Carlson -Final.pdf
Daniel S Carlson Business Trust, Petitioner V City Of Farmington Hills, Respondent · 25-002827-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
Summary of Analysis: Daniel S Carlson Docket No: 25-002827 32781 West Eleven Mile Farmington Hills MI 48336 The subject is located near the central quadrant of the city of Farmington Hills which borders the city of Farmington. The comparable properties are all located in the city of Farmington Hills. The subject’s neighborhood is bound by Eleven Mile to the north, Orchard Lake Road to the east, Ten Mile Road to the south, and Farmington Road to the west. The subject property was built in 1920. Additions were built in 1983 and 1990. The subject property has a 1 story style design. The subject property is reported to have 5 bedrooms with 5.5 baths. The subject property does have a finished basement. The subject property sits on an approximately 2.76-acre site. The property has an inground pool, deck, carport and paver patios. The homeowner is stating they believe their fair market value is $900,000. Since the property sold in 2024 the taxable value became uncapped in 2025. Thus the 2025 Assessed and Taxable values are equal. The property sold in a non-arms length transaction in 2026 to related parties in 2025. Thus, the property became uncapped for the 2026 assessment year as well. Property Tax Assessment: Parcel number: 22-23-22-126-064 Year TCV SEV TV 2025 $1,137,165 $568,580 $568,580 Parcel number: 22-23-22-126-064 Year TCV SEV TV 2026 $ 1,142,998 $ 571,500 $ 571,500
Page 2
Summary of Analysis: Daniel S Carlson Docket No: 25-002827 MARKETING AND EXPOSURE PERIOD The subject property was originally marketed in early 2024 for $1,590,000. The listing price was substantially reduced to $999,900 in August of 2024 before being reduced again to $950,000 in October of 2024 before selling for $950,000. The property was purchased by Ferris State University in 2019 for a reported price of $1,100,000. The property was sold a short time after for $715,000 in 2020. The 2024 purchase in our opinion was not a totally arms-length transaction due to the over 75% reduction from the original listing price and the fact seller obtain the property for a favorable price from a university in 2020 and had substantial equity after 4 years of ownership.
Page 3
Summary of Analysis: Daniel S Carlson Docket No: 25-002827 SALES COMPARISON ANALYSIS 2025 To support the city’s contention of the 2025 assessed value the comparable sales analysis is discussed below. Comparable sales took place between January 31, 2023, and April 17, 2025. The 2023 sales were included due to the lack of 2024 sales of similar style houses. Comparables 3 and 6 sold after December 31, 2024, but are included in the analysis because the sales conditions are similar to December 31, 2024. All of the comparables warrant adjustments for effective age. The subject property was built in 1920 with additions in 1983 and 1990. All of the comparables were built between 1964 to 1994. The comparable properties warrant downward adjustments for the subject’s inferior location on the main street. The adjustment is limited along this section of West Eleven Mile Road. Comparable 1 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. Comparable 2 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. Comparable 3 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. Comparable 4 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. Comparable 5 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location.
Page 4
Summary of Analysis: Daniel S Carlson Docket No: 25-002827 Comparable 6 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. After the adjustments are applied the comparables support a True Cash Value range between $949,101 to $1,319,858. The average indicated value of all 6 six comparable is $1,170,944. Due to the unique nature of the subject property it is difficult to place sole reliance on one sale comparable to determine the subjects value. Thus, the average indicated value for 2025 is rounded to $1,170,000. 2026 To support the city’s contention of the 2026 assessed value the comparable sales analysis is discussed below. Comparable sales took place between May 13, 2025, and January 9, 2026. Sale comparable 3 was negotiated prior to December 31, 2025. All of the comparables warrant adjustments for effective age. The subject property was built in 1920 with additions in 1983 and 1990. The comparables were built between 1972 to 2019. Sale comparables 1 and 2 warrant downward adjustments for the subject’s inferior location on a main street. Comparable 3 does not warrant an adjustment because it is also located along West Eleven Mile road. Comparable 1 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. Building Comparable 1 also warrants a greater adjustment under location due to its proximity to Franklin. Comparable 2 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches, basement square footage and finish and location. Comparable 3 warrants adjustment for improvements in market conditions, differences in land value, building effective age, building square footage, number of bathrooms, garage square footage, porches and basement square footage and finish.
Page 5
Summary of Analysis: Daniel S Carlson Docket No: 25-002827 The reference sale was not used in the primary comparable analysis because the sale occurred well after the appraisal sale date but does support the 2026 value estimate. The subject property is larger in acreage and significantly larger in building size (6,747 square feet) compared to (2,978 square feet). The reference sale supports the city’s contention of value for the 2026 year. After the adjustments are applied the comparables support a True Cash Value range between $1,149,336 to $1,464,232. The average indicated value of all 3 six comparables is $1,268,263. Due to the unique nature of the subject property, it is difficult to place sole reliance on one sale comparable. Thus, the average indicated value for 2026 is rounded to $1,270,000. The sale comparables indicate the subjects True Cash Value for the 2025 assessment year is well supported. The analysis supports the city’s 2025 contention of value of: $1,137,165 (True Cash Value) $568,580 (SEV) $568,580 (TAXABLE) Property Sale Acreage Sale Year Square Price per Address Price Size Date Built Feet sf 33733 Braebury Ridge $800,000 2.1 7/16/2026 1947 2,978 $269.00 Reference sale
Page 6
Summary of Analysis: Daniel S Carlson Docket No: 25-002827 The sale comparables indicate the subjects True Cash Value for the 2026 assessment year is well supported. The analysis supports the city’s 2026 contention of value of: $1,142,998 (True Cash Value) $571,500 (SEV) $571,500
Page 7
2025 Comparable Analysis Feature Subject Parcel Comparable #1 Comp. #1 Adjustment Comparable #2 Comp. #2 Adjustment Comparable #3 Comp. #3 Adjustment Comparable #4 Comp. #4 Adjustment Comparable #5 Comp. #5 Adjustment Comparable #6 Comp. #6 Adjustment Parcel Number 22-23-22-126-064 22-23-01-276-023 0 22-23-01-277-004 0 22-23-11-204-004 0 22-23-12-152-011 0 22-23-12-376-031 0 22-23-14-326-019 0 Address 32781 ELEVEN MILE 27816 LAKEHILLS 0 32426 SCOTTSDALE 0 29252 SUMMERWOOD DR 0 28899 MILLBROOK 0 28575 DANVERS CT 0 26823 SHADY CREEK 0 Record Card Image Appraisal/Sale Date 12/31/24 01/31/23 67,032 02/27/23 38,813 03/17/25 06/02/23 43,200 11/29/23 36,238 04/17/25 Land Size (Summary Acreage) 2.767 2.000 0 1.000 0 0.000 0 2.000 0 4.000 0 1.000 0 Land Value 124,311 116,500 7,811 100,000 24,311 49,500 74,811 122,595 1,716 149,160 (24,849) 62,040 62,271 Style RANCH CONTEMP. 0 RANCH 0 OTHER 0 COLONIAL 0 OTHER 0 CONTEMP. 0 Year Built 1920-1954 1970 0 1969 0 1968 0 1964 0 1978 0 1994 0 Effective Age 59 48 ($92,169) 48 ($55,688) 50 ($49,613) 51 ($57,600) 43 ($133,800) 30 ($205,538) Square Feet 6,747 5,852 53,700 4,248 149,940 2,891 231,360 4,341 144,360 4,552 131,700 6,343 24,240 Quality BC A 0 B + 10 0 C + 10 0 B + 10 0 B 0 B 0 Bedrooms 5 4 0 4 0 4 0 5 0 3 0 4 0 Full Baths 5 5 0 2 18,000 3 12,000 5 0 3 12,000 4 6,000 Half Baths 1 1 0 2 3,500 0 3,500 1 0 1 0 2 (3,500) Basement Square Feet 5,510 1,659 77,020 3,418 41,840 1,213 85,940 1,900 72,200 1,941 71,380 3,839 33,420 Fin Basement Sq. Feet 3,467 0 104,010 0 104,010 0 104,010 1,000 74,010 0 104,010 0 104,010 Garage Square Feet 2,376 1,056 16,500 528 23,100 0 29,700 939 17,963 851 19,063 844 19,150 Porches (Value) 35,056 19,900 15,156 3,347 31,709 8,233 26,823 23,612 11,444 10,204 24,852 23,759 11,297 Land Improvements (Value) 54,774 45,316 9,458 8,122 0 3,563 0 58,336 0 9,172 0 24,649 0 Location (55,860) (33,750) (36,750) (48,000) (55,750) (47,250) Actual Sale Price 1,117,200 675,000 735,000 960,000 1,115,000 945,000 Net Adjustments 202,658 345,786 481,782 259,293 184,844 4,101 Net Adjustments % 18.14% 51.23% 65.55% 27.01% 16.58% 0.43% Gross Adjustments 442,856 490,911 617,757 422,493 557,892 469,426 Gross Adjustments % 39.64% 72.73% 84.05% 44.01% 50.04% 49.67% Adjusted Sale Price 1,319,858 1,020,786 1,216,782 1,219,293 1,299,844 949,101 Actual Sale Price $/Sq.Ft. 190.91 158.90 254.24 221.15 244.95 148.98 Adjusted Sale Price $/Sq.Ft. 195.62 151.29 180.34 180.72 192.66 140.67 Average of Comparables Method Estimated Value: $1,170,944
Page 8
2026 Comparable Analysis for Subject Parcel Feature Subject Parcel Comparable #1 Comp. #1 Adjustment Comparable #2 Comp. #2 Adjustment Comparable #3 Comp. #3 Adjustment Parcel Number 22-23-22-126-064 22-23-12-227-032 0 22-23-15-352-009 0 22-23-23-127-015 0 Address 32781 ELEVEN MILE 30545 INKSTER 0 26186 PILLSBURY 0 30527 ELEVEN MILE 0 Record Card Image Appraisal/Sale Date 12/31/25 05/13/25 28,000 08/11/25 8,000 01/09/26 0 Land Size (Summary Acreage) 2.767 2.000 0 1.000 0 1.350 0 Land Value 124,311 114,840 9,471 69,333 54,978 99,000 25,311 Style RANCH RANCH 0 TRI-LEVEL 0 COLONIAL 0 Year Built 1954 1987 0 1972 0 2019 0 Effective Age 59 29 ($364,000) 41 ($182,000) 8 ($382,500) Square Feet 6,747 4,564 130,980 3,423 199,440 2,917 229,800 Quality BC B 0 C 0 C + 10 0 Bedrooms 5 2 0 4 0 4 0 Full Baths 5 6 (6,000) 3 12,000 4 6,000 Half Baths 1 0 3,500 0 3,500 0 3,500 Basement Square Feet 5,510 4,353 23,140 0 110,200 1,283 84,540 Fin Basement Sq. Feet 3,467 4,353 (26,580) 0 104,010 0 104,010 Garage Square Feet 2,376 1,378 34,930 1,000 48,160 1,043 46,655 Porches (Value) 35,056 4,265 30,791 2,123 32,933 3,036 32,020 Land Improvements (Value) 54,774 78,928 0 34,385 0 14,921 0 Location (160,000) (40,000) Actual Sale Price 1,600,000 800,000 1,000,000 Net Adjustments (135,768) 391,221 149,336 Net Adjustments % 8.49% 48.90% 14.93% Gross Adjustments 817,392 795,221 914,336 Gross Adjustments % 51.09% 99.40% 91.43% Adjusted Sale Price 1,464,232 1,191,221 1,149,336 Actual Sale Price $/Sq.Ft. 350.57 233.71 342.82 Adjusted Sale Price $/Sq.Ft. 217.02 176.56 170.35 Average of Comparables Method Estimated Value: $1,268,263
Page 9
Sorry, we have no imager Map data ©2026 Google 2 km Report a map error A 32781 West Eleven Mile Farmington hIlls B 27816 Lakehills Farmington hIlls C 32426 Scottsdale Farmington hIlls D 29252 Summerwood Farmington hIlls E 28899 Millbrook Farmington hIlls F 28575 Danvers Farmington hIlls G 26823 Shady Creek Farmington hIlls × We use cookies to improve user experience, and analyze website traffic. For these reasons, we may share your site usage data with our analytics partners. By continuing to the site, you consent to store on your device all the technologies described in our Privacy Policy. Please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy for full details. 10/14/26, 12:43 PM BatchGeo - Sales Comparison Map https://batchgeo.com/map/efe5e007f4dc50ee8c57ff5bf07dbdec 1/2
Page 10
10/20/26, 4:19 PM rou sows Unie, Keego Harbor @ 5 ass Lak COMMERCE re WESTACRES Lake Village Wolverine Lake Walled Lake Franklin Woo. CREEK FARMS Farmington LIBERTY PARK Hills @ > 4 Novi ORCHARD HILLS Co) Farmington LAGE 0AKS © CHASE FARMS ® & :| Northville ® ww a Y Googie Ta | hi Plymouth Livonia Marker ) Street name A 32781 W Eleven Mile B 30545 Inkster [9 26186 Pillsbury D 30527 Eleven Mile https://batchgeo.com/map/857efeccd1d93d944f462d9c519be8at CASTLE ROUGE Map data ©2026 Google 2km BatchGeo - Sales Comparison Map J Fin Po Bloomfield Hills CHARING CROSS 5LOOMFIELD VILLAGE Birmingham Beverly Hills Berkley Lahm : (©) 3 © Village Et Hunt Southfield ? Oak Park \ BERG-LAHSER O'AIR PARK FIVE POINTS HOLCOMB COMMUNITY THE Eve OLD REDFORD NORTH ROSEDALE PARK ROSEDALE Bg hook PARK HISTORIC Dis’ TRICT GRANDMONT ELIZA HOWELL FRANKLIN PARK city Farmington hills Farmington hills Farmington hills Farmington hills Report a map error 12
Page 11
SUBJECT PROPERTY PHOTOS DURING 2024 MARKETING
Page 12
fl WN gy — = py | 0) — = 8 TT 5 ! Ff = ch been a hw» = Fl gr ey, ! [tml Uy oe
Page 13
il Lig Lo I 1 » ir Il
Page 14
20/8° TY 0ST 22h 000°€6€ 0ST 62 2202 ¥31N3 Viva 8T0Z/80/TT TW 209/‘8€Y 06S ‘Eb 02S ‘TTY 020°2€ £202 Q3ILD3ASNI 0Z0Z/9T/€0 Hamp 2069 09% OTE ‘TES 0ST ‘69% 09129 ¥20¢ | ¥3IN3 VIVA 0202/70/90 HAM _ n08s ‘89S WOS8S ‘896 086 ‘895 0290S 09129 §20Z| 3Bym usaym oym FE anLeA J3y30 M3 LADY anjeA anjeA anLea 9|qexeL LeunqLJL 40 pJeog passassy BuLp| Lng pue Jean uteld pooLd pue|1am auLAey FULRERER-Y puod papoom duems padesspue yb LH " won| Fa Rat ) Bui Loy dviW "770d 9T0Z ¥04 LINIWLSNCAV SY 1IVL3a yee DNIQ1ING OL 39V¥VD ANZ IAOW ST/90/0T 876°€S = an|BA Ysed andl sjuswdAoJdwI pueT palewrls3 |[eloL L 611220 659°T 6L 1 00°00T‘Z ONIdVISANY1 311s *avW HLIM @3SSNISIA "NOILYD0T WII4NOD anjeA ysed pooo % 8zLs 91ey uoLidLadsag 40 Aydeabodol OL 378VYNN "INIWLSNCAY SY WILSAS WO¥4 (S)Wa1I 9dB|d UL Lun “SLLan punodBuspun S1¥0d¥VD 7 QIAOWIY-MIIAIY Q¥0DI¥ $T/0€/9 760:¥T [013 006 07°28 JLise|d :s|00d SOLILL LIN PJepuUBlS EST €T 69 228 61 €¢ pues uo >dLJda :d/m/a LALLY pJep SZPTZZ0 ™HIDIYE YOIWILXI © ISNOH 40 14 DS S8¥ CT AS 0995 18° € buLred Jie :d/M/a s3ybL7 333.3 Q3153¥¥0D ‘HOLINS X3dV 43ILVI¥D 60-/Z-V 288°2T 6/ I 8T"S68°ST pJepuels :(s)oogqazed quand anjeA ysed poos % °zLs a1ey uoLidrJadsad ses S2UBN| JUI/SIUBMNOD S®1BWL1S3 3S0D JusWaAoJdwI puel 514133(3 JIMS £90 dd Ja1em T0-6-/ 9% ® Sb S101 40 1d ST 3 OSTV ‘Das TIE ‘bZT = anLeA puel *31s3 |e1ol S9JDV [BIOL //°7 ‘1994 1UOJ4 [BNIDY SOF JLemapLs OL 14 05°/6 M 00-9€-68 N HL "1d §¢°/0T 3 ‘uoLie| nd ed 9beadde [P1601 Syl 01 9INGLJIUOD 10U Op IBYL SAUL] SSI0UDP x JOM3S WJ01S 8y-¢¢-59 S HL "1d py N HL “¥0D 107 MS LV T6488 00T 000°€E So43v 27-1 SRV CT peoy pared 538 OX3 zy 1071 AOOMIDAIY ZZ DIS ‘36¥ ‘NIL 00099 00T 00099 Sd®JdV 00°'T JV T > peoy [3ABJD uoLidLadsag xel 00 *00T 0 000070 0000°T 00°S2¢ 00°SZT T 3IDV.INO¥US peoy 1Jia 00 =00T 0 0000°0 0000°T 00°S8€ 00°0¥Z T 3IDV.LNOUH an eA uoseay "[pvy @3ed yidea 31uodd yideg obeiuousd uoradiudssa sauawaAos dwt x SJ032Bd 4 o11qnd 0TD3S 378V.L ANV1 0TD3S 9[GeL puel Jo4 S3IBWLISI dN[BA pue] quesen| | ponoudur £00T-9¢€8y In SIRES Taras a3so1d 2150/T8d| /T0Z/TT/SO ¥IVd3¥/¥3LTV/AaV “SIMS 89T :V4L/ADL SOT‘ZET‘T ADL 353 S207 STU. SINISE +S TaTNeg ‘Nota a3so1d 0220/Tdd| £10Z/9T/S0 buLqun|d 10Z doL SSRUPPY/BUEN S$, JDUMO a3so1d Zv€08Tdd| 8102/22/90 buLqun|d %0 "3°d°d a3so1d 9€/06Tdd| 6T0Z/TIT/TT buLqund 1SIA HOS DIT8Nd NOLONIWYVH :[00YdS 31IN NIAIT3 T8/2€ snieis JaqunN a1eq (s)aLwaad buLp|Lng :6ULUOZ| OYJWI-TVILNIAISIY :SSE|D ssaJppy A14adoud a3aa 000: 0000 HLONIT S,WdV-£0 am| £96T/T0/£0 [000° ¥S 00° 00T a3aa 99:/8€¥S 1SNYL 40 1N0/OLNI-¥T am 610Z/TT/0T |000°00T‘T ALISYIAINN F1VIS ST¥¥34| ¥ B® ILVISI 39030 ‘ATTY 00°00T a3aa 069: ¥Sv¥S ANIWNYIAOD-ET am 0z0Z/61/90 [000°STZ NIANV1D ‘LI¥VAW| ALISYIAINN ILIVIS SI¥¥3d 00T a3aa STZ:6£86S HION3T S,WiV-£0 am! $202/52/TT 000006 3NISNG °S TIINVA ‘NOSTAVD NIANVID ‘LIAVW Tsuedl Ag obed » adAL ?1ea 9d Lud 3udud paL4Ldan Jaq 9[BS 40 SwJaL 3suT ales ales 991URID Jojueds 9202/€2/0T uo paiuLad pue|yeo :Aiunod STTIH NOLONIWYVH 40 ALID :UOLIDLPSLAN( $90-92T-¢2-€2-2C :49uNN |ddJed
Page 15
ogi 9 buLys poom :jo0y 22€ eddy 1uodued :9beaes uwsg 0 :JOO[d4 "Du0d ON 0 :eadv abeuols 0 :pood % 9p ready Q :sJ400Q "Yydsw 0 :s400d ‘ony SOA I paystLuld youl zy :uoLiepunod LLeM T :|Lem uowwod 0 :°USA Bu03lS 96 USA dDLJg 2LJg :J40LJ4DIXT og :sse[d Jed z :A3ideaded ued $S6T 13 LNG JIA sbeJses (£1) 9202/€2/01 poom pa1eaJl 87/ ddm|08 (A401s T) ddd 08 rom wa1SAS A1L4ndas WwNN>eA |BJd31u3d Jo1d>edwod ysedl eunes abuey ues|d J|8S abuey puepuels 906856 :°ATD'L pa1ewlls3 669‘¥85 :1s0D> Jdaa |eloL Zv0‘969‘T :MON dseg |e1ol /¥/9 1EdJV J400|d 65 :9bv "29443 OABMOJD LW Dg :sse[d udA0 BD paitoA-1294La qni- dad Lzzndec 9A01S poom qnL Lzznder WodJ433UI POOH P33IUSA POOH pa1udAuN gnL 30H ued UIA J91B9H yleg YlJeaH pasted fy J03B|NDJLD 1B3H A401s Zz qegaud AJ403S T qegadd A401S 7 J0LJ91X3 AJ401S T JOLJ®IXT |Z xxxP991UBJIENG 10U INQ D|RL|DJ PAWIIP ULDJDY UOLIBWUOIUT sys :SWelI wns dun] >11das "ed 000¢ 511das [ed 000T LLeM Jo1em Jamas dL gnd J91eM OL|gnd| T Jamas/Ja1em (¥T) ued JUdA BA0D|V gnL DLWeJdD|§ SULBM d| LL DLwedsd J00|d d| LL DLWeJdD|9 Jamoys @1ededss|T NULS BUIX3 19 LOL BJ1X3 puLqun|d ON 1e9H J@1BM JEB|OS Lenuen ‘Jauljos olny ‘Jauijos yieg sdnmixid z|T yieg sdnixid €|§ (s)34naxLd abedsav butqunid (£1) Mma4 *aAv| X | Auen $1910 "23|3 JO "ON ULW ‘pao X| x3 S94nixL4 Jo *|end/ oN 9D LAJRS sduy 002 5L4329(3 (21) @J'UJNd poom JLV |eJiusd buL|00D>/buLleaH ON dund 3eaH swedg [991s :dns*siud :ua7 paidoddnsun NoLdg :AsuwLyd 9buLys 1reydysv, x "2°09T ‘0Txz :sastoc| P3YS del jJoddns dood (OT) Pe ous pe X (Vv) sJooa 1nhoy [em Q Joon (6) 4s J400[4 ON (8) sJooa 1noy em 9 SU93JDS 7 SWJ01S| X 4s BuLALT|Z9¥€ sJ00g olled 4S uoL1ed.4d9y ysiuid uswased (6) 4004 91942U0d X pOOM pa1edJL Quo1s *2U0D paJnod OT 32018 ‘Ju0d uswasesa (8) 0°0 :sistor 03 3ybLaH "47S 690T :qelS '4°S 6G iLMedd "47S QTSS :3luswaseg uoLleAedxa (2) sbuL| Led (9) POOMpJEBH :J3y3l0 POOMpJEBH :J3Yy3l0 SLL 1uaydaL sJoo[4 (S) ‘2H X pLlOS s100a [00D 7 1BIH PDIJOL| X || [ews pJo, X | 61 @deudnd Joo|d/| [em $19S0|D JO 9ZLS J91e9H @deds uw paol x | x3 ISH LLBM O1J10913 " UoLaeJ0d0a wLdL (400 J-uL) JueLpey : JueLpey -|Ldd "7913 9%L poom pa|aued pJeogaseg d143d9|3 4931se|d| x | [|emAld J91eM 10H padJod (A401S T) ddM $22 (A401s T) d39D|zse (A4031s T) ddd ¢ST 2dAlL |eauv s)29a/sayd40d (91) uo paiutud papLs omL'T LesodsLa abequesn $312n@ /M JLV padJod dels swes/puz T JaysemysLa|T S32n@ 0o/m JLv pId.Jod AJ01S Z J40LJdIUT dol 00D T wes1s Leod poom AJ401S T JOLJ9IUT sode|dadtd (ST) “MO LV ®duelL|ddy sut-iLtng (ST) CIE] LLO sen xX buL|ood/buLiesH (TT) ¥90-92T-2¢-€¢-¢¢ :43qUnN |3dJed JoLuaaur () bueyuaano J4ayao|o bueyasno uodd 0 uoLle|NSuI |X ybnouisane3 (r1uo0d) Jooy (g) sse|9 9[qnoa X juawased 9pLLS "ZLJOH bunH a|qgnoa| Xx yses [AULA yses |eiaw yses poom, Xx CE] "AAV X Aue smoputm (2) uoLlB|NSUI| X | Lews "AAV X abueT yoLJg LAULA/wnuLwn|y, X 91 buLys/poom JoLua3ix3a (1) swooupag|§ J0o|4 pug J400|4 1ST|6 Juswased|y 1SL7 wooy 1UOL3ILpUOd ¥S6T 1LLng JA HONVY :9|A1s buLp|Lng pood 066T pa | apoway aweJd poom X [wed d-v xa dna SWOH umoL SWOH 3 | LOW Al Lwes 3|buLs| x adAL buLp| Lng T 40 T BuLpLLng |eLIudpLsdY
Page 16
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON I. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR DIRECTOR DANIEL § CARLSON TRUST , MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL Petitioner(s) v MTT Docket No, 25-002827 CITY OF FARMINGTON HILLS Respondent(s) PROOF OF SERVICE ROBERT PARRETT states that on 10/23/26 he/she [Name of person serving/mailing petition] [date of service] served a copy of the VALUATION DISCLOSURE relative to the above-captioned matter upon: [Provide name and address of the party/people being served] MTT P.O. BOX 30232, LANSING, MI 48909 AND JOHN A CARLSON, SHIFMAN & CARLSON PC 33533 W 12 MILE ROAD, SUITE 295 FARMINGTON HILLS, MI 48331 [Signature of person who is serving/mailing copy] ROBERT PARRETT MAAO