420 Lahser Rd Property Tax Appeal.pdf
George Barbu Petitioner V Township Of Bloomfield Respondent · 26-002397-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION 2026 PROPERTY TAX APPEAL Property Address: 420 Lahser Rd Bloomfield Hills, MI 48301 Parcel Number: C-19-27-351-003 Petitioners: George I. Barbu & Maria Barbu Respondent: Bloomfield Township SUMMARY OF APPEAL The March 2026 Board of Review reduced the State Equalized Value (SEV) of the subject property from $495,150 to $460,210. While Petitioners appreciate the Board’s adjustment, the revised SEV still implies a market value of approximately $920,420. Petitioners respectfully submit that this value exceeds both: • Comparable sales evidence within Bloomfield Township; • Bloomfield Township’s own estimated True Cash Value (TCV) of approximately $752,066; and • Current market activity for comparable ranch-style homes. The evidence submitted demonstrates that the subject property’s market value is more accurately reflected by a True Cash Value of approximately $752,000. Accordingly, Petitioners request that the Tribunal: • Establish a True Cash Value of $752,000; • Establish a corresponding State Equalized Value of $376,000; and • Adjust the Taxable Value accordingly. Submitted in support of Petitioners’ appeal for the 2026 tax year. Respectfully submitted, George I. Barbu and Maria Barbu 420 Lahser Rd Bloomfield Hills, MI 48301
Page 2
MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION NARRATIVE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF PETITION Property Address: 420 Lahser Rd Bloomfield Hills, MI 48301 Parcel Number: C-19-27-351-003 Petitioners: George I. Barbu & Maria Barbu Respondent: Bloomfield Township I. INTRODUCTION Petitioners respectfully request review of the 2026 assessment for the subject property. The March 2026 Board of Review reduced the State Equalized Value from $495,150 to $460,210. While Petitioners appreciate the reduction, the revised SEV still implies a market value of approximately $920,420. Petitioners submit that this value remains above market-supported value. Based on comparable sales, Township valuation records, and recent 2025–2026 ranch sales, Petitioners request a 2026 True Cash Value of $752,000 and corresponding SEV of $376,000. II. SUBJECT PROPERTY The subject property is a single-family ranch residence located at 420 Lahser Rd. Key characteristics: • Year built: 1952 • Total living area: approximately 2,422 sq ft • Lot size: approximately 0.398 acres • Remodeled and expanded in 2024 • Effective age shown by Township: 14 years • Township estimated TCV: approximately $752,066
Page 3
III. BOARD OF REVIEW ADJUSTMENT The Board of Review reduced the SEV from $495,150 to $460,210. The revised SEV implies: $460,210 × 2 = $920,420 Petitioners submit that this remains materially above market-supported value. IV. COMPARABLE SALES EVIDENCE Primary comparable sales previously submitted: • 1257 Charrington Rd – $650,000 • 1490 Charrington Rd – $725,000 • 6151 Golfview Dr – $780,000 Additional recent market evidence: • 125 S Cranbrook Cross Rd sold October 8, 2025 for $580,000. It is a remodeled 1959 ranch with 1,820 sq ft, 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, and a 15,682 sq ft lot. • 580 S Cranbrook Rd sold April 2, 2026 for $475,000. It is a 1957 ranch with 1,306 sq ft, 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, and a 10,019 sq ft lot. • 174 Hillboro Dr sold April 27, 2026 for $895,000 and is treated as a superior upper-bound indicator. The recent 2025–2026 sales show that remodeled or updated ranch-style homes in the subject market are not supporting a value near $920,420. Even the superior Hillboro sale closed below the current implied value of the subject property. V. TOWNSHIP VALUATION RECORD Bloomfield Township’s own BS&A property record identifies an estimated True Cash Value of approximately $752,066. This is substantially below the $920,420 market value implied by the post-Board of Review SEV.
Page 4
Petitioners respectfully submit that the Township’s own BS&A property record estimates a True Cash Value of approximately $752,066, which is substantially below the market value implied by the post-Board of Review assessment. VI. ECF AND EFFECTIVE AGE OBSERVATION The Township record shows the subject property has an effective age of 14 years, meaning the Township has already recognized the 2024 remodeling and addition. The subject property is also assigned to ECF Area 27150 Ranches. The Township’s ECF study shows this ECF area is based on a single sale, 3624 Tuckahoe Rd, producing an ECF of 2.58758. Petitioners do not challenge the Township’s use of approved assessing methodology. However, when a cost-model result produces an implied value materially above actual market sales and the Township’s own estimated TCV, the sales comparison approach should be given greater weight. VII. VALUE CONCLUSION The evidence supports the following: • Board of Review already reduced the original assessment. • Current SEV still implies approximately $920,420 in market value. • Township’s own estimated TCV is approximately $752,066. • Recent 2025–2026 ranch sales support values below the current implied assessment. • Even the superior Hillboro sale closed below the current implied value. Petitioners respectfully request that the Tribunal establish: True Cash Value: $752,000 State Equalized Value: $376,000 Taxable Value: Adjusted accordingly Respectfully submitted, George I. Barbu Maria Barbu 420 Lahser Rd Bloomfield Hills, MI 48301
Page 5
EXHIBIT 1 BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION
Page 6
EXHIBIT 2 BS&A PROPERTY RECORD (Refer TCV from township on page 3)
Page 7
General Information for Tax Year 2026 A Property Class 401 RESIDENTIAL-IMPKGVED School District BIRMINGHAM CITY SCHOOL DIST IT POST TT — x WBpradpttaiuing to use thivowelastdispyagree to the . User Alpha 3 No Data to Display Historical District No User Alpha 2 No Data to Display Unit C Township of Bloomfield Assessed Value $460,210 Taxable Value $412,880 State Equalized Value $460,210 Date of Last Name Change 12/02/2020 Notes Not Available Census Block Group No Data to Display Exemption No Data to Display Principal Residence Exemption Information Effective Date 10/03/2017 Principal Residence Exemption June 1st Final 2026 100.0000% 100.0000% Previous Year Information Year MBOR Assessed Final SEV Final Taxable 2025 $234,860 $234,860 $213,830 2024 $234,060 $234,060 $207,410 2023 $204,320 $204,320 $197,540 Land Information A Zoning Code SI Land Value $229,560 Renaissance Zone No ECF Neighborhood E.C.F. Table 27150Village/Ranch Lot Dimensions/Comments No Data to Display Total Acres 0.398 Land Improvements $0 Renaissance Zone . Expiration Date No Data to Display Mortgage Code 00000 Neighborhood Enterprise N Io Zone Lot(s) Frontage Depth No lots found. Total Frontage: 0.00 ft Average Depth: 0.00 ft Legal Description A T2N, R10E, SEC 27 JUDSON BRADWAY'S BLOOMFIELD VILLAGE NO. 4 SLY PART OF LOT 965, SAME BEING 25 FT ON FRONT & 17 FT ON REAR, ALSO ALL OF LOT 966 https:/fbsaonline.com/SiteSearch/PropertyDetails?SearchType=0...-27-351-003&RecordKey=C+-19-27-351-003&RecordKeyType=0 6/9/26, 10:05 PM Page 2 of 5
Page 8
Land Division Act Information A Date of Last Split/Combine No Data to Display Date Form Filed No Data to Display Date Created No Data to Display Acreage of Parent 0.00 Split Number 0 Parent Parcel No Data to Display Number of Splits Left Not Available Unallocated Div.s of Parent Not Available Unallocated Div.s Transferred Not Available Rights Were Transferred No Courtesy Split No Sale History A Sale Date Sale Price Instrument ~~ Grantor Grantee Terms of Liber/Page ~~ Comments Sale 08/16/2017 $300,000.00 WD ALICE BARBU 22-OUTLIER 50991:850 ELIZABETH GEORGE | TODD TR 02/27/2014 $0.00 QC TODD, RALPH BETSY 08-ESTATE 46829121 in trust-sole TODD beneficiary AGRMNT OF TR Building Information - 2422 sq ft Ranch (Residential) A General Floor Area 2,422 sq ft Garage Area 490 sq ft Foundation Size 2,401sq ft Estimated TCV $752,066 Basement Area 1,720 sq ft Year Built 1952 Occupancy Single Family Effective Age 1ayrs Percent Complete 100% AC w/Separate Ducts No Year Remodeled No Data to Display Class C-5 Tri-Level No Heat Forced Heat & Cool Wood Stove Add-on No Basement Rooms 1 1st Floor Rooms 7 2nd Floor Rooms 0 Bedrooms 4 Water No Data to Display Sewer No Data to Display Style Ranch https:/fbsaonline.com/SiteSearch/PropertyDetails?SearchType=0...-27-351-003&RecordKey=C+-19-27-351-003&RecordKeyType=0 6/9/26, 10:05 PM Page 30f 5
Page 9
Area Detail - Basic Building Area Height Foundation Exterior Area Heated 1Story Basement Siding/Brick 1,720 sq ft 1 Story 1Story Crawl Space Siding 440 sq ft 1 Story 1Story Slab Siding 2415sq ft 1Story Area Detail - Overhangs Area Story Height Exterior Included in Size for Rates 21sq ft 1Story Siding No Exterior Information Brick Veneer 0sqft Stone Veneer 0sq ft Basement Finish Recreation 0sq ft Living Area 0sq ft Walk Out Doors 0 Recreation % Good 0% Living Area % Good 0% No Concrete Floor Area 0sqft Plumbing Information 3 Fixture Bath 3 Extra Sink 1 Ceramic Tub Alcove 1 2 Fixture Bath 1 Ceramic Tile Floor 3 Built-In Information Dishwasher 1 Vented Hood 1 Standard Range 1 Garbage Disposal 1 Microwave 1 Fireplace Information Dishwasher 1 Vented Hood 1 Standard Range 1 Garbage Disposal 1 Microwave 1 Garage Information https://bsaonline.com/SiteSearch/PropertyDetails?SearchType=0...-27-351-003&RecordKey=C+-19-27-351-003&RecordKeyType=0 6/9/26, 10:05 PM Page 4 of 5
Page 10
Area 490 sq ft Foundation 42 Inch Year Built 1952 Auto Doors 1 Exterior Brick Common Wall 1 Wall Finished No Mech Doors 0 Porch Information (CGEP (1Story) 202 sq ft [Foundation Standard Deck Information [Composite 277 sqft https://bsaonline.com/SiteSearch/PropertyDetails?SearchType=0...-27-351-003&RecordKey=C+-19-27-351-003&RecordKeyType=0 6/9/26, 10:05 PM Page 5 of 5
Page 11
EXHIBIT 3 COMPARABLE SALES SUMMARY Subject Property: 420 Lahser Rd Bloomfield Hills, MI 48301 Living Area: 2,422 SF Year Built: 1952 Remodeled and Expanded: 2024 Property Address Sale Price Purpose 1257 Charrington Rd $650,000 Lower Indicator 1490 Charrington Rd $725,000 Most Comparable Sale 6151 Golfview Dr $780,000 Upper Indicator 125 S Cranbrook Cross Rd $580,000 Remodeled Ranch (2024 Renovation) 174 Hillboro Dr $895,000 Superior Upper-Bound Sale Summary The Charrington and Golfview sales represent the strongest comparable sales identified and support values generally within the mid-$700,000 range. 125 S Cranbrook Cross Rd sold on October 8, 2025 for $580,000. The property underwent substantial renovation in 2024 and provides additional evidence regarding market pricing for renovated ranch-style homes within the subject market area. 174 Hillboro Dr sold on April 27, 2026 for $895,000. This property reflects a superior renovation level, condition, and overall market position and therefore serves as an upper-bound market indicator rather than a direct comparable sale. Even the superior Hillboro sale closed at $895,000, below the approximately $920,420 market value implied by the current assessment.
Page 12
EXHIBIT 4 COMPARABLE SALES RECONCILIATION Subject Property: 420 Lahser Rd Bloomfield Hills, MI 48301 Living Area: 2,422 SF Remodeled and Expanded: 2024 Item Subject 1257 Charrington Rd 1490 Charrington Rd 6151 Golfview Dr 174 Hillboro Dr Sale Price — $650,000 $725,000 $780,000 $895,000 Living Area 2,422 SF 2,486 SF 2,277 SF 2,317 SF Superior Relative Condition Remodeled + Addition (2024) Inferior Similar Slightly Superior Superior Location Influence Typical Similar Similar Superior Superior Market Position Subject Lower Indicator Best Comparable Upper Indicator Upper-Bound Sale Value Indication — $700,000– $735,000 $725,000– $775,000 $740,000– $800,000 $850,000– $895,000 * = Added Comp to the initial Bloomfield Township Board Appeal
Page 13
Supporting Market Evidence 125 S Cranbrook Cross Rd sold for $580,000 on October 8, 2025. The property is a 1,820-square-foot ranch residence built in 1959 that underwent substantial renovation in 2024. This sale provides additional market evidence regarding pricing for renovated ranch-style homes in the subject market area. Market Reconciliation The strongest indicators of value are 1257 Charrington Rd, 1490 Charrington Rd, and 6151 Golfview Dr. These properties are most comparable to the subject in terms of living area, overall utility, age, and market position. 174 Hillboro Dr represents the upper end of the local market and reflects a superior renovation level and condition. Even this superior property sold below the approximately $920,420 market value implied by the current assessment. Reconciled Market Value Range $725,000 – $800,000 Requested Value Support The requested True Cash Value of $752,000 is not an arbitrary figure. It corresponds closely to Bloomfield Township’s own estimated True Cash Value of $752,066 and falls within the market value range supported by the comparable sales presented herein. Conclusion The comparable sales evidence demonstrates that the current assessment implies a market value materially above observed market transactions. The most comparable sales support a value in the mid-$700,000 range, while Bloomfield Township’s own property record estimates a True Cash Value of approximately $752,066. Accordingly, Petitioners respectfully request that the Michigan Tax Tribunal establish:Accordingly, Petitioners respectfully request that the Michigan Tax Tribunal establish: True Cash Value: $752,000 State Equalized Value: $376,000 Taxable Value: Adjusted accordingly.
Page 14
EXHIBIT 5 PRIMARY COMP SHEETS Property Details submitted with Board of Appeals submission (March 2026) • 1257 Charrington Rd – $650,000 • 1490 Charrington Rd – $725,000 • 6151 Golfview Dr – $780,000 • 174 Hillboro Dr – $850,000 Pending (Sold after board appeal for $895,000) Additional Comp included: • 125 S Cranbrook Cross Rd – $580,000
Page 15
1257 Charrington Road, Bloomfield Hills 48301-2116 fos gum BE gE Soom MR Ne mm (g Status: Sold ERTS/Fs 650; Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp:2.5 Acreage: 0.55 City: Bloomfield HillsGrg Sz: 2.5Car LotDim: 150X160.01 Malling City: ~~ Bloomfield HillsGrg Dim: 0 Rd Front Ft:150 Side of St Grg Feat: ched School Di Birmingham Location: quarton & lahser Directions: north on lahser & east on quarton Square Footage Layout Sqft Source: public Records gods: 3 Name: ABBY KUSHNER 486 Baths: 21 Phone: (248) 854-7875 4STot L pred Ranch ot Lower: : 85086 Fin: Meh Ii 1'story + Site Desc: Waterfront Information WErfrnt Name: Year Built: 1956 Water Facilitie Year Remod: Water Features Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Listing Date: 08/15/2025 List Type/Level Of Service:Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 08/15/2025 Srvcs Offered: Arrange /Present Offers, on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: ~~ 08/15/2025 Off Mkt Date: 08/15/2025 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 180 Restrictions: No Exclusions: No Possession: At Close Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20251026232 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation: Basement I: Block Partially Finished Ending Brick Cooling: Natural Gas, Forced Air Road: oth Sewer: Paved Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Level Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Flooring First/Entry6 x 11 Bath - Lav First/Entry4 x Ceramic First/Entry11 x 4 Bedroom First/Entry13 x 13 First/Entry13 x 9 Carpet Bedroom - Primary ~~ First/Entry18 x 13 First/Entry22 x 12 Kitchen First/Entry12 x 21 First/Entry16 x 16 Three Season Room First/Entry14 x 12 Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID 1927176005 Subdivision: Morningside Heights Ownership: Standard (Private) Occupant: Owner Tax Summer: $4,330 Tax Winter: $3,487 Homestead: Yes Oth/Sp Asmnt: SEV: $308,970 Taxable Value: $208,250 Existing Lease:No Home Warranty:No Legal Desc T2N, R10E, SEC 27 MORNINGSIDE HEIGHTS LOT 36 Agent/Office Information List Office: @properties Christie's Int'l R.E. Birminghas List Office Ph:(248) 850-8632 List Agent: ABBY KUSHNER |g List Agent Ph:(248) 854-7875 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment Sold Information LB Location: Sold Date: 08/15/25 Sold Price: 650,000 Short Sale: 3rd Party Appr: Phance Code: Cash Sale SP/SaFt Abv: Selling Office: 's Int’ gham Selling Agent: Cheryl F Riback Co-Selling Agent: Sell Concessions: No Sell Concession Comments: Notices and Disclaimers No $261 248)808-3112 1.Through thisplatform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker c broker services are free or available at no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be received; or (Iv) make an) ; (ih) (f rh lon limited to or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative. ANY DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE INMEGIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP If LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. missions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3 Tre ctcinaty of oi oemation rancmized hevemith, sSoartiess of source, though deemed relale, I not 7 Copyright® Realcomp IT Ltd All Rights Reserved. or should be ly verified.
Page 16
1490 Charrington Road, Bloomfield Hills 48301-2119 MLS#: 20251004015 Area 02193 - Bloomfield Twp Short Sale: No o Plype: Residential DO 70/0 Trans Type: Sale otf: 73 888 Status: Sold RTS/FS SP: $725,000 Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 5 Acrea 0.49 City: rg r Lot Dim: 141x122x153x161 Mailing City: ~~ Bloomfield HillsGrg Dim: attached Rd Front Ft:141 Side of St Grg Feat: School Dr Birmingham JE of Lah : rton / E of Lahser Directions: Sof ebeed / E of Lahser Square Footage Layout Sqft Source: ~ public Records eds: Name: LOGAN WERT Est Fin Ab Gr:2,277 Baths: 2.0 Phone: (248) 320-1142 Est Fin Lower: Rooms: 7 Est Tot Lower: 2,277 Arch sty: Ranch Est TotFin: 2,277 Arch Lvl: 1 Story Price/Sqft: $318.4 Site Desc: Waterfront Information WERE Name: Water Facilities: Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Year Built Year Remod: 1956 Listing Date: 05/28/2025 List Type/Level Of Service: Exclusive Right to Sell /Full Service Activation Date: 06/03/2025 Srves Offered: Arrange A /Present Offers, on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 05/28/2025 Off Mkt Date: 05/28/2025 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: @ Protect Period: 180 R No Exclusions: No Possession: Negotiable Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20251004015 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation: Slab Fndtn Material: Exterior: Brick, Vinyl Cnstret Feat: Porch Typ Patio Appliance: , DI Dryer, Fr Gas R Fr Refrigerator, Microwave, Washer Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Wir Hur Fuel: Natural Gas Road: Paved Water Source: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Flooring Level Flooring th - Full First/Entry First/Entry Bedroom First/Entry14 x 14 First/Entry13 x 13 Bedroom - Primary First/Entry16 x 13 Dining Room First/Entry15 x 15 Great Room First/Entry20 x 15 Kitchen First/Entry20 x 15 Living Room First/Entry20 x 15 Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 1927126003 Subdivision: ~~ Morningside Heights Ownership Standard (Private) Owner Tax Summer: $5,228 Tax Winter: $4,209 : Yes SEV: $296,950 Taxable Value: $296,950 Existing Lease:No Home Warranty:No Legal Desc: T2N, R10E, SEC 27 MORNINGSIDE HEIGHTS LOT 22 Agent/Office Information List Office: DOBI Real Esta List Agent: LOGAN C WERT [if Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox List Office Ph:(248) 385-3350 248) 320-1142 Remarks Public Listing listed and sold same day. Remarks: Sold Information Sold Date: 3rd05/28/25 Sold Price: $725,000 Short Sale: No SP/LP:100.00% Party Api Finance Code: CONV Sale SP/SqFt Abv: $318 SP/OLP:100.00% Selling ~~ Office DORI Raat Estate Selling Office Ph:(248)385-3350 Selling ~~ Ages Selling Agent Ph:(248)891-3204 Co-Selling Agent: Sell Concessions: Sell Concession Comments: Notices and Disclaimers Co-Seliing Agt Ph: 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker sensation from any source will be received; or (iv) make any concession Toe FORE ING SHOULD BE INMEBIATLLY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY 70 REALCOMS If LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. commissians are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3 Ti ocr oF Epemution aman herein, Furs of soures, Wisogh doomed sefobl, ir sot or 1 All pe unless no financial DISCOVERED VIOLATN Copyright® Realcomp IT Ltd All Rights Reserved. should be verified. er compensation; (1) disclose broker compensation; (1) represent brokerage services are free or avaiable a no cost fo or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative.
Page 17
6151 Golfview Drive, Bloomfield Hills 48301-2064 MLS#: 20251005606 Area: 02193 - Bloomfield Twp Short Sale: No pe: Residential Dom: N/8/8 Trans Type: Sale Status: Sold ERTS/Fs Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 2.4 Acreage: 0.41 City: Bloomfield HillsGrg Sz: 2car Lot Dim: 120X150 Mailing City: ~~ Bloomfield HillsGrg Dim: Rd Front Ft:120 Side of Str: E Grg Feat: Side Entrance, Electricity, Door Opener, Attached, Basement School Dist: Bloomfield Hills Access, Detvoway Location: North off Maple, West of Lahser Directions: Golfview runs north off Maple Road, West of Lahser Square Footage :— Layout Cabal Lafazratizn Public Records Beds: 3 Name: SHONDELL PATTERSON Est Fin Abv Gr:2,317 Baths: 3.0 Phone: (248) 765-0308 Est Fin Low Rooms: 8 Est Tot Lower: 2,100 Arch Sty: Ranch EstTotfin: 2,317 Arch Lvl: 1 Story Price/Sqft: $323.69 Sie Desc:On Golf Course (Golf Frontage), Sprinkler(s) Waterfront Information General Information Werfrnt Name Year Built: 1953 Water Fact Water Features Water Frt Feet: Year Remod:2000 Listing Information Listing Date: Activation Date: Pending Date: Land DWP: Protect Period: Terms Offered: Listing Exemptions: Pets Allowed: Exterior: 06/06/2025 List Type/Level Of Service: Exclusive Right to Sall/Pul Service Arrange Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, 06/13/2025 d /13/; Srves Offered: Neo for Seller 06/26/2025 Off Mkt Date: 06/26/2025 "BMK Date: 07/07/2025 Contingency Date: . Land Int Rate: ~~ % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: 120 Restrictions: Exclusions: Possession: At Close Cash, Conventional MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20251005606 tures Entry Location: Ground Level Crawl, Basement Fndtn Material: Block Unfinished Chimney Cap(s), Lighting, Fenced Brick, Vioyt Deck, Patio Cnstret Feat: Asphalt Fireplace Loc: Library, Living Room overs one: Back Yard Vented Exhaust Fan, Built-In Electric Oven, Con Dryer, Electric C Electric Oven, Free-Standing Gas Oven, Free-Standing Ratrigerator, Ice Maker, Microwave, Self Cleaning Oven, Washar Smoke Alarm, 220 Volts, High Spd Internet Avail, Humidifi Thermostat Natural Gas, Forced Air Natural Gas Public (Municipal) Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Elaoring Room Level Dimen Elooring Bath - Full First/Entry8 x 7 Ceramic Bath - Full First/Entry® x 5 Ceramic Bath - Primary First/Entry15 x 15 Wood Bedroom First/Entry12 x 11 Wood Bedroom First/Entry11 x 11 Carpet Bedroom - Primary ~~ First/Entry10 x 6 Ceramic Dining Room First/Entry10 x 12 Wood Family Room First/Entry17 x 13 Carpet Kitchen First/Entry17 x 17 Ceramic Library (Study) First/Entry17 x 14 Ceramic Living Room First/Entry13 x 21 Wood Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 1928476005 Subdivision: Oakland Hills Country Club 1 Ownership: Standard (Private) Occupant Owner Tax Summer: $3,277 Tax Winter: $2,639 Homestea Yes Oth/Sp Asmnt: SEV: $328,740 Taxable Value: $328,740 Existing Lease:No Home Warranty:Ne Legal Desc: T2N, R10E, SEC 28 & 33 OAKLAND HILLS COUNTRY CLUB SUB NO.1 LOT 226 & S 1/2 OF LOT 227 Homeowner Association Information Assoc Fee Amt: 800 Working Capital: It n Contact) : Patterson Fee Frequency: Annually Association Phone\Email: 248.765.0308 Fee Includes: Agent/Office Information List Office: Crain Homes List Office Ph:(248) 940-5510 List Agent: SHONDELL PATTERSON = List Agent Ph:(248) 765-0308 Co-list Agent: ~~ KAITLYN KRAMER [ff Co-List Agent Ph:(248) 318-8151 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/Key LB Location: Front Door Remarks Public Located across from the 7th tee of Oakland Hills, this sought-after ranch sits on nearly a half of g . ONE Remarks: DAY SHOWINGS ON SUNDAY, 6/15/25. ALL OF! Y TUESDAY, 6/17/25. This ome a living room with a dual-sided fireplace that opens to a cozy den with radiant heated fare. The expansive famiy room that leads to a brand new Trex style deck. The large cherry kitchen offers g Enjoy beautiful rdens with a drip irrigation m, and wind on the front brick paver patio with Unobsiruceed sunset ny Sol Soiree Viawa. Siew HUACS tn 3034. rip Irrigation syste a = REALTOR® All offers due on 6/17/25. No L must yall Remarks: Sold Information Sold Date: 07/30/25 Sold Price: $780,000 Short Sale: No SP/LP:104.00% 3rd Party Appr: No Finance Code: ~~ CONV Sale SP/Saft Abv: $337 SP/OLP:104.00% Selling Office: Brookside Realty Company Selling Office Ph:(248)430-8888 Selling Agent: Luis Suarez Selling Agent Ph:(586)744-8762 Co-Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agt Ph:
Page 18
174 Hillboro Drive, Bloomfield Hills 48301-3314 42 Are 2026101 92193 - Bloomfield Tw Short Sale: No : Resident N77 ? Frans Type: Sale offi §836:888 @ Pending ERTS/FS Location Information Garage: Yes County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp:2.0 0.37 Bloomfield HillsGrg Sz: 2car © 115x141 Mailing City: omfield HillsGrg Dim: Rd Front Ft:115 Side of Str: Grg Feat: Direct Access, Attached School Dist: m Location s ple Road W of Cranbrook Road Diractions: South on Westbourne off Maple, West on Hillboro Square Footage Layout Cantact Information Sqft Source: ~ public Records : 3 Name: TRACEY FREEMAN Est Fin Abv Gr:2,488 2.2 Phone: (248) 772-1997 £5 Fn Cowerrioses. 8 E5568: Lower: . Ranch 850531 Fin: Arch Lvl: 1 Story $34Y Br: Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information WErTRE Name: Year Built: 1957 Water Facilities: Year Remod:2019 Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Recent CH: 03/08/2026 : PEND : ACTV->PEND Listing Information Listing Date: 03/01/2026 List Type/Level Of Service:Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 03/03/2026 Srves Offered: Amn nge, Appoints ntments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Pending Date: 03/08/2026 Off Mkt Date: 03/08/2026 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 3180 Restrictions: Exclusions: Yes Possession: Close Plus 31-60 Days Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20261010742 Listing Exemptions: Features Pets Allowed: Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation: Basement Fndtn Material: Poured Basement: Finished Exterior Feat Lighting, Fenced Exterior: Brick Cnstret Feat: Fireplc Fuel: Gas Fireplace Loc: Prep Sas pl Living Room Roof Materi: Asphalt Qut Bulldings: Fencing: Fenced Appliances: DI Oven, ig , Gas Ci , , Range Hood, Stainless Steel Appliance(s) Natural Gas, Forced Alr Cooling: Central Air Wir Hr Fuel: Natu § Water Source: ral Gas Road: Other Sewer: Saver (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Elooring ath - Full First/Entry12 x 8 Ceramic Basement 5x5 Laminate ath - Lav First/Entry6 x 5 Wood First/Entry15 x 8 Ceramic Bedroom First/Entry12 x 10 Carpet First/Entry13 x 12 Carpet Bedroom - Primary ~~ First/Entry19 x 19 Carpet Breakfast Nook/RoomFirst/Entry10 x 12 Wood Dining Room First/Entry1S x 12 Wood Great Rutoy24 x 18 Wood Kitchen First/Entry20 x 12 Wood Eneoaruthyas/Raom Ceramic Legal /Tax/Financial Property ID: 1934126024 Subdivision: Westchester Village 2 Ownershif Standard (Private) Occupant: Owner Tax Summer: $6,149 Tax Winter: $4,834 Homestea Yes Oth/Sp Asm SEV: $396,440 Taxable Value: $297,630 Existing Lease:No Home Warrant Legal Desc: T2N, R10E, SEC 34 WESTCHESTER VILLAGE NO 2 LOT 336 Homeowner Association Information Assoc Fee Amt: 100 Working Capital: Association Contact\Website: Marilyn Beckham, Westchester Village HOA Fee Frequency: Annually Association Phone\Email: ill com Fee Includes: Agent/ Office Information List Office: KW Domain 248) 590-0800 List Agent: TRACEY FREEMAN [+] 248) 772-1997 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox ront Door Remarks Public ***OFFERS RECEIVED. HIGHEST AND BEST OFFERS DUE 5:00PM SATURDAY, MARCH 7*** Welcome to Westchester Village—one of the Remarks: This ranch on a wide lot boasts 3 bedrooms, 2 full and 2 half baths, and is flooded with The reces n is a chef's dream with stainless steel appliances, double ovens, a tered reverse osmosis water tap and a large island, flowing seamlessly into a sprawling open-cancept living area partect for ing. A y adds practicality, while the finished basement offers two S20rage rooms and 8 bonis room With a Window desi for 8 home office or gym. The front gorch and back patio were com lately ‘redone in 2025 and the proj has both sprinkler and alarm systems. Located in a highly desirable community and served by the award. 9 this home light, and the ease of ranch-style living in a location buyers love. REALTOR® *#**OFFERS RECEIVED. HIGHEST AND BEST OFFERS DUE 5:00PM SATURDAY, MARCH 7+** POSSESSION THROUGH MAY 15, 2026. Remarks: SHOWINGS TO BEGIN FRIDAY, MARCH 6 - NO EXCEPTIONS. WASHER & DRYER EXCLUDED FROM SALE. BACKYARD PLAYSET EXCLUDED FROM SALE. K/W DOMAIN REQUIRES THAT A LICENSED AGENT BE PRESENT FOR ALL SHOWINGS. PLEASE SEND ALL INQUIRIES AND OFFERS TO TRACEY@TSFHOMES.COM. BUYERS AGENT TO ACCOMPANY ALL SHOWINGS. ALL MEASUREMENTS AND DIMENSIONS APPROXIMATE. BUYER'S AGENT TO VERIFY ALL INFORMATION. I.D.R.B.N.G. Notices and Disclaimers L. Through ths platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (1) make offers of broker compensation; 1) disclose broker compensation; (i) represent brokerage services ae free or avaiable a no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be received; or (Iv) make any concession limited to of in the of or to another broker or DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP If LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION.
Page 19
Residential Full 125 S Cranbrook Cross Road, Bloomfield Hills 48301-3423 20251029992 Area: 02193 - Bloomfield Twp Short Sale: No Lp: 559,000 Residential oom: N/1/1 Trans Type: Sale op: poss 000 @ Status: Sold ERTS/F8 SP: $580,000 Location n Lot Information County: Oakland Acreage: 3 Township: Bloomfield Hills Lot Dim Bloomfield Hills &d Front Birmingham Grg Feat: S of Maple Rd / W of Cranbrook Rd Directions: ~~ Take Cranbrook Cross Rd South off Maple Rd re 2 Contact Information Sqft Source: Public Records Name: MARK SHAFTNER Est Fin Abv Gr: 1,820 Phone: (248) 396-1741 Est Fin Lower: 800 Est Tot Lower: 1,313 EstTotFin: 2,620 Price/Sqft: $307.14 Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Wirfrnt Nam Year Built: 1959 Water Facilities: Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Year Remod: 2024 Direct Access, Electricity, Door Opener, Attached Listing Date: 09/04/2025 List Type/Level Of Service: Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 09/05/2025 Srves Offered: ATrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 09/05/2025 Off Mkt Date: 09/05/2025 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: ~~ % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 180 Restrictions: No Exclusions: No Possession: Negotiable Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20251029992 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: try Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation Basement Fndtn Material: Poured Partially Finished Lighting, Fenced Brick Cnstret Feat: Fireplace Loc: Living Room Porch - Covered, Patio, Porch, Patio - Covered, Covered Asphalt Fencing: Fenced Appliances: Di er, Di: , Dryer, ing Gas Range, ing Refrigerator, Microwave, Washer Interior Feat: Programmable Thermostat Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air Wir Hir Fuel: Natural Gas Road: Paved Water Scurce: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Leve| Dimen Elooring Room Dimen Bath - Full First/Entry 12x 5 Ceramic Bath - Full Basement 7x8 Bath - Primary First/Entry 5x6 Ceramic Bedroom First/Entry 11x 10 Bedroom First/Entry 12x 10 Wood Bedroom - Primary First/Entry 13 x 14 Dining Room First/Entry 12x 11 Wood Family Room First/Entry 21x12 Flex Room Basement 12x13 Luxury Vinyl Tile/IFour Season Room ~~ First/Entry 12x12 Kitchen First/Entry 13x 11 Wood Library (Study) Basement 12x12 Living Room First/Entry 18x 14 Wood Media Room (Home ThBasement 22x 18 Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 1934226001 Subdivision: Judson Bradways Bloomfield Village 5 Standard (Private) Occupant: Owner $3,340 Tex $2,689 Homestead: Yes tbsp Asm $222,200 Value: $160, Existing Lease: No xable 620 e Warranty: N; T2N, R10E, SEC 34 JUDSON BRADWAY'S BLOOMFIELD VILLAGE NO. S WLY 10 FT OF LOT 1223 & ALL OF LOY 1324 Agent/Office Information List Office: KW Domain List Agent: MARK P SHAFTNER [gf Listing Exemptions: List Office Ph: (248) 590-0800 List Agent Ph: (248) 396-1741 Access: Appointment/LockBox L5 Location: Front Door Remarks Situated within the highly sought after Birmingham School District, this impeccably remodeled ranch is both impressive and comfortable - inspiring and convenient - light and bright - easy to live and easy to love. Move-in-ready, with a combined 2800+ square feet on the main level and lower level, you'll enjoy 3 generously sized bedrooms, 3 full baths, a finished lower level, an attached two car garage, and a rare for the area 6’ privacy fence. Impeccably renovated with an eye on design, the features warm style y, sleek quartz countertops, and a full suite of stainless steel appliances. Crown molding details and full height storage add a touch of sophistication, while the peninsula with gas range creates the perfect gathering space for both everyday living and entertaining. Open and flowing with two large living spaces, your front living room is filled with light and features a cozy gas fireplace, while the main family room is tucked away and offers custom built-ins for both function and style. A light filled sul is the p space for ing coffee, zoom sessions, and relaxing evening retreats. Two bedrooms share a main bathroom with shower tub combo, while the primary suite features two closets and its own fully remodeled ensuite bath. Down a flight of stairs you'll find an expansive recreation room, separate office/future bedroom, a flex room perfect for a home gym, and an added full bathroom. Step outside to your huge back yard with brick paver patio and the rarest of features with your newly installed 6’ privacy fence. Homes in the Birmingham School District don’t stay on the market long, and this one blends updated style, everyday function, and the location buyers wait for. Welcome Home! Public Remarks: REALTOR® REALTOR Please feel free to call Mark with any questions at 248-396-1741. Email offers to mark@markshaftner.com. Please remove shoes or wear emarks: shoe covers. Good luck with your showing! Sold Information Short Sale: No SP/SqFt Abv: $319 Sold Date: 10/08/25 3rd Party Appr: No Selling Office: Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agent: Sold Price: Finance Code: $580,000 CONV sale SP/LP:103.76% SP/OLP:103.76% Selling Office Ph:(248) 590-0800 Selling Agent Ph: (248) 772-1997 Co-Selling Agt Ph: Domain Tracey Freeman Sell Concessions: Sell Concession Comments:
Page 20
EXHIBIT 6 ECF AREA 27150 SUPPORT The subject property is assigned to ECF Area 27150 Ranches. According to Bloomfield Township’s ECF study, this ECF area is derived from a single sale located at 3624 Tuckahoe Rd and produces an ECF of 2.58758. Petitioners do not challenge the Township’s methodology but submit that actual market sales provide a more reliable indicator of value than the resulting cost-model output.
Page 21
ven wee Wo ssanrsune sums se wma sen ame Comuizmy gE tare 8 Seater ras seams A samsLBG aes seas [Rr — se Commas sass larasemoe wn 6 Segeremy Sen aoe A sanrsiond Senmo tot nse ones 200 Comazsy 12a aun a 6 Sera tomas smess mA samesien mow seuss same se py Comat sii arsarmie Sera Sn mow Wo samsieni seme we uo py Commasy Suton laatusazos an 6 Sera] seu ass Wo ssamsuoni sesso was fret ae Comin Sa asamie Sram warn sow Pe sssusome smo sion rr — am Commasy STS lature an 8 Seoterany| Towa sess Assamese fon ie [et 2 Comat SN aurea 6 Soran mms somes wo ssassusers susms sms sms seen sn Commnsy stow iarsaioe an 6 sepersm Te es PA BAMSBG mee ween 6 mem wa wr Coy eee wr 7 seer] Ga Ramee Wo Gams Same Swse a8 ame see we Comazsy SSM leataezoo wn 7 Seger swe mes mA amsusom wise wim Be men snes pe Commits Briss arses wt Segura es sao wo cians, ow we aw sew sae wo Comaasy nso laatusazon an © Seotramy| ease wame A sAmDG wsawe mene wi prey so Comin Stk ausarie Sera ams somes A BawsGY Snes seam as pro py Commasy Sm lessens wn 8 Seger ams Hemme PIA GAMSLDGT. Haewe mse ie prety 2 powtuisedupessriegiviotnsio gu ed sans imme FA samsiGn sioaws wes we prov pres Commas SH lasers wt @ Seger en nome MA casio names wee a peony pry postuieeduprssshiivotnssiogu ed sms mess mA samsusomd simen ews ma pv py Comaizsy Sma arsarme ww Sera Tan wimee MA awsiGn Hea wise om pry aot Commasy Sion laaTasazon an 6 Seotramy Sin smsms mA samesiom semen sus su prin sm Comite essere a 6 Seger x sims Wo mawsiem sme sims 08 sone Commasy ST lesseros wr @ Seger sma wimme Wo GAMSBGTY ims ws au pron Comin BHT dTaainoo Segara Gur mew wo samsusem mee seus 6» prov Commasy Saks lessee wi Seger Goons sme mA saws sme teow a pron powiuieaduprmsviciiietvnss hoger sd sun smms mA sawsiom se sams on pret Commas wists arusaime wt a Segura Ta fumee Wo SAWSLENTH fimo es We prev Commasy Ss eatasezo a1 © Seger Fo pres Commasy Soran lessee wt 8 Seger wn mow FA casio Heme pam as swe Commasy Sa eaTasezoo wn G Seger samen sess Wo samsuboTd Mises dws pros Comat wien arses 8 Sera Ten sme Wo samsLBGTH ses seams ou suse Commasy SUS eases wn @ Sepersmy feo Je) pry Comite aaroe Soran Gon sisams Wo amsiem seam seers ao pr Commasy Sar lessee wi 8 Segersmy prem) a sameson wemo wm ten pron postuisedupsiogiiviotnsiogpu end same wveme FA samsusom wise sem un pr Commas SA leatsame wt 6 Segura Gen wae MA samsie Haeew nes 08 ame Comazty Sw aan a 6 Sram me sew samsibe mes wum me pry Commits $uioe larsazms 8 Sram Wr seas A ASG Sum wee a prory Commasy Sms lessee anu Sepersmy Grae wumee A samen sme ees an prey Comin Soa arabes wn Hse Imam samme a _samsipen sme sm en prey Commnsy asm lessee ano seers = Tem ws me we Ea Ea ptresssoen saws om ems sae pro Commas $20 laser a Sera casasman sam nn wees ees se suse Commasy Sine lessee wn 8 Seger presen woe aw sees sam roa Comazsy S60 easezoo wn © Seger commas wie we wer ne Jrog Commits Grier Larabee wt Msgr Conrssaser wan wa umm ues prope Commasy sass Leataeroo wn 4 Seger Canamsmon ww wn wea wes prog Comin dass arabes aH Seger Conran we wn smear swam Jer Commasy $mem latusawos a Sera] Cannan w am mem oem oe wan postuisaduprssiiliviotnsciogu ed casmamans somes wn esse mse Jr Commas Sse lestsamos wn 6 Seger Carano wan wn mew oem ean posiuieeduprsvseiiviotnsciogu sand coma Rp een Commas poss isseimse anu segura rr TTR Tren we FA Smo samen ams ww wm we aT Coy ae Gee ww re] Casares HbOMNONOR wan Smee FIA GAWSLBGI Same Seas Gu sums seen frog Commasy Uma essere wn 6 Seger Canmaen eomNoNOR Gui Wms Wo mawsLbGN New ase BE wm sem am wan Comitty AAEN iTaaimoo 6 Seren comma Siem eww pa sms seems wei wn ses uses son sus Commnsy sim iesnsese wr w seers Se Too unas ee pA samesien wees wen wm wee aes pra CTT T——r