Binder_MTT_Parcel No- 7309-11-5-04-4113-000.pdf

Mohammed S Filali Petitioner V Township Of Bridgeport Respondent · 26-002383-TT

Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.

Page 1

STATE OF MICHIGAN

GRETCHEN WHITMER

DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS

MARLON I. BROWN, DPA

GOVERNOR

DIRECTOR

LANSING

_____________________________,

MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL

Petitioner(s)

MTT Docket No.

_____________________________,

Respondent(s)

ENTIRE TRIBUNAL PROPERTY TAX PETITION

Property Parcel No: _____________________________________________

(If more than one parcel is at issue, attach a completed Multiple Parcel Petition

Form addressing all other parcels at issue.)

The property identified above is ___real ___personal.

If more than one parcel of real property is under appeal, are the properties

contiguous? ___Yes ___No. (If no, separate Petitions are required for each non

contiguous parcel.)

Are all of the parcels of personal property located on a parcel of real property

under appeal? ___Yes ___No. (If no, separate Petitions are required for each

parcel of personal property not located on a parcel of real property under

appeal.)

If parcels of personal property are under appeal, when were the personal

property statements filed by parcel number (attach additional page if necessary):

The property identified above is classified as _________________________

If the assessment or assessments at issue were protested, the protest was made

to Respondent’s ___ March ___ July ___December Board of Review.

MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL · 611 W. OTTAWA ST., LANSING, MI 48933 · 517-335-9760

PO BOX 30232, LANSING, MI 48909 · Other Carriers: 2407 N. GRAND RIVER AVE., LANSING, MI 48906

Mohammed & Ilham Filali

Bridgeport Charter Township

7309-11-5-04-4113-000

N/A

Residential

Page 2

MTT Docket No. _________________

Page 2 of 4

If a protest was required and no protest was made, list the separate and specific

facts upon which Petitioner relies to invoke the Tribunal’s authority over the

assessment or assessments at issue (attach additional page if necessary):

If the appeal was not submitted by the deadline for the filing of an appeal for the

classification or classifications of the properties at issue (i.e., May 31 or July 31

of the tax year involved), list the separate and specific facts upon which

Petitioner relies to invoke the Tribunal’s authority over the assessment or

assessments at issue (attach additional page if necessary):

10.

The property or properties at issue are located in _______________County. The

property or properties’ address is:

11.

The assessment or assessments at issue were established by the (applicable

local governmental unit): ________________________________________

12.

Petitioner’s legal residence or principal office address is:

13.

This appeal involves issues relating to the (check all that are applicable):

________the property or properties’ true cash and taxable values

________the property or properties’ taxable value only

If the property or properties’ taxable value is at issue, is there a

dispute as to the value of an addition or loss? ___ Yes ___No

________uniformity of the property or properties’ assessment

________the property or the properties’ exemption from ad valorem taxation

under MCL ______

14.

The tax year(s) at issue are: _______________________________________

Petitioner made a timely, good-faith effort to appeal the 2026 assessment to the local Board of Review. On February 25, 2026, Petitioner submitted a formal written appeal and supporting

evidence via email to the exact email address explicitly provided on the official L-4400 Notice of Assessment (ASSESSOR@BRIDGEPORTMI.ORG) under the "Appeal Options" section.

The Assessor's office acknowledged this submission on February 25, 2026, engaged in substantive discussions regarding the appeal, requested further photographic evidence, and

provided appointment times. At no time did the Assessor's office inform Petitioner that email submission was invalid or that a physical mailing was strictly required to preserve appeal

rights. Petitioner reasonably relied on the official state form (L-4400) which provided the email address under "Appeal Options" and the Assessor's subsequent engagement.

The local Board of Review's failure to hear the appeal was the direct result of the Assessor's office providing ambiguous instructions and failing to clarify submission methods, not due to

taxpayer negligence. Petitioner respectfully requests the Tribunal accept jurisdiction under the doctrines of equitable estoppel and substantial compliance to prevent a miscarriage of

justice regarding a severely overvalued, distressed property acquired at a tax sale for $7,580.81 that is currently assessed at $30,000 SEV despite severe deterioration.

N/A

Saginaw County.The property or properties' address is:

3944 Cluttier Rd, Saginaw, MI 48601

6341 Mercury Dr, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050

2026, AND 2025

Page 3

MTT Docket No. _________________

Page 3 of 4

15.

If more than the current tax year is being appealed, list the separate and specific

facts upon which Petitioner relies to invoke the Tribunal’s authority over the prior

tax year or years (attach additional page if necessary):

16.

The values for the property identified above as established by Respondent’s

Board of Review are:

Tax Year

True Cash Value

Assessed Value

Taxable Value

17.

Petitioner contends that the values for the property identified above are:

Tax Year

True Cash Value

State Equalized Value

Taxable Value

18.

The values in dispute for the property identified above are:

Tax Year

True Cash Value

State Equalized Value

Taxable Value

19.

Petitioner requests the following relief (attach additional page if necessary):

20.

List the separate and specific facts upon which Petitioner relies to support the

relief requested (attach additional page if necessary):

The petitioner has paid the the 2025 (1) Fear of defaulting (2) assuming the

prop tax would get reduced after the judicial Tax sale at 7,600 but the opposite

has happened.

2026

58,000 to 60,000

30,000

27,523

2025

58,000 to 60,000

30,000

27,523

2026

15,000

7,500

2025

15,000

7,500

2026

45,000

22,500

20,023

2025

45,000

21,500

18,753

Accept jurisdiction over this appeal despite the Township's procedural objections, based on Petitioner's good-faith reliance on the email address provided on the

official L-4400 Notice of Assessment and the Assessor's office engagement with the appeal.

1. Reduce the 2026 True Cash Value from $60,000 to $15,000.

2. Reduce the 2026 State Equalized Value (SEV) from $30,000 to $7,500.

3. Reduce the 2026 Taxable Value from $27,523 to $7,500.

4. Grant such other and further relief as the Tribunal deems just and equitable.

5. Redo the process 1 to 5 with year 2025

PROPERTY ACQUIRED AT TAX SALE: The property was acquired through a Saginaw County tax sale on September 4, 2024,

for a minimum bid of $7,580.81. This tax sale price is strong evidence of the property's severely diminished market value.

SEVERE DETERIORATION: The property suffers from extensive deferred maintenance, physical depreciation, and functional

obsolescence. The structure is in a severely deteriorated condition with no habitable features. No repairs, improvements, or

upgrades have been made since acquisition.

NO MARKET DEMAND: Prior to the tax sale, the property was exposed to the open market, and no Realtor was willing to list it

due to its distressed condition. No cash offers were made, demonstrating its complete lack of marketability

Page 4

______________________________________________________________________ 

______________________________________________________________________ 

______________________________________________________________________ 

______________________________________________________________________ 

______________________________________________________________________ 

______________________________________________________________________ 

MTT Docket No. _________________ 

Page 4 of 4 

Signature of Petitioner’s Authorized Representative or, if none, Petitioner: 

Printed Name of Petitioner’s Authorized Representative or, if none, Petitioner: 

Email Address: _________________________________________________________ 

Mailing Address: 

Telephone Number: _____________________________________________________ 

Date: _________________________________________________________________ 

Mohammed S Filali

Mohammed & Ilham Filali

filali.mo.sam@gmail.com

6341 Mercury Dr.Mechanicsburg PA 17050

(319) 331-8228

06/19/2026

Page 5

ATTACHMENT A: RESPONSE TO QUESTION 8 

STATE OF MICHIGAN, MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL 

Petitioner: Mohammed & Ilham Filali 

Respondent: Bridgeport Charter Township 

Parcel No: 7309-11-5-04-4113-000 

Property Address: 3944 Clutier Rd, Saginaw, MI 48601 

8. If a protest was required and no protest was made, list the separate and specific facts 

upon which Petitioner relies to invoke the Tribunal’s authority over the assessment or 

assessments at issue: 

Petitioner made a timely, good-faith effort to appeal the 2026 assessment to the local 

Board of Review. On February 25, 2026, Petitioner submitted a formal written appeal and 

supporting evidence via email to the exact email address explicitly provided on the official 

L-4400 Notice of Assessment (ASSESSOR@BRIDGEPORTMI.ORG) under the "Appeal 

Options" section, which stated: "TO SCHEDULE APPT OR FOR ASSISTANCE OR TO REVIEW 

ASSESSMENT IN ADVANCE OF MEETINGS, CALL 989.777.0940, OR EMAIL 

ASSESSOR@BRIDGEPORTMI.ORG." 

The Assessor's office acknowledged this submission on February 25, 2026, engaged in 

substantive discussions regarding the appeal, requested further photographic evidence, 

and provided appointment times. At no time did the Assessor's office inform Petitioner that 

email submission was invalid or that a physical mailing was strictly required to preserve 

appeal rights. 

Petitioner reasonably relied on the official state form (L-4400) which provided the email 

address under "Appeal Options" and the Assessor's subsequent engagement. The local 

Board of Review's failure to hear the appeal was the direct result of the Assessor's office 

providing ambiguous instructions and failing to clarify submission methods, not due to 

taxpayer negligence. 

Petitioner respectfully requests the Tribunal accept jurisdiction under the doctrines of 

equitable estoppel and substantial compliance to prevent a miscarriage of justice 

regarding a severely overvalued, distressed property acquired at a tax sale for $7,580.81 

that is currently assessed at $30,000 SEV despite severe deterioration.

Page 6

ATTACHMENT B: RESPONSE TO QUESTION 19 

STATE OF MICHIGAN, MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL 

Petitioner: Mohammed & Ilham Filali 

Respondent: Bridgeport Charter Township 

Parcel No: 7309-11-5-04-4113-000 

Property Address: 3944 Cluttier Rd, Saginaw, MI 48601 

19. Petitioner requests the following relief: 

Petitioner requests that the Michigan Tax Tribunal: 

Accept jurisdiction over this appeal despite the Township's procedural objections, based 

on Petitioner's good-faith reliance on the email address provided on the official L-4400 

Notice of Assessment and the Assessor's office engagement with the appeal. 

Reduce the 2026 True Cash Value from $60,000 to $15,000 (or such other amount as the 

Tribunal deems just and proper). 

Reduce the 2026 State Equalized Value (SEV) from $30,000 to $7,500 (or such other 

amount as the Tribunal deems just and proper). 

Reduce the 2026 Taxable Value from $27,523 to $7,500 (or such other amount as the 

Tribunal deems just and proper). 

Grant such other and further relief as the Tribunal deems just and equitable.

Page 7

ATTACHMENT C: RESPONSE TO QUESTION 20

STATE OF MICHIGAN, MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL

Petitioner: Mohammed & Ilham Filali

Respondent: Bridgeport Charter Township

Parcel No: 7309-11-5-04-4113-000

Property Address: 3944 Clutier Rd, Saginaw, MI 48601

20. List the separate and specific facts upon which Petitioner relies to support the relief

requested:

PROPERTY ACQUIRED AT TAX SALE: The property was acquired through a Saginaw County

tax sale on September 4, 2024, for a minimum bid of $7,580.81. This tax sale price is strong

evidence of the property's severely diminished market value.

SEVERE DETERIORATION: The property suffers from extensive deferred maintenance,

physical depreciation, and functional obsolescence. The structure is in a severely

deteriorated condition with no habitable features. No repairs, improvements, or upgrades

have been made since acquisition.

NO MARKET DEMAND: Prior to the tax sale, the property was exposed to the open market,

and no realtor was willing to list it due to its distressed condition. No cash offers were

made, demonstrating its complete lack of marketability.

ASSESSMENT INCREASE CONTRADICTS CONDITION: The current L-4400 shows a 2026

SEV of $30,000, increased from $26,800 in 2025, with the reason listed as "Market

Adjustment." This increase is completely inconsistent with the property's actual condition

and the fact that it could only be sold at a tax sale for $7,580.81.

NO ONSITE INSPECTION: The Assessor's office admitted in their June 17, 2026 email that

they have not conducted an onsite inspection of the property. The assessment is based on

mass appraisal techniques that fail to account for the property's specific severe

deterioration.

TRUE CASH VALUE UNDER MCL 211.27: Under Michigan law (MCL 211.27), true cash value

must reflect the property's actual state, not hypothetical market conditions. The current

assessment violates this statutory requirement by valuing the property as if it were in

average condition.

TIMELY APPEAL SUBMITTED: Petitioner submitted a formal written appeal on February 25,

2026, via email to assessor@bridgeportmi.org, which was the exact email address

Page 8

provided on the official L-4400 Notice of Assessment under "Appeal Options." The 

Assessor's office acknowledged receipt, engaged in discussions, and requested additional 

documentation (photographs), which were provided. At no time was Petitioner informed 

that email submission was insufficient. 

EQUITABLE ESTOPPEL: The Township provided ambiguous instructions on the official state 

form and engaged with Petitioner's appeal for months without objecting to the method of 

submission. The Township should be estopped from raising procedural objections after 

leading Petitioner to believe the appeal was being processed. 

SUBSTANTIAL COMPLIANCE: Petitioner substantially complied with appeal requirements 

by submitting a detailed written appeal with supporting documentation before the March 

12, 2026 deadline to the contact information explicitly provided on the L-4400. 

DISPARATE TREATMENT: The property's assessment ($30,000 SEV) is nearly 4x the amount 

Petitioner paid at tax sale ($7,580.81) for a completely uninhabitable structure, 

demonstrating a clear valuation error that results in unjust taxation of approximately 

$1,750 annually on a property worth less than $10,000.

Page 9

EXHIBIT INDEX 

Petitioner: Mohammed & Ilham Filali 

Respondent: Bridgeport Charter Township 

Parcel No: 7309-11-5-04-4113-000 

Property Address: 3944 Cluttier Rd, Saginaw, MI 48601 

 

Exhibit A: 2026 L-4400 Notice of Assessment 

Description: The official Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification issued by 

Bridgeport Charter Township for the 2026 tax year. 

Purpose: Establishes the disputed valuation (SEV increased to $30,000 due to "Market Adjustment"). 

Crucially, it highlights the "Appeal Options" section at the bottom, which explicitly directs taxpayers to 

email ASSESSOR@BRIDGEPORTMI.ORG to schedule appointments or for assistance, establishing 

Petitioner's reasonable reliance on this official contact method. 

 

Exhibit B: Formal Written Appeal Letter (Dated February 25, 2026) 

Description: The formal, substantive appeal letter drafted by Petitioner, detailing the property's severe 

deterioration, functional obsolescence, and acquisition via tax sale, requesting a review of the 2026 

assessment pursuant to MCL 211.27. 

Purpose: Proves that Petitioner had a fully formed, timely, and substantive written appeal prepared and 

ready for submission well before the March 12, 2026 deadline. 

 

Exhibit C: Complete Email Correspondence Chain (February 25, 2026 – June 17, 2026) 

Description: The complete, unedited email thread between Petitioner and the Bridgeport Charter 

Township Assessing Department (Erica Dethloff and Sharon Frischman). 

Purpose: This is the primary evidence for the Tribunal's jurisdiction. It proves that: 

Petitioner submitted the formal appeal and attachments via email to the exact address provided on the 

L-4400 on February 25, 2026. 

The Assessor's office acknowledged receipt, engaged in substantive discussions, and requested further 

documentation (pictures). 

The Assessor's office never informed Petitioner that email submission was invalid until months later 

(June 17, 2026), establishing the doctrines of equitable estoppel and substantial compliance. 

 

Exhibit D: Saginaw County Tax Sale Documentation 

Description: Official county records showing the property (Lot 7806) was sold at a public tax sale 

auction on September 4, 2024, with a minimum bid/acquisition price of $7,580.81. 

Purpose: Provides objective, arms-length market evidence of the property's True Cash Value at the time 

of acquisition, directly contradicting the Township's $60,000 True Cash Value / $30,000 SEV 

assessment. 

 

Exhibit E: Photographic Evidence of Property Condition (Slide Show) 

Description: A comprehensive photographic slideshow detailing the interior and exterior condition of the 

structure at 3944 Cluttier Rd.

Page 10

Purpose: Visually demonstrates the severe physical depreciation, deferred maintenance, and functional 

obsolescence of the structure, proving that the building has negligible market value and that the "Market 

Adjustment" applied by the assessor is factually incorrect.

Page 11

-

Michigan Department of Treasury, 

1019 (Rev. 10-25) 

THIS IS NOT A TAX BILL 

L-4400 

Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Pr~~e~nt~•~!~:u~e~~!?i!!essor 

This form is issued under the authority of Public Act 206 of 1893, Sec. 211.24c and Sec.211.34c, as amended. This is a m 

e assess 

FROM ASSESSING DEPARTMENT 

BRIDGEPORT CHARTER TOWNSHIP 

6740 DIXIE HWY 

BRIDGEPORT Ml 48722 

OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS/PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: 

********AUTO**MIXED AADC 493 

TS 

Pl 

### 

FILALI, MOHAMMED & ILHAM 

6341 MERCURY DR 

MECHANICSBURG, PA 17050-5269 

3843 

lll,l 111ll1111ll11lll11ll1ll'•111ll1ll1'l11•111l•11111•111111•111 

PARCEL IDENTIFICATION 

PARCEL NUMBER: 

7309-11-5-04-4113-000 

PROPERTY ADDRESS: 

3944 CLUTIER RD 

SAGINAW, Ml 48601 

SCHOOL DISTRICT CODE: 

73180 

EXEMPTIONS 

% Exempt As "Homeowners Principal Residence": 

% Exempt As "Qualified Agricultural Property": 

.00% 

.00% 

.00% 

.00% 

% Exempt As "MBT Industrial Personal": 

% Exempt As "MBT Commercial Personal": 

Exempt As "Disabled Veteran or Surviving 

Spouse": 

Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property": 

Exempt As "Development Property": 

O Yes IB] No 

O Yes 00 No 

O Yes 00 No 

3843 

LEGAL DESCRIPTION: 

--~ _ 

~ 

__ ~-

_ 

--r.'--

---- -- 1/2 OF SE 1/4 SEC 04 

-

--

LOT 13 EXC S 85.08 FT THEREOF ALSO LOT 15 EXC N 100 FT J W CLUTIERS SUBDIV.OF THE W 1 /2 OF E 

T11N R5E 

ACCORDING TO MCL 211.34c THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS: 

4 o 1 

Residential 

PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION IF DIFFERENT: 

4 0 1 

The change in taxable value will increase/decrease your tax bill 

for the 2026 year by approximately: $38 

Residential 

PRIOR AMOUNT 

YEAR: 

2025 

CURRENT 

TENTATIVE AMOUNT 

YEAR: 

2026 

CHANGE FROM 

PRIOR YEAR TO 

CURRENT YEAR 

1. TAXABLE VALUE: 

26 800 

27,523 

723 

2. ASSESSED VALUE: 

26,800 I 

30,000 

3.200 

~ 

·--

·1K --- "" 

3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR: 

1.000 

_ 

_ _ _ 

. -"-- __ =-

--

4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV): 

26,800 I 

30,000 I 

3,200 

5. WAS THERE A TRANSFER OF OWNERSHIP lft025 THAT RESULTED IN A TAXABLE VALUE UNCAPPING? 0 Yes [] No 

6. Assessor Change Reason(s): 

Market Adjustment 

The 2026 Inflation rate Multiplier is: 1.027 

___ _....Ouestioos...regarding the ~otice otAssessment,Jaxable Valuation,..and-Eroperty-ClassificatioA rnay~be..oirected.io the-Eo\\cwingu..:~---

Name: 

SHARON FRISCHMAN 

Telephone Number: 

989-777-0940 

213 

Email Address: 

ASSESSOR@BRIDGEPORTMI.ORG 

March Board of Review Appeal Information. The Board of Review will meet at the following dates and times: 

THE 2026 MARCH BOARD OF REVIEW IS IN SESSION MONDAY, MARCH 9TH, 2026 FROM 9 AM TO 3:00 PM & THURSDAY, 

MARCH 12, 2026 FROM 3:00 PM TO 9:00 PM AT THE BRIDGEPORT TOWNSHIP HALL, 6740 DIXIE HWY, BRIDGEPORT, Ml, 

48722 - - - APPEAL OPTIONS - - - (1) SCHEDULE AN IN-PERSON APPT; OR (2) APPEAL BY LETTER. LETTER. APPEALS MUST 

BE RECIEVED BY NOON ON MARCH 12, 2026. TO SCHEDULE APPT OR FOR ASSISTANCE OR TO REVIEW ASSESSMENT IN 

ADVANCE OF MEETINGS, CALL 989.777.0940, OR EMAIL ASSESSOR@BRIDGEPORT.ORG 

PLEASE CHECK THE UPPER RIGHT HAND CORNER OF THIS NOTICE FOR INFORMATION REGARDING PRINCIPAL 

RESIDENCE AND VETERAN'S EXEMPTIONS.

Page 12

Property Assessment Appeal Letter 

Parcel No.: 7309-11-5-04-4113-000 

Property Address: 3944 Clutier Rd, Saginaw, MI 48601 

Date: February 25, 2026 

To: 

Sharon Frischman, Assessor 

Bridgeport Charter Township 

6740 Dixie Hwy | Bridgeport, MI 48722 

Re: Formal Appeal of 2026 Assessment – Pursuant to MCL 211.24c, 211.34c, and 211.27 

I am submitting this formal written appeal of the 2026 property assessment for the parcel located at 3944 

Clutier Rd, Saginaw, MI, Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000, as provided under MCL 211.24c, MCL 211.34c, 

and the statutory requirement that assessments reflect true cash value under MCL 211.27. 

The current assessed and taxable values do not accurately reflect the property’s actual condition, marketability, 

or acquisition history. The property was acquired through a tax sale in 2024, which is a strong indicator of 

severely diminished market value. Prior to the tax sale, no realtor was willing to list the property due to its 

distressed and deteriorated state, and no cash offers were made. The structure remains in significantly 

deteriorated condition, with extensive physical depreciation, functional obsolescence, and substantial deferred 

maintenance. No repairs, improvements, or upgrades have been made since acquisition. 

Under MCL 211.27, true cash value must reflect the property’s actual state, not hypothetical market conditions. 

The assessment increase is inconsistent with the property’s real-world condition and its complete lack of market 

demand. 

I respectfully request that the 2026 Assessed Value and Taxable Value be reviewed and adjusted downward to 

reflect the property’s true cash value, consistent with Michigan law and the evidence of its condition and market 

history. 

Please mail all correspondence, notices, and any required paperwork to my mailing address listed on the Notice 

of Assessment. I am prepared to provide supporting documentation, including photographs, repair estimates, 

and any additional information the Board of Review may require. 

Please confirm receipt of this appeal and advise on next steps for the March Board of Review. 

Sincerely, 

Mohammed Filali 

6341 Mercury Dr 

Mechanicsburg, PA 17050

Page 13

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

14 messages

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 10:24 AM

To: assessor@bridgeportmi.org

Dear Assessor Frischman,

I am submitting this formal appeal of the 2026 assessment for my property located at 3944 Clutier Rd, Saginaw, MI (Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000), pursuant to

the rights afforded under MCL 211.24c and MCL 211.34c.

The current assessed and taxable values do not reflect the property's true condition, market value, or acquisition circumstances. The property was acquired

through a tax sale in 2024, and its condition at the time of acquisition—and continuing to the present—was and remains severely deteriorated. The structure

suffers from extensive deferred maintenance, physical depreciation, and functional obsolescence. No improvements, repairs, or upgrades have been made since

acquisition.

Additionally, the property was exposed to the open market prior to the tax sale, and no realtor was willing to list it due to its distressed condition. No cash offers

were made, further demonstrating its diminished market value and lack of marketability. These facts directly contradict the assessment increase attributed to

“Market Adjustment.”

Given the property's substantial deterioration and the absence of any market activity supporting an increased valuation, I respectfully request that the 2026

assessed value and taxable value be reviewed and adjusted to accurately reflect the property's true cash value as required under MCL 211.27.

Please also mail any correspondence or required paperwork to my mailing address listed on the Notice of Assessment.

I am prepared to provide supporting documentation, including photographs, repair estimates, and any additional information the Board of Review may require.

Please confirm receipt of this appeal and advise on the next steps for the March Board of Review.

Sincerely,

Mohammed Filal

6341 Mercury Dr. Mechanicsburg PA 17050

CELL (319) 331-8828

CPS Management & Investments LLC

2 attachments

Adobe Scan Feb 25, 2026.pdf

523K

P-7309-11-5-04-4113-000- Property Assessment Appeal Letter.pdf

117K

Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 11:16 AM

To: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Hi Mohamed,

 

Thank you for reaching out. I just left you a detailed voicemail regarding an appointment with the Board Of Review. Please let us know if you

have any further questions or need assistance in making an appointment or submitting a letter appeal. Letter appeals will need to be submitted

by noon on March 12th.  

 

I hope this helps.

 

Respectfully,

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

1/11

Page 14

Erica Dethloff

Assessing Team Member

 

________________________

Township Assessing Office

Bridgeport Charter Township

6740 Dixie Hwy

Bridgeport, MI 48722

Phone: (989) 777-0940 ext 213

Fax: (989) 777-4802

Tuesday & Friday 10am – 3pm

assessor@bridgeportmi.org

Bridgeport twp, MI (bridgeportmi.org)

[Quoted text hidden]

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 11:26 AM

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Dear Sharon. Yes, I got your voice message and  truly thank you 

When would the Appt be available for me to talk to them?

Best

Trust | Excellence | Dedication

Mohamed Sam Filali

CPS.medlogic@gmail.com

cps-advisor@outlook.com

(223) 895-6100

(319) 3318228

[Quoted text hidden]

Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 11:48 AM

To: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

We have openings on March 9th from 9am-2:45pm. We do have breaks scheduled for the board members and a brief lunch break from 11:30-

12:00. We also have evening openings on March 12th from 3pm-3:45pm, 4:15-4:45pm,5:30-6:15, 7:15-8:45pm. Appointment slots are for 15

minutes to accommodate the community.

[Quoted text hidden]

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Feb 2

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

I can't be there physically. Should I just mail the request via certified mail? Thanks !

[Quoted text hidden]

--

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

2/11

Page 15

Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 1:23 PM

To: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Yes! That would be great. You may want to include any documentation about the condition of the house and any other supporting evidence you

would want the board to review as it relates to the property.

 

You can send the letter appeal and related documents to:

 

Bridgeport Charter Township

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

3/11

Page 16

Att: Assessing Department

6740 Dixie Hwy

Bridgeport, MI 48722

 

Erica

[Quoted text hidden]

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 1:51 PM

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Thank you ! 

Trust | Excellence | Dedication

Mohamed Sam Filali

CPS.medlogic@gmail.com

cps-advisor@outlook.com

(223) 895-6100

(319) 3318228

[Quoted text hidden]

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Mon, Jun 

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Dear Assessor, 

I am following on our convesation dated Feb 25, 2026 about reviewing the Tax asessement of this property.

I am attaching a link to pictures showin the err state of this broken property.

The property market value is about 5K, with a zero dollar on any structure

Please review the assessment based on the evidence provided.

Here's the file "Parcel_7309_11_5_04_4113_000.pdf" for you to view.

https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:US:77ac1494-5367-4476-a830-77b321fd61df

You don't need to download Acrobat to access the file.

Thank You !

---------- Forwarded message ---------

From: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Date: Wed, Feb 25, 2026 at 10:24 AM

Subject: Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

To: <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

[Quoted text hidden]

--

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

4/11

Page 17

3 attachments

Adobe Scan Feb 25, 2026.pdf

523K

P-7309-11-5-04-4113-000- Property Assessment Appeal Letter.pdf

117K

Parcel_7309_11_5_04_4113_000_slide_show.pdf

1756K

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Jun 10, 2026 at 12:10 PM

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

5/11

Page 18

Hello Assessor,

Very Urgent - Have you received my message and Inquiry yet? 

It us veru Urgent 

Dear Assessor, 

I am following on our conversation dated Feb 25, 2026 about reviewing the Tax asessement of this property.

[Quoted text hidden]

3 attachments

Adobe Scan Feb 25, 2026.pdf

523K

P-7309-11-5-04-4113-000- Property Assessment Appeal Letter.pdf

117K

Parcel_7309_11_5_04_4113_000_slide_show.pdf

1756K

Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Thu, Jun 11, 2026 at 1:58 PM

To: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Hello,  we did not receive a written appeal during the appropriate time period for the March Board of Review.  Did you get some type

of confirmation that the appeal was received in February?

Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone

Get Outlook for Android

From: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Sent: Wednesday, 10 June 2026 12:10:48

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Subject: Fwd: Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

 

[Quoted text hidden]

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Thu, Jun 11, 2026 at 2:43 PM

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Here below is a copy of the message received, and the appeal of Feb 25, 2025 is attached.

My letter of appeal attacghed was dated Feb 25,2026

The message asked for pictures which I have shared with you a few times; do you want to see them again?

Hi Mohamed,

 

Thank you for reaching out. I just left you a detailed voicemail regarding an appointment with the Board Of Review. Please let us know if you

have any further questions or need assistance in making an appointment or submitting a letter appeal. Letter appeals will need to be submitted

by noon on March 12th.  

 

I hope this helps.

 

Respectfully,

 

Erica Dethloff

Assessing Team Member

 

________________________

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

6/11

Page 19

1 1/4 Story House On ~0.53 Acres, Bridgeport

 Minimum Bid:

 $7,580.81

 Current Tax: 

 $194.62

Auction Info:

 September 04, 2024 - 10:00am EDT to 7:00pm EDT

 Parcel ID: 

 09-11-5-04-4113-000

 SEV: 

 $16,300.00

Address:

 3944 CLUTIER RD

Legal Description: 

 LOT 13 EXC S 85.08 FT THEREOF ALSO LOT 15 EXC N

100 FT J W CLUTIERS SUBDIV OF THE W 1/2 OF E 1/2 OF SE 1/4 SEC 04 T11N R5E

Township Assessing Office

Bridgeport Charter Township

6740 Dixie Hwy

Bridgeport, MI 48722

Phone: (989) 777-0940 ext 213

Fax: (989) 777-4802

Tuesday & Friday 10am – 3pm

assessor@bridgeportmi.org

Bridgeport twp, MI (bridgeportmi.org)

The initial Valuation as was on you county tax sale was misleading and completely inaccurate.

It gots me to bid and buy a property that want worth 1/4 of the state State Value.

Tye error costs more taxes, more times, and a loss if sold. 

The current Tax on the website says $194.62 ?

[Quoted text hidden]

--

3 attachments

Parcel_7309_11_5_04_4113_000_slide_show.pdf

1756K

L4400.pdf

523K

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

7/11

Page 20

Lot 7806_ Saginaw _Tax-Sale.info.pdf

411K

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Jun 1

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Greetings;

I am following up regarding my property assessment appeal for Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000, which initiated on February 25, 2026.

The attached documentation clearly confirms my timely intent to schedule an appointment with the Board of Review. As suggested in your previous correspondence, I h

provided property records and supporting evidence demonstrating the severe deterioration of the home.

While the property's actual market value ranges between $5,000 and $7,000—consistent with its mid-$7,000 state value at the county tax sale—the current L-4400 refl

valuation of $30,000. This discrepancy results in an unjustified property tax of $1,750, which does not reconcile with the home's true condition.

Please correct the assessment data to accurately reflect the true cash value and forward the revised assessment sheet. I am willing to allow a week for review and adju

which I will escalate this matter back to the board or pursue civil remedies to resolve the valuation error.

Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.

---------- Forwarded message ---------

From: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Date: Thu, Jun 11, 2026 at 2:43 PM

Subject: Re: Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Here below is a copy of the message received, and the appeal of Feb 25, 2025 is attached.

My letter of appeal attached was dated Feb 25,2026

[Quoted text hidden]

[Quoted text hidden]

--

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

8/11

Page 21

3 attachments

Parcel_7309_11_5_04_4113_000_slide_show.pdf

1756K

L4400.pdf

523K

Lot 7806_ Saginaw _Tax-Sale.info.pdf

411K

Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

Wed, Jun 17, 2026 at 2:53 PM

To: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simpl…

9/11

Page 22

Actually,  the email confirms that you had not filed a written appeal. We are happy to visit them properly this fall to determine the

current condition.  We can't change a prior assessment already established. 

Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone

Get Outlook for Android

From: Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Sent: Wednesday, 17 June 2026 12:28:33

[Quoted text hidden]

 

[Quoted text hidden]

Mohamed S FILALI MBA <msfilali2007@gmail.com>

Wed, Jun 

To: Bridgeport Assessor <assessor@bridgeportmi.org>

That's why was my point before Before Feb 25. The assessment is way off and do not match the market or State Value.

They said "we need pictures" and even with that request. it was not wise to ask me for proof of house sold in Tax Sale.

The assessment isn't accurate and comlpetely off. Other counties take action when the owner's convery the information and put arequest for a revision. I am not waitin

Thanks 

[Quoted text hidden]

--

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simp…

10/11

Page 23

6/19/26, 12:32 PM

Gmail - Parcel 7309-11-5-04-4113-000. Appeal Appointment

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=5f99444670&view=pt&search=all&permthid=thread-a:r4830063866895891018&simpl=msg-a:r328763425929745525&simp…

11/11

Page 24



FIRST TIME BUYER?

CLICK TO LEARN MORE!

 (/)

(/)

Lot 7806 : Saginaw

Sold for $7,600.00

 Add to favorites

Back to Catalog

962 Views

Previous Lot (/lot/show/id/149753)

Next Lot

 (/lot/show/id/149521)

 Minimum Bid:

 $7,580.81



Auction Info:

 September 04, 2024 - 10:00am EDT to

7:00pm EDT

 09-11-5-04-4113-000

 $16,300.00

Address:

 3944 CLUTIER RD

 LOT 13 EXC S 85.08 FT THEREOF ALSO

LOT 15 EXC N 100 FT J W CLUTIERS SUBDIV OF THE W 1/2 OF E

1/2 OF SE 1/4 SEC 04 T11N R5E

1 1/4 Story House On ~0.53 Acres, Bridgeport



 Current Tax: 







 Parcel ID: 





 SEV: 





Legal Description: 

Read Full Description



Parcels are sold "as is" based on the assessed legal description only. All other information on this page, though reliable to the best of our knowledge, is

provided as unverified reference and is not guaranteed to be accurate. You should verify this information with your own research and investigation prior

to bidding.

Bidding is now closed. You can no longer place or modify bids for this lot.

Your Bid Information:

Amount

Date Added

Delete Bid

$7,600.00

September 4th at 11:59am EDT

locked

Parcel Information:

1 1/4 Story House On ~0.53 Acres, Bridgeport

 Parcel ID: 09-11-5-04-4113-000  Address: 3944 CLUTIER RD  View Map (http://maps.google.com/?q=43.38071104,-83.88080209)

LEGAL DESCRIPTION:

Local Unit: Bridgeport Township Section: 4 Town: 11N Range: 5E

LOT 13 EXC S 85.08 FT THEREOF ALSO LOT 15 EXC N 100 FT J W CLUTIERS SUBDIV OF THE W 1/2 OF E 1/2 OF SE 1/4 SEC 04

T11N R5E

COMMENTS:

~79 ft road frontage on Clutier Rd to the east, ~293 ft deep.

The interior of this property was not viewed during our inspection. Buildings which are dangerous, occupied, boarded, condemned, or

otherwise difficult to enter are inspected from the exterior/curbside only. You are NOT authorized to enter these or any other buildings

offered for sale. You should limit your inspection to that which can be made safely from the building's exterior.

ASSESSMENT DETAILS:

View Assessor Card (/forms/AssessorCards/2024/73/09-11-5-04-4113-000/Assessor_Card_09-11-5-04-4113-000.pdf)

Note: The assessment information linked in this section was prepared by the tax assessor for the local unit in which this parcel is located. It

was not prepared by the Seller This information is offered here without representation or warranty of any kind as to accuracy or

Bid on This Lot:



My Account (/account) | Logout (/logout)

MY ACCOUNT (msfilali24) (/account)

LOGOUT (/LOGOUT)

Skip to main content

(https://taxsaleimg.com/2024/73/09-11-5-04-4113-000/IMG_1306.JPEG)







HOME

(/)

VIEW AVAILABLE PROPERTIES 

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

(/FAQ)

CONTACT US

(/CONTACT)

SEARCH LOTS





Page 25

Related Propertie

Related Links:

Saginaw County - Government Website

(https://www.saginawcounty.com/)



Saginaw County - GIS Mapping (https://app.fetchgis.com/?

currentMap=saginaw)



State of Michigan - GIS Mapping (https://gis-

michigan.opendata.arcgis.com/)



Related Documents

Auction Salebook (/forms/s

09-04_salebook_final.pdf)



Auction Rules (/forms/sale

04_rules_final.pdf)



Property Transfer Affidavit 





Michigan's Premier Land Auction Service

Alger

(/listings/catalog/2827)

Alger DNR

(/listings/catalog/2922)

Allegan

(/listings/catalog/2828)

Allegan DNR

(/listings/catalog/2932)

Alpena DNR

(/listings/catalog/2923)

Antrim

(/listings/catalog/2830)

Antrim DNR

(/listings/catalog/2904)

Arenac

(/listings/catalog/2831)

Baraga

(/listings/catalog/2832)

Baraga DNR

(/listings/catalog/2905)

Barry

(/listings/catalog/2833)

Bay

(/listings/catalog/2834)

Berrien

(/listings/catalog/2836)

Berrien DNR

(/listings/catalog/2906)

Cass

(/listings/catalog/2839)

Charlevoix DNR

(/listings/catalog/2907)

Cheboygan DNR

(/listings/catalog/2908)

Chippewa DNR

(/listings/catalog/2924)

Clare

(/listings/catalog/2843)

Clinton

(/listings/catalog/2844)

Crawford

(/listings/catalog/2845)

Crawford DNR

(/listings/catalog/2909)

Delta DNR

(/listings/catalog/2910)

Dickinson DNR

(/listings/catalog/2911)

Gladwin

(/listings/catalog/2850)

Houghton DNR

(/listings/catalog/2925)

Iosco DNR

(/listings/catalog/2912)

Jackson DNR

(/listings/catalog/2913)

Kalkaska

(/listings/catalog/2863)

Kalkaska DNR

(/listings/catalog/2914)

Lake DNR

(/listings/catalog/2915)

Lapeer DNR

(/listings/catalog/2916)

Livingston

(/listings/catalog/2869)

Livingston DNR

(/listings/catalog/2926)

Luce

(/listings/catalog/2870)

Luce DNR

(/listings/catalog/2917)

Mecosta

(/listings/catalog/2877)

Menominee DNR

(/listings/catalog/2927)

Missaukee

(/listings/catalog/2879)

Monroe

(/listings/catalog/2880)

Oakland DNR

(/listings/catalog/2920)

Oceana DNR

(/listings/catalog/2928)

Ogemaw DNR

(/listings/catalog/2929)

Osceola

(/listings/catalog/2888)

Oscoda DNR

(/listings/catalog/2919)

Otsego DNR

(/listings/catalog/2918)

Presque Isle DNR

(/listings/catalog/2930)

Roscommon

(/listings/catalog/2893)

Roscommon DNR

(/listings/catalog/2931)

Saint Clair

(/listings/catalog/2895)

Sanilac

(/listings/catalog/2897)

Shiawassee

(/listings/catalog/2899)

C A L L U S :

1-800-259-7470

S E N D A N E M A I L :

Click to Drop Us a Line

(/contact)



Like us

on Facebook

(https://www.facebook.com/taxsaleinfo)



© 2026 Title Check, LLC. All Rights Reserved

Frequently Asked Questions (/faq) / Terms of Use (/termsOfUse) /

Privacy Policy (/privacyPolicy) /

Accessibility (tax-sale.info_WCAG_ACR_20260331.pdf)

Lot 7922

1 1/4 Story On S 9Th

Minimum Bid: $5,921.98

(/lot/show/id/149632)

Lot 7950

Very Old Home On Gallagher St.

Minimum Bid: $7,670.62

(/lot/show/id/149660)

Lot 7873

Two Story Hom

Minimum Bid: $

(/lot/show/id/149

Enter your Email

Subscribe





HOME

(/)

VIEW AVAILABLE PROPERTIES 

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

(/FAQ)

CONTACT US

(/CONTACT)

SEARCH LOTS





Page 26

% 

mid 

ew 

— 

pee 

TE 

oe 

Se 

= 

— 

—_— 

A) 

Noe d 

bi 

BT — 

ee 

oo 

Eo 

a 

e 

=p 

i 

or 

| 

—— 

r_ 

pc 

he 

= 

i 

mr 

_ 

ak 

we? 

= 

= — 

eas 

pose 

(a 

= 

— 

J

Page 27

NE 

2 

ha 

EEN 

£4 

lS 

I(t 

Vi 

of 

§ 

Ls 

1 

LA 

a 

tr 

Ee 

i 

a 

mac 

_— Pas 

- 

oe 

== £2 2 

os 

EEE 

= 

EAE PRA, 

Le 

(a 

ee AE 

————— 

{| Res 

b= 

IE Ca 

Pi 

TA 

Te 

es TE 

i] 

SEENNS 

— 

SL, 

SEINE ES 

kV 

pre 

— 

ETERS 

—h 

ea 

BNE 

fe 

rn 

So 

, 

\e 

Wh

Page 28

i l 

p> 

RY) 

I 

& 

= 

4g 

Sig Soy 

YaRs 

x7 

EA 

r- 

Nb 

% 

Al 

3 

i 

3 

_—— 

Gr 

Ar 

tl 

| 

iY 

BEY 

| 

PRET 

= 

| 

Sv 

=A 

= 

a 

a 

i 

Bs 

5% 

SE 

= 

a 

pk 

E_= 

is 

| Ss Sa 

2, AS: 

i 

Los 

2. a 

7= 

7.5% 

\X 

fini 

Rr 

SEE 

\ 

— RT 

QS 

Ne al 

yy 

& 

“ 

j=) 

Vo res 

a — 

i 

Ch 

= 

MENT 

= 

% 

Gl 

he 3 

Bini 

i 

_ eh 

a 

J 

AEE 

= 

Es 

= 

Ae 

= 

Ea 

Sd 

oJ 

A 

- 

he 

it 

Ap 

vy 

C= 

& 

s 

= 

52 

NS 

Si 

a 

l} 

AN 

So w= 

Se 

5 

15 

pn 

B: 

AA 

SLES 

oT ns 

A 

fq 

Ly 

3s 

B\ 

i! 

£7 

Ji 

bi 

A 

No: 

AF 

& 

Io 

@ 

RY 

Ser 

Po 

~ 

2 

roo 

i 

NX 

Nas 

Ne 

REX 

Ly 

oR 

NSS 

Pg 

23 SHES “BS 

LN

Page 29

F 

LZ 

Ni 

[a oY 

Z 

Sd 

£4 

SP 

oem 

|| 

> 

i 

ru SSE 

2 

— 

—e 

o— 

= 

ls 

-:] 

= 

= 

anv a 

— 

= — 

—_— 

—_— 

IN 

== 

=P 

it 

— 

ra He 

5 

=r 

5 

TR 

{mm 

{8 

a 

~~ 

Lr 7% 

a 

WV. 

, 

EN 

$ 

Eh 

oN de 

| pre 

Ta® 

EN

Page 30

a 

1 

7. 

Rp 

7 7 

we 

Pe 

a 

Wy 

Sw, 

ty 

a 

0 \ 

i al 

4 

EN 

3) 

\ 

4 

1%, 

po. 

1 

jit 

A 

| 4 

\ 

4.3, 

aM, 

hi 

Ii 

i 

UAT 

4 

go 

A 

#7). 

a7 po 

22s Bi 

of 

2 

“% 

SE] 

- 

i 

— 

=u 

re] 

= 

[= 

IE 

| 

x 

I 

cam 

— 

1 

Ses 

all oe 

— 

J 

I 

SH 

sR 

a 

= 

cor 

= 

NA 

i 

— 

I 

2) 

$2 

i 

(El 

ol 

ZPy 

= 

ol 

i 

14 

ee wh aN 

Ih: 

a 

oa 

A

Page 31

—— 

Ty 

—tr— 

or 

AMP 

ua | 

1 

| 

| 1 

2 

ey 

= a 

immer” 

— 

NN 

NN 

NN 

J — 

~NE 

~~ 

_— 

= 

8 a 

Ps 

s—— 

a 

= 

Se 

= 

— 

— 

aN \ 

> 

= 

F, 

Trg] 

j= 

=3 

= 

Tr a 

Ca 

AED 

>” 

EE 

7 

\ 

Ze > 

WSS 

Jer

Page 32

=i. 

fond 

| 

\» 

15 

{1 

= 

DN 

RQ) 

NL 

—— 

oT 

SN 

RS 

- 

— 

= 

SO 

~~ 

Re 

A\ 2 

- 

Ee 

— 

—— 

m— 

¥ 5) 

Tre 

\\ 

\ 

Por 

\ Rh 

Sai 

— — 

—— 

i= 

BO 

NN 

RX 

NZ 

¢ 

\ 

= 

NR 

— 

\

Page 33

ev 

8 

7 Ad 

N 

F) 

— 

SN 

NN 

¥ 

A 

N 

ll — 

NN 

{ 

4 

ee 

“N\ 

Be 

Ww 

Epa 

(17 

we 

y BE 

dns 

{ek 

[MESES 

ESN 

==] 

: 

NZ 

[| omaniaty 

SATE 

Cd 

a n 

Rk 

es 

——— 

Ei AOE 

bY) 

= 

bg 

= 

hw 

ie 

> 

PE 

highs

PDF reading copy

← View full record