26-001294 Enerson Respondent Answer Supporting Docs.pdf
Samantha Enerson Petitioner V City Of Norton Shores Respondent · 26-001294-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
Se rage Tres THIS IS NOT A TAX BILL L-4400 Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification This form is issued under the authority of Public Act 206 of 1883, Sec. 211.24¢ and Sec.211.34c, as amended. This is a model assessment notice to be used by the local assessor. FROM CITY OF NORTON SHORES PARCEL IDENTIFICATION ASSESSING DEPARTMENT PARCEL NUMBER: 27-173-000-0066-00 4814 HENRY ST PROPERTY ADDRESS: MUSKEGON MI 49441 4731 ROOD RD MUSKEGON, MI 49441 SCHOOL DISTRICT CODE: 61060 OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS/PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: EXEMPTIONS HUTCHINSON CHAD/ENERSON SAMANTHA % Exempt As "Homeowners Principal Residence": 100.00% 4731 ROOD RD % Exempt As "Qualified Agricultural Property": .00% NORTON SHORES MI 49441 % Exempt As "MBT Industrial Personal": .00% % Exempt As "MBT Commercial Personal": .00% Exempt As "Disabled Vet: Survivi Spouse” Ss “Uisabled Veteran or surviving 0 Yes No Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property”: O0 Yes [X] No Exempt As "Development Property™: [1] Yes No LEGAL DESCRIPTION: CITY OF NORTON SHORES BIRCHWOOD SHORES EST NO 3 LOT 66 ACCORDING TO MCL 211.34c THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS: 401 Residential PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION IF DIFFERENT: 401 Residential The change in taxable value will increase/decrease your tax bill PRIOR AMOUNT CURRENT TENTATIVE RARER for the 2026 year by approximately: $8118 YEAR 2025 AMOUNT YEAR: ro 1. TAXABLE VALUE: 210,904 417,700 206,796 2. ASSESSED VALUE: 374,900 417,700 42,800 3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR: 1.000 4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV): 374,900 417,700 42,800 5. WAS THERE A TRANSFER OF OWNERSHIP IN2025 THAT RESULTED IN A TAXABLE VALUE UNCAPPING? Yes Od No 6. Assessor Change Reason(s): Parcel Review The 2026 Inflation rate Multiplier is: 1.027 Questions regarding the Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification may be directed to the Following: Name: Telephone Number: Email Address: DEREK ENDRES 231-799-6806 ENDRESDE@CO.MUSKEGON.MI.US March Board of Review Appeal Information. The Board of Review will meet at the following dates and times: NORTON SHORES CITY HALL - 4814 HENRY ST, NORTON SHORES MI 489441 APPEALS MAY BE MADE BY LETTER OR BY ATTENDING IN PERSON. FOR INQUIRIES OR TO SET AN APPOINTMENT CONTACT DEREK ENDRES. LETTER APPEALS MUST BE RECEIVED BY NOON MARCH 10. MONDAY MARCH 9, 2026 9:00AM-12:00 NOON & 1:00PM-4:00PM & 6:00PM-9:00PM TUESDAY MARCH 10, 2026 9:00AM-12:00 NOON & 1:00PM-4:00PM
Page 2
06/10/2026 02:28 2M 2026 BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION FROM CITY OF NORTON SHORES ASSESSING DEPARTMENT 4814 HENRY ST MUSKEGON MI 49441 NAME AND ADDRESS OF OWNER OR PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION: (Parcel Code required. Property address and legal description optional.): 27-173-000-0066-00 HUTCHINSON CHAD/ENERSON SAM 4731 ROOD RD 4731 ROOD RD NORTON SHORES MI 49441 THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED 401 (RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED) Thank you for attending this years March Board of Review. The Board has reviewed the information you supplied and the data necessary to compute your assessment and taxable value. The Board has completed their review of parcel number 27-173-000-0066-00 They have made the following determination based on the information you supplied. Board of Review Comments ASSESSMENT ADJUSTED TO 50% OF MARKET VALUE [2026 ORIGINAL ASSESSED VALUE 417,700 [2026 "BOARD OF REVIEW" ASSESSED VALUE 400,000 (If the above amounts are the same, no revisions have occured) 2026 ORIGINAL TAXABLE VALUE 417,700 2026 "BOARD OF REVIEW" TAXABLE VALUE 400,000 2026 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION/QUALIFIED AG 100.0000 Please feel free to contact the assessor at the address listed above or call if you have any questions. 231-799-6806 [f you disagree with the decision of the Board of Review, further appeal may be made to the Michigan Tax Tribunal by May 31 for Commercial Real, Industrial Real, Developmental Real, Commercial Personal, Industrial Personal and Utility Personal Property by July 31 for Agricultural Real, Residential Real, Timber - Cut Over Real, and Agricultural Personal Property. Effective March 1, 2013 the Tribunal is no longer able to accept Small Claims letter appeals. Rather, you are required to file a petition to initiate a new appeal. Petition forms are available on the State's website at: http://www.michigan.gov/taxtrib/0,4677,7-187-38254---,00.html Property Classification appeals ONLY may be appealed to the State Tax Commission: State Tax Commission Classification Appeals P.0.Box 30471 Lansing MI 48909 More information about the Michigan Tax Tribunal can be found on the internet at WWW.MICHIGAN.GOV/TAXTRIB
Page 3
+¢xP233URIRNG
JOU
ING STYET[SI PBWIAP UTAIDY UOTIPWIOTUT
yyy
uebTUo
TW
‘uobsysny
Jo Ajuno)
:o] pasusnIq
nby ay
&,
ybtakdon
raezTTPR
$2DUBNTIUT /SIUSUOD
29
101
STIOHS QOOMHIUIE
STYOHS
NOLMON
J0
ALID
uotadransaq
xe
€
ON
ISd
TPb6y
IW STIOHS NOLMON
ad
aocoyd
TEL
YHINVWYS NOSHENA/AYHD NOSNIHOLOH
SSBIPPY/OUELN
§, I8UMO
ad aood
TELb
0728 'b61
|
{009 '10€
loot ’822
005 '€L
£202
’
i
!
;
,
N
Q4LOFSNI 9707/82/60 OTH
J€95
"POC
0017082
005
°€L
PE0Z}
qa103dSNT €202/60/80
H¥A| 5007 - 6661
(0)
2106 '0TC
000LL
|
Szoz|dIAZY NSEQ S20Z/L1/90 dvd
15000 ‘00¥
W000 '00%
100L°LTP
1005 ‘08
970]
3EuM
uaum
oum
anrep
19430
MITADY
jentea
anTep
a1qexR]
/teunqriy,
|3o pavog
|passassy
tpueT
Tea}
ured
pootd
.
puPTiam
autaey
JuoaIILIRY
puog
papoon
duemg
padeospueq|
x
uybTH
MOT
OOH
¥ 340 WVEL
1L00Z/80/80 PANSSI
‘69G0-L008d
ITWIdd
103 uoTIATIOSDA
¥i1oM
butTT0y
0/¥ 2102/60/L0 PIUSSI
'T€Z0-ITEWA
ITwWIsg
103 uoT3dTansaq yIom
12897
X
TI8TTOd
19T0Z/91/80 POUSSI
‘LTp0-9T3Wd
3ITWISd
103 uoT3dTIossq YIoM
591s
§001-21 pue JFo Id
1£Z07/62/90 PANSSI
‘LTb0-£Z08d ITWIdd
103 uoT3dTIOSBQ FIOM
30 Aydeabodog
Cy
“STTin punoibiapun
6C9°¢G
=
BNTPA
Yse)
anil
sajuawaaordur
pur
psjrwilsy
[ej01L
SSTITTTIN
PIPPURIS
z8Lp
29
091
62°GV
‘ouop/suWeIy poom
en
i
;
.
.
YbTIT 389138
006
'92
[si
£06
231TUNg
:71004
qo
866 '€
[4]
008
231810U0D §'€
1d/M/q
ses]
x
STP 'T
z9
98z
$I9I0U0D Gg
:d/M/a
sT1i081d
%
PLG9T
29
0GE€
218100) GE
:d/M/Q
remas|
x
anTea ysen
poo
%
9ZTS
uotadtansaq
Io1eM
§33PWTIST
150)
Juswaacidwi
pueT
§TeMapPTS
I9M3S WIOIS
000191
= anTep pueT
*1sd TRIO
$9I0Y TPIOL
p/°0
‘3983 UCI TeNIDY 0GT
PeoY paard|
x
0
00T
©
S2I0¥ 0pL0
peod Taare
000191
IHSYYW
OL
0000£2
ADUYT
<D dUTeA I3TS>
PEod 3710
anyep
uoseay
-[pyy
23ey
yadeg
2uoiz
yidag
abeyuoig
uotidraosaq
sjuawaaocrduy
HOLEMS
#3S MVTIOOEMMI
+
$1030BI
4
21TYnd
Po
i
AOVINOYA
HMVT VNOW G0°900¥°
9d STAPL PUP]
IOI S93BUTISH anes puel
queoep’
|
pasordurf
x
ALIATANOD
6960-.009d|
£002/80/80
Q
3 SmOPUTM/HUTPTS/DBUTIOON|G0 LSh
V¥AL/ADL
¥6F’'SEE ADL
383 9707
ALATANOD
T€20-2TaWd|
2102/60/40
|
©daU/T93TY/PPY T2TIUBPTSOY
920-E0T-€T-LT-L7
‘# AVN
ALATANOD
LTPO-9TEWd}
9T0Z/9T/80
eday/1831Y/PPY 1TIUBPTS3Y
GZ0Z/61/80
%00T
"3°d°d
ALATINOD
LTp0-£209d|
£202/62/90
butprg/buryooy TeTIUaPTSAY
LOTYLSIA TOOHOS SIHOHS YNOW
:TOOYOS
__smaeag
ToqUNN
ajeq
(s)aTwrag
Butpiing|
€-u
:butuoz| OWAHI-TYIINGGISTY :sSETD
00
azaq
6597/6081]
LSTHALNI TYILNVA-9Z
oo)
ve6T/2T/21
lo
amv DROOL BLOM
07001
| VIS ALYIONd
TYay]
v91/9z22|
¥IHI0/AASN ION-TZ
aml
666T/51/€0 [000/662
|
0°0
HAISNVHL ALHAIONE |
¥$8/1L8E]
Y3IHLO/adAS0 LON-TZ
20]
1102/80/€0
jo
|
¥ HLIANC/L IAYG SY¥ONID|
0°00T
| JIISNVYL ALYAIOHEd
829/v6€0|
HLIONET S.Wd¥-£0
am|
SZ0Z/61/80
[006 °1LO
['s NOS¥ENE/QYHD NOSNIHOLOH|
crsueay
A
abeg
»|
ad&g,
ESL
301g
tjusag
pPaTITIS,
31eS
jo
swIal,
“3sur
artes
lates
a93jurin
9202/01/90
uo pajuTig
NODINSOH
:A3unos
SAHOHS NOLMON 40 ALID
:UOTIOTPSTIN
ssaappy Ajisdorg
¢
ZLAYMSE
IYD
WO
EDAOL
3
LA0OM
ZIWYMS
¥ HLI40L/C0
AIAYA
SYHONID| VHS -ATATIYD/o LEON
ZLYVMS
¥ HLIAOL/C dIAYA
SYHONIO
¥ HLIANL/C
AIAYA
SYHONIOD
103UPIH
00-9900-000~£LT-LZ
:18qunN
T9DIed
1Page 4
¢yypa23URPITIEND JOU INQ STYRTTAT POWSAP UT2I8Y UOTIPWIOTIUT 44 IVT YNOW ra BURY X27 Aq yore 00°09 878 450989212 9% 101 .89'8%1 .06'vel avod dood 00041 9202/01/90 Uo pajutad sbewr pueT ‘00-9900-000-£LT-L7 :IdqUON To0Ied
Page 5
“ccs
*Hutorad
s3lardwon
107
InojurIid
UOTIRNTRA
335
HUOT
003
SUOTIPTNDTED
>>
€L6
EFT
[4
asuado
100Q
6611
GOL’ T-
1
TTeM Z/T
:TTeM uowwo)d
£0V TE
T8190
£59
350) aseg
(PaYsSTUTd)
YOUI
gf
:uoTiepunog
HUTPTS
:I10TIBIXT
g
:SSPTD
sabexeg
TL9'G
6EE'8
£66
poo pajesay
¥29q
)
£66 -
616-
[13
MOTTRUS
fuoTIepunog
680°T
z09'T
[43
(A1035
1)
400
saYNIO0q
TEV 'b
8159
T
yard
2anixtd
g
962 '€T
£6661
z
yieqg 2In3xty
burtquntg
€88'T
69L's
1
BPPIH
2A0QY
‘doOuPIIUY
SpTISING
‘Jjuswasegq
vers
£18'€T
999
128UBA YO TIF
I0TI2IXT
SH9 ‘Zh
£1.29
CETT
Pa1y BUTATT jususseq
sjususnlpy/sSuoTITPPY I3Ul0
825 'v0E
818 LYE
1Te3og
47
bueyzsag
butpts
A1oas
1
80¢
juswaseqg
butpts
Azoag
z
LSE
juswsseg
butpts
Az035
6° 1
1843
Juswaseq
putpts
A103
+1
OFT
Juswaseg
butpts
Aros
1
150)
txdeg
man
3S0D
321g
uoTIepUNOI
I0TI83XY
saTI01%
sealy butpring
89/00T/00T/001/89=P009
2
"quOD/uodE/dung/Aud -qy/Aud
"dS
8781
=
PaIy¥y I00T4
4S
T6Z1
= B2I¥ punoin
:
BUTUOTATPUOD
ITY
‘I31RM
JOH PODIO
:walsAS ButiesH
(IT
,
8861
3T8
OL
9
STO
AJOLs
OoML
ArTues
=THuTs
1
:HpTg
‘sed IO
"31sE
1S0D
|
200m
wa3sAg Aytannag
1ea1y 3r0dred
5987079
:ATD"L PolEWTISH
roamadnon demas
J.
06F°T
X
889 °917
:3s0)
1daq
Teor:
eunes
1obRIRD JUUSH|
3°53
66L°2T9
non 2sed Teaor.
sbuey ues) 3198
0
:I00Td
*DUOD
ON
gest
Shy as
sbuey pIepuels
0
:ea1y sberolg
cr
ese
QABMOTDTH
0 poo
0T+
§
is
wo:
usa0
:
169
rea1y
|
PO PAIUIA-]DDIT
qnp* dex
Tzznoep
.
0
51000
"UDSNW
H
SA0]S
POO;
gnL
tzznoep
Z
is1000
‘oany
Y31PsH
paste:
woDIBIUL
‘
$91
14 PAUSTUTY
T03eTONITO LAH]
POOH pajuap
©
UDUL
Zp
ruoTiepunog
A10as
7 qegaiql
POOH pPa3judAuf
Cem
Z/T
tTTeM uoumio)
£1038
T qe3ax
ani
10H
:
0
:'usp BUOIS
A103g
7
T0TIOAX:
ued
Juss
1
0
:rusp YoTad
i
A103g
1
T0TIOAX
12308H yieg
butpTs
F101193%3
poo
paiesinlecs
pPapIS
ond,
1esodstq
abeqien
8
SSPID|
aioac
1)
ano ct
Dels Bues/puz
Isysemystq
tAqtoede)n
aed
Azolg
7
10TIB3U
dog, oon
8861
:3TTNg
189}
adALiea1y | A103g
1
IoTIBIUL|
“moTTy 2ouetrddy
aberen
(LT)
| synaa/sayuniod
(91)
saoetdarta
(ST)
|
sut-37INg
(GT)
9202/01/90
uo psjutiq
00-9900-000-€L1-LC
8A0DTY nj
suteM STL OTWPIa)
10073
OTTL OTWRIa)
1P9H
I331BM IPOS
Juetpey
wealg
ReE0 gc
»xyP323ueIEND
J0U
INQ STGRTTIST PAWSSP UTSI2Y UOTIPUIOIUT
4x4
iswall
ung
dung
otadss
Te9 0007
oradas
Teo 000T
TTeM
191PM
Tamas oTrqng|
1
183eM OTTANG|
Tamag/1aem
(pl)
uri Jus
oTWRIa)
Tamoys
siepaedag
HUTS
eI13IXy
I9TTOL
RING
BbutqunTg
on
Tenugp
‘1sus13J0S
o3ny
'yauailog
yieg san3xty
zl
1
yieg
2InINtg
€)
¢
{s)91In3xTg
abeiaay
burqunra
(eT)
mag]
| ;
TAY
Xi ol
$13[IN0
"DIT
JO
url
|
“PIO; X
“xa
§2INIXTI
JO
‘Tengd/t ON
SDTAISS
sdurg}00T
oTI302Td
(ZT)
¢
9DRUINI
POOM}
ITY
Texjuadl
¥
butTo0)n/buTIEsy
ON
dung jee
TOO)
¥
1IRAH
pPad10jg
20PUINg
T00TA/TTPM
1a3pal
20rdg
Pal
TTeM DTI308T7d
{(100T3-uT)
Juerpey
1ten
08rd
pirogaseqg 2TI309TH
PERI)
X
burroop/butivsy
(11
sIsquinyg
[90Ied
(ga)
JOH pa210d|
X
§30NQ
/#
ITY panIod
$39nq o/M
ITY paorod
rang ta3un
ua
pajroddnsupn
is3sTOop
jroddng
10074
(OT)
(¥)
$1600
INOATPeM|T
as
I00Td
ON
$1000
NOY [eM
BUTATTIZETT
UoTIPa1nay
4s
as
YSTUTq
jusuaseg
10074
83121010)
pooy pa1eax
auolg
*OUO0) PaINog
plalel
§<
IREelb{ele}
(6)
Jjuswaseqg
(8)
‘0
:isastop
01
3Jubray
‘d's
0
qPIS
ATS
0
fImMeID
"3's
9pgl
:juswaseg
uotIPARDXY
({)
TTemAT
sbutTTed
(9)
[ECLEN]
119430
TuUBYNITH
S100T4
(g)
07H
|PTTOS
Xj s1000
TTeUS|
pao]
x |
$33S0TD
JO P71
wil
|
pao] x
|
val
UOTIRIONSJ
§ WTI
931 poon|
pateueg
1935eT4d|
TTeMAIQ]
¥
10TIB3UT
(bh)
hueyrsao
18430|0
bueyrsnp
uorglo
UOTIPTNSUT Ix
ybno1yssaeg|
quod)
Jooy
(g)
§o1Id
athurys
pat
pIesury
TRIquPs|
SUBBIOG
¥
SWIOIG|
X
§100(Q
0T1ed
sseTH aTgnog
JusuBs
PY
APTTS
puny
sTgnog
xX
yseg
TAUTA
|
yses
TejeW|
|
yseg poom|
x
Sh
uoTiIeTNSUT; X
TAUTA/UMUTUNTY
¥
:
atbutys/poom
oT
Suo0IpaE| br
70014
pug]
007d
387
Juaweseq
Poon
patapo
ia1h3s
swerg
aul
DUIOH 3TT0H|
Attueg
oTbuTS|
X
adAy
sRauutyn
J1eydsy|
X
Jed
dry
a1qen|
x
jood
(g)
*ZTIOH
Mag
“Bav|
x
Auep
oputy
(2)
I
{011g
T83%y
9ST wooy
1UOTITPUOD
AdOLS
OML
putprIng
f
i
i
|
|
|
|
}
pooM|
X
Quel -y|
®e1dng|
10H
umoL|
|
xi
|
i
butpTTng
T
30
1 BUTPTING TeT3IUdpTSaYPage 6
9202/01/90 uo pajutig 1507091 O-QHS ——- 0 [673 FZ iS 06viT avd-ONOO Ob cb +x ¢PO2IUPTEND JOU ING SIGRTTT PAWS UTSIBY UOTIPMIOTUT yyy Hig Hedy 6quorNS AT o S059 8 Q YIYYO S06 doo S Sl ZL @ [Tr - 57) ylo |N dS 6¢ "n ¥I-HO-SI ‘ 15 0'Lbe I N YG -——1NST-HI-S+| . 15 0'80€ » LWSg-8352|R ~N oN — 1S 0°2G¥ To pet _ | iwsa-uass 1ASEYI SIO wl NONE bl IS v'E58 . o 1S 0°98 am BS) 5 .&'€ ONOD £F AL T BUTPTING [RTIUBPTS®Y ‘00-9900-000~£LT-L7 :1aquny [9dIed
Page 7
06/10/2028 valuation Report 02:31 PM E 27-173-000-0066-00 2026 Est. T.C.V. HUTCHINSON CHAD/ENERSON SAMANTHA Property Class: 401 4731 ROOD RD Map #: 27-17-13-103-026 CITY OF NORTON SHORES MUSKEGON, MI 43441 Land Value Estimates for Land Table R6.R006.05 MONA LAKE FRONTAGE * Factors * IRREGULAR SEE SKETCH Description Frontage Depth Front Depth Rate %adj. Reason Value <Site Value C> LARGE 230000 70 MARSHY 1¢1,000 0.740 Acres 0 100 0 150 Actual Front Feet, 0.74 Total Acres Total Est. Land Value = 161,000 Land Improvement Cost Estimates Description Rate Size * Good Cash value D/W/P: 3.5 Concrete 7.98 3350 62 16,574 D/W/P: 3.5 Concrete 7.98 286 62 1,415 D/W/P: 3.5 Concrete 7.98 800 82 3,958 Pool: Gunite 73.92 903 40 26,900 Wood Frame/Conc. 45.29 160 66 4,782 Total Estimated Land Improvements True Cash Value = 53,629 Cost Est. for Res. Bldg: 1 Single Family TWO STORY Cls B 10 Blt 1988 (11) Heating System: Forced Hot Water, Air Conditioning Ground Area = 1291 SF Floor Area = 1828 SF. Phy/Ab.Phy/Func/Econ/Comb. %* Good=68/100/100/100/68 Building Areas Stories Exterior Foundation Size Cost New Depr. Cost 1 Story Siding Basement 140 1+ Story Siding Basement 341 1.5 Story Siding Basement 457 2 Story Siding Basement 308 1 Story Siding Overhang 45 Total: 447,818 304,528 Other Additions/Adjustments Basement Living Area 1132 62,713 42,545 Exterior Brick Veneer 666 13,873 9,434 Basement, Outside Entrance, Above Grade 1 2,789 1,883 Plumbing 3 Fixture Bath 2 19,553 13,2986 2 Fixture Bath 1 6,518 4,432 Porches CCP (1 Story: 35 1,602 1,089 Foundation: Shallow 35 -519 -35 Deck Treated Wood 553 8,339 5,671 Garages Class: B Exterior: Siding Foundation: 42 Inch (Finished; Base Cost €57 31,403 Common Wall: 1/2 Wall 1 -1,159 Door Opener 2 973 Water/Sewer Public Water 1 2,083 Public Sewer 1 2,093 Totals 612,759 416, 688 Notes:
Page 8
06/10/2028
Valuation
Report
02:31
BM
>=:
Parcel
Number:
27-173-000-0065-00
Page:
2
ECF
{R006.06
MONA LAKE
FRONTAGE)
1.490
=>
TCV:
620,865
2028
Est.
T.C.¥.
27-173-000-006&-00
=
335,494
Est.
TCV/Total
Floor Area
= 457.05,
Most recent
sale 08/19/2025
for
£74,900
2025 Assessed
MBOR
S.E.V.
Base
for
Cap
IRM
374,900
374, 900
374,900
210,904
2.70
2028
New
Eg.
Adjustment
Loss
Additions
Tax Adjustment
Losses
14,100
11,000
0
11,100
174,996
0
2026 Assessed
MBOR
S.E.V.
Capped
->Taxable<-
PRE/MBT
417,700
460, 000
400,000
230,698
400,000
400,000