Valuation Disclosure - Docket #24-003780 - HAMMAD.pdf
Adnan Hammad, Petitioner V Township Of West Bloomfield, Respondent · 24-003780-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
MTT Docket No: Tax ID: Petitioner: Respondent: Appeal Year: Prepared by: VALUATION DISCLOSURE FOR PROCEEDINGS AT THE MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL 24-003780 18-05-128-033 Adnan Hammad 1715 Heron View West Bloomfield, MI 48324 Charter Township of West Bloomfield 4550 Walnut Lake Road West Bloomfield, MI 48323 - December 31, 2023 for 2024 Tax Year December 31, 2024 for 2025 Tax Year Na obert Scripture, Assessor Daniel L. Sears, Chief Appraiser ver, Chief Appraiser Keith Hartman, Property Appraiser
Page 2
2 Table of Contents Cover Letter .............................................................................................. 1 Table of Contents ...................................................................................... 2 Master Letter ............................................................................................ 3 Township Map ........................................................................................... 4 Subject Photographs ............................................................................... 5-6 Subject Aerial Map ..................................................................................... 7 Subject Record Cards............................................................................ 8-11 Valuation Report..................................................................................12-15 Market Comparison Analysis .................................................................16-17 ECF Analysis ........................................................................................18-19 Subject and Comparable Map ...............................................................20-21 Subject Sketch ........................................................................................ 22 File Maintenance Records ......................................................................... 23 Scope of Work and Certification ................................................................ 24 Appraiser’s Qualifications .....................................................................25-28 Addendum .............................................................................................. 29 Pictures and Maps of Comparables .......................................................30-50 Listing ................................................................................................51-54
Page 3
Charter Township of ONst SSloomfiel? Assessing deprtment December 30, 2025 (248) 451-4850 Chief Clerk Michigan State Tax Tribunal P.O. Box 30232 Lansing, Michigan 48909 RE: Address: 1715 Heron View Property Tax ID: X-18-05-128-033 MTT Docket No: #24-003780 Dear Sir/Madam: Please find enclosed the valuation disclosure for the subject property listed above. We set the Assessment utilizing Mass Appraisal. For appeal purposes, the property is valued on an individual basis with the Sales Comparison Approach, which focuses on the specifics of that home only. We used the Cost Approach and the Sales Comparison Analysis in preparation for this disclosure. The ‘original’ Assessed Value, True Cash Value, and Taxable Value for the year at issue are: Tax Day Tax Year TCV Assessed Value Taxable Value 12/31/2023 2024 337,740 168,870 168,870 12/31/2024 2025 360,060 180,030 174,104 The Michigan Tax Tribunal makes an independent determination of value based on all the evidence available. This valuation disclosure concludes the following values: Tax Day Tax Year “TCV Assessed Value Taxable Value 12/31/2023 2024 374,900 187,450 187,450* 12/31/2024 2025 404,000 202,000 193,260 HP Nose 5 al obert Scripture, Assessor Daniel L. Sears, Chief Appraiser RA Chief Appraiser Keith Hartman, Property Appraiser 4550 Walmit Take Road + West Bloomfield, MI 48325-0130 & ww. hup.wess-bloomfield mius > Fax (248) 682-7851
Page 4
4
TOWNSHIP MAP
TOWNSHIP MAP
—
i
J
>
i
-
B
—e—
he
a)
#
F
rt
3
>
3
4
’
3
RE
aa:
BN
:
-
—-—
:
&
T.
o
RB
h
F
off
:
Ay
-
-
|
=
o
as
&
~
5
,-
h
pry
fry,
ull
—
-—
al
4
|
it
o-
i
a
I~
3
—
{
—
=)
1
.
5
CI
i
y
:
SY
ae,
|=
£2
al
7
/
|
£4
ul
i
—
y/
’
|
Yet
i
4
:
|
1
1]
)
p—
Er
Ea
a
x
:
~~
al
—_~
(ad Lad
ii
.
fh Pa he 2c
|Page 5
5 1715 Heron View (Subject Property) – Front 1715 Heron View (Subject Proper
Page 6
6 1715 Heron View (Subject Property) – Rear 1715 Heron View (Subject Prope — Rear
Page 7
7 1715 Heron View (Subject Property) – Aerial Map 1715 Heron View (Subject Property) — Aerial Map [.] 23 =x.
Page 8
8
Subject Property – 2024 Record Card – Page 1
Page 1
2024 Record Card —
Subjec t Property
»e+P323usIEnd 20U ING STGEITSI PSWSSP UTSISY UWOTIFWIOIUL
see
uebTUSTH ‘pueTAEQ Jo A3uncy
szoz/Lu/Tt
uo pazutig
QN¥DIvO :A3umed
PTaTIWo0TE 358M 30 dal
JUOTIDTPSTINL
0052 18
[ovo‘oet
[oss ‘eT
[00s “st
TZ0Z| ET
—-—
i
|
BD
F
2,
2
|
TIDY
‘PTeTIWOOTE 353M JO
dTYsumol
:OL PasusdTT
{Does
‘es
06251
06L ‘321
|00s’s1
a] BEd
77
| sgbue’ —saaer:
fo) braid:
Taesipenby wiz)
{o9z1 ‘88
|
1086 ‘$31
|08F ‘85T
|oos ‘31
£20Z| 33BuUTPTTNE 9661/82/90 66)
§
p
50.8891
|HoLs ‘891
|oL8“89T
loc zstT
loos ‘91
vzoz)
3TUM.
usuM
oun,
ante)
23430
maTASY
ants
anTeEp
saTEn
stgexer
| /Teungrar
|30 pIsog
pssssssy
SuTpTTRE
[put
Imex
UTE POSTE
Ss
=
L
pusTasy
sutazy|
auozzzetEN|
ubtH
mog|
ButTToY|
1ea91] X
|
8315
30 Audexbodor
"sTTan punozbaspup|
53T3TITaQ PITPusas
i
s3ybTT 389135)
|
163°
= anTep ysE) anIl S3usWeAoIdW] PUET PSIEWTIST TEI0L
0
18
T
0070
-ouop/udsy/AEmsaTIg
x|
anTEp ysed
poog
§ 32TS
aE
uoradrIassg
21730573]
X
Wi
- Psp
(5)we3] 32ETE UT 2TUR
z3m85
£auezzes zad ogut pezepdn
-
€£2/32/60
Le3’e
EL
[434
1s°L
338I0uU0)
UTH
-4/M/0
I33EN
Wd
- ¥1d
33d ojut paaepdn
- £2/62/50
snTEp Used
Poon
§ 92T§
samy
NT— sa
|
FTEmepTS|
ssousnT3uI/sausmmon
|
gd
S00-L2T i 56-21% EL
Blass toe
I0T
Z ON SMOUVEW QOOMINNH
§ DIS
‘368
‘NZI
000 'g€
= onyEp pueT "353 [EOL
S8I0Y TE30L 5270 399g 3u0Iz TEMA
|
|
igerii
A
uotadrIosaq xeL
000
‘cE
001
0008S
£9Z°
©3 SZ"
<8 SNTEA 33TS>
B
Ta)
Xi
sntep
uosesy -[pys s3wy
uyadeq
3uczy
yadsq
sbeauozry
uoradrIosag
|
sauswsaozdmy
- 5303083
.
|
STTang.
i
S9E STQEL PUST SIE STQEL PUST IOF SSATWTASY SNTEA PuST
|
JuEdsp
psaozday| x
L66£-pZE8) IW QTILINOOTE ISM;
he =,
re erm
:
il
ID MEIA NOWEH STLT
s
as
|S9P°¥BT
WAI/ADL ZEL'LEE ADL
3ST FOE
|
oe rs
€ ATuorr|
E53IPPY/SWEN
5, ISUMD
€202/10/1T $001 “3 4d]
|
|
IDTUISIQ TOCHDS TMOJWIIVM :TOOUDS|
MITA NOWEH STLT|
snaEag
Taqumy
s3EqQ
(s)aTmzag BuTpTINg
18 :BUTUOZ| OWaNI-TYIINSQISTS 55812)
ssaxppy Aazsdozg|
|
|
|
|
|
|
00
|
QITITMIA ION
9££¢0LLSY| OIINITISNI ONIONST OI-bE|
HIO| £T02Z/08/v0 |613°SS
ANVE ESVHD NESUORAL
0°00T
| wEisNwdl AINZaONd
|
EIONTT S.WE¥-£0|
¥1d| £202/80/60 [000 ELE
NENG OHNE
-suezy
ig
sbeg
3
sdAz|
=38Q
|so12a
-quaag
paTITIaN
TaqTT
S185 JO
swmIaL|
-asug|
3TES
aTeS
SI3uEI)
:zsqumy Te0IEg.
€€0-8ZT1-50-81- XPage 9
9
Subject Property – 2024 Record Card – Page 2
<<<<< "BuroTad 2397dWOD 303 2nouTid UOTIENTEA 995
-BuOT 003 SUOTIETNOTED >>>>>
++4P323UEIENG 30U 30 STGEITSI PSWSSP UTSISY UOTITWIOIUL mew
| sw=sg T8835 dng Iu) |
zuaT pazzoddnsup
|
:AsumTy)
s12’s
HTL
1
qur-1ds1 tzznoEp
ce
b
-gastop —— |
67%
519
1
Pooy peausp
|
:swea ung dung |
707031
‘0TXz
:s3sTor
|
T
90Z
z8T
T
Tesodstg sbeqien
RRL Te
_3zoddng 20012 (01)
|
stbutus aTeudsy x
£19
ov
T
TsusERYSTQ
Stades Tes goof]
| (¥) 520° 3noxTeM
-
00°
0
}
;
suI-37TNg
Trem Pre)
as
Td
ON
98L
L18°E
20z
I3UB) FDTIY
zene Strang)
|
(8) 5790Q InoxTEM
ETT Z-
568 ‘Z-
:3
TTEM T :TTEM uommod
RR Sy aa
3s
SutaT
LS0’6T
50132
9z¥
150) sseg
eae Gp |
Evasey
(PSYSTUTI) YOUT zp TUOTAEPUNOZ BUTPTS 1IOTIIIXI D Sry
:
| usTuta auswesem (6)
|
susszog
3 smog]
x
.
"
SO
=:
co
weg usp
20074 93370000 X
sz00Q OTa%a
528
0ET‘T
z
=
00, | SATE, Syme)
§
oh sea
Rida
i
)
7a
SUTEM TTI dTWeIa)|
suoag|
IUSWIEE)
£8T°T
1291
z
SAODTY qUL dTWEIS)
| z0073 STTL STWEI|
Z
-suoy panog
oT
SPITS -ZTIOH X
PLT
91% ‘Z
z
I00T3 STTL dTWEISD
z8moys sasxedag
1
23074
~om03)]
flied 00
0Lo‘t
99% ‘T
T
T3mous IzEredss
prran—
Lo]
gid biiim
353°
800°s
T
uaeg szmaxss
©
as7Tor ®aaNE
Jumensed
(8)
|
uses Teas
UT
|
.
.
ry
ctiicste)
H
-
uses pow
0s6°¢
IP's
z6T
JUS) 12TIE
2ESH ISIE IPOS
t
f
T
IOTIZIXT |
renuey ‘I8W83IOS|
E's
0 :a=Ts
jo]
Reps
sauswasn(pyY/SUCTATEPY I3U30
oany ‘zsusazos|
2°S
0 TmeId
¥|
X
YX
L10 "922
209 ‘s0g
STE3I0L
yasg srmaxty
z|
3°S
g6LT :ausweseg
|
abe
Ausl
oz
pen
iit
Tis
T
yaeg 8In3IxXTy
§|
Z
uotqeAEIXT
(L
smoputy
(Z)
61
uI250
uTPTS
203
1 | (5)sInaxty sbezeny
I
—
ZEL'T
auswaseg
butpts
£z035
1
——
Butqunta
(£1)
UOTIEINSUT|
X
aso)
-adag
MBN 3500
IzIS
UOTIEPUNOF
I0TISIXT
E3TI028
{
seaxy burping
| #33
[
“sa
X
| Fumy
|
TrEmMiag|
X
|
i.
327128
£L/00T/00T/00T/EL=PO0I
§ "quoD/ucdg/dung/Aud-qy/Aug
sasTang -9°73 30 ox
rr ——
T rte Lmtd
x
“3S TEBT = ®aIY 20014
JS TELT = ®AIY pumoy
[paolx|
-
=
TBuTys/PooM]
100)
3 3Eey psdozog -weasAs buraEsy
(11)
TH]
PXO|
x3
|
ss
z0TTRIXT
(1)
966T 37d
OT
D
STD
£2035
7
ATTwe3 s7buTts
1 :6PTE "S9§ 203
"153 30D |
S3INIXTI JO ~TERD/ ON
oss eed
| [
[r—
oo]
weasAs Aatindss|
|
soTazss sdwy|00z
POOMDIWH :uSEDATH
|
20013 =
3
”
Jr
umnoE)
TEI
ee tar
zeaxy 3zodzen|
SE0
‘ZOE “ADL PS2EWIISH
Resid
=)
ITIIDBTA (ZT)
|
s100T3
(5)
OOS hela
Sau
aios
2
.
E
Hor
Tan
D usEIL
1
JUBEREHY
i
TEE
XK
150°49g 350) zdag TE3OL
Se
PLOTETnn
ebwaey:aumenl -yng
Z18°595
: meN ss=g TE30L|
_
—
bt
DT)
x eros | sz00g]|
Je73 woos |
|
Te8’T cmery zoorz|
°PUTM
USSTD 3185
| IW
2
x0 x|
51]
0
:I00TF "DUD ON
Lz
-eby
-2833%
abuey papunag|
ButToon/BuTaEsy oN
|
S—
0 rey peri
01+ D :ssETD
Rasa
T
dumg 2=sH|
5388501) 30 e275
Liar
=
4
Roos
|
T
100)
® 3E8H P3JI03|
X
3861
5zy cay
=9 paausp-1933TQ
qrr-tdez TzzmoEr
1
sosuma 00TA/TTeM
wm
|
30] x x3
| pogepemsd
« Ste
0 :sz00Q -yoSRW|
sa0325 PooM
qn Tzzooep
Tada soRdg
STE
as uSy| ated IX
|
0
:sI00Q
-oany
YIIESH PSSTEY
WODISIUT
3ESH TTEM OTI309TH
-
2A
|
ail
Pid
T
53%
Ii PaysTuTi
I03ETNDIT) IEE
POOH pI3usp
|
(zoorz-ut) austpey
| 991 pooM
| peTsuEd
:3143s
SutpTTng
9our zy uoTaEPunc:
&z035
7 qE3eig,
PooE paausaun
Pll rE lid
inch tion
Trenszal x
TT=M T STTEM uowmo)
Az035
1 qEzsad
T
ani 30H
prEogeseE 01I295TT
re
=a
swezz
poow
xX
20TIS3UT
(F)
0
Tusa Spo3E|
£1035
7 I0TIBIXT
ueg usp
z328y 20H psoiog
¥
SEAL
—_—
30
:-uspA XITIF|
£1025
T IOTIIIXT
I31E3H Y3eg
s10ng
/M ITY Pad3oz
Butprs
:I0TIBIXF|
PSPTS oML
Tesodstqg sbeqaeg
1
53900 o/M ITY Lo
Subject Property — 2024 Record Card — Page 2
2 :85%T2|
(£70,
ze
z :Aatosden zEn
gi
BIT);
BANE | Az0a5
7 ToTIIAUT
dor x003|
966T :3TTNg I®ax,
3dAL|®aIY | £7035 1 IOTISIUT|
-moTTY ®soustrddy
sbex®g
(LT)
| sxoea/ssuaz0a
(31)
ADE SWES/pPUZ
ssoetdsIta (sD)
IsyseAYsTy
T men | my a
os13|
|
T1Y0|
| sE9l X
SutToon/BuTaEsE
(11)
suT-aTTRE
(ST)
| seoz/L/eEt
uo pajuTIg
€E0-BEZT-S0-81-
X
Buryzsap 134300
Busyzsap 3u03I 0
uoT3IETNSUL X
ubnozissasy
|
{-3uod)
zooy
(g)
:Tsquny TeoIEg
1 30
1 ButprTng TETIUSPTSSYPage 10
10
Subject Property – 2025 Record Card – Page 1
nenP393UEIENS 30U ING STETTSI PSWSSP UTSISY UOTITWIOIUT mes
0)
[oz est
lose sZt
loos ‘st
|
zzoz]
No
pe
SETI ‘puRTIZO 30 Fawn
=
=
T32¥3
‘PTsTIWOOTE 35sM 30
dTYsuMOL 01 PeSUSITT
=!
ye
ADUGAIOT
Sl
{UHI
8202) 1aoyanetes
7
¥
ODOT
CECT:
(3) wpa Emel aE
j=)
WoLa’eer
loce’at
locezst
00s "51
v20e sabupTne 9651/52/90 66s Em
Sp
©
|
|
080081
loss “eat
00591
szoz|
3TuM
usu
cum
o
[re
—
—
/TeungTxl
|30 pamog
pessassy
ButpTIng
|
mex
uTeTd PooTd
|
=
.
.
gia
pueTasy
sutasy
O
quozzzsey
puog
—
P3pooy
[40]
Gumas
(
)
padeaspus]
ubTH
stir
O
uTTTOR
Pe
tone x|
Oo
sats
(@)
30 Audezbodor
Q
-sTTan punoxbiepup
oY
S9TATTT3N PIEPUElS
i
|
52ubTT 298335
]
lzp9'z
= enTsp yssn snIl s3usWsA0IdWI PUST PSITWTAST TEI0L
pee
|
LN
io
08
1
00-0
-ouep /udsy/Aemantiq
sus|
%
CN
| Tren wo
Poon
§ szTS
saw
uotadraosag
BR
Sia
imam
(s)wa3] SDETg UT
3ITUN
23M35
Kauezzes 13d ozur paaepdn
-
£Z/32/60
QO
mez
zL
zev
9%L
s3315u0) uTH a/M/a
a
We - wid zed ojut peaspdn - £2/62/60
(\]
| =oTes Ese
Poon
§ szTs
LEU
uoTadrIosag
JATEMSPTS.
ssousnTFul/sauswEon
ssaTwrasy 150) 3uswesozdwl pusT
13mg W015
ctf
500-427 B3 55-21% EL
|
PHO: PRON
I0T
z ON SMOUVEW UOOMINDH S D3S
‘36d ‘NZl|
000°ce
= snr pus "35% TEIOL
$9I0¥ TE10L 52-0
‘3933 3JUOI3 TENIOY
T
puoy "TRANS
uotadrIossg XEL|
000 ‘cE
00T
000EE
£927
©3 TST" <g SNTEA 93TS>
PEOY 3TT@)
X
!
anTEp
uoseey -(pysy @3wy
uyadeg
3uoiz
yadsq
ebeauozry
uoradridseg
sauswanozdaT
= SIDIOBE
—
__oITang;
(0)
S9§ STQEL PUST 59E STQEL PUST I0F SSIEBWTISE STE PuET
que)
paaozdur|
X
L665-5ZE8F IH QTILIHOOTE ISEM
F—
—
Ba
a
meron
Z
=
1D MITA NOWEH STLT
=
74
ES
’,
1
(a)
$9°96T
WAL/AOL BS0°09E AIL
387 SEOT
were ‘qos
(@]
|
I.
ssappy/suEy 5, 3susg)
jul
£20Z/T0/TT $001 "T°¥°d
1
[al
|
|
|
IDTHISIO TOCHDS QHOIWAIVM
© TOOUDS|
MITA NOWEH STLT)
sn3Els
Toqumy|
@38Q
|
(s)3Tmzag SutpTINg
™
:butuoz
CYAWI-TVIINZQISTE
55°12
.
ss31ppy Aaxadoxg
0
Q
[
[
[
[
"PY
00
|
odIaIudA ION
98EY0LLSP OIINITISNI ONIGNST OI-pe
HIO| £102/08/30 |613°SS
|
MVE SVED NUOHOWIC
2 RIE HIDE
QO
oor
| ¥maswwer xrwsacua
|
EIONTT §.J¥-£0|
¥1d| £202/80/60 [000 ELE
|
ENTE OAH |
2 YI¥¥R ‘ELIWS
p=}
suszy
ig
abeg
3
dA
s3EQ
20133
|
|
0p]
{01g
|
PETITISA
ISAT
SI9S.30 Wher
“zeux|
SES
[21=5
|
ts i
ni ae
S202/L1/2T
uo paauTig
QN¥DI¥0 :£3umo)
PT2TIW00TE 253M 30 ~dMl
UOTADTPSTIOL
££0-82T-50-8T- X
:ISquny Ta2I=g
10Page 11
11
Subject Property – 2025 Record Card – Page 2
<<<<<
"Burotad s3aT7dwod
203 3nojutid uOTIENTEA IIS
-BuoT ©03 SUOTIEBTNITED >33>>
»ssP323usIENd 20U ING STQETTSI PIWSIP UTSISY UOTIBWIOIUT
saw
swesg Tes3§
dng I3ud
:uaT paazoddnsup
:Asumtyd
Subject Property — 2025 Record Card — Page 2
01T’s
L60°L
1
qnr-1dsx TzZOOEQ
I
2
By
ory
119
1
pooH paausp
:swe31 wns dun
| 727097
"0TXT -S3sTOpP
z
5
Cr |
mam mam
|r yg | MiSs strat
sur-aTTNg
orades 1=9 anor
as
20013
ON
Pays
IETS
ogL’z
ZEL'E
202
zssusy ¥o1Ig
TI3M 338M
|
0" 200g anoxTem
pIEsuEy|
dry
g-
9L8‘Z-
T
TEM
T CTTE
:
Tames DTTANG|
3s
Buta
TexquEg)|
s1aE9|
X
Loz
LBZ;
TTEM T =TTEM uomwmo)
zo9wy Tama
T
oL3’stT
186752
Zh
aso) seg
CT NR
35
uoT3IEsIDBY|
Fo0¥
(g)
(PSYSTUTI)
YDUI
Zp
-UOTIEPUNOF BUTPTS
:IOTISIXT
J
ISEETD
Imag /I338M
(FT)
ve
sebuies
T
| USTUTS 3uswERE
(6) |
sussiog
3 swioas|
xX
usg ausp!
T
=
wos 0 G5
moore wu TD
© | mem |
see ee x
?;
3
E3UD20d | gutey STI dTWEISD|
suoag|
Juswese)
031’1
1e't
z
SAODTY UL JTWEIS)
| 70073 STTL STWR)
-suoy painog
oT
SPITS -ZTIOH X
LeL't
11
4
z
30073 STTL dTWEIS)
zamoys saszsdes
T
iE isn]
Suny saved]
890°T
9551
I
SBOE pILucey
quis ®33xE
og
hey
uses TAuTA|
X
zes’‘e
SLE'F
1
yaeg smaxis
€
187T0L ®13¥E|
quewmeseg
(g)
bid his
TqunTd
Butquntg oN|
we’s
sLe’s
z62
I88ul) YITIG
3eey z83EM TETOS|
0°B
:s3sTor
031 aubteH
-
20T232%¥F |
tenusy ‘zsusazos
4S
0 avis
|
TTWS|
|
s3usw3sn{py/sUCTITPPY I3Y30
o3ny ‘1susazog
i's
0 ITeEID
Bay)
xX
vZy ‘122
Lss‘Loe
z1E3oL
Y3EE SINIXTI
Z|
"3°s
geLT auswssEg | 3b1wT
B08
id
Becvpransy
Sutpts
A2098:%
y3eg aInaxti g|
z
uotaEaEoXz
(L)
smoputH
(2)
61
Busyzaag
Butpts
£1035
1|
(s)sanaxty sbezsay
—T
:
SE
zeL'T
usweseg
butpts
£1025
T
SE
uoTaETRSUT|
X
asop -zdsg
MeN 350)
az1g
uoTIEPUNOF
20TIIIXT
£37035
=
—
i
sesxy butprTng | 4°
| "aa¥ X
| Aue
TrEmMAIg X
— BE
|
ZL/00T/00T/00T/2L=PO0D
%
"quo /uodg/>ung/Aud-
qy/Aug
sasTang
pr
TAuUTA/mmuTEnTy|
X
“E5160 = WSIWAOOLY)
A DALE = MEIN UNOS
[rT
S5UTTT®D
(3)
3T5uTYS/PooK
1000
3 38s pedozog weasks butamen
(TT)
| TAL
|
.
z0T709X7
(1)
966T 37d
0T 3
STD
Az035
1
ATTWe3 STBuTS
1 :6PTE "53W 203 "157 350D |
5IINIXTI JO “TERD/ ON
hei
hi Eon
F———
|
weasis Zaranosg
sotazsg sdwry|00T
L
fpr
20012
puz|
300
poate
oe)
I
ri 2 LL
POOMPIEH USUDITH |
12 puz|
seaxy 3z0dIE)
91% ‘$2€ AD 1 PIIEWIASE
Bip
pire
n
DTI309T3 (ZT)
s70073
(5)
End
|
ane Smeg
WEEE
K
923 ‘19Z :3s0p zdsg TE3OL
ee
po
a
i
A
il
J
=
EG
| -gen-
.
3
wuing, poo
110!
=
P=
So
PES'SDS
© ASN SW TOOL uy yer sre
|
ave reams
pm
277 woo
0 :I00T3 ~DUO) ON
3
p:
sbusy pIespu=ag,
|
P30| X
x
gz by
-23333
Butroop/butaEsy oN
ms
El Sm
BE
3
0 :®axy sber03g
SABMOIOTH
T
dmg aes
i
eae
PooY :uoTATPUO)
Era
=
=
=
=
AO
00)
3
3ESH
PsIIoF|
|
a
[Jee Be
(r=
|
9zy tEaTy
=9 psausp-1993TQ
qnp-tdsz tzzmoep|
1
Based se
Bein
X
um
PI0| X
x3
pot
ol Teor
0 8000 “YO
34035 POOH
qui yEsuoEp
13qE8y so=dg
uOTIEIODSQ
3 WIIL!
or
0 :s300q
-oany
yaTEsE pasTEY
wooza3ur|
I slp)
1035 1
|
SSX
Ii peusTUTI
I03E[NDITY AEH
POOH peau
T
(z0073-uT) 2uETpEY
931 poom|
| psTsuEg
otha Surpimg
|
oe or Spm
ie
£ hc)
POOH ede
ueTpEY "TTD Brel
I335ETd
TTEsiag)
X
:
1EOQESEE
DTIIDD
swezz
PooM| X
0
: usp Suo3g
£1025
7 IOTIIIXF
usg usp
Lo it rr]
I0TIZIUL
(F)
|
90z
:-usp YotIg
XK109g
1 F0TI=3XT
131%sy yaEg
song Jn ITY pesos]
[
SwEzI-¥
ButpTs :I0TIBIXY
PSPTS OMT
TesodsTa 6%A7®9|
T | Loong osm zry peozod|
Suwyzasg 1343p 0
xs1dng
DJ *SS®ID|
(Zxo35
1)
4aoddlze
X0E3§ SWES/pug.
IsyseMysTa
1
T
|
T
T
BusyzaaQ 3IuUOII|Q
SWoH umol
z :Aatoede) IED
+————| &z035
7 I0TISIUL
dor 3000
wesag
aac
poo
uoT3ETNSUT X
SwWoR STTAoH
966T
:3TTINg IESX
8dA1|®33% | £1025
1 zoTIZIUI
-MOTTY souetrddy
ict
TT0!
seg)
X
|
uybnoxasanegy
If
Arrweg stbuts| x
sbexey
(LT)
| syos0/s9ud0g (3T) |
seoeTdsaTa (ST) |
sut-attng (51)
|
Burroop/butiEsH (TT) |
(-3uo2) 300¥
(E)
sdil ButpTTng
sZ0Z/LT/2T
uo pIIUTIG
££0-82T-50-8T- X
:ISqumN T32Ieqd
T 30
T BuTPTTNg TETIUSPISSY
11Page 12
12 2024 Valuation Report – Page 1 2024 Valuation Report — Page 1 12/17/2025 Valuation Report 08:26 AM 0B: X -18-05-128-033 2024 Est. T.C.V. HAMMAD, ADNAN Property Class: 401 1715 HERON VIEW Map #: 3 Twp. of West Bloomfield WEST BLOOMFIELD, MI 48324 Land Value Estimates for Land Table 365.Land Table 365 * Factors * Description Frontage Depth Front Depth Rate %Adj. Reason Value <Site Value B> .251 to .263 33000 100 33,000 1 Actual Front Feet, 0.25 Total Acres Total Est. Land Value = 33,000 Land Improvement Cost Estimates Description Rate size % Good Cash Value D/W/P: 4in Concrete 7.51 492 73 2,697 Unit in Place Item(s) Description Rate Size % Good Cash Value Driveway/Asph/Conc. 0.00 1 81 0 Total Estimated Land Improvements True Cash Value = 2,697 Cost Est. for Res. Bldg: 1 Single Family 1 Story cls C10 Blt 1996 (11) Heating System: Forced Heat & Cool Ground Area = 1792 SF Floor Area = 1831 SF Phy/Ab.Phy/Func/Econ/Comb. % Good=73/100/100/100/73 Building Areas Stories Exterior Foundation Size Cost New Depr. Cost 1 Story Siding Basement 1,792 1 Story Siding Overhang 19 1 Story Siding Overhang 20 Total: 309, 602 226,017 Other Additions/Adjustments Exterior Brick Veneer 292 5,411 3,950 Plumbing 3 Fixture Bath 1 5,008 3,656 Separate Shower ¥ 1,466 1,070 Ceramic Tile Floor 2 2,416 1,764 Ceramic Tub Alcove 2 1,621 1,183 Porches CCP (1 Story) 32 1,130 825 Garages Class: C Exterior: Siding Foundation: 42 Inch (Finished Base Cost 426 26,105 19,057 Common Wall: 1 Wall 1 -2,895 -2,113 Brick Veneer 206 3,817 2,786 Built-Ins Dishwasher 1 840 613 Garbage Disposal 1 282 206 Vented Hood 1 615 449 Jacuzzi repl.Tub 1 7,144 5,215 Microwave 1 456 333 Fireplaces Prefab 1 Story 1 2,794 2,040 Totals: 365,812 267,051 Notes: ECF (ECF Table 365) 1.131 => TCV: 302,035 2024 Est. T.C.V. X -18-05-128-033 = 337,732 12
Page 13
13 2024 Valuation Report – Page 2 2024 Valuation Report — Page 2 12/17/2025 valuation Report 08:26 AM Parcel Number: X -18-05-128-033 Page: 2 Est. TCV/Total Floor Area = 184.45, Most recent sale 09/08/2023 for 373,000 2023 Assessed MBOR v. Base for Cap IRM 164,980 164, 980 164, 980 88,126 5.00 2024 New Eq. Adjustment Loss Additions Tax Adjustment Losses 0 3,890 0 80,744 0 2024 Assessed MBOR Capped ->Taxable<- PRE/MBT 168,870 168,870 92,532 168,870 168,870 13
Page 14
14 2025 Valuation Report – Page 1 2025 Valuation Report — Page 1 12/17/2025 Valuation Report 08:29 AM 0B: X -18-05-128-033 2025 Est. T.C.V. HAMMAD, ADNAN Property Class: 401 1715 HERON VIEW Map #: Twp. of West Bloomfield WEST BLOOMFIELD, MI 48324 Land Value Estimates for Land Table 365.Land Table 365 * Factors * Description Frontage Depth Front Depth Rate %Adj. Reason Value <Site Value B> .251 to .263 33000 100 33,000 1 Actual Front Feet, 0.25 Total Acres Total Est. Land Value = 33,000 Land Improvement Cost Estimates Description Rate size % Good Cash Value D/W/P: 4in Concrete 7.46 492 72 2,642 Unit in Place Item(s) Description Rate Size % Good Cash Value Driveway/Asph/Conc. 0.00 1 80 0 Total Estimated Land Improvements True Cash Value = 2,642 Cost Est. for Res. Bldg: 1 Single Family 1 Story cls C10 Blt 1996 (11) Heating System: Forced Heat & Cool Ground Area = 1792 SF Floor Area = 1831 SF Phy/Ab.Phy/Func/Econ/Comb. % Good=72/100/100/100/72 Building Areas Stories Exterior Foundation Size Cost New Depr. Cost 1 Story Siding Basement 1,792 1 Story Siding Overhang 19 1 Story Siding Overhang 20 Total: 307,557 221,424 Other Additions/Adjustments Exterior Brick Veneer 292 5,376 3,871 Plumbing 3 Fixture Bath 1 4,975 3,582 Separate Shower ¥ 1,456 1,048 Ceramic Tile Floor 2 2,399 1,727 Ceramic Tub Alcove 2 1,611 1,160 Porches CCP (1 Story) 32 1,122 808 Garages Class: C Exterior: Siding Foundation: 42 Inch (Finished Base Cost 426 25,931 18,670 Common Wall: 1 Wall 1 -2,876 -2,071 Brick Veneer 206 3,792 2,730 Built-Ins Dishwasher 1 834 600 Garbage Disposal 1 280 202 Vented Hood 1 611 440 Jacuzzi repl.Tub 1 7,097 5,110 Microwave 1 453 326 Fireplaces Prefab 1 Story 1 2,776 1,999 Totals: 363,394 261,626 Notes: ECF (ECF Table 365) 1.240 => TCV: 324,416 2025 Est. T.C.V. X -18-05-128-033 = 360,058 14
Page 15
15 2025 Valuation Report – Page 2 2025 Valuation Report — Page 2 12/17/2025 Valuation Report 08:29 AM Parcel Number: X -18-05-128-033 Page: 2 Est. TCV/Total Floor Area = 196 Most recent sale 09/08/2023 for 373,000 2024 Assessed MBOR S.E Base for Cap IRM 168,870 168,870 168,870 168,870 3.10 2025 New Eq. Adjustment Additions Tax Adjustment Losses 0 11,160 0 5,234 0 2025 Assessed MBOR 3 Capped ->Taxable<- PRE/MBT 180,030 180,030 180,03 174,104 174,104 174,104 15
Page 16
16 2024 Sales Comparable Analysis 2024 Comparable Analysis for Subject Parcel X -18-05-128-033 Feature Subject Parcel Comparable #1 Comp. #1 Adjustment Comparable #2 Comp. #2 Adjustment Comparable #3 Comp. #3 Adjustment Comparable #4 Comp. #4 Adjustment Parcel Number X -18-05-128-033 X -18-05-127-006 X -18-05-128-008 X -18-05-126-057 X -18-05-128-011 Address 1715 HERON VIEW1580 HUNTWOOD PARK 6589 CARDINAL PL 1703 CARDINAL RIDGE 1636 CARDINAL RIDGE Neighborhood/Location Huntwood Meadows Huntwood Meadows 0 Huntwood Meadows 0 Huntwood Meadows 0 Huntwood Meadows 0 Appraisal/Sale Date 12/31/2023 8/5/2022 0 9/9/2022 0 9/18/2023 0 9/22/2022 0 Time Adjustment 2022 +4%, 2023 +2% 22,900 2022 +3%, 2023 + 2% 18,700 2023 0% 2025 +3%, 2023 0% 19,460 Land Size (Summary Acreage) 0.254 0.388 0 0.263 0 0.295 0 0.272 0 Year Built / Addn / Alter 1996 1996 / 2021 0 1993 / 2018 0 1992 / 2016 0 1995 / 2017 0 Quality / Construction Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Style 1 Story 1 Story 0 2 Story 0 2 Story 0 2 Story 0 Bedrooms 2 3 0 4 0 3 0 3 0 Full Baths 2 3 (5,000) 2 0 2 0 2 0 Half Baths 0 0 0 1 (3,000) 2 (6,000) 1 (3,000) Square Feet 1,831 1,642 2,577 (29,840) 2,154 (12,920) 2,109 (11,120) Fireplaces 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 HVAC Type Forced Heat & Cool Forced Heat & Cool 0 Forced Heat & Cool 0 Forced Heat & Cool 0 Forced Heat & Cool 0 Garage Capacity 2 Car Attached 2 Car Attached 0 2 Car Attached 0 2 Car Attached 0 2 Car Attached 0 Fin Basement Sq. Feet None Finish (20,000) Some Drywall 0 Finish (20,000) Finish (20,000) Basement Walkout Doors No Walk-out No Walk-out 0 No Walk-out 0 No Walk-out 0 No Walk-out 0 Porches / Decks Concrete Porches Concrete Porch, Brt 0 Concrete Porches 0 Concrete Porch, Deck, Brt 0 Concrete Porches 0 Grantor GLEKEL, OLEG & VERA SIORDA, JESUS JR & STEPHANIE DEPOTTER, THOMAS & ROSE POLICELLI, DAVID J Grantee TRIPP, AMY R TTE BATES, NICOLE LAFER, MARLENE WILLIAMS, BRIAN Miscellaneous Actual Sale Price DOM: 9 377,000 DOM: 12 369,500 DOM: 10 450,000 DOM: 10 384,900 Net Adjustments Cash Sale (2,100) FHA Sale (14,140) Cash Sale (38,920) CONV Sale (14,660) Net Adjustments % 0.56% 3.83% 8.65% 3.81% Gross Adjustments 47,900 51,540 38,920 53,580 Gross Adjustments % 12.71% 13.95% 8.65% 13.92% Adjusted Sale Price 374,900 355,360 411,080 370,240 ***MOST WEIGHT GIVEN TO COMP#1 (1 STY )
Page 17
17 2025 Sales Comparable Analysis 2025 Comparable Analysis for Subject Parcel X -18-05-128-033 Feature Subject Parcel Comparable #1 Comp. #1 Adjustment Comparable #2 Comp. #2 Adjustment Comparable #3 Comp. #3 Adjustment Parcel Number X -18-05-128-033 X -18-05-126-057 X -18-05-128-043 X -18-05-127-008 Address 1715 HERON VIEW 1703 CARDINAL RIDGE 1772 HERON VIEW 1604 HUNTWOOD PARK Neighborhood/Location Huntwood Meadows Huntwood Meadows 0 Huntwood Meadows 0 Huntwood Meadows 0 Appraisal/Sale Date 12/31/2024 1/23/2024 0 3/22/2024 0 9/30/2024 0 Time Adjustment 2024 + 6% 27,000 2024 +4.5% 18,650 2024 +0% Land Size (Summary Acreage) 0.254 0.295 0 0.287 0 0.306 0 Year Built / Addn / Alter 1996 1992 / 2016 0 1997 0 1997 / 2018 0 Quality / Construction Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Standard Deluxe / Siding- Brick 0 Style 1 Story 2 Story 0 2 Story 0 2 Story 0 Bedrooms 2 3 0 4 0 3 0 Full Baths 2 2 0 3 (5,000) 2 0 Half Baths 0 2 (6,000) 1 (3,000) 1 (3,000) Square Feet 1,831 2,154 (12,920) 2,313 (19,280) 2,007 Fireplaces 1 1 0 1 0 1 0 HVAC Type Forced Heat & Cool Forced Heat & Cool 0 Forced Heat & Cool 0 Forced Heat & Cool 0 Garage Capacity 2 Car Attached 2 Car Attached 0 2 Car Attached 0 2 Car Attached 0 Fin Basement Sq. Feet No Finish Finish (20,000) Finish (20,000) Finish (20,000) Basement Walkout Doors No Walk-out No Walk-out 0 Walk-out (10,000) No Walk-out 0 Porches / Deck Concrete PorchesConcrete Porches, Deck 0 Concrete Porch, Decks, Brt 0 Concrete Porches, Brt 0 Grantor LAFER, MARLENE GJERGJI, BERTI & LEONORA MARKARIAN, MATTHEW Grantee SHERMAN, JACKSON MARO, NAMIR BURSHTEYN, VIKTOR P Miscellaneous Actual Sale Price No MLS 450,000 DOM: 20 415,000 DOM: 3 427,000 Net Adjustments (11,920) CONV Sale (38,630) CONV Sale (23,000) Net Adjustments % 2.65% 9.31% 5.39% Gross Adjustments 65,920 75,930 23,000 Gross Adjustments % 14.65% 18.30% 5.39% Adjusted Sale Price 438,080 376,370 404,000 ***MOST WEIGHT GIVEN TO COMPARABLE #3 (LEAST AMOUNT OF GROSS ADJUSTMENTS %)
Page 18
18 2024 ECF Analysis 2024 ECF Analysis <=o3UELEN "INY SETT <=UoPeInag ‘pis TETT ST'LSTS <=43MY EE <="h9Q PIS <=3473 £6705 <= opney ‘ales 00'685'7$ __ v.8'826'T$ T60'VLE'ES 052'£89'1$ 00V'0TE'ES _isieioL 00V'OTE'ES. 58'vLTs EEVTTES £95'SS 967°TLES BE'6Y 0ST'981$ 000°LLES HLONI1SN¥Y-E0 Vid 000'LLES TT/S0/80 N¥vd QOOMLNNH 08ST 900-LZT-S0-8T- X| TZE'B6TS 008'ETES 00Z'9ES 6S0'18€$ vs 0ES'06TS 000'0SES. HLONI1S,WYY-E0 VLd 000'0SE$ TZ/LT/60 HQ TIONM NILYYW S099 020-6Z1-50-81- X| SL1'28TS LYL'TYES €SL'OYS LYG'OLES 98'LY 0LY'S8TS 005'£8€$ ~~ HLONIISWHV-E0 Vid 00S'LBES 1/01/80 3901 WNIQHVD £991 ¥S0-9Z1-50-8T-X| TS0'T62 THT'6LES 85L7vS ETZ'6LES 8625 O19'681$ 000796$ HIONIISINYYV-E0 Vid 000Z9ES TZ/vz/SO 390M WNIQHYD 8991 ET0-BZI-S0-BI-X| S9€ 423) S9€ # PooyJoqudian / sishieuy 453 yZ0T seoz/st/en 18
Page 19
19 2025 ECF Analysis 2025 ECF Analysis WT SION 10 109PY90) 988s LC 520996800 <= £10 <=BueeA SAY 00v'69E78__sieoL SITE ZE'TOIS LEYS HION31SWNV-€0 Vid 000STvS VL/CC/€0 “M3IA NOUIH ZLT _EV0-8L1-50-81- X 3001 IWNIQUYD 9€9T TT0-8ZT-60-81-X 14 IVNIQYYD 6859 800-821-50°61- X| [a HIONTISWYV-E0 Vid 006'%BES 22/22/60 00L'61S 00S'63ES HLONIISINV-E0 Vid 00S'69ES 72/60/60 20'591$ PEOETS 'T T26'9LTS 9v0'8875 SoH pooyioqBaN / sishjeuy 133 5207 seoz/st/zt 19
Page 20
20 Subject and Comparable Map – 2024 Subject and Comparable Map — 2024 5 5 8 of ox % = : i % 2% g Ew 2 EN = S= ) %, H 83 = (Fd = © < & & 15 2 @ ov 8 Hero = Henbert = JE] oH = ® nS HH = 2 HH 2 Bl = El © ven Rd 8 Lochaven Rd Lochaven Rd Lochaven Rd tocha = = I= = — 2 : 3 = 5] 7 5 = Lo = g inal Rid ct g cardinal Ridge 1D @6pry jeuipsen 5 > 2 oO & (Cr & ~ pr [=3 & S = 2 = 2 = = = Ss = i irk Dr @ Yiey POO, ung, Daman uoIaH Heron Vig 1580 Huntwood Park West Bloomfield MI Petrolia St oe & xs Petrolia St 1715 Heron View West Bloomfield MI g 1636 Cardinal Ridge West Bloomfield MI Scotch Lake, > -e marcedes Ave Mercedes Ave w : 20
Page 21
21 Subject and Comparable Map – 2025 Subject and Comparable Map — 2025 IN PiBULLIOOIE ISM YiEd POOMUNH #09} ) IN PiRULLI00G 153M MBIA U0IRH 71/1} sous dewe podsy swe] F———-jwg 2/6009 c70ZA BiEp dep py pURWIRH 5 P oR 4 % & 2 B&F § % 0 2 § I 2 2 iq jou) udaueN 0 g |] | g 2 rd 3 Jt 5) T & N % F 5 ) % 1 2 z 2 Q Jie |jouy S BH Piaywoolg y ° Q [3 [] § 3 H [4 8 = 8 £ i ® po) ° [4 c [1 = J A I PIRYWOOIg Sap a6PR [EUDIED £0.) v 10 [|0u uape Heron View Dr DV main uoson IN PRUWIOOE 153M MBIA LOH GILL Petrolia St Petrolia St [1] > a 0 0 | 0 0 2 [1 2 Mercedes Ave Ssaippy 21
Page 22
22 Subject Property – Sketch Subject Property — Sketch SKETCH/AREA TABLE ADDENDUM SUBJECT INFO File No. Parcel No.: X -18-05-128-033 Property Address: 1715 HERON VIEW City: WEST BLOOMFIELD County: OAKLAND State: MI ZipCode: 48324 Owner: HAMMAD, ADNAN Client: 00000 Client Address: Appraiser Name: Inspection Date: SKETCH T2437 — © ‘0 CT lo 492 sf 5 : 1 OH FR ha Ee Nl ——— 11x17 28.2" 18.7 sf in 1-B Fr a 5 1791.8 sf 1 OH FR -1—27x98 19.6 sf 27.8 o 0-6 EN 101 145 Cccp Fin FrGar ~~ — 32.3 sf 426.1 sf I< +8' BRK x 36.6' 21.2 +8' BRK x 25' oma yw _— 22
Page 23
23 Subject Property - File Maintenance Record Subject Property - File Maintenance Record 7/2025 08:45 AM Comments Report X -18-05-128-033 4/14/25 Updated s 09/29/23 - Updated i 09/26/23 ~- Updated 23
Page 24
Scope of Work This Valuation Disclosure has been prepared due to a Statutory Duty of the Assessor defending an Ad Valorem property assessment. We have not been granted access to the subject property for this disclosure, or for the original Ad Valorem assessment. In such cases where we have not had access to the subject property, the condition, quality and amenities may be based upon an estimate. We have taken reasonable steps to ensure that these estimates are reasonable and just. Market research includes a review of recorded sales, current listings of the subject's market area and/or competing market areas. Certification The undersigned certify that: To the best of our belief, all statements and information contained herein are true and correct, subject to the assumptions and limiting conditions as set forth in the valuation disclosure. We have no present or contemplated future interest in the property that is the subject of this valuation disclosure. We have no personal interest or bias with respect to the subject matter of this valuation disclosure or the parties involved. This assignment is a statutory requirement. This valuation disclosure was not contingent upon the value estimated, nor upon reporting a predetermined value. The Assessor's Department for the Charter Township of West Bloomfield completed this document for the Michigan Tax Tribunal proceedings. Michigan statute requires the annual assessment of property. This valuation disclosure has been prepared with accepted standards of assessment administration. The wages of the West Bloomfield Assessing Department personnel are not contingent in any outcome of the proceedings. Daniel L. Sears, Chief Appraiser Trt NS Keith Hartman, Property Appraiser Ange sia Chief Appraiser
Page 25
25 Robert C. Scripture MMAO, Michigan Master Assessing Officer Certified Personal Property Examiner West Bloomfield Assessor Current Employment: Charter Township of West Bloomfield ~ Assessor 2016 – Present Previous Employment: Oakland County Equalization ~ Chief Assessor 2004 – 2016 Certifications: Michigan Masters Assessing Officer (MMAO) R-8560 2014 Michigan Certified Personal Property Examiner #1810 Formal Education: Baker College of Business, Auburn Hills Bachelor of Business Administration Oakland Community College Associates of Business Affiliations: IAAO – Member OCAAO – Trustee, Technology Committee MAA – District III Representative, Long-Term Planning Committee, Instructor, Author
Page 26
26 DANIEL L. SEARS, MAAO (3) CHIEF PROPERTY APPRAISER CERTIFIED PERSONAL PROPERTY EXAMINER CURRENT OCCUPATION: * Chief Property Appraiser, West Bloomfield Township 1990 - Current Appraisal Education: * Fundamentals of Real Estate * Property Value Assessment Administration, Business 280 * Property Tax Law Valuation Concepts, Business 281 * Commercial and Industrial Appraisals, Business 283 * Assessment, Equalization and Allocation, Business 284 * Advanced Income Approach to Value, Business 288 * State Assessors Board, Course I and II * IAAO Mass Appraisal of Residential Property * Personal Property, MAA * Michigan Tax Tribunal Procedures, MAA * Computer, MAA * Narrative Appraisal, MAA * Tax Law and Exemptions, MAA * Appraisal Standards and Ethics, MAA * Proposal A Implementation * Planning and Administering Finance * Introduction to ArcView GIS * Advanced Computers, MAA * Principles of Public Administration, MAA * How to Critique an Appraisal, MAA Formal Education: * Oakland University, Business Management Professional Appraiser Certifications: * MAAO #1992 State Certified Appraiser * State Certified Personal Property Examiner #949 Organizations: * Michigan Assessors Association * O.C.A.A.O. Licenses: • Real Estate License
Page 27
27 Angela Skiver, MAAO (3) Chief Property Appraiser Charter Township of West Bloomfield Current Occupation Chief Property Appraiser Charter Township of West Bloomfield Appraisal Education Personal Property Course Communications/Public Speaking Course Property Tax Law Course Michigan Tax Tribunal Procedures Course Computers/Financial Calculators Course Income Approach Course Principal Residence Exemption Course General Education Associate Degree Liberal Arts Oakland Community College Appraiser Certification Michigan Advanced Assessing Officer (Level III) #8959 Certified Personal Property Examiner Michigan State Tax Commission Organizations Oakland County Association of Assessing Officers Michigan Assessors Association
Page 28
28 Keith W. Hartman, MAAO (3) Property Appraiser Charter Township of West Bloomfield Current Occupation o Property Appraiser, Charter Township of West Bloomfield 2013 – 2019 2021-Current Appraiser Education/Courses o Basic Income o Principles of Appraising o Commercial and Industrial Appraising o Statistics o Valuation and Economic Concepts o Personal Property o Land Valuation & Economic Condition Factors o Property Tax Administration o Equalization and Data Collection General Education o Bachelor of Arts in Psychology - San Francisco State University o Pre-requisites for Graduate Studies – University of British Columbia, Vancouver Appraiser Certification o Michigan Advanced Assessing Officer certification (MAAO – Level III) o Michigan Certified Assessing Officer (MCAO - Level II) o Certified Personal Property Examiner Organizations: o Michigan Assessors Association o Appraisal Institute
Page 29
29 ADDENDUMS
Page 30
30 1580 Huntwood Park – Comparable #1 (Front) 2024 un ood =. = Front 2024 tw Es 1580 H Ld Park — Comparable #1 ROR 7 IES oe Ton &v £5 NEE = ie. a a a 7 4 = ¥ ZL ad A “. 7 of Ai ir # gi x ay I =f A (i 111 Hl san 70d Ames (IAFF | a zy TTI | Te I TT] (l Iii! £ es & = =~ Bn Hi I] | os 3 Na 11] I I Ee Te SS SG Ea 2 = C7 LX CE (RN S55 £2 a» 4 XS —s F “ 2 ‘e = « hc ZL 70 ead Pe ss / AA 7 VL fi LT A 1 7 (4 4 a 2 AL 2 1 2 9 Fs, ee ae 25 "a 8 30
Page 31
31 1580 Huntwood Park – Comparable #1 (Rear) 2024 1580 Huntwood Park — Comparable #1 (Rear) 2024 ; SN RL h Lg : f 12:30 15.2022 Io) @2) 31
Page 32
32 1580 Huntwood Park – Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2024 1580 Huntwood Park — Comparable #1 (Aerial Map)
Page 33
33 6589 Cardinal Pl – Comparable #2 (Front) 2024 6589 Cardinal P| — Comparable #2 (Front ie 7 , J 40s LE / 33
Page 34
34 6589 Cardinal Pl – Comparable #2 (Rear) 2024 6589 Cardinal P| — Comparable #2 (Rear Hi 34
Page 35
35 6589 Cardinal Pl – Comparable #2 (Aerial Map) 2024 6589 Cardinal Pl — Comparable #2 § H i = 3 1 1 3 2 L] | (© Print the Map!
Page 36
36 1703 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #3 (Front) 2024 1703 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #3 (Front) 2024 36
Page 37
37 1703 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #3 (Rear) 2024 2024 #3 (Rear -— bra >>) 7 Sy 1703 re — Comparable # 37
Page 38
38 1703 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) 2024 1703 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) 2024 iE—— Standard Detaled Hybid Mor 013! bi 6) = 38
Page 39
39 1636 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #4 (Front) 2024 1636 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #4 LHR & 39
Page 40
40 1636 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #4 (Rear) 2024 1636 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #4 (Rear) 2024 40
Page 41
41 1636 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #4 (Aerial Map) 2024 1636 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #4 (Aerial Map) 2024 . 2 @
Page 42
42 1703 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #1 (Front) 2025 1703 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #1 (Front) 2025 42
Page 43
43 1703 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #1 (Rear) 2025 2025 ear #1 (Rear) 1703 oe aS — Comparable # i” J = gz 707 43
Page 44
44 1703 Cardinal Ridge – Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2025 1703 Cardinal Ridge — Comparable #1 (Aerial Map) 2025 § £ i i i 3 i 2 44
Page 45
45
1772 Heron View – Comparable #2 (Front) 2025
1772 Hero
-
RA!
~<a
n View — Com parable #2
(Front)
2025
PRIN
$s
aN
7
— “3
nn _— ER
i
a
(7a
Ni
ns
&
\
SOR
A
lid
XZ
«3
TL
'N
Vix
NZ
&7
ng
>
Ls
WV.
=
\/
a>
7
Lg
»
Va
[Sl
-—
TT)
NEA
(
4
i
D A
£4
ig
id
4
\)
+
a
~~
7%
{A
le
CL
i)
£2%
7
Ih}
fi]
!
-
[A]
1
“Ta
1}
i
ill
ii)
li
{1
J
be,
M/
Il
-)
li
Ni
Ii
Nd
hE EATER
ERT
LO
£3 +5
4 / SN
A
HEA
nD
WP,
(>
Hass
oF
,
i
4
©
Beh
I
l
KH
- AE
av
7
de
A
QV
Log
2.3
45Page 46
46 1772 Heron View – Comparable #2 (Rear) 2025 parable #2 (Rear) 2025 46 Com 1772 Heron View —
Page 47
47 1772 Heron View – Comparable #2 (Aerial Map) 2025 1772 Heron View — Comparable #2 (Aerial Map)
Page 48
48 1604 Huntwood Park – Comparable #3 (Front) 2025 1604 Huntwood Park — Comparable #3 (Front) 2025 LR Ney A NE 4 SHR Fh Z HEIL AY Plea
Page 49
49 1604 Huntwood Park – Comparable #3 (Rear) 2025 1604 Huntwood Park — C NE ix omparable #3 (Rear) 2025 = REAL 49
Page 50
50 1604 Huntwood Park – Comparable #3 (Aerial Map) 2025 1604 Huntwood Park — Comparable #3 (Aerial Map)
Page 51
51 Subject Listing – Page 1 11/5/25, 7:29 AM Subject Listing — Page 1 Realcomp Online Residential Full_w/Photos 1715 Heron View Court, West Bloomfield Twp 48324-3997 20230062024 Area: 02181 - West Bloomfield Twp Short Sale: No LP: $379,900 Residential DOM: N/8/8 Trans Type: Sale oP: $379,900 Status: Sold ERTS/FS Sh $373,000 Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 2.0 Acreage: 0.25 Township: lest Bloomfield gro sz; 3 car LotDim: 89.17 x 134.50 Mailing City: ~~ West Bloomfield Grg Dim: Rd Front Ft: 72 Side of Str: Grg Feat: Attached School Dist: ~~ Waterford Location Lochaven Road and Greer Road Directions: Quarter mile North of Greer Road, Huntwood Meadows subdivision on the West side of Lochaven Road Square Footage Layout Contact Information Saft Source: Assessor Beds: 3 Name: RUSS RAGONE Est Fin Abv Gr: 1,831 Baths: 2.1 Phone: (248) 506-1196 Est Fin Lower: Rooms: 9 Est Tot Lower: 1,792 Arch Sty: Ranch EstTotFin: 1,831 Arch Lv: 1 Story Price/Sqft: $207.48 Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Werfrnt Name Year Built: 1996 Water Facilities: Year Remod: Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Listing Date: 07/25/2023 List Type/Level Of Service: Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 07/29/2023 Srves Offered: Arrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 07/31/2023 Off Mkt Date: 07/31/2023 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 90 Restrictions: Exclusions: Possession: Close Plus 31-60 Days Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional, FHA MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS # 20230062024 Listing Exemptions: Features Pets Allowed: Entry Location: Ground Level Foundation: Basement Fndtn Material: Poured Basement: Unfinished Exterior: Brick, Vinyl Cnstret Feat: Fireplc Fuel: Gas Fireplace Loc: Great Room Porch Type: Patio, Porch Roof Material: Asphalt Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling Central Air Wer Htr Fuel: Natural Gas Road: Cul-De-Sac Water Source: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Elooring Room Level Dimen Elooring Bath - Full First/Entry 9x5 Ceramic Bath - Lav First/Entry 6x5 Ceramic Bath - Primary First/Entry 13 x9 Ceramic Bedroom First/Entry 15 x 10 Carpet Bedroom First/Entry 14 x 10 Carpet Bedroom - Primary First/Entry 20 x 11 Carpet Breakfast Nook/Room First/Entry 11 x9 Wood Dining Room First/Entry 11x 10 Wood Great Room First/Entry 24 x 16 Wood Kitchen First/Entry 11x 10 Wood Laundry Area/Room First/Entry 7 x 6 Ceramic Other First/Entry 7x7 ‘Wood Legal/Tax/Financial Property 1D: 1805128033 Subdivision: ~~ HUNTWOOD MEADOWS NO 2 Ownershij Standard (Private) Occupant: ~~ Owner Tax Summer: $1,794 Tax Winter: $1,133 Homestead: Yes Oth/Sp Asmnt:6.00 $143,290 Taxable Value: $83,930 Existing Lease: No Home Warranty: Yes T2N, R9E, SEC 5 HUNTWOOD MEADOWS NO 2 LOT 73 4-12-95 FR 127-005 Homeowner Association Information 100 Working Capital: Association Contact\Website: Fee Frequency: Annually Association Phone\Email: 248-123-4567 Fee Includes: Agent/Office Information List Office: Real Broker LLC List Office Ph: (517) 200-3245 List Agent: RUSS RAGONE [ig List Agent Ph: (248) 506-1196 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox LB Location: Front Door Remarks Public Welcome to this exquisite ranch home, perfectly situated on a peaceful cul-de-sac. The original owner spared no expense, adding all the Remarks desirable extras offered by the builder. From the first floor laundry to the extra half-bath, additional square footage, and a private direct entry to the basement this home has it all! Plus it is a "true ranch"... no step-downs like you'll find in many other ranch homes. Indulge in the luxurious master suite with a jacuzzi tub and separate shower, complemented by a spacious walk-in closet. Granite countertops. adorn all the bathrooms, while the kitchen boasts its own granite countertops and a cozy breakfast nook. With generously-sized bedrooms and storage closets galore, staying organized is effortless. The charm of hardwood floors and cathedral ceilings exudes elegance throughout. Step outside to the vast back patio and relish in the possibilities for outdoor entertainment. If you would like a fence for more privacy, kids, or pets... Good News... this association is one of very few in West Bloomfield that allow yard fences! The unfinished basement has plumbing prep for a full bathroom... for when its time for you to finished the basement. New roof less than 15 years ago, hardwood floors and granite countertops were installed in 2012, and additional insulation added in the attic just last year. ly, the highly-reg West d Schools of Choice are within reach, ensuring exceptional education for your family. Seller is also including a home warrantee! The seller kindly requests offers to include post-closing occupancy, and appliances (as-is) are negotiable. Agent is related to Seller. REALTOR® BATVAL Sold As-Is. All Measurements are approximate. Buyer's agent must be physically present at all showings and inspection (the Remarks: entire duration). SentriLock will only allow access during the scheduled appointment time frame. For offers, please reference the hitps://matrix.realcomponline.com/Matrix/Printing/PrintOptions.aspx?c=H4sIAAAAAAAEAIWS|AZM1HSUTIF YkMgNjIwN4F TeaUSORBCYRyZhS9QMg... 1/4 51
Page 52
52 Subject Listing – Page 2 11/5/25, 7:29 AM Subject Listing — Page 2 Realcomp Online disclosures. Home warrantee is included. Seller is aware that some updates are necessary, but these are apparent during the showing walk-through. Any negotiation after inspection is expected to be for only major unknown repairs. No games of high offer with intent to widdle down price after inspection will be played. Thank you! Sold Date: 3rd Party Appr: Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agent: Sell Concessions: Sell Concession Comments: — Sold Information $373,000 Short Sale: No CONV sale SP/SaFt Abv: $204 09/08/23 Arterra Realty Michigan LLC Heather Hosking Sold Price: Finance Code: No 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker compensation; (ii) disclose broker compensation; (iil) represent brokerage services are free or available at no cost unless na financial compensation from any source will be received; or (iv) make any concession limited to or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative. ANY — Notices and Disclaimers SP/LP:98.18% SP/OLP:98.18% Selling Office Ph: (248) 731-0048 Selling Agent Ph:(248) 731-0048 Co-Selling Agt Ph: DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP I1 LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. 2. Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3. The accuracy of all information transmitted herewith, regardless of source, though deemed refiable, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Copyright© Realcomp II Ltd All Rights Reserved, https://matrix.realcomponline.com/Matrix/Printing/PrintOptions.aspx?c=H4sIAAAAAAAEAItWsjA2M 1 HSUTIF YkMgNjlwN4F TeaUSORBCyRyZh59QMg.. 52
Page 53
53 Subject Listing – Page 3 Subject Listing — Page 3 11/5/25, 7:29 AM Realcomp Online https:/matrix.realcomponline.com/Matrix/Printing/PrintOptions. aspx ?c=H4s|AAAAAAAEAIIWsjAZM1HSUTIF YkMgNjiwN4F TeaUSORBCyRyZh59QMg. . 53 3/4
Page 54
54 Subject Listing – Page 4 Subject Listing — Page 4 Realcomp Online 11/5/25, 7:29 AM Basement plumbing prep for full bathroom Yard fences are allowed by the association! https:/matrix.realcomponline.com/Matrix/Printing/PrintOptions.aspx?c=H4s|IAAAAAAAEAI'WS|A2ZM 1 HSUTIF YkMgNjiwN4F TeaUSORBCyRyZh59QMg.... 4/4 54