms: Water: Well interlor Pellet Stove; Tile Floor; Wood Laminate ’ Sewer: Septic; Age: Newer 2019 Features: Age: Unknown Exterior: Vinyl Exterior Features: Deck; Extra Garage; Fence; Landscaped; Pole Building; RV Parking Road: Dirt Terms: Cash; Conventional Mortgage Sign: Sign: Yes Under Contract Date: ~~ 03/21/2025 Sold Date: 03/28/2028 Sold Price: $ 100,000 How Sold: Land Contract Ownership Status: Owner
Page 9
ichigen Doparimant of Treasury. THIS IS NOT A TAX BILL L-440( Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification This form is issued under the authority of Public Act 206 of 1893, Sec. 211.24¢ and Sec.211.34c, as amended. This is a model assessment notice to be used by the local assessor. FROM ASSESSOR PARCEL IDENTIFICATION BIG CREEK TOWNSHIP . PARCEL NUMBER: 001-325-018-60 1175 WEST RYNO ROAD PROPERTY ADDRESS: ’ LUZERNE MI 48636 136 W RAY ROAD , MIO, MI 48647 Do SCHOOL DISTRICT CODE: 68010 OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS/PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: HN EXEMPTIONS Sext+4AUTO*ALL FOR AADC 481 T10 PL #4 % Exempt As "Homeowners Principal Residence": 00% KLEBBA GERARD A JR & LORETTA J % Exempt As "Qualified Agricultural Property": 00% 47049 LAUREN CT VAN BUREN TOWNSHIP, MI 48111-4294 % Exempt As "MBT Industrial Personal”: 00% [eters EH bed El ee ef fe % Exempt As "MBT Commercial Personal" 00% Exempt As "Disabled Veteran or Surviving Spouse”: [7] Yes No Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property™: Oa Yes Xl No Exempt As “Development Property": 0 Yes Xi No LEGAL DESCRIPTION: T26N R2E SEC 25 - E 1/2 OF $172 OF § 1/20F SW 1/4 OF SE 1/4. EXCW 22573 30A ML. ~~ 7 777 ¢ ACCORDING TO MCL 211.34c THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS: 401 Residential PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION IF DIFFERENT: 401 Residential The change in taxable value will increase/decrease your tax bill PRIOR AMOUNT CURRENT CHANGE FROM for the 2026 year by approximately: $561 YEAR: 2025 TENTATIVE AMOUNT PRIOR YEAR 1. TAXABLE VALUE: 45,715 59,300 13,58! 2. ASSESSED VALUE: 57,500 : 59,300 1,80 3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR: . £060 4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV): } 57,500 59,300 1,200 5. WAS THERE A TRANSFER OF OWNERSHIP 18025 THAT RESULTED IN A TAXABLE VALUE UNCAPPING? [X] Yes 0 No 6. Assessor Change Reason(s): i > Market Adjustment Si TE The 2026 Inflation rate Multiplier | is: 1. 027 Questions regarding the Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification may be directed to the Following: Name: Telephone Number: Email Address: JAMES (RANDY) BOOTH (989) 390-0716 JRBOOTHZ427 @GMAIL.COM March Board of Review Appeal Information. The Board of Review will meet at the following dates and times:
Page 10
“#5 WRAY ROAD
MIC, MI 48647
Parcel #001-325-018-60
Property Owner: KLEBBA GERARD A & LORETTA J
Owner and Taxpayer Information
KLEBBA GERARD A & LORETTA J
Taxpayer
SEE OWNER INFORMATION
Owner
47049 LAUREN COURT
VAN BUREN, M1 48111
~
General Information for Tax Year 2026
Property Class
401 RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED
Unit
001 BIG CREEK TOWNSHIP
School District
MIO AU SABLE SCHOOLS
Assessed Value
$59,300
Map Number
No Data to Display.
{Taxable Value
$59,300
User Number index
0
State Equalized Value
$59,300
User Alpha 1
No Data to Display
Date of Last Name Change
08/22/2025
User Alpha 3
No Data to Display
|
Notes
Not Available
Historical District
No
i
[Census Block Group
No Data to Display
User Alpha 2
No Data to Display
|
Exemption
)
No Data to Display
Principal Residence Exemption Information
Effective Date
05/10/1994
'
Principal Residence Exemption
Jun
2026
0.00
Previous Year Information
Year
MBOR Assessed
Final SEV
2025
ee
rere
ee
—
Co SIB00
en SSTE00
2024
)
-
]
$47,700
12023
$38,200
Land Information
~~
Zoning Code
|
[Total Acres
3.300
Land Value
$35,800
|
Land Improvements
$0
Renaissance Zone
~__No
‘Renaissance Zone Expiration Date:
No Data to Display
ECF Neighborhood
ECF'S FOR STUDY
Mertgage Code
No Data to Display
Lot Dimensions/Comments
No Data to Display
Neighborhood Enterprise Zone
No
Lot(s)
Frontage
No lots found.
_—
ee
a
]
—
N
Total Frontage: 0.00 ft on
»
_
Legal Description
T76N RZE SEC 25 - E 1)2 OF S 1/2 OF § 1/2 OF SW 1/4 OF SE 1/4. EXC W 225" 3.30 A, M/L.
Land Division Act Information
[Date of Last Split/Combine
No Data to Display
Number of Splits Left
Not Available
Date Form Filed
No Data to Display
Unallocated Div.s of Parent
Not Available
Date Created
No Data to Display
i
Unallocated Div.s Transferred
Not Available
iAcreage of Parent
0.00
i
Rights Were Transferred
No
Split Number
Q
i
Courtesy Split
No
{Parent Parcel
No Data to Display
;
Sale HistoryPage 11
Sale Date
Grantor
Grantee
Sale Price instrument
Terms of Sale
08/21/2025
$90,000.00 WD
PALAZZOLO DEBORAH K
KLEBBA GERARD A & LORETTA J
03-ARM'S LENGTH
12/11/2024
$1.00 QC
BELLOW, JR THEODORE B
PALAZZOLO DEBORAH K
21-NOT USED/OTHER
Building Information - 1876 sq ft MOBILE (Residential)
General
-
Fioor Area
1,876 sq ft
Estimated TOV
$54,271
Garage Area
864 sq ft
Basement Area
Osqgft
Foundation Size
1,876 sq ft
Year Built
No Data to Display
{Year Remodeled
No Data to Display
Occupancy
Mobile Home
Class
BC
Effective Age
24 yrs
Tri-Level
Ne
Percent Complete
100%
Heat
Forced Air w/ Ducts
‘AC w/Separate Ducts
No
Waod Stove Add-on
No
Basement Rooms
0
Water
Water Well
“st Floor Rooms
0
Sewer
Septic
2nd Floor Rooms
0
Style
MOBILE
Bedrooms
[¢]
Exterior information
N
Brick Veneer
Osqft
-
Stone Veneer
Osqft
Basement Finish
.
Recreation
0sqft
Recreation % Good
0%
Living Area
Osqft
Living Area % Good
0%
Walk Out Doors.
0
No Concrete Floor Area
_Osqft
Basement Finish - Mobile Home Items
_
_
_
Foundation Type
Crawlspace
Square Feet of Wall
Osqft
[Frost Free Footings
0 Lineal Ft,
Plumbing information
3 Fixture Bath
2
Garage Information
Area
864 sq ft
Exterior
Siding
[Foundation
18 inch
Common Wall
Detached
Year Built
No Data to Display
Finished
No
Auto Doors
]
Mech Doors
jo]
_
Deck Information
Treated Wood
204 sq ftPage 12
Our refreshed BSA Online page goes live April 1st. Be sure to check it out! Details can be found at: https://info.bsasoftware.com/ct- resources/updates/bsao 136 W RAY ROAD MIO, MI 48647 (Property Address) Parcel Number. 001-325-018-60 comer Property Owner: PALAZZOLO DEBORAH K i ’ Summary Information ’ To Te i > Residential Building Summary > Assessed Value: $57,500 | Taxable Value: $45,715 : No Images Found «Year Built: N/A - Bedrooms: H - Full Baths 2 - Half Baths: 0 | - 3g Feet 1876 - Acres: 3308 Cwaer and Taxpayer Information | Owner PALAZZOLO DEBORAH K Taxpayer SEE OWNER INFORMATION 34997 QUAIL TRAIL General information for Tax Year 2025 | PropertyClass _ _ 401RESIDENTIALIMPROVED Unit School District MIO AU SABLE SCHOOLS A Map Number No Dota to Display User Number Index "No Data to Display Historical Di istrict Census Block Group User Alpha 2 Exemption Principal Residence Exemption Information - Effective Date oo... 05/10/1994 Principal Residence Exemption June ist | Final 2024 100.0000 % : 6.0000 % Previous Year Information vear | Final SEV Final Taxable 2024 $32,911 $31,344 $29,852 Co Total Acres 3300 - La $52,800 d - . i. - Renaissance Zone Expiration No Data to Display
Page 13
Act Information ] Date of Last Spiit/Combine No Dota to Display Number of Splits Left Not Available Date Form Filed No Data to Disp Date Created Acreage of Parent Unallocated, Divs Transferred Not Avaliable Rights Were Transferred No Courtesy Split _ f ; R i : Sale Date i Sale Price ! Instrument Grantor “ | Liber/Page | Comments 24-02977 12/11/2024 $1.00 | aC | BELLOW, JR Building Information - 1876 sq ft MOBILE (Residential) | General Floor Area .. 1876sgft Poe Percent Complete Forced Airw/ Ducts AC w/Separate Ducts _No 1st Floor Rooms _ Nn 2nd Floor Rooms Exterlor Information Brick Veneer Basement Finish ut ing Area % Good No Concrate Floor Are Basement Finish - Mobile Home ltems Foundation Type Crawlspace Footings Olineal ft Plumbing Information 3fixtureBath ~ Garage information Area en — Foundation ~ _ Common Wall Year Built Finished Deck Informction TreatedWood __ 4sqft
Page 14
20.0% 18.0% 16.0% 14.0% 12.0% 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% “2.0% -4.0% 6.0% -8.0% Source: FHFA 2016Q2 6.2% 2017Q2 House Price Appreciation Over Previous Four Quarters for U.S. Purchase-Only FHFA HPI® (Seasonally Adjusted, Nominal) through 2026Q2 6.1% 4 54% ) i 48% 2018Q2 2019Q2 5.6% 17.3% 16.6% 2.8% 57% 3.1% | [| mn 2020Q2 2021Q2 2022Q2 2023Q2 2024Q2 2025Q2 2026Q2
Page 15
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON |. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Loretta J, Klcbba MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL Petitioner(s) MTT Docket No.2 6 = DO) 95°F Township of (Bie Creek Respondent(s) PROOF OF SERVICE velba 3. Klebba, states thaton |O ~~ 240 2.¢ helshe [Name of person serving/mailing petition] [date of service] Ura Wp served a copy of the Narrat we A relative to the above-captioned matter upon: Atlach nae ts [Provide name and address of the party/people being served] James Hand Bact GI Crepe Tassie LTB West Ryno Road Luzerne, MT H863¢ Smeets Z foddo [Signature of perséfi who is serving/mailing copy] Lore ta oa AK lebhe [Print/type name of person serving/mailing copy]
Page 16
[ore was alanis JU fi ally! Heli, “A704 ER ST i en aU Va gEmm— Gif chs / gar? 0, Loy 7 i wns.