25-002685_2026 Valuation Disclosure_FINAL.pdf
Daniel A Mancia, Petitioner V City Of Birmingham, Respondent · 25-002685-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
OAKLAND COUNTY EXECUTIVE DAVID COULTER Equalization Division (248) 858-0740 | equal@oakgov.com 9/17/2026 Michigan Tax Tribunal PO Box 30232 Lansing, Michigan 48909 RE: Daniel A. Mancia v. City of Birmingham Docket No. 25-002685 Dear Honorable Tribunal: In accordance with the rules of the Michigan Tax Tribunal, the enclosed valuation disclosure is being submitted on behalf of the Respondent by Oakland County Equalization for the above referenced docket number. The purpose of this report is to estimate the true cash value of the subject property as of the date at issue, exclusively for defense of the property tax assessment. The subject property is a single-family residential home located at 2454 Windemere Rd in the City of Birmingham. The subject property has approximately 1,129 square feet of living area with 3 bedrooms, 1 full baths and 1 half bath including approximately 0 square feet of basement finish, and a 1 car detached garage. The subject’s site is considered improved. The lot is rectangular in shape and is 0.16 acres. The subject property sold May 14, 2019 for $275,000. Respondent’s Comparable Sales Analysis is for the 2026 assessment, the unadjusted sale prices of the comparable properties range from $420,000 to $550,000, or $330.19 to $400.17 per square foot, respectively. The comparable sales occurred between 10/25/2024 and 6/2/25. The selected comparable properties are similar in location, age, style, class, and quality of construction as the subject property. The comparable properties have been adjusted to the subject property based on market data. The adjusted sale prices of the comparable properties range from $394,100 to $510,000, or $309.75 to $383.33 per square foot, respectively. Consideration is given to all comparables with additional weight given to comparable 2 due to its lower gross adjustments and proximity to tax day. An inspection letter was mailed to the Petitioner on October 8, 2025. There has been no response to the inspection letter and no recent inspection has occurred. Based on the Sales Comparison Approach to Value (Market Approach), it is our opinion that the true cash value for the subject property for tax year 2026 is: Parcel Number: 08-20-30-406-010 12/31/2025………………………………………………………………………$430,000 Sincerely, Oakland County Equalization Division /S/ Terry Schultz Terry Schultz, Chief, MMAO, MCPPE ELIZABETH LAKE ROAD CENTER - 250 ELIZABETH LK RD STE 1000 WEST - PONTIAC MI 48341 - (248) 858-0740 1
Page 2
MTT Small Claims Docket 25-002685 A Valuation Disclosure of Real Property Parcel Number: 08-20-30-406-010 Daniel A. Mancia vs. City of Birmingham Prepared For: THE STATE OF MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL Report Date: 9/17/2026 Prepared By: 250 Elizabeth Lake Rd, Suite 1000w Pontiac MI 48341 2
Page 3
Table of Contents • Summary of Assessment 4 • Assessors Certification 5 • Function and Purpose of the Valuation Disclosure 6 • General Assumptions and Limiting Conditions 7 • Highest and Best Use 8 • Subject Property Description 9 • Valuation Process 11 • Comparable Sales Analysis 12 • Final Reconciliation 14 • Appendix 15 3
Page 4
SUMMARY OF ASSESSMENT PETITIONER: DANIEL A. MANCIA PROPERTY LOCATION: 2454 WINDEMERE RD PROPERTY CLASSIFICATION: RESIDENTIAL IMPROVED PARCEL IDENTIFICATION NUMBER: 08-20-30-406-010 TRANSFER OF OWNERSHIP: THE SUBJECT PROPERTY DID NOT UNCAP FOR 2025. PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION: THE PROPERTY HAS 100% PRE FOR 2025. DATE INSPECTION REQUEST LETTER WAS MAILED: 10/8/2025 DATE OF LAST RECORDED INSPECTION: No recent inspections have occurred. PROPERTY TAX ASSESSMENT AS OF 12/31/2025: 2026 TRUE CASH VALUE: $379,340 2026 ASSESSED VALUE: $189,670 2026 CAPPED VALUE: $171,170 2026 TAXABLE VALUE: $171,170 ESTIMATE OF VALUE (SALES COMPARISON APPROACH) AS OF: 12/31/2025 2026 TRUE CASH VALUE: $430,000 2026 ASSESSED VALUE: $215.000 2026 CAPPED VALUE: $171,170 2026 TAXABLE VALUE: $171,170 4
Page 5
ASSESSORS CERTIFICATION 1) We have no present or contemplated future interest in the subject of this report. 2) The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions and are my personal, impartial, and unbiased professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions. 3) The engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or reporting predetermined results. 4) As of the date of this report, the authors have completed the requirements under the continuing education program of the Michigan State Tax Commission; and have maintain current certification. 5) Our compensation for completing this assignment is not contingent upon the development or reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favors the cause of the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the intended use of this appraisal. 6) We have (or have not) made a personal inspection of the property that is the subject of this report. (If more than one person signs this certification, the certification must clearly specify which individuals did and which individuals did not make a personal inspection of the appraised property.) 7) No one provided significant real property appraisal assistance to the person signing this certification. (If there are exceptions, the name of everyone providing significant real property appraisal assistance must be stated. 8) This valuation disclosure assignment was not based upon a specific valuation or a specific outcome of any dispute regarding the subject property of this report. Respectfully Submitted, Oakland County Equalization Division /S/ Terry Schultz Terry Schultz Chief, MMAO, MCPPE /S/ Faith Martin Faith Martin Equalization Appraiser II, MAAO, MCPPE /S/ Cindy Baker Cindy Baker Equalization Appraiser II, MAAO, MCPPE 5
Page 6
THE FUNCTION OF THE VALUATION DISCLOSURE This valuation disclosure is intended to be relied on by the City of Birmingham, in its pending 2026 real property tax appeal at issue, which is the sole intended use of this valuation disclosure. Other intended users include the responsible authority of the Michigan Tax Tribunal assigned to hear and adjudicate this case. This valuation disclosure is not intended to be used for any other use(s) and the conclusions and valuation opinions expressed within are void if attempted. The valuation disclosure is not prepared or communicated for any financial-related transaction or real estate-related financial transaction use. Any attempt to use it for any other use other than that identified above is strictly prohibited. Any third party receiving a copy of this valuation disclosure due to disclosure requirements is not considered an intended user of this report, despite its retention of a copy. This valuation disclosure was not prepared for third party use. The Petitioner is specifically not identified as an intended user of this report. This valuation disclosure is divided into identifiable sections and further into specific subsections. Each subsection is an integral part of each section and further an integral part of the analysis. Each section and subsection are considered interrelated to each other and cannot be separated without diminishing this valuation disclosure’s integrity. This valuation disclosure must be considered entirely within its context and not separated in any manner, or that part, and the disclosure sections remaining, would be considered out of context and invalid. Omission and/or commission of any section(s) of this report are strictly prohibited. THE PURPOSE OF THE VALUATION DISCLOSURE The purpose of this valuation disclosure is to estimate the true cash value of the subject property for assessment purposes as of the effective date(s) of valuation. The term true cash value, as used in this report, is defined in the General Property Tax Act as: 211.27(1) As used in this act, "true cash value" means the usual selling price at the place where the property to which the term is applied is at the time of assessment, being the price that could be obtained for the property at private sale, and not at auction sale except as otherwise provided in this section, or at forced sale. The usual selling price may include sales at public auction held by a nongovernmental agency or person if those sales have become a common method of acquisition in the jurisdiction for the class of property being valued. The usual selling price does not include sales at public auction if the sale is part of a liquidation of the seller's assets in a bankruptcy proceeding or if the seller is unable to use common marketing techniques to obtain the usual selling price for the property. 6
Page 7
GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS AND LIMITING CONDITIONS This valuation disclosure is prepared and communicated to satisfy Tax Tribunal Rule 283(3) which states “… witness may not testify as to the value of property without submission of a valuation disclosure.” A valuation disclosure is defined as “documentary evidence or other tangible evidence in a property tax appeal which a party relies upon in support of the party’s contention as to the true cash value of the subject property or any portion thereof and which contains the party’s value conclusions and data, valuation methodology, analysis, or reasoning.” Tax Tribunal Rule 101(1) (m). This report and my analyses contained herein are not, and should not be construed as, an appraisal report, which would be governed by Article 26 of the Michigan Occupational Code. The following analyses are prepared for, and serve as a basis of, my contentions of the property’s assessment for the subject property for tax year 2026. No other use is permitted. This valuation disclosure report has been made with the following general assumptions: 1. No responsibility is assumed for the legal description provided or for matters pertaining to legal or title considerations. 2. The property is valued free and clear of any liens or encumbrances unless otherwise stated. 3. The information furnished by others is believed to be reliable, but no warranty is given for its accuracy. 4. It is assumed that the property is in full compliance with all applicable federal, state, and local environmental regulations and laws unless the lack of compliance is stated, described, and considered in the valuation disclosure. 5. This valuation disclosure was prepared in defense of assessments placed on the subject property before the Michigan Tax Tribunal. The valuation disclosure and the assessment roll were prepared by individuals with the certification requirements commensurate with the guidelines established by the Michigan State Tax Commission. 7
Page 8
HIGHEST AND BEST USE According to The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, Seventh Edition (2022), a publication of the Appraisal Institute, highest and best use was defined as: 1. The reasonably probable use of property that results in the highest value. The four criteria that the highest and best use must meet are legal permissibility, physical possibility, financial feasibility, and maximum productivity. 2. The use of an asset that maximizes its potential and that is possible, legally permissible, and financially feasible. The highest and best use may be for continuation of an asset’s existing use or for some alternative use. This is determined by the use that a market participant would have in mind for the asset when formulating the price that it would be willing to bid. (IVS) 3. [The] highest and most profitable use for which the property is adaptable and needed or likely to be needed in the reasonably near future. (Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions) 4. [For fair value determination] The use of a nonfinancial asset by market participants that would maximize the value of the asset or the group of assets and liabilities (for example, a business) within which the asset would be used. (FASB Glossary) The highest and best use of a nonfinancial asset takes into account the use that is physically possible, legally permissible, and financially feasible. (FASB 820-10- 35-10B). The highest and best use of a nonfinancial asset establishes the valuation premise used to measure the fair value of the asset, as follows: (a) The highest and best use of a nonfinancial asset might provide maximum value to market participants through its use in combination with other assets as a group (as installed or otherwise configured for use) or in combination with other assets and liabilities (for example, a business). (b) The highest and best use of the asset might provide maximum value to market participants on a standalone basis. (FASB 820-10-35-10E) After carefully reviewing the four tests outlined for highest and best use, and carefully applying them to the subject property, Respondent has concluded the following: The highest and best use of the subject property, as of the effective date of value, “as though vacant” is for residential improved. The highest and best use of the subject property, as of the effective date of value, “as currently improved” is as residential improved. 8
Page 9
SUBJECT PROPERTY DESCRIPTION The subject property is a single-family residential home located at 2454 Windemere Rd. in the City of Birmingham. The subject property has approximately 1,129 square feet of living area with 3 bedrooms, 1 full baths and 1 half bath including approximately 0 square feet of basement finish, and a 1 car detached garage. The subject’s site is considered an improved parcel. The lot is rectangular in shape and is 0.16 acres. The subject property sold 5/14/2019 for $275,000. 9
Page 10
Plot Map 10 Plot Map - <1N & Na —— ey 5 i I - oF > 1) he 7 fon bi | 10
Page 11
VALUATION PROCESS The three approaches to value were considered in determining the value of the Subject Property, namely the cost, income, and market approaches. The degree of dependability on any one approach will change with the availability of reliable data. COST APPROACH The cost approach is based on the principle of substitution: a rational informed purchaser will pay no more for a property than the cost of an acceptable substitute. The cost approach provides an estimate of value based on the depreciated cost of the property, is applicable to most types of property and serves as a good foundation for uniformity and equity in assessments. Appendix A is Respondent’s Valuation Report, Sketch, ECF Study, and Land Study utilized for the value placed on the 2026 Assessment Roll. INCOME APPROACH The income approach produces an estimate of the present worth of capitalized income to be received in the future. The capitalization process restates market value by converting the future benefits of property ownership into an expression of present worth. This approach is based on the principles of substitution: a rational informed purchaser will pay no more for a property than the cost of an acceptable substitute. Considering that the subject property is a single-family residential home and there is insufficient data to produce a credible result, the income approach will not be performed. MARKET APPROACH (COMPARABLE SALES APPROACH) The market approach utilizes the application of sales data to indicate the value of the property under appraisal. This approach is based on the principle of substitution: no commodity has a value greater than that for which a similar commodity offering similar uses, and similar function and can be purchased within a reasonable timeframe. The market approach is most reliable when there are a sufficient number of sales to be analyzed. These principles are best applied for the subject property. Below is a comparable sales analysis that will be utilized for the final determination of value for the Market Approach: THIS SPACE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK 11
Page 12
12
Asof:
12/31/2025
COMPARABLE SALES ANALYSIS
2026
08-20-30-406-010
Residential
Docket No: 25-0026
Petitioner: Daniel
SUBJECT
COMPARABLE 4
COMPARABLE §
or
City of Birmingham
City
of
Birmingh
City
of
Birmingh
City
of
Bimingh
City
of
Birmingh
Parcel #
08-20-30-406-010
08-20-30-429-014
08-20-30-451-018
08-20-30-427-002
08-20-30-404-028
Address
2454 Windemere Rd
2850 Windemere Rd
2109 Dorchester
Rd
2626 Pembroke Rd
2209 Windemere Rd
Design (style)
Bungalow
Bungalow
Bungalow
Bungalow
Bungalow
Sales Price
$275,000
$420,000
$425,000
$485,000
$550,000
Price/Sq Ft
$243.58
$330.19
$348.08
$400.17
$344.83
A
Adjustment
Adjustment
Adjus
Date of Sale Time
May-19
October-24.
35,000)
May-25
18.000]
June-25
18.000
April-25
Site (acres)
0.16
0.15
0f
0.17
of
0.16
0)
0.17
Year Built
1950
1951
0)
1946
of
1951
0)
1948
Effective Age:
2000
2000
0f
1995
of
2010
10.000]
2000
Gross Living Area
1,129 SqFt
1272 SqFt
16000]
1.221 SqFt
0]
1212 SqFt
0)
1,595 SqFt
Foundati
Basement
Basement
[
B
0
Basement/Crawl
2.700]
B
Basement Finish
0SqFt
749 SqFt
30,000)
510 SqFt
20400]
740 SqFt
~29.600)
0SqFt
Full Bath
1
2
-8.500]
3
-17.000}
2
-8.500]
2
Half Bath
1
0
5,500)
0
5.500)
1
0)
0
Heating Cooling
Forced Heat & Cool
Forced Heat
& Cool
0|
Forced Heat
& Cool
0]
Forced Heat
& Cool
0
Forced Heat
& Cool
Garage
1 Car
2 Car
12,000]
2 Car
12,000]
0 Car
12.000
2 Car
Decks, Patios
1 Total
1 Total
0f
1 Total
of
2 Total
-5.000]
0 Total
Fireplaces
1
1
[i
1
0
1
0
1
Net Adj
$26,000
Net Adj
$25,900
Net Adj
-$20,400
Net
Ad
-$40
Current TCV
379,340
Adjusted Sales Price|
$394,000
Adjusted Sales Pricel
$399,100
Adjusted Sales Price|
$464,600
Adjusted Sales Price]
$510
TCV Per SqFt
$336.00
Adjusted Price
/ SF|
$309.75
Adjusted Price
/ SF|
$326.86
Adjusted Price
/ SF|
$383.33
Adjusted Price / SF|
$31
Gross Adjustment{
$107,000
Gross Adj
$72,900
Gross Adj
$85,800
Gross Adj
$109
Gross
Adj / Sale Price|
25%
Gross
Adj
/ Sale Price|
17%
Gross
Adj / Sale Price]
18%
Gross
Adj / Sale Price]
2
[Comments
on Sales Comparison (including the subject property's compatibility to the
nei
ete):
| The comparables
selected are the most similar properties available for comparison. The comparables have been adjusted to the subject based on market data.
| Consideration
is given
to all
with:
weight given to
2 due to its lower gross adjustments and proximity to tax day.
[Analysis of any current
of sale, option, or listing of the subject property and analysis of an prior sales of subject and.
within one year of the date of valuation:
INDICATED VALUE BY SALES COMPARISON.
I
Bo
* Prepared By OPage 13
MAP OF SUBJECT AND COMPARABLE PROPERTIES Comp 1 is approximately 0.20 miles from the Subject Comp 2 is approximately 0.40 miles from the Subject Comp 3 is approximately 0.20 miles from the Subject Comp 4 is approximately 0.10 miles from the Subject 13
Page 14
FINAL RECONCILIATION Three approaches to value were considered in developing an estimate of market value of the subject property and are as follows: For 2026 Tax Year: Mass Appraisal Cost Approach: $379,340 Sales Comparison Approach: $430,000 Income Capitalization Approach: N/A The sales comparison approach will be given full consideration in this analysis as this approach is the most relevant to the appraisal of the Subject Property and supportable by available data. Final Opinion of Value for 2026 Tax Year………...……………………………$430,000 14
Page 15
APPENDIX A. Respondent’s 2026 Valuation Report (Mass Appraisal Cost Approach). B. Subject’s 2026 March Board of Review Results Letter C. ECF Study and Land Study D. City Area Analysis E. REALCOMP (MLS) Property Sale Listing Reports 15
Page 16
Valuation Report DB: Assessing-26 09/17/2026 11:45 AM 217,280 189,670 189,670 171,170 171,170 171,170 2026 Assessed MBOR S.E.V. Capped ->Taxable<- PRE/MBT 0 -20,510 0 0 4,500 0 2026 New Eq. Adjustment Loss Additions Tax Adjustment Losses 210,180 210,180 210,180 166,670 2.70 2025 Assessed MBOR S.E.V. Base for Cap IRM Est. TCV/Total Floor Area = 384.91, Most recent sale 05/14/2019 for 275,000 2026 Est. T.C.V. 08-20-30-406-010 = 434,559 ECF (E.C.F. Table 30U) 1.035 => TCV: 131,487 Notes: Totals: 254,094 127,041 013-OvenMicrowaveCom 1 3,885 1,942 Unit-in-Place Cost Items Exterior 1 Story 1 6,893 3,446 Fireplaces Vented Hood 1 604 302 Garbage Disposal 1 277 138 Dishwasher 1 824 412 Cook Top 1 824 412 Built-Ins Base Cost 361 16,981 8,490 Class: CD Exterior: Siding Foundation: 42 Inch (Unfinished) Garages CCP (1 Story) 42 1,489 744 CPP 232 4,559 2,279 Porches Ceramic Tub Alcove 1 796 398 Ceramic Tile Wains 2 4,761 2,380 Ceramic Tile Floor 1 1,269 634 2 Fixture Bath 1 3,234 1,617 Plumbing Recreation Room 875 17,911 8,955 Other Additions/Adjustments Total: 189,787 94,892 1 Story Siding Overhang 17 1 Story Siding Overhang 18 1.25 Story Brick Basement 875 Stories Exterior Foundation Size Cost New Depr. Cost Building Areas Phy/Ab.Phy/Func/Econ/Comb. % Good=50/100/100/100/50 Ground Area = 875 SF Floor Area = 1129 SF. (11) Heating System: Forced Heat & Cool Cost Est. for Res. Bldg: 1 Single Family Bungalow Cls C Blt 1950 50 Actual Front Feet, 0.16 Total Acres Total Est. Land Value = 303,072 <Site Value A> -59 303072 100 303,072 Description Frontage Depth Front Depth Rate %Adj. Reason Value * Factors * Land Value Estimates for Land Table 30U.Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams Map #: . City of Birmingham BIRMINGHAM, MI 48009-7518 Property Class: 401 2454 WINDEMERE RD 08-20-30-406-010 2026 Est. T.C.V. MANCIA, DANIEL ANTHONY 16
Page 17
Valuation Report DB: Assessing-26 09/17/2026 11:45 AM *** Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed*** Parcel Number: 08-20-30-406-010, Residential Building 1 17
Page 18
3. TAXABLE VALUE If you disagree with the decision of the Board of Review regarding classification, appeal is made by sending Form 2167 to the State Tax Commission, PO Box 30471 Lansing MI 48909 by June 30th. Michigan Tax Tribunal Decisions received February through May are not reflected in this March Board of Review Change Notice. A COPY OF THIS NOTICE MUST ACCOMPANY ANY PETITION TO THE MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL OR YOUR APPEAL WILL DEFAULT. Personal Property is July 31st. All other matters have 35 days to appeal. Commercial Real, Industrial Real, Developmental Real, Commercial Personal, Industrial Personal, and Utility Personal Property. The final date for further appeal of valuation for Agricultural Real, Residential Real, Timber Cut-over Real, and Agricultural and mailed to PO Box 30232, Lansing, MI 48909 by May 31st for www.michigan.gov/taxtrib (click Small Claims Tab) by filing a petition that can be obtained at Further appeal of valuation may be made to the Michigan Tax Tribunal ** Notice of March Board of Review Change ** FROM CITY OF BIRMINGHAM MICHEAL R. LOHMEIER, ASSESSOR PO BOX 3001 BIRMINGHAM MI 48012-3001 NAME AND ADDRESS OF OWNER OR PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION: MANCIA, DANIEL ANTHONY 2454 WINDEMERE RD 08-20-30-406-010 BIRMINGHAM MI 48009-7518 63010 SCHOOL DISTRICT: PROPERTY ADDRESS 2454 WINDEMERE RD THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS: PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE/QUALIFIED AG EXEMPTION: 100.00% PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION IF DIFFERENT: 0.00% MICHIGAN BUSINESS EXEMPTION: The Board of Review has Examined your 2026 Assessed Value and/or Capped Value and has made the following decision: 149 03/17/2026 PETITION NUMBER DATE: VALUE PRIOR MBOR VALUE AFTER MBOR CHANGE 1. ASSESSED VALUE 217,280 189,670 -27,610 2. CAPPED VALUE 171,170 171,170 0 171,170 0 171,170 4. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR: 1.000 189,670 5. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE: 217,280 -27,610 WAS NOT 6. There WAS/WAS NOT a transfer of ownership on this property in 2025. The 2026 Capped Value Formula is the 2025 Taxable Value, minus losses, increased by the Inflation Rate Multiplier of 3.1%, plus Additions. Taxable Value is the lower of Assessed Value or Capped Value unless an Ownership Transfer occurred. Your Taxes are Levied on the Taxable Amount. CITY OF BIRMINGHAM BOARD OF REVIEW 401 401 Residential Residential 18
Page 19
NBHD Total Sales Sale Price Assessment Ratio Used ECF 25A 20 $41,059,400 $20,421,780 49.74% Tab 25A 25H 13 $14,723,000 $7,246,340 49.22% Tab 25H 25O 7 $15,659,000 $7,782,330 49.70% Tab 25O 25V 20 $19,502,000 $9,553,980 48.99% Tab 25V 26J 34 $82,718,819 $40,931,840 49.48% Tab 26J 26N 7 $10,550,000 $4,807,920 45.57% Tab 26N 30N 11 $12,286,749 $5,901,330 48.03% Tab 30N 30U 53 $41,710,345 $20,798,990 49.87% Tab 30U 31A 125 $91,675,948 $44,902,940 48.98% Tab 31A 35A 27 $31,449,725 $15,237,380 48.45% Tab 35A 35I 9 $21,007,500 $9,658,250 45.98% Tab 35I 35O 18 $24,323,200 $11,820,850 48.60% Tab 35O 35U 11 $11,903,000 $5,899,810 49.57% Tab 35U 36A 3 $2,910,000 $1,441,030 49.52% Tab 36A 36C 23 $30,733,538 $15,425,660 50.19% Tab 36C 36H 11 $17,141,000 $8,852,200 51.64% Tab 36H 36V 111 $103,283,330 $51,498,710 49.86% Tab 36V 36W 10 $13,152,500 $6,537,770 49.71% Tab 36W K01 0 1.570 K02 1 $280,000 $143,730 51.33% 1.185 K03 0 1.010 K04 0 1.040 K05 0 1.500 K06 3 $871,500 $434,720 49.88% 1.590 K08 0 1.555 K10 0 0.885 K11 9 $9,671,000 $4,565,950 47.21% 1.200 K12 0 1.300 K13 0 1.450 K14 0 1.310 K15 0 1.240 K16 1 $955,700 $440,920 46.14% 1.330 K18 0 1.170 K19 0 1.020 K20 0 0.975 K22 0 1.800 K23 2 $367,500 $175,450 47.74% 1.235 K24 1 $727,700 $289,330 39.76% 1.735 K25 4 $1,951,000 $1,025,150 52.54% 1.125 K26 4 $1,543,500 $770,110 49.89% 1.050 K27 0 1.000 K28 1 $1,150,000 $572,960 49.82% 1.365 K29 0 1.325 City of Birmingham 2026 ECF Study 1 Last saved: 02-13-24 9:25:44 AM 19
Page 20
K31 0 1.550 K32 0 1.210 K33 0 1.580 K34 0 1.170 K35 2 $985,000 $490,950 49.84% 1.550 K36 2 $709,000 $353,360 49.84% 1.500 K37 0 0.910 K38 2 $635,000 $304,920 48.02% 1.020 K39 0 1.275 K40 2 $4,550,000 $2,197,620 48.30% 1.410 K41 1 $318,000 $156,060 49.08% 1.210 K42 4 $1,331,500 $660,600 49.61% 1.355 K43 3 $898,000 $447,720 49.86% 1.030 K44 1 $1,125,000 $561,860 49.94% 1.750 K45 2 $795,000 $383,920 48.29% 1.465 K46 0 1.485 K47 0 1.420 K48 1 $761,500 $343,680 45.13% 1.335 K49 0 1.325 K50 1 $2,065,000 $1,097,620 53.15% 1.290 K51 2 $4,725,000 $2,357,590 49.90% 1.365 K52 3 $2,590,000 $1,238,710 47.83% 1.240 K53 19 $9,354,050 $4,610,800 49.29% 1.540 K54 0 1.045 K57 0 1.375 K59 4 $644,750 $321,080 49.80% 1.380 K60 3 $946,555 $460,760 48.68% 1.530 K61 3 $559,000 $272,550 48.76% 1.100 K62 2 $332,000 $164,770 49.63% 1.170 K63 1 $2,097,485 $1,046,480 49.89% 1.100 K64 11 $2,032,600 $1,011,440 49.76% 1.190 K65 2 $2,800,000 $1,271,340 45.41% 1.400 K66 0 1.205 K67 1 $1,200,000 $607,560 50.63% 1.165 K68 26 $6,226,749 $3,085,060 49.55% 1.590 K69 1 $1,525,000 $758,950 49.77% 1.755 K70 10 $7,287,000 $3,458,430 47.46% 1.100 K71 1 $570,000 $262,580 46.07% 0.955 K72 1 $1,750,000 $927,590 53.01% 1.150 K73 3 $3,176,500 $1,575,400 49.60% 0.900 K74 0 1.030 K75 0 1.365 K77 0 1.685 K78 3 $620,000 $259,880 41.92% 1.090 K79 0 1.040 K80 1 $140,000 $60,830 43.45% 1.190 K81 6 $1,331,500 $606,460 45.55% 1.000 2 Last saved: 02-13-24 9:25:44 AM 20
Page 21
K82 2 $272,500 $135,460 49.71% 1.300 K83 9 $1,990,000 $987,690 49.63% 1.705 K84 8 $1,112,300 $560,370 50.38% 1.310 K85 0 1.750 K86 0 1.175 K87 3 $938,000 $462,720 49.33% 1.310 K88 0 1.780 K89 0 1.375 K90 13 $4,494,900 $2,225,720 49.52% 1.275 K91 3 $670,000 $330,810 49.37% 1.000 K93 0 1.115 K96 2 $1,570,000 $866,670 55.20% 1.180 K97 1 $2,987,600 $1,664,780 55.72% 1.640 K98 0 1.140 K99 0 1.175 Totals: 704 $681,423,443 $335,728,220 49.27% Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Property Class Terms of Sale NBHD Sale Price Cur. Asmnt. Ratio $/Sq.Ft. Floor Area Building Style 08-19-25-303-009 780 GREENWOOD BLVD 7/28/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $2,700,000 $1,511,010 55.96 $380.32 5,177 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-304-004 855 VINEWOOD AVE 11/7/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $830,000 $387,690 46.71 $112.60 2,085 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-327-006 628 WOODLAND ST 8/1/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,950,000 $894,150 45.85 $347.56 3,556 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-327-016 451 VINEWOOD AVE 12/20/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $3,450,000 $1,640,020 47.54 $470.64 5,323 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-327-022 600 ATEN CT 2/5/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $3,200,000 $1,354,790 42.34 $591.69 4,215 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-327-079 555 VINEWOOD AVE 1/30/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $3,800,000 $1,926,290 50.69 $343.71 6,565 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-351-008 375 BALDWIN RD 10/2/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $2,550,000 $1,277,100 50.08 $402.22 4,616 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-352-022 839 RANDALL CT 3/6/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $2,250,000 $1,168,790 51.95 $269.59 4,450 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-353-006 446 BALDWIN RD 4/3/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $2,500,000 $1,242,870 49.71 $266.76 5,885 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-353-011 376 BALDWIN RD 6/15/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $2,599,900 $1,476,340 56.78 $406.67 4,450 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-353-023 407 GREENWOOD BLVD 12/11/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $3,320,000 $1,674,060 50.42 $609.03 4,256 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-353-049 710 WILLITS ST 3/28/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,999,000 $827,210 41.38 $640.95 2,218 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-355-012 200 GREENWOOD BLVD 12/13/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,350,000 $668,660 49.53 $191.85 3,429 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-356-001 192 BALDWIN RD 6/26/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,350,000 $713,140 52.83 $160.19 3,187 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-376-040 488 WILLITS ST 12/13/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $980,000 $491,550 50.16 $111.96 2,620 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-376-042 448 WILLITS ST 3/27/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,150,500 $540,170 46.95 $208.58 2,210 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-376-082 556 TOOTING LN 6/4/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,850,000 $945,270 51.10 $149.80 3,812 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-427-004 774 LAKESIDE RD 8/23/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $1,600,000 $799,170 49.95 $190.90 3,531 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-427-034 549 LAKEVIEW AVE 9/16/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $900,000 $454,240 50.47 $122.86 1,826 Bungalow 08-19-36-102-004 110 BALDWIN RD 10/24/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25A $730,000 $429,260 58.80 $22.36 2,129 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-177-025 175 WIMBLETON DR 7/28/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $625,000 $321,160 51.39 $71.02 2,157 Ranch 08-19-25-253-014 511 HENLEY DR 7/11/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $850,000 $453,440 53.35 $155.92 2,390 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-254-017 463 WIMBLETON DR 3/5/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $1,350,000 $558,890 41.40 $251.48 3,295 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-257-001 202 WIMBLETON DR 5/17/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $1,450,000 $647,150 44.63 $358.77 2,794 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-257-012 498 WIMBLETON DR 3/28/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $885,000 $407,590 46.06 $187.97 2,183 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-276-001 610 TOTTENHAM RD 1/30/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $780,000 $357,470 45.83 $102.79 2,232 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-25-276-023 699 ABBEY RD 10/31/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 25H $1,340,000 $688,340 51.37 $194.02 4,463 Colonial/2Sty 2 Year Sale Ratio: 2 Year *Sale Study Period: 4/01/2023-03/31/2025 3 Last saved: 02-13-24 9:25:44 AM 21
Page 22
Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Property Class Terms of Sale NBHD Sale Price Cur. Asmnt. Ratio $/Sq.Ft. Floor Area Building Style 08-19-26-229-018 1137 WILLOW LN 6/21/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,500,000 $691,010 46.07 $189.88 3,793 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-230-032 1234 WILLOW LN 4/10/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $4,250,000 $2,111,390 49.68 $565.66 5,965 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-251-008 908 CHESTERFIELD AVE 6/26/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,657,000 $751,660 45.36 $247.76 3,586 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-252-005 1010 FAIRFAX AVE 7/14/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,700,000 $749,170 44.07 $208.27 3,778 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-252-014 1075 SUFFIELD AVE 9/28/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,104,000 $580,350 52.57 $147.48 3,054 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-252-030 1076 FAIRFAX AVE 1/5/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $2,450,000 $1,064,750 43.46 $493.93 3,598 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-253-006 998 SUFFIELD AVE 9/5/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,151,520 $559,330 48.57 $173.66 2,786 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-254-011 1095 PURITAN AVE 11/22/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $3,834,800 $2,059,420 53.70 $542.82 5,497 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-278-004 1097 LAKESIDE RD 6/11/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,314,000 $697,710 53.10 $183.16 3,561 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-279-015 960 LAKESIDE RD 12/17/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $3,995,000 $1,883,600 47.15 $613.16 4,633 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-279-020 1030 LAKESIDE RD 1/30/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,800,000 $808,280 44.90 $249.03 3,555 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-279-026 970 OAK AVE 10/17/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $930,500 $542,900 58.34 $83.58 2,628 Ranch 08-19-26-378-060 235 CHESTERFIELD AVE 8/28/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $3,278,000 $1,548,720 47.25 $547.10 4,762 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-401-004 766 CHESTERFIELD AVE 7/22/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $2,739,100 $1,386,890 50.63 $474.77 4,292 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-401-019 767 FAIRFAX AVE 10/23/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,315,000 $679,240 51.65 $124.09 3,201 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-401-022 685 FAIRFAX AVE 10/20/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $3,999,999 $1,984,330 49.61 $451.72 6,908 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-402-027 545 SUFFIELD AVE 11/8/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $3,250,000 $1,395,540 42.94 $323.08 6,082 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-403-006 746 SUFFIELD AVE 9/8/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,125,000 $612,280 54.42 $105.31 3,093 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-453-016 451 PILGRIM AVE 1/6/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $1,345,000 $701,610 52.16 $126.80 3,332 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-454-008 316 PILGRIM AVE 12/3/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $899,900 $469,680 52.19 $33.28 2,359 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-477-008 200 LAKE PARK DR 1/4/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26J $3,125,000 $1,613,300 51.63 $299.34 6,864 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-326-002 861 WESTWOOD DR 10/30/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $1,900,000 $707,720 37.25 $253.01 4,750 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-327-007 638 WESTWOOD DR 12/4/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $1,125,000 $517,550 46.00 $165.64 3,312 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-327-009 586 WESTWOOD DR 8/23/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $1,150,000 $481,380 41.86 $194.13 2,961 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-328-006 634 N GLENHURST DR 7/6/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $2,375,000 $1,348,310 56.77 $359.43 4,890 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-330-015 1854 WINTHROP LN 7/9/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $1,150,000 $407,020 35.39 $243.37 2,737 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-330-025 1832 WINTHROP LN 5/26/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $2,100,000 $939,200 44.72 $490.39 3,288 Colonial/2Sty 08-19-26-378-035 1900 FAIRVIEW AVE 6/30/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 26N $750,000 $406,740 54.23 $107.09 2,499 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-301-003 1151 MANCHESTER RD 8/5/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $1,870,000 $850,670 45.49 $400.89 3,654 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-301-004 1185 MANCHESTER RD 9/6/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $2,300,000 $1,121,790 48.77 $409.48 4,622 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-301-028 1585 BUCKINGHAM AVE 6/15/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $899,000 $479,230 53.31 $168.76 2,627 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-352-014 1215 YORKSHIRE RD 7/12/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $1,380,000 $564,840 40.93 $292.23 3,172 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-353-006 1260 YORKSHIRE RD 11/13/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $765,000 $381,540 49.87 $112.78 2,803 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-354-006 1582 BUCKINGHAM AVE 4/4/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $941,500 $504,820 53.62 $137.04 3,561 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-355-002 1452 DORCHESTER RD 5/24/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $1,235,000 $519,650 42.08 $272.92 2,737 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-355-014 1509 YORKSHIRE RD 1/14/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $690,000 $377,140 54.66 $112.32 2,145 Bungalow 08-20-30-356-009 1648 YORKSHIRE RD 3/14/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $725,000 $365,430 50.40 $158.15 1,746 Bungalow 08-20-30-376-002 1731 DORCHESTER RD 7/27/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $821,250 $386,640 47.08 $138.45 2,680 Bungalow 08-20-30-378-002 1756 YORKSHIRE RD 1/9/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30N $659,999 $349,580 52.97 $107.33 1,967 Bungalow 08-20-30-101-029 811 NORWICH RD 2/14/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $550,000 $268,280 48.78 $118.68 1,144 Ranch 08-20-30-327-012 1845 PEMBROKE RD 5/31/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $425,000 $261,310 61.48 $7.84 1,593 Ranch 08-20-30-401-002 2032 DERBY RD 9/27/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $465,000 $225,020 48.39 $129.60 1,243 Ranch 08-20-30-401-016 2288 DERBY RD 5/15/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $443,500 $211,030 47.58 $116.67 1,171 Ranch 08-20-30-401-028 2205 PEMBROKE RD 6/26/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $425,830 $212,080 49.80 $98.68 1,244 Bungalow 08-20-30-403-004 2378 PEMBROKE RD 9/7/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $715,500 $301,610 42.15 $226.17 1,816 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-403-008 2440 PEMBROKE RD 10/23/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,550,000 $655,660 42.30 $367.63 3,388 Colonial/2Sty 5 Last saved: 02-13-24 9:25:44 AM 23
Page 23
Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Property Class Terms of Sale NBHD Sale Price Cur. Asmnt. Ratio $/Sq.Ft. Floor Area Building Style 08-20-30-403-009 2456 PEMBROKE RD 5/11/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $380,000 $208,140 54.77 $68.38 1,125 Bungalow 08-20-30-403-031 2571 MANCHESTER RD 9/12/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $400,000 $220,510 55.13 $84.36 1,149 Bungalow 08-20-30-404-004 2078 MANCHESTER RD 7/12/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,450,000 $819,610 56.52 $351.71 3,261 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-404-009 2168 MANCHESTER RD 5/15/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,347,000 $690,460 51.26 $271.29 3,848 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-404-024 2139 WINDEMERE RD 4/12/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $414,900 $218,110 52.57 $101.85 1,098 Bungalow 08-20-30-404-027 2193 WINDEMERE RD 7/21/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $735,000 $361,570 49.19 $185.62 2,327 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-405-018 2335 WINDEMERE RD 5/15/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $965,000 $451,600 46.80 $209.71 3,123 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-406-027 2471 BUCKINGHAM AVE 5/23/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,358,000 $764,470 56.29 $262.42 4,020 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-406-032 2577 BUCKINGHAM AVE 9/25/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $451,215 $194,950 43.21 $157.31 934 Ranch 08-20-30-426-021 2662 DERBY RD 4/11/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $490,000 $222,870 45.48 $134.00 1,395 Ranch 08-20-30-426-023 2706 DERBY RD 9/8/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $365,000 $208,940 57.24 $52.86 1,170 Ranch 08-20-30-426-029 2802 DERBY RD 2/14/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $695,000 $349,070 50.23 $159.54 2,311 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-426-031 2313 PEMBROKE RD 8/17/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $502,000 $224,570 44.74 $153.22 1,283 Ranch 08-20-30-426-039 2457 PEMBROKE RD 8/28/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $430,000 $226,540 52.68 $102.03 1,244 Bungalow 08-20-30-426-049 2647 PEMBROKE RD 5/6/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $570,000 $261,620 45.90 $191.22 1,390 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-427-004 2666 PEMBROKE RD 6/5/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $495,000 $226,320 45.72 $161.42 1,189 Bungalow 08-20-30-427-009 2762 PEMBROKE RD 8/11/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $580,000 $272,270 46.94 $152.83 1,812 Bungalow 08-20-30-427-012 2806 PEMBROKE RD 8/15/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $430,000 $225,000 52.33 $104.53 1,153 Bungalow 08-20-30-428-004 2668 MANCHESTER RD 10/19/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,120,000 $669,020 59.73 $220.17 3,697 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-428-010 2786 MANCHESTER RD 10/17/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $475,000 $245,840 51.76 $116.80 1,472 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-428-012 2810 MANCHESTER RD 7/31/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $510,000 $265,620 52.08 $137.39 1,495 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-428-015 2601 WINDEMERE RD 2/12/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $395,000 $223,460 56.57 $56.92 1,615 Bungalow 08-20-30-428-031 657 COOLIDGE HWY 9/15/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $310,000 $184,130 59.40 $51.84 1,191 Bungalow 08-20-30-429-003 2648 WINDEMERE RD 3/7/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $306,500 $211,970 69.16 $2.24 1,008 Ranch 08-20-30-429-014 2850 WINDEMERE RD 10/25/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $420,000 $228,610 54.43 $91.92 1,272 Bungalow 08-20-30-429-016 2623 BUCKINGHAM AVE 5/10/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $657,000 $287,090 43.70 $119.21 2,969 Bungalow 08-20-30-429-032 463 COOLIDGE HWY 12/29/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $370,000 $196,450 53.09 $98.16 1,269 Bungalow 08-20-30-451-010 2220 BUCKINGHAM AVE 8/23/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,745,000 $780,660 44.74 $350.63 3,978 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-451-014 2005 DORCHESTER RD 5/11/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,250,000 $554,850 44.39 $323.11 3,066 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-452-006 2400 BUCKINGHAM AVE 1/10/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $395,000 $199,220 50.44 $97.72 934 Ranch 08-20-30-452-009 2460 BUCKINGHAM AVE 6/8/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $389,900 $205,050 52.59 $74.53 1,097 Ranch 08-20-30-453-002 2042 DORCHESTER RD 9/8/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,285,000 $695,000 54.09 $248.22 3,666 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-453-007 2160 DORCHESTER RD 10/21/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $450,000 $266,160 59.15 $52.24 1,462 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-453-008 2194 DORCHESTER RD 10/13/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $510,000 $238,270 46.72 $104.33 1,299 Ranch 08-20-30-453-013 2043 YORKSHIRE RD 12/22/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,650,000 $881,060 53.40 $317.58 4,019 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-453-014 2057 YORKSHIRE RD 2/11/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,590,000 $720,010 45.28 $302.19 3,995 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-454-009 2546 DORCHESTER RD 7/19/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $575,000 $255,210 44.38 $158.33 1,252 Ranch 08-20-30-454-014 2379 YORKSHIRE RD 6/30/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,580,000 $714,160 45.20 $318.48 3,759 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-456-001 2324 YORKSHIRE RD 8/10/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,710,000 $820,780 48.00 $322.09 4,149 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-456-008 2510 YORKSHIRE RD 5/17/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $690,000 $316,500 45.87 $142.77 2,216 Bungalow 08-20-30-476-020 2647 DORCHESTER RD 2/20/2025 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,465,000 $717,750 48.99 $347.36 3,345 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-476-022 2681 DORCHESTER RD 8/27/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,150,000 $644,380 56.03 $246.40 3,423 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-476-032 2851 DORCHESTER RD 4/26/2023 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $450,000 $243,350 54.08 $97.67 1,480 Bungalow 08-20-30-477-009 2760 DORCHESTER RD 10/15/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,349,000 $695,560 51.56 $302.34 3,453 Colonial/2Sty 08-20-30-477-015 2896 DORCHESTER RD 6/19/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $330,000 $183,280 55.54 $63.14 970 Ranch 08-20-30-478-001 2614 YORKSHIRE RD 10/30/2024 401 03-ARM'S LENGTH 30U $1,950,000 $873,940 44.82 $333.28 4,716 Colonial/2Sty 6 Last saved: 02-13-24 9:25:44 AM 24
Page 24
91-99% 81-90% 71-80% 61-70% 51-60% 0-50% Total Parcels 91-99% 81-90% 71-80% 61-70% 51-60% 0-50% Total Parcels Current ECF 1.465 1.380 1.210 1.560 1.420 1.350 196 1.305 1.305 1.305 1.305 1.305 1.305 205 New ECF 1.465 1.435 1.160 1.410 1.320 1.135 1.035 1.035 1.035 1.035 1.035 1.035 91-99% 81-90% 71-80% 61-70% 51-60% 0-50% Total Parcels 91-99% 81-90% 71-80% 61-70% 51-60% 0-50% Total Parcels Current ECF 1.025 1.025 1.025 1.025 1.025 1.025 210 0 0.835 0.835 0.835 0.835 0.835 0.835 Reason/Notes 91-99% 81-90% 71-80% 61-70% 51-60% 0-50% Total Parcels Current ECF 0.950 0.950 0.950 0.950 0.950 0.950 3 0.795 0.795 0.795 0.795 0.795 0.795 17% Reason/Notes Tri-Level/Quad 30U Colonial Bungalow Ranch Town Home Land Move = 22
Page 25
City of Birmingham Land Table Land Table 30U Color Key Parcel Count 617 # of Sales 59 Vacant Sales ECF Nbhd 30U, MEX Sales Ratio 48.34% Min ECF 0.950 (Land Resid.-Est. Land Value)/Est. LV 9.04% Max ECF 1.560 % Change 17.50% Land Table LtoB 46.94% Projected Land Table LtoB 55.15% CVT LtoB 46.92% Sales Sample Size 9.56% OLD RATE CALC'D RATE USED RATE MEDIAN $414,752 $452,249 $487,334 MINIMUM $257,934 $281,254 $303,072 MAXIMUM $2,343,030 $2,554,862 $2,753,060 Parcel Number Street Address Sale Date Sale Price Cur. Appraisal Land Residual Est. Land Value Total Acres Dollars/Acre Other Parcels in Sale Land Table Land to Building 08-20-30-101-029 811 NORWICH RD 10/06/23 $365,000 $439,654 $277,885 $352,539 0.28 $996,004 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 80.19% 08-20-30-176-014 1921 DERBY RD 12/18/24 $442,000 $434,001 $325,982 $317,983 0.27 $1,207,341 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 73.27% 08-20-30-327-012 1845 PEMBROKE RD 05/31/23 $425,000 $481,489 $294,481 $350,970 0.26 $1,132,619 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 72.89% 08-20-30-401-002 2032 DERBY RD 09/27/23 $465,000 $432,254 $290,680 $257,934 0.15 $1,937,867 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 59.67% 08-20-30-401-016 2288 DERBY RD 05/15/23 $443,500 $398,712 $302,722 $257,934 0.16 $1,903,912 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 64.69% 08-20-30-401-021 2093 PEMBROKE RD 04/15/24 $380,000 0.16 $2,360,248 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams #DIV/0! 08-20-30-401-028 2205 PEMBROKE RD 06/26/24 $425,830 $407,441 $276,323 $257,934 0.16 $1,716,292 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 63.31% 08-20-30-403-004 2378 PEMBROKE RD 09/07/23 $715,500 $585,384 $388,050 $257,934 0.17 $2,269,298 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 44.06% 08-20-30-403-008 2440 PEMBROKE RD 10/23/24 $1,550,000 $1,233,360 $574,574 $257,934 0.17 $3,360,082 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 20.91% 08-20-30-403-009 2456 PEMBROKE RD 05/11/23 $380,000 $398,301 $239,633 $257,934 0.17 $1,401,363 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 64.76% 08-20-30-403-031 2571 MANCHESTER RD 09/12/23 $400,000 $428,166 $229,768 $257,934 0.17 $1,343,673 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 60.24% 08-20-30-404-004 2078 MANCHESTER RD 07/12/24 $1,450,000 $1,562,892 $145,042 $257,934 0.17 $848,199 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 16.50% 08-20-30-404-009 2168 MANCHESTER RD 05/15/24 $1,347,000 $1,305,075 $299,859 $257,934 0.17 $1,753,561 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 19.76% 08-20-30-404-024 2139 WINDEMERE RD 04/12/24 $414,900 $421,680 $251,154 $257,934 0.17 $1,468,737 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 61.17% 08-20-30-404-027 2193 WINDEMERE RD 07/21/23 $735,000 $711,941 $280,993 $257,934 0.17 $1,643,234 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 36.23% 08-20-30-405-001 2314 MANCHESTER RD 02/09/23 $326,500 $371,354 $213,080 $257,934 0.20 $1,081,624 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 69.46% 08-20-30-405-018 2335 WINDEMERE RD 05/15/23 $965,000 $952,962 $269,972 $257,934 0.17 $1,578,784 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 27.07% 08-20-30-405-027 2497 WINDEMERE RD 12/16/24 $350,000 $390,903 $217,031 $257,934 0.17 $1,269,187 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 65.98% 08-20-30-406-027 2471 BUCKINGHAM AVE 05/23/23 $1,358,000 $1,450,504 $165,430 $257,934 0.16 $1,008,720 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 17.78% 08-20-30-406-032 2577 BUCKINGHAM AVE 09/25/23 $451,215 $361,203 $347,946 $257,934 0.16 $2,121,622 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 71.41% 08-20-30-426-003 2350 DERBY RD 10/24/24 $380,000 $404,941 $232,993 $257,934 0.15 $1,574,277 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 63.70% 08-20-30-426-021 2662 DERBY RD 04/11/24 $490,000 $427,670 $320,264 $257,934 0.15 $2,193,589 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 60.31% 08-20-30-426-023 2706 DERBY RD 09/08/23 $365,000 $394,348 $228,586 $257,934 0.15 $1,565,658 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 65.41% 08-20-30-426-029 2802 DERBY RD 02/14/24 $695,000 $680,296 $272,638 $257,934 0.15 $1,867,384 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 37.91% 08-20-30-426-031 2313 PEMBROKE RD 08/17/23 $502,000 $430,627 $329,307 $257,934 0.19 $1,780,038 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 59.90% 08-20-30-426-039 2457 PEMBROKE RD 08/28/23 $430,000 $443,240 $244,694 $257,934 0.16 $1,519,839 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 58.19% 08-20-30-426-049 2647 PEMBROKE RD 05/06/24 $570,000 $488,499 $339,435 $257,934 0.15 $2,233,125 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 52.80% 08-20-30-427-004 2666 PEMBROKE RD 06/05/24 $495,000 $442,509 $310,425 $257,934 0.16 $1,928,106 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 58.29% 08-20-30-427-009 2762 PEMBROKE RD 08/11/23 $580,000 $554,760 $283,174 $257,934 0.16 $1,758,845 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 46.49% 08-20-30-427-012 2806 PEMBROKE RD 08/15/24 $430,000 $437,372 $250,562 $257,934 0.16 $1,556,286 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 58.97% 08-20-30-427-020 2713 MANCHESTER RD 11/14/23 $350,000 0.16 $2,173,913 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams #DIV/0! 08-20-30-428-004 2668 MANCHESTER RD 10/19/23 $1,120,000 $1,258,844 $119,090 $257,934 0.16 $739,689 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 20.49% 08-20-30-428-010 2786 MANCHESTER RD 10/17/24 $475,000 $431,913 $301,021 $257,934 0.16 $1,869,696 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 59.72% 08-20-30-428-012 2810 MANCHESTER RD 07/31/23 $510,000 $496,831 $271,103 $257,934 0.16 $1,683,870 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 51.92% 08-20-30-428-031 657 COOLIDGE HWY 09/15/23 $310,000 $359,382 $156,965 $206,347 0.15 $1,039,503 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 57.42% 08-20-30-429-014 2850 WINDEMERE RD 10/25/24 $420,000 $415,457 $262,477 $257,934 0.15 $1,704,396 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 62.08% 08-20-30-429-016 2623 BUCKINGHAM AVE 05/10/23 $657,000 $590,516 $324,418 $257,934 0.16 $1,978,159 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 43.68% 08-20-30-429-031 497 COOLIDGE HWY 06/14/24 $260,000 $329,499 $136,848 $206,347 0.13 $1,028,932 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 62.62% 08-20-30-429-032 463 COOLIDGE HWY 12/29/23 $370,000 $391,524 $184,823 $206,347 0.16 $1,192,406 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 52.70% 08-20-30-451-010 2220 BUCKINGHAM AVE 04/25/24 $1,745,000 $1,476,098 $553,681 $284,779 0.21 $2,687,772 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 19.29% 08-20-30-451-014 2005 DORCHESTER RD 05/11/24 $1,250,000 $1,068,934 $400,310 $219,244 0.18 $2,187,486 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 20.51% 08-20-30-452-009 2460 BUCKINGHAM AVE 06/08/23 $389,900 $383,175 $264,659 $257,934 0.17 $1,547,713 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 67.31% 08-20-30-453-002 2042 DORCHESTER RD 09/08/23 $1,285,000 $1,273,967 $329,016 $317,983 0.22 $1,502,356 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 24.96% 08-20-30-453-004 2098 DORCHESTER RD 03/30/23 $1,560,000 $1,665,867 $212,116 $317,983 0.22 $968,566 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 19.09% BSA DATABASE SALES DATA Demo Sales or New Build after sale 616, 100% 1, 0% Parcel Count by ECF 30U 1.56 MEX 0 ECF ECF- Sum of Parcel Count Land Table Page 10 of 86 25
Page 26
City of Birmingham Land Table Land Table 30U 08-20-30-453-007 2160 DORCHESTER RD 10/21/24 $450,000 $502,294 $265,689 $317,983 0.22 $1,207,677 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 63.31% 08-20-30-453-008 2194 DORCHESTER RD 10/13/23 $510,000 $439,795 $388,188 $317,983 0.22 $1,764,491 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 72.30% 08-20-30-453-013 2043 YORKSHIRE RD 12/22/23 $1,650,000 $1,659,980 $308,003 $317,983 0.26 $1,198,455 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 19.16% 08-20-30-454-009 2546 DORCHESTER RD 07/19/24 $575,000 $480,571 $412,412 $317,983 0.22 $1,841,125 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 66.17% 08-20-30-454-014 2379 YORKSHIRE RD 06/30/23 $1,580,000 $1,343,738 $554,245 $317,983 0.26 $2,156,595 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 23.66% 08-20-30-455-001 2020 YORKSHIRE RD 11/03/23 $400,000 $408,031 $262,255 $270,286 0.25 $1,057,480 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 66.24% 08-20-30-456-001 2324 YORKSHIRE RD 08/10/23 $1,710,000 $1,546,329 $481,654 $317,983 0.26 $1,874,140 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 20.56% 08-20-30-456-008 2510 YORKSHIRE RD 05/17/24 $690,000 $637,366 $370,617 $317,983 0.26 $1,442,089 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 49.89% 08-20-30-476-008 2756 BUCKINGHAM AVE 07/15/24 $400,000 $472,074 $185,860 $257,934 0.16 $1,154,410 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 54.64% 08-20-30-476-022 2681 DORCHESTER RD 08/27/24 $1,150,000 $1,176,873 $231,061 $257,934 0.16 $1,435,161 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 21.92% 08-20-30-476-032 2851 DORCHESTER RD 04/26/23 $450,000 $483,011 $224,923 $257,934 0.16 $1,423,563 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 53.40% 08-20-30-477-002 2630 DORCHESTER RD 12/18/24 $310,000 $370,984 $196,950 $257,934 0.16 $1,223,292 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 69.53% 08-20-30-477-009 2760 DORCHESTER RD 10/15/24 $1,349,000 $1,308,844 $298,090 $257,934 0.16 $1,817,622 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 19.71% 08-20-30-477-015 2896 DORCHESTER RD 06/19/24 $330,000 $326,354 $231,469 $227,823 0.20 $1,134,652 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 69.81% 08-20-30-478-001 2614 YORKSHIRE RD 10/30/24 $1,950,000 $1,643,323 $624,660 $317,983 0.26 $2,430,584 Land Table 30U N Maple, E Adams 19.35% Page 11 of 86 26
Page 27
Market Area Characteristics City of Birmingham: The subject property is located within the city of Birmingham, which is in Oakland County, Michigan. Oakland County is considered part of the Detroit metropolitan area, located northwest of Detroit. As of the 2020 Census, the County’s population was approximately 1,275,000, making it the second-most populous county in the state, behind neighboring Wayne County. In 2023, Oakland County had a total population of 1,270,880, a slight decrease from the 2020 Census count of 1,274,395, reflecting an annual population change rate of 0.00% since 2020. Similarly, Birmingham experienced a slight decrease, with its 2023 population reaching 21,612, compared to 21,813 in 2020, representing an annual population change of 0.58% since 2020. The city of Birmingham is located about 21 miles north of Detroit and covers an area of approximately 4.8 square miles. The residential areas are characterized by a mix of architectural styles, from classic colonial and Tudor homes to contemporary designs. Birmingham also features a downtown area with a mix of boutiques, restaurants, cafes, and cultural attractions. The city also has a range of recreational amenities, including parks, a public library, and community events. Birmingham has a median housing value in 2025 of $698,300, which represents a growth rate of 39.4% since 2010. Additionally, the median household income in 2025 was $153,510, demonstrating a 7.9% rise since 2010. Birmingham maintains a local school system (Birmingham City School District) and provides various public services. The city's location within the Detroit metropolitan area provides residents with access to major highways such as I-75 and Woodward allowing access to nearby cities such as Detroit, Ferndale, and Pontiac. 27
Page 28
2850 WINDEMERE Road, Birmingham 48009-7523 MLS#: 20240053236 Area: 02192 - Birmingham Short Sale: No P Type: Residential DOM: N/32/32 Trans Type: Sale Status: Sold ERTS/FS LP: $429,900 OLP: $459,900 SP: $420,000 Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 2.0 Acreage: 0.15 City: Birmingham Grg Sz: 2 Car Lot Dim: 47.00 x 143.00 Mailing City: Birmingham Grg Dim: Rd Front Ft: 47 Side of Str: Grg Feat: Electricity, Door Opener, Detached School Dist: Birmingham Location: Maple & Eton Directions: East off Eton or west off Coolidge onto Windemere (north of Maple) Square Footage Layout Contact Information Sqft Source: Public Records Beds: 3 Name: DONNA BARLOW Est Fin Abv Gr: 1,272 Baths: 2.0 Phone: (248) 640-0744 Est Fin Lower: Rooms: 6 Est Tot Lower: 999 Arch Sty: Bungalow Est Tot Fin: 1,272 Arch Lvl: 1 1/2 Story Price/SqFt: $337.97 Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Wtrfrnt Name: Year Built: 1951 Water Facilities: Year Remod: Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Listing Date: 09/06/2024 List Type/Level Of Service:Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 09/06/2024 Srvcs Offered: Arrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 10/08/2024 Off Mkt Date: 10/08/2024 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 180 Days Restrictions: Exclusions: Possession: Negotiable Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20240053236 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: Yes Entry Location: Ground Level Foundation: Basement Fndtn Material: Poured Basement: Unfinished Exterior Feat: Lighting, Fenced Exterior: Aluminum, Brick Cnstrct Feat: Fireplc Fuel: Natural Fireplace Loc: Living Room Porch Type: Deck, Porch Out Buildings: Fencing: Back Yard, Fenced Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Free-Standing Gas Range, Free-Standing Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Wtr Htr Fuel: Natural Gas Road: Paved Water Source: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Flooring Bath - Full First/Entry Bath - Full Second Bedroom First/Entry 8 x 12 Carpet Bedroom First/Entry 11 x 12 Carpet Bedroom - Primary Second 11 x 19 Carpet Dining Room First/Entry 9 x 11 Wood Kitchen First/Entry 8 x 9 Wood Living Room First/Entry 11 x 18 Wood Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 2030429014 Subdivision: PEMBROOK MANOR SUB - BIRMINGHAM Ownership: Standard (Private) Occupant: Owner Tax Summer: $4,465 Tax Winter: $1,182 Homestead: No Oth/Sp Asmnt:0.00 SEV: $170,810 Taxable Value: $109,590 Existing Lease: No Home Warranty:No Legal Desc: T2N, R11E, SEC 30 PEMBROOK MANOR SUB LOT 214 Agent/Office Information List Office: Signature Sotheby's International Realty Bham List Office Ph:(248) 644-7000 List Agent: DONNA M BARLOW List Agent Ph:(248) 640-0744 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox LB Location: Remarks Public Remarks: A great opportunity to move into Pembrook Manor Sub and enjoy Pembroke Park, tennis courts and Birmingham schools and convenient shopping. This lovely 3-bedroom, 2 full bath home has lots to offer. The beautiful, refinished hardwood floors and freshly painted rooms add to the beauty of this home for its new owner. The kitchen has been redone, formal dining room, fireplace in living room, partially updated first floor bath and full new bath in primary bedroom upstairs. The primary bedroom has walk-in closet and loads of storage. The deck off the dining room leads to a large partially fenced rear yard and newer driveway. Updated landscaping, power washing, partially finished basement, 2 car garage. This one won’t last long. BATVAI REALTOR® Remarks: Sold Information Sold Date: 10/28/24 Sold Price: $420,000 Short Sale: No SP/LP:97.70% 3rd Party Appr: Finance Code: CONV Sale SP/SqFt Abv: $330 SP/OLP:91.32% Selling Office: DOBI Real Estate Selling Office Ph:(248) 385-3350 Selling Agent: Jaimie Seitz Selling Agent Ph:(707) 499-3345 Co-Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agt Ph: Sell Concessions: Yes Seller's Closing Concession Amounts Closing Cost Concessions: Financing Cost Concessions: Professional Fee Concessions: (other than broker commissions) Property Improvement Cost Concessions: Sell Concession Comments: 28
Page 29
Other Closing Concession Costs: (other than broker commissions) SELLER'S TOTAL CLOSING CONCESSIONS AMOUNT: $10,000 Notices and Disclaimers 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker compensation; (ii) disclose broker compensation; (iii) represent brokerage services are free or available at no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be received; or (iv) make any concession limited to or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative. ANY DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP II LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. 2. Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3. The accuracy of all information transmitted herewith, regardless of source, though deemed reliable, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Copyright© Realcomp II Ltd All Rights Reserved. Living Room with fireplace Another view of living room with large window Dining Room with doorwall to deck Kitchen Gas stove and ss appliances Dining Room Another view of Dining room Beautiful granite countertops/kitchen Refrig built in - kitchen Hallway first floor 1st flr rear bedroom #1 29
Page 30
1st Flr 2nd Bedroom 1st Floor Main Bath 1st Floor Main Bath w/tub Primary Bedroom 2nd flr Another view of Primary Bedroom Walk in closet in Primary bedroom Additional storage in Primary Bedroom Full shower bath in Primary suite Primary Bath suite Lower level finished basement New flooring in lower level Large family room entertaining in lower level 30
Page 31
Built in Bar in lower level/refrig Bar in lower level Laundry room in lower level Side door driveway entrance 2 1/2 car garage Deck off of Dining Room Rear Deck Another view of rear yard Rear of home Partially fenced Large rear yard Rear of home Front of home 31
Page 32
2109 Dorchester, Birmingham 48009 MLS#: 20251025630 Area: 02192 - Birmingham Short Sale: No P Type: Residential DOM: N/22/22 Trans Type: Lease Status: Sold ERTL/FS LP: $2,600 OLP: $2,650 SP: $2,500 Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 2.0 Acreage: 0.17 City: Birmingham Grg Sz: 2 Car Lot Dim: 50 x 149 Mailing City: Birmingham Grg Dim: Rd Front Ft: 50 Side of Str: N Grg Feat: Direct Access, Electricity, Door Opener, Detached School Dist: Birmingham Location: Maple & Eton Directions: North of Maple & East off Eton Square Footage Layout Contact Information Sqft Source: Public Records Beds: 3 Name: PATRICK CAROLAN Est Fin Abv Gr: 1,221 Baths: 3.0 Phone: (248) 342-7653 Est Fin Lower: 510 Rooms: 7 Est Tot Lower: 855 Arch Sty: Bungalow Est Tot Fin: 1,731 Arch Lvl: 1 1/2 Story Price/SqFt: $2.13 Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Wtrfrnt Name: Year Built: 1946 Water Facilities: Year Remod: Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Listing Date: 08/09/2025 List Type/Level Of Service:Exclusive Right To Lease/Full Service Activation Date: 08/11/2025 Srvcs Offered: Arrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 09/10/2025 Off Mkt Date: 09/10/2025 BMK Date: 09/05/2025 Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 180 Restrictions: Exclusions: Possession: At Close Terms Offered: Lease MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20251025630 Listing Exemptions: Lease Information Application Fee: $40.00 Security Deposit: 3,975.00 Additional Fees: $195.00 Terms Offrd: Lease Lease Type: Single Family House Smoking Allowed: Lease Length: 12 Months, 13-24 Months, 25-36 Months Parking: Rent Includes: Trash Collection Includes: Tenant Amen: Spec Policies: **No Pets** Features Pets Allowed: No Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation: Basement Fndtn Material: Block Basement: Finished Exterior: Brick Cnstrct Feat: Fireplc Fuel: Fireplace Loc: Living Room Porch Type: Patio, Porch Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Free-Standing Electric Range, Free-Standing Refrigerator, Microwave, Washer Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Wtr Htr Fuel: Road: Paved Water Source: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Flooring Bath - Full Basement Ceramic Bath - Full First/Entry Ceramic Bath - Primary Second Ceramic Bedroom First/Entry 10 x 8 Wood Bedroom First/Entry 12 x 9 Wood Bedroom - Primary Second 23 x 15 Wood Dining Room First/Entry 11 x 8 Wood Game Room Basement 17 x 13 Carpet Kitchen First/Entry 10 x 8 Ceramic Living Room First/Entry 16 x 11 Wood Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 2030451018 Subdivision: Pembrook Manor- Birmingham Ownership: Standard (Private) Occupant: Vacant Tax Summer: $0 Tax Winter: Homestead: Oth/Sp Asmnt: SEV: Taxable Value: Existing Lease: No Home Warranty: Legal Desc: T2N, R11E, SEC 30 PEMBROOK MANOR SUB LOT 71 Agent/Office Information List Office: Coldwell Banker Professionals-Birm List Office Ph:(248) 644-6300 List Agent: PATRICK K CAROLAN List Agent Ph:(248) 342-7653 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox LB Location:Front Door Remarks Public Remarks: SHARP & CLEAN BIRMINGHAM 3 BEDROOM/3 FULL BATH BUNGALOW - COVED CEILINGS, HARDWOOD FLOORS, BAY WINDOWS, GREAT LOCATION NEAR "PEMBROKE PARK" - TWO CAR GARAGE - MASTER BEDROOM W/PRIVATE BATH, MANY BUILT IN'S, AND SECRET BONUS ROOM/CLOSET - GORGEOUS LIVING ROOM W/FIREPLACE - KITCHEN WITH S/S APPLIANCES - BEAUTIFUL BRICK PAVER PATIO - FINISHED BASEMENT W/FULL BATH - THREE BATHS, ONE FULL BATH ON EACH LEVEL - OWNERS RENTING REQUIREMENTS: MUST HAVE YEARLY INCOME OF $90,000 OR MORE, CREDIT SCORE OF 720 OR HIGHER, CLEAN BACKGROUND CHECK, ONLINE RENTSPREE APPLICATION SERVICE $40 FOR EACH ADULT APPLICANT - NO PETS ALLOWED/BACKYARD NOT FENCED IN - THIS ONE WON'T LAST LONG, IT IS A REALLY NICE RENTAL PROPERTY! REALTOR® Remarks: Sold Information Sold Date: 10/31/25 Sold Price: $2,500 Short Sale: No SP/LP:96.15% 3rd Party Appr: No Finance Code: Lease SP/SqFt Abv: $2 SP/OLP:94.34% Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Professionals-Birm Selling Office Ph:(248) 644-6300 Selling Agent: Patrick K Carolan Selling Agent Ph:(248) 342-7653 32
Page 33
Co-Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agt Ph: Sell Concessions: Sell Concession Comments: Notices and Disclaimers 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker compensation; (ii) disclose broker compensation; (iii) represent brokerage services are free or available at no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be received; or (iv) make any concession limited to or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative. ANY DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP II LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. 2. Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3. The accuracy of all information transmitted herewith, regardless of source, though deemed reliable, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Copyright© Realcomp II Ltd All Rights Reserved. 33
Page 34
34 HE | - 4 \d RE par bel i ho Jad cry ds iy isaca) 34
Page 35
2626 Pembroke Road, Birmingham 48009-5830 MLS#: 20250030447 Area: 02192 - Birmingham Short Sale: No P Type: Residential DOM: N/4/4 Trans Type: Sale Status: Sold ERTS/FS LP: $475,000 OLP: $475,000 SP: $485,000 Location Information Garage: No Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: Acreage: 0.16 City: Birmingham Grg Sz: No Garage Lot Dim: 47.00 x 149.00 Mailing City: Birmingham Grg Dim: Rd Front Ft: 47 Side of Str: S Grg Feat: School Dist: Birmingham Location: Maple and Coolidge Directions: N Maple, W Coolidge Square Footage Layout Contact Information Sqft Source: Public Records Beds: 3 Name: COREY LIGHT Est Fin Abv Gr: 1,456 Baths: 2.1 Phone: (248) 207-5544 Est Fin Lower: 750 Rooms: 7 Est Tot Lower: 938 Arch Sty: Bungalow Est Tot Fin: 2,206 Arch Lvl: 1 1/2 Story Price/SqFt: $326.24 Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Wtrfrnt Name: Year Built: 1951 Water Facilities: Year Remod: Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Listing Date: 05/01/2025 List Type/Level Of Service:Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 05/01/2025 Srvcs Offered: Arrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 05/12/2025 Off Mkt Date: 05/12/2025 BMK Date: Contingency Date: ABO Date: 05/05/2025 Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 90 Restrictions: Exclusions: No Possession: Close Plus 6-15 Days Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20250030447 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation: Basement Fndtn Material: Poured Basement: Partially Finished Exterior Feat: Fenced Exterior: Aluminum, Brick, Vinyl Cnstrct Feat: Fireplc Fuel: Gas Fireplace Loc: Living Room Porch Type: Deck, Patio, Porch Roof Material: Asphalt Out Buildings: Shed Fencing: Fenced Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Free-Standing Electric Range, Free-Standing Refrigerator, Washer Interior Feat: Furnished - Negotiable Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Wtr Htr Fuel: Natural Gas Road: Paved Water Source: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Flooring Bath - Full First/Entry 7 x 7 Ceramic Bath - Full First/Entry 5 x 8 Ceramic Bath - Lav Basement 3 x 6 Ceramic Bedroom Second 12 x 13 Carpet Bedroom First/Entry 11 x 12 Wood Bedroom First/Entry 9 x 12 Wood Dining Room First/Entry 8 x 11 Wood Family Room First/Entry 13 x 14 Wood Kitchen First/Entry 10 x 11 Wood Living Room First/Entry 12 x 18 Wood Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 2030427002 Subdivision: PEMBROOK MANOR SUB - BIRMINGHAM Ownership: Standard (Private) Occupant: Vacant Tax Summer: $5,913 Tax Winter: $725 Homestead: Yes Oth/Sp Asmnt:0.00 SEV: $188,040 Taxable Value: $173,600 Existing Lease: No Home Warranty:No Legal Desc: T2N, R11E, SEC 30 PEMBROOK MANOR SUB LOT 386 Agent/Office Information List Office: @properties Christie's Int'l R.E. Birmingham List Office Ph:(248) 850-8632 List Agent: COREY LIGHT List Agent Ph:(248) 207-5544 Co-list Agent: PIERRE G BINANDEH Co-List Agent Ph:(248) 787-9200 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox LB Location:Front Door Remarks Public Remarks: ** OFFER DEADLINE - MONDAY MAY 5TH AT 1PM** Welcome to this beautifully maintained and updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offering nearly 1,500 square feet of comfortable living space plus a finished basement. This house is on a great street in Birmingham, centrally located close to downtown Birmingham, Somerset Mall, Target, Whole Foods and tons of parks. Step inside to find a warm and inviting living room with a beautiful fireplace, and refinished hardwood floors throughout. The kitchen features warm and rich wood cabinetry, sleek stainless steel appliances, and granite countertops — ideal for any home chef. The family room is light and bright with lots of windows. There are 2 bedrooms and 2 fully updated full bathrooms to finish off the main level. The spacious primary bedroom has a large walk-in closet, something you rarely see in a bungalow. The fully finished basement is an entertainer’s dream — complete with a built-in bar and a convenient half bath, perfect for game nights or hosting guests. Outside, enjoy your morning coffee or evening BBQ on the low-maintenance composite deck or paver patio overlooking the large, gorgeously landscaped and fenced-in backyard — offering plenty of space for pets, play, or entertaining. Don’t miss your chance to make this warm and welcoming house your new home! BATVAI REALTOR® Remarks: Sold Information Sold Date: 06/03/25 Sold Price: $485,000 Short Sale: No SP/LP:102.11% 3rd Party Appr: No Finance Code: CONV Sale SP/SqFt Abv: $333 SP/OLP:102.11% Selling Office: RE/MAX Leading Edge Selling Office Ph:(734) 404-8800 Selling Agent: Ryan E Kain Selling Agent Ph:(313) 277-7777 Co-Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agt Ph: Sell Concessions: Yes Seller's Closing Concession Amounts 35
Page 36
Closing Cost Concessions: $2,500 Financing Cost Concessions: Professional Fee Concessions: (other than broker commissions) Property Improvement Cost Concessions: Other Closing Concession Costs: (other than broker commissions) SE ER'S TOT C OSING CONCESSIONS MOUNT Sell Concession Comments: Notices and Disclaimers 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker compensation; (ii) disclose broker compensation; (iii) represent brokerage services are free or available at no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be received; or (iv) make any concession limited to or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative. ANY DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP II LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. 2. Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3. The accuracy of all information transmitted herewith, regardless of source, though deemed reliable, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Copyright© Realcomp II Ltd All Rights Reserved. 36
Page 37
37 — - h =| | ZS Tr 9 123 | IN Ll BT a ed Ny = Nay 8 | ml = m wives |& a = = | | Ee ror 5 Oa oe : es ee | 27 | & Ww »| BE All } - . > ii | i go 4 ~ UE tn 36 ———— | - ~~ “i om _— - vj — To——— | NR Elke "| Il Jul Jol dab WE Sosisaias Crass Cates 11 42 37
Page 38
38
y 1
Ll
|
au
lk
\ Lo
ype
oy
Ll
|
_—
In EE
s
|
|
LLL
If
—
Be
\
«®
®
-
4
TN
CE)
>
,
ae M
po
—y,
|
Bo
rey
h
—
4
Jil
Sa |
a
i
Healy
{k
|
=r
|
LE
|
KH
n
pre
a
|
38Page 39
39 - 8 —~—— C1 R en Fmt [ oo Vo “4 - | WR = FE Nn, se BE 39
Page 40
2209 WINDEMERE Road, Birmingham 48009-7517 MLS#: 20250016015 Area: 02192 - Birmingham Short Sale: No P Type: Residential DOM: N/4/4 Trans Type: Sale Status: Sold ERTS/FS LP: $549,000 OLP: $549,000 SP: $550,000 Location Information Garage: Yes Lot Information County: Oakland Tot Grg Sp: 2.5 Acreage: 0.17 City: Birmingham Grg Sz: 2.5 Car Lot Dim: 50.00 x 149.00 Mailing City: Birmingham Grg Dim: Rd Front Ft: 50 Side of Str: N Grg Feat: Detached, Garage Faces Front School Dist: Birmingham Location: Maple and Eaton Directions: Maple Road, North on Eton, Right on Windemere Square Footage Layout Contact Information Sqft Source: Public Records Beds: 3 Name: RONNA SCHMERIN Est Fin Abv Gr: 1,595 Baths: 2.0 Phone: (248) 505-0111 Est Fin Lower: Rooms: 7 Est Tot Lower: 867 Arch Sty: Bungalow Est Tot Fin: 1,595 Arch Lvl: 2 Story Price/SqFt: $344.2 Site Desc: Waterfront Information General Information Wtrfrnt Name: Year Built: 1948 Water Facilities: Year Remod: 2000 Water Features: Water Frt Feet: Listing Information Listing Date: 04/02/2025 List Type/Level Of Service:Exclusive Right to Sell/Full Service Activation Date: 04/03/2025 Srvcs Offered: Arrange Appointments, Accept/Present Offers, Advise on Offers, Assist with Counteroffers, Negotiate for Seller Pending Date: 04/04/2025 Off Mkt Date: 04/04/2025 BMK Date: Contingency Date: Land DWP: Land Int Rate: % Land Payment: Land Cntrt Term: Protect Period: 180 Restrictions: Exclusions: No Possession: Negotiable Terms Offered: Cash, Conventional MLS Source: REALCOMP Originating MLS# 20250016015 Listing Exemptions: Includes: Features Pets Allowed: Yes Entry Location: Ground Level w/Steps Foundation: Basement Fndtn Material: Block Basement: Unfinished Exterior Feat: Chimney Cap(s) Exterior: Brick, Vinyl Cnstrct Feat: Platted Sub. Fireplc Fuel: Gas, Natural Fireplace Loc: Family Room Porch Type: Patio, Porch Roof Material: Asphalt Out Buildings: Fencing: Fence Allowed Appliances: Built-In Electric Range, Built-In Freezer, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Cooktop, Free-Standing Refrigerator, Microwave, Washer Interior Feat: Cable Available, Circuit Breakers, High Spd Internet Avail, Jetted Tub, Furnished - No Heat & Fuel: Natural Gas, Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Wtr Htr Fuel: Natural Gas Road: Paved, Pub. Sidewalk Water Source: Public (Municipal) Sewer: Sewer (Sewer-Sanitary) Room Information Room Level Dimen Flooring Room Level Dimen Flooring Bath - Full First/Entry 6 x 8 Granite Bath - Primary Second 10 x 16 Ceramic Bedroom First/Entry 10 x 11 Wood Bedroom First/Entry 12 x 12 Wood Bedroom - Primary Second 24 x 23 Wood Dining Room First/Entry 8 x 10 Wood Kitchen First/Entry 10 x 11 Wood Laundry Area/Room Basement 10 x 8 Living Room First/Entry 13 x 15 Wood Legal/Tax/Financial Property ID: 2030404028 Subdivision: PEMBROOK MANOR SUB - BIRMINGHAM Ownership: Standard (Private) Occupant: Owner Tax Summer: $6,019 Tax Winter: $738 Homestead: Yes Oth/Sp Asmnt:0.00 SEV: $225,270 Taxable Value: $176,720 Existing Lease: No Home Warranty:No Legal Desc: T2N, R11E, SEC 30 PEMBROOK MANOR SUB LOT 249 Agent/Office Information List Office: Max Broock, REALTORS®-Birmingham List Office Ph:(248) 644-6700 List Agent: RONNA SCHMERIN List Agent Ph:(248) 505-0111 Co-list Agent: ROBIN WELFORD Co-List Agent Ph:(248) 225-5059 Listing Exemptions: Access: Appointment/LockBox LB Location:Front Door Remarks Public Remarks: Welcome to this charming Birmingham home located across the street from Pembroke Park, providing a peaceful green space for you to enjoy. With 1,597 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this property offers the perfect blend of comfort and style. The home features three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, making it an ideal space for families or anyone looking for a peaceful retreat. As you step inside, you are greeted by beautiful hardwood floors that flow throughout the home, adding warmth and elegance to every room. The inviting living room is centered around a cozy fireplace, perfect for relaxing or entertaining guests during colder months. The kitchen has sleek granite countertops along with ample cabinetry and modern appliances. The master bedroom is a true standout, boasting a vaulted ceiling and skylights that flood the space with natural light, creating an airy and open atmosphere. The adjoining master bath is equally impressive, with plenty of space for relaxation and privacy. Situated on a deep lot, the home offers a generous backyard perfect for outdoor activities or simply enjoying the fresh air. Whether you're hosting a family barbecue, taking a stroll in the park, or simply enjoying a quiet evening at home, this property provides the perfect setting. Don’t miss your chance to own this beautiful home in one of Birmingham’s most desirable neighborhoods—schedule your private showing today! REALTOR® Remarks: Sold Information Sold Date: 04/30/25 Sold Price: $550,000 Short Sale: No SP/LP:100.18% 3rd Party Appr: Finance Code: CONV Sale SP/SqFt Abv: $345 SP/OLP:100.18% Selling Office: KW Domain Selling Office Ph:(248) 590-0800 Selling Agent: Gerald Hall Selling Agent Ph:(248) 760-5991 Co-Selling Agent: Co-Selling Agt Ph: 40
Page 41
Sell Concessions: No Sell Concession Comments: Notices and Disclaimers 1. Through this platform, users MUST NOT IN ANY WAY: (i) make offers of broker compensation; (ii) disclose broker compensation; (iii) represent brokerage services are free or available at no cost unless no financial compensation from any source will be received; or (iv) make any concession limited to or conditioned on the retention of or payment to another broker or representative. ANY DISCOVERED VIOLATION OF THE FOREGOING SHOULD BE IMMEDIATELY REPORTED BY THE DISCOVERING PARTY TO REALCOMP II LTD FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. 2. Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. 3. The accuracy of all information transmitted herewith, regardless of source, though deemed reliable, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Copyright© Realcomp II Ltd All Rights Reserved. 41