25-003417.pdf
Alfa Kibbi Properties LLC, Petitioner V City Of Detroit, Respondent · 25-003417-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
RECEIVED
FEB 03 2026
MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL
’
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
MARLON |. BROWN, DPA
GOVERNOR
MICHIGAN OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS AND RULES
ACTING DIRECTOR
SUZANNE SONNEBORN
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
PROPERTY TAX APPEAL ANSWER FORM
VALUATION / EXEMPTION / CLASSIFICATION APPEAL
MOAHR DOCKET NO. __ 257-003 417-TT
Pursuant to Michigan Tax Tribunal Rule (TTR) 277(3), you MUST submit a copy of the notice giving rise to the appeal
{e.g. Board of Review Decision, Notice of Uncapping, or Assessment Change Notice) with this Small Claims Answer, if
applicable. if you do not submit this document, you may be held in default.
Section 1: Respondent’s Contact Information
First Name:
M.A:
Last Name/Company Name/Unit of Government:
Alfa libb;
Fropecties LLC
Home Address (No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route):
County:
Moo]
SouthPleld
RD,
Ste
loo
Oafland
City or Town:
State:
iP Code:
South bred
M]
Usors
Telephone Number:
Fax Number:
E-mail Address (do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email):
Section 2: Respondent's Attorney/Authorized Representative’s Contact information
I
First Name:
ME:
Last Name:
Cole.
:
Brock
Firm Name {if any):
Address {No., Street, P.O, Box or Ruraf Route):
2 Woodard
# 804
City or Town:
State:
ZIP Code:
Perot +
MN)
48226
Telephone Nuniber:
Fax Number:
212-654 ~4478
E-mail Address (do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondance via email):
Cole. broch @ debrott
mi. pov
Section 3: Subject Property InformationPage 2
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
MARLON |. BROWN, DPA
GOVERNOR
MICHIGAN OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS AND RULES
ACTING DIRECTOR
SUZANNE SONNEBORN
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Section 4: Explain Your Answer to this Appeal
Propecty is
10 1me With
ECF nebhborhoed 5 value.
Bequest
+o sustain
property
Value
Section 5; Jurisdictional Issues
IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE TRUE CASH ANDIOR TAXABLE VALUES
Did Petitioner protest the assessment ata — {BOR)? [i] Yes
[i] No
if yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended:
March
[W] July
[} December
If no, was the Notice of Assessment properly sent to Petitioner prior to the March BOR? 0 Yas
[| No
*Submit a copy of the Notice of Assessment with the Answer.
ifthe July or December BOR revised the assessment(s) at issue, did it have authority? [H] Yes
[ma] No
If yes, cite the Board's authority.
/
Was the assessment(s} at issue established as the result of a clerical error or mutual mistake of fact? [i] Yes
Eno
Hf yes, explain
Is Petitioner
appealing from a State Tax Commission Order?
(m]} Yes
NoPage 3
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
GOVERNOR
MICHIGAN OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS AND RULES
SUZANNE SONNEBORN
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
/
MARLON |. BROWN, DPA
ACTING DIRECTOR
Did Petitioner request a Poverty Exemption at
a BOR? 0 Yes
Hho
If Yes, check which BOR Patitioner attended: O March
[| July
O December
List the date the BOR denied Petitioner's Poverty Exemption:
IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE DENIAL OF AN EXEMPTION
OTHER THAN POVERTY, PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE, OR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL EXEMPTIONS
Did Petitioner request the exemption at
a BOR? [I] Yes
[1] No
If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner altended: i] March
0 July
[I] December
Tax Year(s) denied:
List the date the exemption was denied:
What statutory section did Petitioner request the subject property be exempt?
IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY
What do you believe the classification should be:
Real
Personal
{check cne}
O
Agricultural
Commercial
Industrial
Residential
Timber-Cutover
Developmental
Utility
(check one)
Section 6: Valuation Information *use the multiple parcet form for additional, contiguous parcels.
Parcel Identification Number:
Classificatjon of Property:
Real
oe
{check one)
Agricultural
Commercial
Industrial
Resident];
imber-Cutover
Developmental
‘o
(check one)
Current Assessed Value {also known as State Equalized Value) as established by the BOR:
$33,000
Current Taxable Value as established by the BOR:
$34 ,6¢9
What do you believe is the fair market value (also known as True Cash Value)?
$64,000
Multiply the True Gash Value by 6 and enter here. This is your contention of Assessed Value,
$32,000
If you betieve the Taxable Value differs from your contention of Assessed Value, enter your contention of Taxable Value.Page 4
#x+P993URTENL 30U INQ ITqET
rm.
$008
°zZT
mgo8 ‘ze
loos ‘zz
oov’ze
007
£202.
2076 ‘€Z
00L’LT
00€’LZ
00%
202
I3930
ZAN 8002/21/50
S
0289 ‘ve
W000 ‘ze
000°zE
009 ‘0¢
00% ‘T
§C0Z;
Id AQY-TAL 9T0Z/10/80
TIX
saTieUs]
saTIRIUSL
isaTiRIUBY
SaTIRIUS]
9z07
aeumM
usyy
oum:
snten
15430
meTARY
snrep
‘snres
lentes
aTgexey
/TPUNgIIL
30 pawog
ipesssssy
{buTtpTIng
ipuet
Tes}
UTRTd PoOTd:
pueTien
sutaey
JuoxyIDLeM!
pug,
pspooy
duemg:
padeospueT;
ubtH
MOT
Burrioy
Taa2T!
831%
30 Aydeabodog
*STTIN punoxbzspun
SBTITTTIN pIgpueis
x
s3ybTT
3898138
X
ANTYA
pES
= SUTRA Used SNIL sIuswesosdwI PUR PSILWTISY Telol
t
oL
0z
00T
gp ¢
TT#
‘USeR axTy
:BuTousy
am
ZEN ¥04
v5
0z
00%
S0°L
333I0U0D UTP d/M/Q
|
2X
sures uses
p00Y
§ 8715
Jaey
UoT3dT 085]
|
STIYOSTE
X
UENIVI
S83BWTISE 350) uswesordur puey
18mg.
X.
MX
TTCTGELOL
Ate
PIS
EX
HZIN’E
TELE
= °NTRA DURT "3S TROL
$8IDY TEIOL TT'0
‘3393 JUOII TENIOY Of
TOMBS WIOIS
X
ang snEaW
‘uoT3eInoTRd 965I0E
Te303
BY3l
03 SINYTIJUOD
10U
OP IBYJ Sour $330UBD
Peoy psaeg
xX
1€L'T
00T
§S°0
3a bs 000°226°¥
32IS XE ILE Id 0S
PEoY Taavan
0
=00T
0
0000°0 0000°T 00°€ZT 000%
PEOY 37%TQ
sure
uosesy
-{pyy ied
yiadeg
auoxg
yadeg
sbejuoxg
uotadransaq
|
s3uswsaozduy
+ Sx030BF
oTTANg
(¥6£0Z)
¥ dNO¥O-¥¥VA INZIOFI-LZEUE ECE¥E STGRI PUBT I0J S30WTas antes pueg
Jueoes
psaoxdur x
,
~
SATIRIUSL ADL
3ST
9702
1 Haun
30
BoA:
I0I¥LSIA TOOHOS XIID IIOWIEQ
:Tooyss.
Sniels
Taqumpy
23eqQ
(s)3Tuxag
durprIng
Ty
:butuoy
OYdWI-TYIINIQISTI
:SSeTd
07001
HEISNVIL AI¥IIONd
| INIIISNI ONIGNIT WO¥I-ZT
Yd
9T0Z/0€/0T
.z06’8
“0 MAEANY
NOIY
0°00T
YRISNTIL XI¥IIoNd
YEHLO/JASN ION-TZ.
¥Id. 9T0Z/0£/0T
120S°8
“Lf MEEANY
‘NOI
0°001T
YEHLO
7928£02202
YEHIO/QESN ION-1Z.
am:
2202/11/20
.000°ze
OTT AN
0°00T
HEISNTEL AL¥IIOHEd
£00L%02202!
HIONZT §,WIY-£0:
aM
220Z/8T/T0
100S°TE
OTT SHILYAIONd
IE€IN
ssuexg
.
Ag
abea
3
adAy
ayeq
@0Tag
-3uoag
©ITITIBA
8qTT)
3TeS 3O swrel
-3sug
ates
ares
s
9202/12/10
uo peluTIg
ENAYM iA3unc)
LIO¥IHG 40 ALID
:UOTIOTPSTIANGPage 5
~xxPo97URIENG
JOU ING STRT[
ua
:swell ums dum
pr
7
3xoddng
otadeg
Tes
0007
(GT
ST50T
otades Ted 000T
is
1
TIO IBIBM
oy
arog
I9Md8 DTT
{
is
Io3en oTIANd
4S
UOT
15m55/153E
(VT)
UYSTUTI j
ueg usp
1007d
| PAODTY UI OTWRISH
pOOM
| SUTeM TTI OTWRIsD|
26699
ADL
<= QTL°0
(HINON MY¥d INEOFY
- YETE)
IDF
.
10073 TTL OTURIS)
‘DUD
:S330N
|
zamoyg sjexedes
007
SSE‘V6
LST'LST
*STR30L
HUTS BIH,
ope
LSS
6T
4dd
19TTOL
®BIIXT,
J
saynzod
Butrqunty
ON.
oo
0ZZ'6
99€’ST
80¢
180)
Iswvyg
1BSH I93BM JETOS!
0°0
isasto
(PRUSTUTIUA)
UYDUI
§T
:UOTILPUnod HUTPTS
1XOTABIXE
OD SSD
Tenuey
‘Is5us3FOS!
d
sabeae
ony
‘ISUSITOS
"d'
$3uBWASNLPY/SUOTITPOY IBYIO
|
yieg INIT
Z|
d°S
88
S6L°%8
yZe/ 191
1Te303
gseg SInIxTL £1
uoT
91
Juswe seq
BuTPTS
£1038
T
| (s)sanaxid sbexsay
Le
Juswesed
butpts
Ax03S5
ST°T
sutqunta
(£1)
aso
-adsqg
MIN
3ISOD
ITTS
UOTIBPUNCT
JIOTIADIXY
§9TI03§
=
seaxy Burpiing
M8
“aay
¥ | AueH!
09/00T/00T/00T/09=P00D
§ "qWOD/UODE/Pund/Aud
av/Aud
5201900 001d 70 oN
3S
908
= ®aIy I00Td
dS
889
= PAIY PUNOID
|
e
-
—
syong
O/# ITY PODIod
1WSISAS BUTITIH
((1)
UTH!
PIO
X
hac
yer 31d
OD
STD
ATINVA TTONIS
ATTwed oTHuUTS
T
:5pTH "$9 IOF
"ISH IS0D |
s2aniIxtd
JO "Tend/
oN
we3shs A3TIND3S|
2014238 SAWY(Q
soon
_
Cm
wnnoes TeIIUSD;
>
1227Y 330908
Fie ioe xen Toa0s
z030RdWOD UseAL
21232913
(21)
0TL"0
X
N
runes;
soRUANg
POO,
N
Cyne
N
"OHI
:ebexen Jwwsg
-3-5°%
L6Z7LST ives oaoy
sbuey ueaTD ITOS
ITY TeIIUSD|
REX
0
1I00Td
DUO) ON:
1oBy
‘05
sbuey paepuels;
HUTTCOD/BUTIEAH ON
1TEWS]
07
:3b¥
"39333
SARMOIOTH
;
’
0
:esiy abex03s,
0
isSBTD
:
dumg esq
$39
0
:poo9
3
uso
T003
3 1EsH pPavIOI
80€
:®aIY
°9 PIIUBA-IODITQ
qnr- dex TzZZnoRL
soRUINg T0OTA/TTeH!
UTH
:
.
240
00M
qn TzInOEp
0
:sx00Q
JUOSH
38 poe
woo 28uT
z23e8y soed
uoTIB
0
:SI00Q
"03INY
Y3lIeeH
posTeyd
:
QE8H TTeM OTIIOLT
ii pIUSTUTI
TORBINDATH ISH]
POOH Pa3u@A
(x00TF~UT)
IURTPE
| O31 poop:
youl
gr
:uoTiepunog
41035
g qeFsid;
pool pelusaun
JueTpey TTD
‘09T
I935RTd,
SUYoe31Seg
:TTEM UOUMIOD
Axo3s
1
qegeag;
AOL
30H,
pIecgesedg 2TII08TH
0
I USA
SUO03AS
| Ax03g
7 z0TIDINH
uel
JUBA
I87eN
10H POOIOI
0
:-usA ¥OTIE
| Kz03g
T F0TIIXT
To3e0H UBL
$3000
/# ITY P9203
BueyIL
BUTPTS
:XOTISIXI
PIPTS omy
TesodsTq @beqren
$3000 O/m ITY PeoI0d|
X
fuoeao
.
5
:sserd
a
T
AORIS Bueg/pug
IYSeMUST
-
o
:Aatoeden xed:
kt
I
. £7038
7 I0TIBIUL
dol
%00D:
wesas
Te0D
POOM
:
1aTTng XeSi
odAriesay Kxo3§
T IOTISIUT
“#oTTY eouetTddy
Td
TTO:
sen!
¥
|
ybn
sbexes
(LT)
| S¥99Q/53Y020d
(91)
ssoeTdaaTd
(ST)
Sut-37I0g
($1)
burroop/butiesy
(TT)
(r3uo
9202/12/10
uo paUTII
“86G6Z0TC
IPQqUNN TI0XBJPage 6
City of Detroit Assessor Office 2 Woodward, Ste 804 Detroit MI 48226 Kibbi Properties LLC 24001 Southfield Rd, Ste 100 Southfield MI 48075
Page 7
7 2 - - - - - - _ . =. - - — ~ oo - - oo - - - oo - - : - . . = ~ - ~ - oo - Co ~ - - . - oo - - - : _ - - : a - - - . . _ - . - 7 - — . _ : - _ oo = % . 0 . = - - on . - _ ~ oo . . J . . - - ~ . - - - . - _ 4 ET = . ~ - . _ . - _ . - - - > . - ~~ = / - _ _ - . . =~ a - 2 . _ = = - - _ ~ - - - a Fr we 5 - ie - - . a - - | 2 5 : - 0 - = = > - . -_ - . - . - _ - 0 . 2 : - - - - - = . ow 5 o . - - _ . C = - e . - = oo . . - _ oo . 0 - . - : . . - - . _ - = : - . - - - - = oN - - < . - = - - - . - . - =~ ¢ - ~ - = - oo ~ i = . . : - - So . _ oo oo ~ - — ~ . . > x ‘a _ _ - - - ~ : - . - _ = - ~~ - - Go _ > oo oo - - = = .- lL Po . _ . - _ oo oo . - - : = - - J 7 - - - - _ = A - i _ - - - - - - rw 5 - - Ee 2 ~ — - - y - _ - - : — - L = Po - . . - _ _ . = Po -— - a - c = . _ . . . - . . = - . - . - - - : . oo - - - . PE = _ : - - . fp - - - - - _ - - Ee - oo - = oo oe i - co _ = iL - “ - - . _ - - - - > - PL = . Pp - - . . . = . . Pe - - — - - . - | > - L _ _ - - oo - = - - -.- - - . _ LE _ . = | . - - - ~ - - ~~ - - = - > : - - : . = - . - . - - _ |] - _ - _ - . _ - - - - . . = - . - - : - 4 0 . . — - . - 0 - . - - - : - =. - . . - _ — = - - < _ = . oo : oo _ - . - _ oo oo - . - - _ . - - - - - . = - . - - o _ . - . - - . . . . - - - - . - - a = . . = - - - . 0 - = - bo 0 . . = = - - - _ To a . - - oo - > - - - - . - - : - - . ~ : . - . . - . - - - - oo | -
Page 8
0 em ce | . . . . Lo - oo - - - oo - - - . . - | . - = - - - oo _ - . - 0 - . _ - < - - - - . A oy = - - - - > > oo 0 oo - - . . oo Co _ - : PE . - . - oo - - < - vy 0 - _ - - - = © 3 = = . = - - : : - _ . _ = Lo = oo . - = a - > eo = . - - x Le - . = - co . . - . . > 7 - : - . - = z > . - . - . - - . - 0 - = _ - - ~ oc e oo Po iP _ - : - _ _ - = _ - oo 4 oo = - - - _ oo = - : - - - No 0 . - - _ - ~~ = - vo - - - = . < - - - ~ - . oo - - - - - = - - - - . . e - . . . = . : ~ . oo - - - a - - . . = _ : - | _ - _ = - . _ _ Z - - - . - = - i ~ . : L - Ye a - - - - . - . = - - . _ - - - _ - . - | : = oo - = = oo . - | ~ . - - | ~ - | | - . - - - . = - : . = - = . . oo - - - . : - - Le - - i - - - - 1 - _ _ - oo oo = : ~ - - - - | - 0 . - - . . ~ - i - . _ =~ - - . ~ 7 - - ji - : = | - - - . - - - - = 0 - - | - . - - . - - . - = - - c . . - = - _ = - - - . = _ = - - - . - - - - oe - - . - - - . _ _ _ - - = =~ =~ - _ - = - - - - - _ - . _ - . Pe <n . oo - - ~~ Pe Ee = = . - - _ c - - = = = - or i . - . _ - = 0 - - - - . oo - rr _ . - - - - - _ - - - - Co : : - _ - - - . 0 . - - - = . ~ - . os - - - - . =]
Page 9
STATE OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING & REGULATORY AFFAIRS MICHIGAN ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING SYSTEM MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL Alfa Kibbi Properties LLC Petitioner, v MTT Docket No. 22-003417-TT CITY OF DETROIT, Respondent. PROOF OF SERVICE On 01/27/2026 1, Cole Brock, mailed a copy of the City of Detroit's Answer relative to the above-captioned matter to: Alfa Kibbi Properties LLC 16074 Eastburn Detroit MI., 48205 Michigan Tax Tribunal Po Box 30232 Lansing MI, 48909 I declare that the statement above is true to the best of my information, knowledge, and belief, Dated: 01-27-2026
Page 10
x a NE Ah 4 dy of bDoboit Yessesso 5 OFFiae 2 woodwer & Ble. QU Dobos WT , U9 De cH Hw 0) A = Qporteres oF Fie gen “Tos P.O. Box 0 Lowing \HI