24-003589.pdf
Judy L Gentner, Petitioner V Township Of Burtchville, Respondent · 24-003589-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
ReCelveD APR 21 2025 MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS ~~ MARLON BROWN. DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Judy L Gentner, Petitioner, MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION v MTT Docket No.: 24-003589 Township Of Burtchville, Respondent. NOTICE OF TELEPHONE HEARING The Tribunal has scheduled a telephone hearing to be conducted as follows. Hearings are generally 30 minutes in length. HEARING DATE: | May 20. 2025 HEARING TIME: | 10:00 AM EST JOIN BY PHONE: | 1-248-509-0316 495507942 ACCESS CODE: This hearing will be held by telephone conference call with the Judge as the host. In order to join the hearing, call the phone number listed above at least 5 minutes prior to the hearing time. You will then be required to input the access code, followed by # to connect. The Tribunal judge will call in and join by phone at the hearing time. Failure to timely call in may result in the placement of a party or parties in default. This is an important legal document. Please have someone translate the document. Este es un documento legal importante. Por favor, haga traducir este documento. Af6 a%fh gFFesyel SRR WT, TE[AT FE (FT WAFL SIT FF | ECV POPPE ALIN PEETE VER PEE ELE PRAT ito ay isang mahalagang legal na dokumento. Mangyari lamang na magkaroon ng isang tao isalin ang dokumento.
Page 2
ATIONER: Judy L. Gentner MT¥ DOCKET NO: 24-003589 2024 ~ BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION APPEAL FOR: 6486 LAKESHORE RD., BURTCHVILLE, MI MIT DOCKET NO: 24-003589
Page 3
1. For full transparency, I bought my home at 6486 Lakeshore Rd, knowing I was paying over market value for it... There were medical reasons for that decision... When I bought my home, I talked to two different real estate agents, the owner who was a real estate agent, [ researched online the assessment and valuations mandates for Michigan and talked to a contractor that works with permits and SEV issues... I was told that the SEV cap would be uncapped and the taxable value would be reset to the SEV that had been determined by the township, on file at the time of purchase... That was not the case... The assessor raised the SEV to the amount that I bought the home for, added the 1.05 inflation rate multiplier and an additional $562.50... The 1.05 inflation multiplier is based on a one-year period of time ~ I was charged that 1.05 multiplier for a one-month period of time... When I asked about the additional $562.50, my question was ignored... When the home at 6500 was purchased, the new SEV was placed at less than what they bought it for... Going by the determined township SEV when I purchased my home November 30, 2023 to what the township raised the SEV to with the 2024 assessment, the SEV is up 11%, for a one-month period of time... 2. I have attached to my appeal a list of homes that sold in 2023 and 2024... I have compared those homes to mine adding or subtracting comparable features of each home... The most comparable home is my home to the home next door to me that sold the year before I bought mine... Both homes have the same lot depth, are the same area, are on the same main road, have the same view, have the same beach and both have sea walls... The home at 6500 has a calculation of $3,706 per foot for land value ~ mine is calculated at $4,806 per foot... The home at 6500 has a house value calculation of $119.70 per sq.ft., mine is calculated at $206.93 per sq. ft My home is brick, 6500 is vinyl, but the Excell sheet shows a calculation for that... For those reasons and the evidence, I have provided, | am appealing this assessment... FIND ATTACHED: An Excell spread sheet with just the comparable to the home that the board accepted as “very comparable”, 6232 Wildrose, and the home that is next store to mine, 6500 Lakeshore... The biggest difference in denominator is the calculation of land value between the 6500 Lakeshore address and my address of 6484 Lakeshore... Both homes have the same view, same lot depth, same beach, both sea walls yet the
Page 4
+ Tam appealing the 2024 Board of Review Decision from Burtchville Township, MI 1 presented to the board multiple comparable and the board chose to focus on the comparable of 6232 Wild Rose, Burtchville Township, MI for their decision. The board’s decision states: “Subject property is assessed uniformly within township, and within range of comparable provided — along with sales prices of comparable. 6232 Wildrose was provided and very comparable. Property sold for $1 million which is more than subject property.” Focusing on 6232 Wildrose comparable that the Burtchville Township Board of Review chose as their “very comparable.” 6232 Wildrose VS differences to 6486 Lakeshore Rd: 6232 Wildrose has: 1,754 more home sq footage 308 more basement sq footage 2 more full bathrooms A walk out basement A finished basement 2 more fireplaces 6-foot wider lot 4 car attached garage vs a 2-car detached garage A hot tub A spa An irrigation system With these items being calculated to a comparison cost level as shown on the Excell sheet, the value of 6486 Lakeshore Rd would be a value of $495,842 When the township board state: “Subject property is assessed uniformly within township, and within range of comparable provided: This is not an accurate statement. The comparable for sq footage, bathrooms, walk out basement, finished basement, lot size, garage size and other features where not taken into consideration. The Burtchville Township board state: “6232 Wildrose was provided and very comparable. Property sold for $1 million which is more than subject property.” You can see from the above list of variables in the 6232 Wildrose address and the 6486 Lakeshore address the homes are not “very comparable”. The homes have to be compared in kind to all of those variables. You can see those on the attach Excell spread sheet. Also submitted to the Board of Review, Burtchville Township, MI is the home, 6500 Lakeshore, that sold next door to the 6486 Lakeshore address. This home is the same location, the same view, the same depth of the lot, the same road. At the time of the review submission, I did not have a comparable on the Excel sheet that I gave them, but I did submit a hand written comparable for the 6500 Lakeshore property. I have since done a more in depth comparable for that home vs the 6486 Lakeshore address: 6500 Lakeshore Rd VS differences to 6486 Lakeshore Rd: 6500 Lakeshore has; 54 more home sq footage 1 more full bathroom
Page 5
’ : _ ~ i _ _ i Zv8's6v$S | 0000ZS- | 000'Z€$- | 0000TS 000°vZ$~ [0000S 0000ZS~ 000'0TS- 8SI'B6ES- oo ‘SAS | GIHOVLLY | SIA SIA 9/0S € INONIVM S pS/T-/00vy i © Nowvomui Lv CT aMsiNe © ; eT — eb ... Q3HSINE EI BT i IR a rT TeT'9TSS | 000'S$- 000'9TS- | 0000TS © 000'v7z$- 000'S$- 000'0Z$- | 000'SS- BLS'ET$- 0 © sAksD3s @aHovLY s3A SIA 95/00 Ino vm bv vs-fooc | CU wsawo oe CT TT Tans sses | TT TT BN To Tr RE Co | Q3HOVLIA © SAA TS RZ I _ RINOSYI Te 9v9z7 f EE A or : a ’ © uwyidd uvd¥ad ) | HLLY-N8S H.LLY-igS | 1004 ¥3d | - 3018d 3$VHOUN 63 HI3IONSS HUIANSS TIVM 0007S 000 ‘s$ 000 ‘0Z$ | 000'SS . ASNOH IAA VAD ~~ IOVEVD 35vavD VES Divi HIGIM | DIVid ININTSVE Hivd | “13°08 NOSTVAINOD 151 TH INOWIVM
Page 6
Michigan Department of Treasury,
1019 (Rev, 11-23)
THIS
IS NOT A TAX BILL
L-4400
Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification
This form is issued under the authority of P.A, 206 of 1893, Sec. 211.24 (¢) and Sec.211.34c, as amended. This is a model assessment notice 10 be used by the local assessor.
FROM: BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR
SHELLY BAUMEISTER
4000 BURTCH ROAD
LAKEPORT, MI 48059
PARCEL IDENTIFICATION
PARCEL NUMBER:
7411-470-0031-000
PROPERTY ADDRESS:
6486 LAKESHORE RD
LAKEPORT, MI 48059-2557
GENTNER, JUDY LYNNE
56373 NICKELBY SOUTH
UTICA Mi 48316
OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS/PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL:
PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION
% Exempt
As "Homeowners Principal Residence":
00%
% Exempt As "Qualified Agricultural Property”:
.00%
% Exempt As "MBT Industrial Personal":
.00%
% Exempt As "MBT Commercial Personal":
.00%
Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property”:
0 Yes
No
Exempt
As "Development Property":
7] Yes
No
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
S1/2 OF LOT 26 EXC S 6' LAKELAND BEACH PLAT QC 1259/524
ACCORDING TO MCL. 211.34¢ THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS:
401
(RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED)
PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION:
401
{RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED)
The change in taxable value will increase/decrease your tax bill for the 2024
PRIOR AMOUNT
GURRENT TENTATIVE
CHANGE FROM
year by approximately:
$11,120
YEAR:
093
AMOUNT YEAR:
2024
JAE
1. TAXABLE VALUE:
222,169
379,500
157,341
2. ASSESSED VALUE:
342,000
379,500
37,500
3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR:
1.000
4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV):
342,000
379,500
37,500
5. There WAS or WAS NOT a transfer of ownership on this property in2023
WAS
6. Assessor Change Reason:
Market Adjustment
The 2024 Inflation rate Multiplier is: 1.05
Questions regarding the Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification may be directed to the Following:
Name:
SHELLY BAUMEISTER
Phone:
(810) 385-8577
Email Address:
SBAUMEISTER@HOTMAIL.COM
March Board of Review Appeal information. The board of review will meet at the following dates and times:
GS MONDAY, MARCHPage 7
FROM BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP 4000 BURTCH ROAD LAKEPORT, MI 48059 NAMEEAND ADDRESS OF OWNER OR PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL 2024 BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION Thank you for attending this yea PROPERTY IS CLA GENTNER, JUDY LYNNE 56373 NICKELBY SOUTH UTICA MI48316 D401 (RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED) (0 compute your assessment and taxable value. PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION: (Pateel Code required. Property address and legal description optional.) 7411-470-003 1-000 6486 LAKESHORE RD S12 OF LOT 26 EXC S 6' LAKELAND BEACH PLAT QC 1259/524 March Board of Review. The Board has reviewed the information you supplied and the data nece The Board has completed their review of parcel number 7411-470-003 1-000 They have made the following determination based on the information you supplied. 2024 ORIGINAL ASSE [2024 "BOARD OF REVIEW" AS SED VALUE 379,500 | SED VALUE 379,500 | (If the above amounts are the same, no revisions have occured) [2024 ORIGINAL TAXABLE VALUE 379,500 | 2024 "BOARD OF REVIEW" TAXABLE VALUE 379.500 J 2024 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION/QUALIFIED AG 100.0000 vicase reel tree to contact the assessor at the address sted above or call if you have any questions. “Liffective March 1, 2013, the Tribunal is no longer initiate a new Small Claims appeal. Petition forms http: www.michigan.gov/1axtrib/0,4677,7-187-38254--- 00. html are available on this website.” able to accept Small Claims letter appeals. Rather, you are required to file a petition to
Page 8
«0 OF REVIEW USE ONLY
UTIONS: Incorporate a copy of this form and the assigned number in the Board of Review minutes.
1 Number’
Parcet Code
87
11-470-0031-000
L
—
1. ASSESSED VALUE
Disposition by Board of Review. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below.
Denied
0
Assessed Value Changed From
[
379,500
ro:
{
Resord of Vote - Board or three member commitfee of board
Chairperson: [3fYes
[7] no AL
Member:
ves
[7] no By;
Member
[DFves
[Tn
£1
Tnifials
Tiitials,
A
Reason for Hoard Adlon: <5; 1 pect
pr oplriy
15 assessed rer
wath
fowaship, ancl
cyl hie rage
OWA
.
N
:
a
3
-
..
Lo)
;
5, <1
cle WC gible
orovicect -olon Auth
Sales pr
S OF cap paerrrales od BY Lill is
brs previckect ye 7g J7
compatable
epaig soled
fey af pill, plore than subject property.
"
-
a
o
an
Tax
1
al
at
Ifyou disagree with the decision of the BSard of Review regarding tentative assessed value, you may appeal that addi by tiithg a petition with the Michigan Tax Tribunal at
#0.8ox
32.
Lansing. Mi. 48909 Commercial Real, Industrial Real, Developmental Real, Commercial Personal, Industrial Personal and Ulility Personal Property may bi
aoneales
1 Agnewiturs! Real, Residential Real. Timber - Cul Over Real, 40d Agricutanal Persona Property may ba appealed by July 31.
The petition must be filed on
|
at
a idichigar:
Tax Fnbunal for or a form approved by the Michigan Tax Tribunal. Michigan Tax Tribunal forms are avaiable at we. michigan govitaxlrib,
i
2, TENTATIVE TAXABLE VALUE
Disposition by Board of Review. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below
[Denied
[7]
Tentative Taxable Valve Changed From:
379,500
To
Record of Vote - Board or three member commas of board.
Chairperson:
[7 ves
[J
NO <=
Member:
[1]
ves
[1
NO mm
Member:
[J
ves
[] no kal
Reason for Board Action
if yeu disagree with the deamsion of the Board of Review regarding tentative taxable value, you may appeal that decision by filing a pelifion with the Michigan Tax Tribunal at
PO Box 30232, Lansing, Mi. 48909 Commercial Real.
industrial Real, Developmental Real. Commercial Personal, Industrial Personal and Utility Personal Property may be
apoeaied by May 31
Agricutlural Real, Residential Real, Timber
- Cut Over Real, and Agricultural Personal Properly may be appealed by July 31
The pelilion must ba led
on a Michigan Tax Tribunal for or a form approved by the Michigan Tax Tribunal. Michigan Tax Tribunat (orms are avaiable al www. michigan. govitaxtrib
3. CLASSIFICATION
ull
|
Disposition by Board of Review. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below.
Oo
Denied
[|
Classification Changed From:
401
To!
Record of Vote
- Board or (hee member commiltes of board
Chairperson:
[[] yes
[J NO“fme
Member
Clves
[J
no
initais
Member:
[1
ves
[1] noms
Reason for Board Action:
ih he decision of the Board of Review regarding classification: appeal 1s maga by sending Form 2167 1 the State Tax Commission PO. Bos 30471, Lansing My 48579 by Jung 30
J
4. QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL PROPERTY EXEMPTION
Disposition by Board of Review, The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below
7
Exemption Request Denied
[]
Exemption percent modified from
%Page 9
Michigan Department of Treasury
618 (Rev. 11-12)
Petition to Board of Review
L.-4035
This form is issued under the authority of P.A. 206 of 1893, as amended. Filing is voluntary, however you may not appeal to the Michigan Tax Tribunal
or the State Tax Commission unless you first protest to the Board of Review.
TO BE COMPLETED BY OWNER OR OWNER'S AGENT
Owner's Name (Please Print af Type)
Petitioner's Name
(If Other than Owner. Please Print or Type)
Sudu
LL, & ETNER
Township or city”
County
.
Portehol\e
cr.Cla@
The undersigned protests the assessed value and/or the tentative taxable value andlor the property classification andlor the qualified
agricultural property exemption of the following described property:
Property Identified (Parcel code required. Property address & legal description optional)
PARCEL MgnHTeo
3 Deo
Hale (ake shxe RA.
Bugtehoille, na
4POS
Protested {tem
[Xf Assessed Value
] Tentative Taxable Value
7 Classification
[] Qualified Agricultural
Property
Exemption
1. PROTEST OF ASSESSMENT
perty
P
(Complete this section for a protest of assessed value and/or tentative taxable value)
ssessed Amount
Owner's Estimate of True Cash Value
Tentative Taxable Value
Year
M3q, boo
#526 a4
224
2. PROTEST OF CLASSIFICATION
(Complete this section for a request to change the classification. The Board of Review must make their decision regarding classification in
accordance with Section 211.34c of the Michigan Compiled Laws. The Board of Review shall not be influenced by the effect that a particular
classification has on that property's status as a homeowner's principal residence or qualified agricultural property.)
Classification of property on this year's assessment roll
Classification should be (check one of the following):
I] Agricultural
1 Industrial
1] Timber Cutover
1 Utility (Personal Property Only)
J Commercial
] Residential
[] Developmental
3. PROTEST OF EXEMPTION FOR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL PROPERTY
(if the assessor has denied or changed the percentage of the exemption from the 18 mills of local school operating tax for qualified agricultural
property, the owner may appeal this action to the March Board of Review. THE BOARD OF REVIEW HAS NO AUTHORITY TO CONSIDER OR ACT
UPON THE EXEMPTION FROM THE 18 SCHOOL OPERATING MILLS FOR HOMEOWNER'S PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE PROPERTIES.)
Percent qualified agriculiural exemption granted by assessor (Enter 0 if exemption
Percent qualified agricultural exemption requested by owner (Enter 100 if full
denied)
exemption requested)
4. REASON FOR PROTEST
State reason(s) for protest of assessed value and/or the tentative taxable value and/or classification and/or qualified agricultural property exemption
&
Qs - phtnched
Serend sheets Photo Comparisons of otha propetndPage 10
| (5oco
Lukeshoe
—
2024
—
tel
Lake dae
HA3BO
Aes...
#959, 000
Fb go
Fomd Value
2) LCR
22390
MNoune Value
Bun 532
“20.93 (20H)
* WXTO (2ne0>
ea Soy Aw
(Soo L-vkes hoe
JS
(L420 Lokeshow
| Arpehed Grrice
25 eae
Deteched GARAGe 2
Wako) Bice mah
| Fovished
«
InkeRlo
2100
=, Cesk
7
BLY DYE
No
moc
[rast Cog
{ 24 aq Leet
Mone Value
lo cde
Ualue
FQ G32.
©3323 \GO
VS
AS eomee Bon 20
Heune
™ WTO 5 & 3,72
JReod Oodue = F220
up
“Se
ay
* 24 p27
F225
oooPage 11
Real Estate Summary Sheet *xxInformation herein deemed refiable but not guaranteed™** 11/30/2023 9:27 AM Parcel: 11-470-0031-000 Current Class: 401.RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED i 1} M 401.RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED OwnersName: TAYLOR CLYDE/SANDRA TRUST tesabie stone TAXABLE Property Address: 6486 LAKESHORE RD LAKEPORT, MI 48059-2557 Prev, Taxable Stat TAXABLE . Gov. Unit: 11 BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP Liber/Page: 4260/849 Created: / / MAP # 471B ite // iver School: 74010 PORT HURON AREA SCHOOL DIST Split: Active; Active Neighborhood: 4470 470 LAKELAND BEACH PLAT Public Imor.: Paved Road, Water, Electric, Gas Topography: Rolling, Waterfront Mailing Address: Description: TAYLOR CLYDE/SANDRA TRUST $1/2 OF LOT 26 EXC S 6' LAKELAND BEACH PLAT QC 1259/524 6486 LAKESHORE LAKEPORT MI 48059 Most Recent Sale Information Sold on 01/26/2012 for 1 by TAYLOR CLYDE/SANDRA. Terms of Sale: 21-NOT USED/OTHER Liber/Page: 4260/849 Most Recent Permit Information Permit 2089 on 12/18/2000 for $115,000 category Building. Physical Property Characteristics 2024 S.E.V.: 342,000 2024 Taxable: 222,159 Lot Dimensions: 2023 S.E.V.: 342,000 2023 Taxable: 222,159 Acreage: 0.31 Zoning: "RA (*) Land Value: 186,879 Frontage: 44.0 PRE: 100.000 Land Impr, Value: 10,894 Average Depth: 309.0 Improvement Data # of Residential Buildings: 1 Year Built: 2001 Occupancy: Single Family Class: BC Style: 2 STORY Exterlor: Brick % Good (Physical): 77 Heating System: Forced Hot Water Electric - Amps Service: 0 # of Bedrooms: 3 Full Baths: 2 Half Baths: 1 Floor Area: 2,646 Ground Area: 1,492 Garage Area: 484 Basement Area: 1,492 Basement Walls:
Page 12
Real Estate Summary Sheet ***nformation herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed™** 03/11/2024 7:41 AM . - - - Current Class: 401.RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED Parcel: 11-470-0033-000 Previous Class: 401.RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED Owner's Name: ~~ AOUN, RANA Taxable Status ~~ TAXABLE Property Address: 6500 LAKESHORE RD LAKEPORT, MI 48059 Prev. Taxable Stat TAXABLE . Gov. Unit: 11 BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP Liber/ Page: 5532/443 Created: / / MAP # 473 00 it: Ii ive: Acti School: 74010 PORT HURON AREA SCHOOL DIST Split Active: Active Neighborhood: 4470 470 LAKELAND BEACH PLAT Public Imor.: Paved Road. Water, Electric, Gas Topography: Rolling, Waterfront Mailing Address: Description: AOUN, RANA N1/2 OF LOT 27 & S 1/2 OF LOT 28 LAKELAND BEACH PLAT 6117 ARGYLE ST DEARBORN MI 48126 Most Recent Sale Information Sold on 06/01/2022 for 695,000 by BUSCH JOHN H ESTATE, Terms of Sale: 03-ARM'S LENGTH Liber/Page: 5532/443 Most Recent Permit Information Permit B03019 on 03/27/2003 for $27,000 category Building. Physical Property Characteristics 2024 S.EV.: 368,800 2024 Taxable: 346,920 Lot Dimensions: 2023 S.E.V.: 330,400 2023 Taxable: 330,400 Acreage: 0.70 Zoning: "R1B (*) Land Value: 370,650 Frontage: 100.0 PRE: 0.000 Land Impr. Value: 9,330 Average Depth: 305.0 Improvement Data # of Residential Buildings: 1 Year Built: 1950 Occupancy: Single Family Class: C+10 Style: 11/4 STORY Exterior: Vinyl % Good (Physical): 68 Heating System: Forced Heat 8 Cool Electric - Amps Service: 0 # of Bedrooms: 3 Full Baths: 2 Half Baths: 0 Floor Area: 2,700 Ground Area: 1,536 Garage Area: 780 Basement Area: 1,536 Basement Walls:
Page 13
00v'T0TZS 197'ST1ZS 000S60 00L'G80°TS 89V'VET'TS €£9°€ST 006'7€6% 1799'6/8S 970'798 | 005'€99$ v8E'509$ TE€L'959 B MOTIIZ NI4Q3Y 0£8'yZSS$ | 000°0S$- | 000'¥TS$- 000°vZT$- 0000ZS$- 000°ST$- OET'THT'TS- NOILVYO| vds 100d QIHOVLLY | SIA | SIA 001 S LNO NTVM 9 S | T9YE/1909 I nL LOH S Q3HSINH "1405S '0€€S | GY JU 00V‘T9SS | 000°0T$- | 000°9TS- 0002S |000°0T$- 0000T$- 009'30¥$~ NOILYOIYI vdS Q3IHOVLLY SIA | SIA 0s € LOO NTVM S _¥ | 008T/00vv IN gn. LOH v Q3HSINI 1470S °£77S | GY I 009'919$ 000°7$- 000VTTS- 000°0Z$ 00v'1ZCS- QIHOVLLY | SIA | S3A SL SIA ON € v 006/005¢€ ST "1405 "9vT$ NT3 000°05.$ gaHoviIa SIA SIA FZ 1 SAA € € 009¢ Ww z ‘1405 '882$ JU oo 1004 ¥3d T0Id ISYHDU V 8S /A NSS | TIVM 000'v$ | 000°SS$ 000'5$ 334d | SIUNIVII | IOVHVD Vas | IVT HIGIM | IOVId |INJIN3SVE| HIva [a3a 140% § H 101 ETT
Page 14
6486 LAKESHORE RD, BURTCHVILLE, MI 48059 Sold : $750,000.Sold on 11/30/2023 Type:Single Family Residence Year built:2001 Heating: Hot water/Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling:Central Air Parking:2 Detached Garage spaces Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms o Bedrooms: 3 e Bathrooms: 3 o Full bathrooms: 1 e 1/2 bathrooms: 2 Basement o Basement: Block, Not Finished ~ Not Walk Out Heating o Heating features: Hot water/Forced Air, Natural Gas o Cooling features: Central Air Interior features
Page 15
6008 Wildrose Ln, Burtchville Twp, MI 48059 Sold : $860,000 Sold on 10/06/22 Type:Single Family Residence, Ranch Year built:1954 Heating:Baseboard, Zoned, Natural Gas Cooling:Central Air Parking:2.5 Attached Garage spaces Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms o Bedrooms: 4 o Bathrooms: 3 o Full bathrooms: 3 Basement o Basement: None Heating o Heating features: Baseboard, Zoned, Natural Gas Cooling
Page 16
"6232 Wild Rose Rd.. Burtchville, MI 48059 Sold : $1,000,000 Sold on 06/08/21 Type:Single Family Residence Year built:2002 Heating:Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling:No Data Parking:4 Attached Garage spaces Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms e Bedrooms: 4 o Bathrooms: 5 o Full bathrooms: 4 o 1/2 bathrooms: 1 Basement o Area: 1390 Basement o Basement: Finished, Walk-Out Access Heating
Page 17
Property Parking Property o Levels: Two o Stories: 2 » Entry location: Ground Level e Spaincluded: Yes o Spa features: Spa/Hot-tub » Exterior features: Barbecue + Patio & porch details: Patio * View description: Water + Waterfront features: All Sports Lake, Seawall, Beach Front, Direct Water Frontage, Lake Front, Waterfront « Waterbody name: Lake Huron » Frontage length: Frontage: 50',Water Frontage: 50.00' « Waterview: Water Lot e Lotsize: 0.26 Acres o Lot size dimensions: 50 x 230 o Lot features: Sprinkler(s) Other property information « Parcel number: 74117200055000 « Special conditions: Short Sale - No + Other equipment: Whole House Generator Construction Type & style ¢ Home type: SingleFamily » Architectural style: Colonial * Property subType: Single Family Residence Material information + Construction materials: Brick o Foundation: Basement, Concrete Perimeter * Roof: Asphalt Condition
Page 18
"8514 Lakeshore Rd. Burtchville Twp, MI 48059 Sold : $2,000,000S01d on 06/29/23 Type:Single Family Residence Year built: 1998 Heating:Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling:Central Air Parking:5 Attached Garage spaces Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms e Bedrooms: 5 o Bathrooms: 6 o Full bathrooms: 5 o 1/2 bathrooms: 1 Basement o Basement: Block,Finished,Full,Exterior Entry, Walk-Out Access,Yes Heating o Heating features: Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling o Cooling features: Central Air Interior features
Page 19
Parking o Total spaces: 5 « Parking features: 3 or More Spaces » Garage spaces: 5 o Covered spaces: 5 Property Private pool: Yes Pool features: In Ground, Outdoor Pool Spa included: Yes Spa features: Spa/Hot Tub, Spa/Jetted Tub Exterior features: Balcony, Lawn Sprinkler Patio & porch details: Patio, Porch Fencing: Fenced View description: Water Waterfront features: All Sports Lake, Lake Front, Lake/River Access, Seawall, Waterfront, Beach Access, Beach Front Waterbody name: Lake Huron Frontage length: 100 Has waterview: Yes Waterview: Water © & © 6 0 & oo & Lot e Lotsize: 1.07 Acres + Lot size dimensions: 100 x 525 Other property information « Parcel number: 74117600051000 e Special conditions: Standard Construction Type & style ¢ Home type: SingleFamily « Architectural style: Traditional e Property subType: Single Family Residence Material information + Construction materials: Brick, Stone + Foundation: Basement
Page 20
‘hitps://www.bobvila.com/articles/cost-to-frame-a-basement/ How Much Does It Cost to Frame a Basement? Highlights The cost to frame a basement averages $1,200, but a common price range is $500 to $1,600. The size and type of basement, obstructions, framing material, permits. additional finishing work, and labor rates will all factor into the fina basement framing price. Homeowners will usually spend $7 to $23 per square foot to finish a basement. Basement Size Average Cost (Framing Only) Average Cost (Framing and Drywall) ] 500 linear feet $1,000 ta 53,000 $2,500 to 35,000 750 linear feet 51,500 to 54,500 $3,750@ to 7,300 1,000 linear feet $2,000 to 56,000 1,500 linear feet $3,000 to $9,000 2,000 linear feet $4,000 to $12,000 $10,000 to $20,000 Basement Type Average Framing Cost (Materials and Labor) Masonry wall $10 +o 312 per linear foot Poured concrete wall $12 to 516 per linear foot Precast panel $8 to $12 per linear foot https://homeguide.com/costs/foundation-cost How much does it cost to build a basement or foundation? Foundation costs range from $5 to $33 per square foot depending on the type — concrete slab ($7), pier and beam ($9). crawl space ($13). or basement ($33). https://www.ownerly.com/home-improvement/cost-to-build-a-basement/ hese basements have a separate entrance/exit door, making for easy access and additional PE ivacy. It’s a feature that can come in handy if you ik on renting out is basement. Buildin 7 it can cost LEH IErS
Page 21
https://mykitchenandbath.com/cost-to-add-a-new-bathroom/#elementor- toc__heading-anchor-1 Cost to Add a Half Bathroom vs. Full Bathroom Half Bathroom A half bathroom includes just a toilet and a sink. It’s ideal for smaller spaces or as a convenient guest restroom. The average cost to add a half bathroom ranges from $8,000 to $15,000. You’ll save on plumbing and fixtures since there’s no need for a shower or tub. Full Bathroom A full bathroom includes a shower, tub, toilet, and sink. It’s perfect for family use or adding a luxurious retreat to your home. The cost to add a full bathroom starts around $20,000 and goes up depending on the finishes and features you choose. https://www.remodelingcalculator.org/new-bathroom-cost/ Bathroom Materials Prices Low Middle High Bathtub $119.00 $209.00 $379.00 Bathtub Drain $20.00 $56.00 $85.00 Bathtub Liner / Tile $140.00 $370.00 $650.00 Shower Assembly $45.00 $136.00 $229.00 Shower Door / Curtain ~~ $35.00 $199.00 $391.00 Sink * $55.00 $250.00 $550.00 Sink Plumbing $35.00 $55.00 $70.00 Faucet $30.00 $88.00 $160.00 Mirror / Cabinet $30.00 $59.00 $89.00 Toilet ** $98.00 $228.00 $368.00 Towel Hangers $19.00 $49.00 $89.00
Page 22
Re LC] Juamt? BE chicuiaron 3arage Cost Calculator Detached Garage Cost Calculator Garage Dimensions Width (feet): 22 Length (feet): 22 Materials & Features Height (feet): 10 Location Factor: 1.0x The Location Factor adjusts costs based on your region. A value of 1.0 represents the national average construction cost. Higher values (like 1.3) represent expensive areas such as coastal cities, while lower values (like 0.8) represent less expensive rural areas. Adjust this value to match your local construction costs.
Page 23
Select which components you'll do yourself to save on labor costs:
i
Foundation Work
i
1
Roofing
i
i
Electrical Work
Cost Breakdown
Component
Foundation
Framing
Roofing
Exterior
Electrical
Doors
Windows
TOTAL
!
Framing
{J
Exterior Finishing
Materials
Labor
$2662
$3388
$2831
$3872
$1694
$1210
$726
Size: 22' x 22' x 10' (484 sq ft)
Total Project Cost: $40317
$4114
$4356
$4090
$4840
$3630
$1694
$1210
Total
$6776
$7744
$6921
$8712
$5324
$2904
$1936
$40317Page 24
https://www.fixr.com/costs/build-attached-garage Cost to Build an Attached Garage by Number of Cars lean 2ears Jcars $14.4K - $19.2K $24K - $46,080 $36K-$69.120 $9.6K - $14.4K $16K - $34,560 © $24K-$51.840 a edad — O—>0 63] 0 $ $83 H $$$ CI Conventional construction UI prefab construction Cost to build an attached garage by number of cars FIXF Size Conventional Construction Prefab Construction Cost Cost 1Car $14,400 - $19,200 $9,600 - $14,400
Page 25
« https://homeguide.com/costs/brick-stone-wall-fence-cost Cost to build a brick or stone wall ‘I'he average cost to build a brick a stone wall is $3,000 to $9,000 or $80 to $480 per linear foot. A brick wall or fence costs $15 to $45 per square foot, depending on the thickness and style. A stone wall costs $20 to $75 per square foo’ Cost to build a brick or stone wall Linear feet 4’ tall 6’ tall 8' tall 10° $800 - $2,400 $1,200 - $3,600 $1,600 - $4,800 15° $1,200 - $3,600 $1,800 — $5,400 $2,400 - $7,200 25° $2,000 - $6,000 $3,000 - $9,000 $4,000 - $12,000 50" $4,000 - $12,000 $6,000 - $18,000 $8,000 - $24,000 100° $8,000 - $24,000 $12,000 - $36,000 $16,000 ~ $48,000 150° $12,000 - $36,000 $18,000 — $54,000 $24,000 - $72,000 2000 $16,000 - $48,000 $24,000 - $72,000 Cost of brick wall per square foot A brick wall costs $15 to $40 per square foot of wall face installed, depending on the design, wall thickness, and size. Cost of brick wall per square foot Brick wall type Cost per square foot Brick (single layer) $15 - $20
Page 26
PETITIONER: Judy L. Gentner MTT DOCKET NO: 24-003589 2025 ~ BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION APPEAL FOR; 6486 LAKESHORE RD., BURTCHVILLE, MI MTT DOCKET NO: 24-003589 I find the Board of Review Comments confusing. Last year for the 2024 Board of Review, for my home, I provided comparables that where accepted and viewed... This year they are stating: “COMPARABLES PROVIDED WERE NOT A TRUE REFLECTION OF QUALITY/CHARACTERISTICS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY.” All of the homes that were submitted are on Lake Huron, with comparable views, they all are on the same road and they all had a comparable variable to come to a comparison on the Excel spread sheet provided. I would like to understand the boards definition of Quality/Characteristics. Last year when the assessor of Burtchville, MI sent in the reply to the MI Tribunal for the 2024 denial, there were six addresses sent in and two of them were not even on the water, The sq ft of those homes were 4,500 sq ft, 3400 sq ft, 2700 sq ft, 1,600 sq ft, 1,393 sq ft, 1,200 sq ft and one I could not find information on. The address 6500 Lakeshore Rd, that is next door to me, was a comparable that they used. The home that the board deem as the “very comparable” home, 6232 Wildrose Ln, Burtchville, MI, that they used to deny my 2024 appeal was not sent as the boards “proof” the board was correct in their decision. Attached find an Excell spread sheet of the homes used as the assessor’s “proof” of value. How are those addresses “QUALITY/CHARACTERISTICS” acceptable and the homes on the same body of water and the same road not acceptable??? The housing market is down and interest rates are high. The township assessor has determined that the SEV for my home is 24.52% more than the day that I bought it ~ A period of 13 months. When the board speaks: “NOT A TRUE REFLECTION OF QUALITY/CHARACTERISTICS.” I do not understand that judgement... What in the descriptions of my home below are of better quality or better characteristics of the comparables that I submitted for my 2025 Board of Review? Home outside: My home is brick. The homes that were given as a comparable that were not brick receive a value adjustment for that. The house is a basic four wall construction with only a small kick out for the front porch, which is not covered and the basement is not a walkout. First floor of my home: There are no beamed, coffered, indentation, sunken panel, grid panel ceilings or crown moldings. The floor, trim, cabinets and floor are outdated honey oak. There are no custom window coverings. The windows that actually have any type of privacy have an old roller type shade with a lace panel held up by a tension rod. All walls are a painted drywall. The kitchen is so small that no more than two people can prepare a meal together, the counter top is not granite. The bathroom is so small that the door has to open into the hall way. There is a pedestal sink with no storage for cleaning supplies, towels or toilet paper. The floor is tiled but the walls are all painted drywall. Two ceiling fans. Second floor: Floor and trim outdated honey oak. Full bathroom has a tiled floor, painted drywalls. Second bathroom has a free-standing tub, no shower, pedestal sink and toilet. There is no room or place for storage of cleaning supplies, towels, medicine cabinet, personal items or toilet paper. It has a tile floor and painted drywall. No celling fans.
Page 27
Michigan Cepartment of Treasury,
11019 {Rey, 10-24)
THIS
IS NOT A TAX BILL
L.-4400
Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification
This form is issued under the authority of P.A. 206 of 1893, Sec. 211.24 (c) and Sec.211.34c, as amended,
This is a mode) assessment natice to be used by the local assessor.
FROM:
BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR
4000 BURTCH ROAD
LAKEPORT, MI 48059
PARCEL IDENTIFICATION
PARCEL NUMBER:
7411-470-0031-000
PROPERTY ADDRESS:
6486 LAKESHORE RD
LAKEPORT, Mi 48059-2557
OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS/PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL:
GENTNER, JUDY LYNNE
PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION
% Exempt As "Homeowners Principal Residence”:
100.00%
56373 NICKELBY SOUTH
% Exempt
As "Qualified Agricultural Property":
00%
UTICA MI 48316
% Exempt
As "MBT Industrial Personal":
00%
% Exempt As "MBT Commercial Personal”:
00%
Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property":
[J yes
[X
No
Exempt
As "Development Property”:
J Yes
No
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
$1/2 OF LOT 26 EXC S 6' LAKELAND BEACH PLAT QC 1259/524
ACCORDING TO MCL 211.34c THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS:
401
Residential
PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION:
401
Residential
The change in taxable value will increase/decrease your tax bill for the 2025
CURRENT TENTATIVE
CHANGE FROM
year by approximately:
$325
Tenn, Me
AMOUNT YEAR: 55
CURRENT YEAR
1. TAXABLE VALUE:
379,500
391,264
11,764
2. ASSESSED VALUE:
379,500
425,900
46,400
3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR:
1.000
4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV):
379,500
425,900
46,400
5. There WAS or WAS NOT a transfer of ownership on this property in2024
WAS NOT
6. Assessor Change Reason:
Market Adjustment
The 2025 Inflation rate Multiplier is: 1.031
Questions regarding the Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification may be directed to the Following:
lame:
SHELLY BAUMEISTER
Phone:
(810) 385-5577
Email Address:
SBAUMEISTER@HOTMAIL.COMPage 28
03/25/2025 09:46 Ar 2025 BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION FROM BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP 4000 BURTCH ROAD LAKEPORT, MI 48059 NAME AND ADDRESS OF OWNER OR PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION: (Parcel Code required. Property address and legal description optional.): 7411-470-0031-000 6486 LAKESHORE RD GENTNER, JUDY LYNNE 56373 NICKELBY SOUTH UTICA M148316 S1/2 OF LOT 26 EXC S 6' LAKELAND BEACH PLAT QC 1259/524 THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED 401 (RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED) Thank you for attending this years March Board of Review. The Board has reviewed the information you supplied and the data necessary to compute your assessment and taxable value. The Board has completed their review of parcel number 7411-470-0031-000 They have made the following determination based on the information you supplied. [2025 ORIGINAL ASSESSED VALUE 425,900 2025 "BOARD OF REVIEW" ASSESSED VALUE 425,900 (If the above amounts are the same, no revisions have occured) 2025 ORIGINAL TAXABLE VALUE 391,264 2025 "BOARD OF REVIEW" TAXABLE VALUE 391,264 2025 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION/QUALIFIED AG 100.0000 Please feel free to contact the assessor at the address listed above or call if you have any questions. “Effective March 1, 2013, the Tribunal is no longer able to accept Small Claims letter appeals. Rather, you are required to file a petition to initiate a new Small Claims appeal. Petition forms are available on this website.” http://www.michigan.gov/taxtrib/0,4677,7-187-38254---,00.html
Page 29
Michigan Department of Treasury
618 (Rev. 11-12)
Petition to Board of Review
L-4035
This form is issued under the authority of P.A. 206 of 1893, as amended. Filing is voluntary, however you may not appeal to the Michigan Tax Tribunal
or the State Tax Commission unless you first protest to the Board of Review.
TO BE COMPLETED BY OWNER OR OWNER'S AGENT
Owner's Name (Please Print or Type)
Petitioner's Name
(If Other than Owner. Please Print or Type)
Judy L. Gentner
Township or City
County
Burtchville
St. Clair
The undersigned protests the assessed value and/or the tentative taxable value and/or the property classification and/or the qualified
agricultural property exemption of the following described property:
Property Identified (Parcel code required. Property address & legal description optional}
Parcel #: 7411-470-0031-000
6486 Lakeshore Rd.
Burtchville, MI 48059
Protested Item
pd] Assessed Value
] Tentative Taxable Value
[] Classification
J Qualified Agricultural
Property
Exemption
1. PROTEST OF ASSESSMENT
perty
P
(Complete this section for a protest of assessed value and/or tentative taxable value)
Assessed Amount
Owner's Estimate of True Cash Value
Tentative Taxable Value
Year
$851,800
$600,000
2025
2. PROTEST OF CLASSIFICATION
(Complete this section for a request to change the classification. The Board of Review must make their decision regarding classification in
accordance with Section 211.34c of the Michigan Compiled Laws. The Board of Review shall not be influenced by the effect that a particular
classification has on that property's status as a homeowner's principal residence or qualified agricultural property.)
Classification of property on this year's assessment rofl
Classification should be {check one of the following):
J Agricultural
J Industrial
[] Timber Cutover
[] Utility (Personal Property Only)
[1 commercial
[] Residential
[] Developmental
3. PROTEST OF EXEMPTION FOR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL PROPERTY
(If the assessor has denied or changed the percentage of the exemption from the 18 mills of local school operating tax for qualified agricultural
property, the owner may appeal this action to the March Board of Review. THE BOARD OF REVIEW HAS NO AUTHORITY TO CONSIDER OR ACT
UPON THE EXEMPTION FROM THE 18 SCHOOL OPERATING MILLS FOR HOMEOWNER'S PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE PROPERTIES.)
Percent qualified agricultural exemption granted by assessor (Enter 0 if exemption
Percent qualified agricultural exemption requested by owner (Enter 100 if full
denied)
exemption requested)
4. REASON FOR PROTEST
State reason(s) for protest of assessed value and/or the tentative taxable value and/or classification and/or qualified agricultural property exemption
See Attached: Spread sheet, photo comparison of other properties...Page 30
1ST'ETS- 000'95~ 000'7T$- 9€T'697%- 000°0Z$- | 000°sS$- ST6'0YSS vdS aaHs dNLIOH | HOVLLYE | SIA | SIA = 95-/00T SIA [LNO MYM v 9 | ¥19z-/092S REIVE ~ QIHSINIA FY 190° TEYS 000°52$- | 000'7vS- 986'8YTS- 000°02$- | 000'S$- ESL LLTS- TIVMODIYE | HOVLIV S'S | SIA | SIA T€-/SL SIA | LnodIvm v ¥ | 658-/50S€ S3LYD JINOYLITTI 009 X §/ QIHSINIA FY 8YT'SvSS 000°5$~ 00S'€TS- 986'SYTS- 990'6€TS- SYIMIS YI ST SIA 1€-/SL ON SAA € ¥ | T/9/8T¢E IN ~ Q3HOVLLV Z T £YTY09$ 000°0Z$- | 000°9T$~ 9L0'TTTS- 615'6$ SHIMIS vdS 100d payoeny z | SIA 9v-/06 SIA 3 ¥ | 9%+/009Z IN VE NILING payeispz TU 06v'STSS 000°9T$- : 9€T‘692S- | 000'SS- 000°0Z$- | 000°SS- PLTTTS QIHOVLLY 7 1noNIVYM i IN [4 SIA | SIA | 95/00T = SIA S3A v € | vs-/o0Le FU | 008°158$ Q3IHOVLIA | SIA SIA 7v 1 SIA € € 9t9z IN z JY FYOHSHIVT 9819 1004 ¥3d | | od V 85 /a SS | TIVM 908vS$ 000's$ | 00007 | 000°SS$ £6°902% INVA S3dniv3d | I5vEvD | VIS M/IVI| HIAIM PDVid INTW3SVE| Hivd g3g “370s NOSIAVdINDD, 101 38d 1NONTYM
Page 31
- 6486 LAKESHORE RD, BURTCHVILLE, MI 48039 pn Sold : $750,000.Sold on 11/30/2023 e Type:Single Family Residence Year built:2001 e Heating: Hot water/Forced Air, Natural Gas e Cooling:Central Air Parking:2 Detached Garage spaces Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms Bedrooms: 3 Bathrooms: 3 Full bathrooms: 1 1/2 bathrooms: 2 Basement e Basement: Block, Not Finished ~ Not Walk Out Heating o Heating features: Hot water/Forced Air, Natural Gas Interior features e Fireplace: Living room
Page 32
Patio & porch details: Patio, Porch View description: Water Waterfront features: All Sports Lake, Lake Front, Seawall, Waterfront, Beach Access, Beach Front Waterbody name: Lake Huron Frontage length: 44 Lot Lot size: 44° Wide Other property information e Parcel number: 7411470031000 Construction Type & style e Home type: SingleFamily » Architectural style: Traditional « Property subType: Single Family Residence Material information + Construction materials: Brick + Foundation: Basement Condition o Year built: 2001 Utilities & green energy tility » Sewer information: Septic Tank o Water information: Public
Page 33
+6500 LAKESHORE RD, BURTCHVILLE, MI 48059 Sold : $695,000 Sold 2022 e Type: Single Family Residence Year built: 1950 Heating: Hot water/Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Parking:2.5 Attached Garage Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms eo Bedrooms: 3 e Bathrooms: 4 o Full bathrooms: 3 e !5 bathrooms: 1 Basement eo Walk out eo Finished Heating e Heating features: Hot water/Forced Air, Natural Gas o Cooling features: Center Air Interior features
Page 34
[i 4578 Lakeshore Rd, Fort Gratiot, MI 48059 Sold: $850,000 Sold on 6/26/2023 Type: Single Family Residence Year Built: 1905 Heating: Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling: Central Air Parking: Attached garage spaces: 2 Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms Bedrooms: 4 Bathrooms: 3 Full bathrooms: 2 1/2 bathrooms: 1 Bedroom 1 o Features: Carpet o Level: First o Area: 196 o Dimensions: 14 x 14 Bedroom 2 o Features: Carpet o Level: Second eo Area: 168 e Dimensions: 12 x 14 Bedroom 3 o Features: Carpet o Level: Second
Page 35
Total structure area: 3,176 Total interior livable area: 2,600 sqft Finished area above ground: 2,600 Finished area below ground: 0 Property Parking « Total spaces: 2 « Parking features: Garage o Attached garage spaces: 2 Features Levels: Two Stories: 2 Patio & porch: Deck Exterior features: Built-in Barbecue Has private pool: Yes Has spa: Yes Spa features: Spa/Jetted Tub Waterfront features: Lake Front, Waterfront Body of water: Lake Huron Frontage length: 90 o Size: 58 Acres « Dimensions: 90 x 283 o Features: Main Street, Sidewalks Details o Parcel number: 74207650004000 « Zoning description: Residential « Special conditions: Standard Construction Type & style + Home type: SingleFamily o Architectural style: Colonial + Property subtype: Single Family Residence
Page 36
+ 4606 Lakeshore Rd, Fort Gratiot, MI 48059 Sold: $745,000 Sold on 10/12/2023 Type: Single Family Residence Year Built: 1957 Heating: Baseboard, Hot Water, Natural Gass Cooling: Ceiling fans, Wall units Parking: Attached 3.5 Car Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms e Bedrooms: 4 o Bathrooms: 3 o Full bathrooms: 2 o 1/2 bathrooms: 1 Heating e Baseboard, Hot Water, Natural Gas Cooling o Ceiling Fans, Wall Units Appliances o Included: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Free Standing Electric Range, Free Standing Refrigerator, Microwave, Washer
Page 37
Property Parking o Total spaces: 3.5 o Parking features: One and Half Car Garage, Two Car Garage, Attached « Garage spaces: 3.5 Features Levels: Two Entry location: Ground Level w/ Steps Pool features: None Waterfront features: All Sports Lake, Lake Front Body of water: Lake Huron Lot o Size: 0.55 Acres + Dimensions: 75 x 323 Details « Parcel number: 74201350002000 « Special conditions: Short Sale No, Standard Construction Type & style o Home type: Single Family o Architectural style: Traditional « Property subtype: Single Family Residence Materials o Vinyl Siding + Foundation: Basement, Block, Crawl Space, Slab Condition o New construction: No e Year built: 1957 « Major remodel year: 1990 Utilities & green energy
Page 38
+8442 Lakeshore Rd, Lakeport, MI 48059 Sold: $1,400,000 Sold on 7/21/2023 Type: Single Family Residence Year built: 2003 Heating: Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling: Central Air, Ceiling Fans, Heat Pump Parking: 3 Car Attached Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms Bedrooms: 6 Bathrooms: 4 Full bathrooms: 4 Main level bathrooms: 2 Main level bedrooms: 3 Primary bedroom e Level: First Bedroom o Level: Lower eo Area: 224 e Dimensions: 14 x 16 Bedroom 1
Page 39
e Level: Main e Area: 224 e Dimensions: 14 x 16 Bedroom 4 o Level: Upper eo Area: 252 o Dimensions: 12 x 21 Bedroom 5 « Level: Lower o Area: 272 e Dimensions: 16 x 17 Bathroom 1 o Level: Main eo Area: 50 o Dimensions: 5x 10 Bathroom 2 eo Level: Main e Area: 108 + Dimensions: 9x 12 Bathroom 3 e Level: Main eo Area: 63 e Dimensions: 7x 9 Bathroom 4 « Level: Lower o Area: 64 ¢ Dimensions: 8 x 8 Dining room ¢ Level: Main eo Area: 288 e Dimensions: 12 x 24
Page 40
A Heating « Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling o Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air, Heat Pump Appliances » Included: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Range/Oven, Refrigerator, Washer o Laundry: First Floor Laundry, Main Level Features o High Ceilings, Walk-In Closet(s) o Basement: Finished,Full,Yes + Has fireplace: Yes » Fireplace features: Great Room, Natural Fireplace Interior area Total structure area: 5,800 Total interior livable area: 5,260 sqft Finished area above ground: 3,260 Finished area below ground: 2,000 Property Parking o Total spaces: 3 « Parking features: Garage - Attached o Attached garage spaces: 3 Features Levels: One Stories: 1 Patio & porch: Patio Has spa: Yes Spa features: Spa/Hot Tub Has view: Yes View description: Water, Lake Has water view: Yes Water view: Water, Lake o & © © oo 0° ©
Page 41
s Additional structures: Shed(s) ¢ Parcel number: 74111900046000 o Zoning description: Residential e Special conditions: Standard Construction Type & style « Home type: SingleFamily « Architectural style: Contemporary o Property subtype: Single Family Residence Materials « Brick « Foundation: Basement Condition e Year built: 2003 Utilities & green energy o Sewer: Septic Tank + Water: Public
Page 42
COMPARIBLE ADDRESSES SUBMITTED TO THE TRIBUNAL FROM BURTCHVILLE BOARD OF REVIEW These are the address that the Burtchville Township sent to the MI Tribunal as their respondent’s answer to the appeal for 6486 Lakeshore Road. Attached is an Excell spread sheet for four of those address and the printout information from the sale of said home. I was unable to get information for the sale of 8484 Lakeshore, Lakeport, MI on line, the information had been removed. 1 did not do a comparison with the address of 6625 Lakeshore, Fort Gratiot, MI and 6520 Lorraine St, Burtchville, MI because neither home is on the water... The address of 6500 Lakeshore, Burtchville was an address that I submitted to the Board of Review. The Township also used this as a factor to provide proof of value and assessment sent to the Tribunal with their answer to this appeal. The address 6232 Wildrose, Burtchville, MI that I submitted to the Board of Review and the board used to decline the appeal with the comment “very comparable” was not sent to or used as proof of value and assessment when sending in their answer to this appeal.
Page 43
GRETCHEN WHITMER
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GOVERNOR
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
LANSING
MARLON
|. BROWN, DPA
DIRECTOR
PROPERTY TAX APPEAL ANSWER FORM
VALUATION / EXEMPTION / CLASSIFICATION APPEAL
MTT DOCKET NO. 24-003589-T7
Section 1: Respondent's Contact Information
First Name:
Mas
Last Name/Company Name/Unit of Government:
Burtchville Township
Home Address (No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route):
4000 Burtch Rd
“St. Clair
City or Town:
State:
ZIP Code:
Lakeport
Mi
48059
Telephone Number:
Fax Number:
(810)385-5577
(810)385-8551
shaumeister@hotmail.com
E-mail Address (do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email):
Section 2: Respondent’s Attorney/Authorized Representative’s Contact Informatio
1
First Name:
Shelly
ML:
Last Name:
Baumeister
Firm Name (if any);
Burtchville Township Assessor
Address (No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route):
4000 Burtch Rd
City or Town:
Lakeport
State;
2)P Code:
Mi
48059
Telephone Number:
(810)385-5577
Fax Number;
(810)385-8551
sbaumeister@hotmail.com
E-mail Address {do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email):
Section 3: Subject Property Information
[1%] Yes
0
No
Does the subject property have a Principal Residence Exemption of 50% or more?
Are the parcels listed by Petitioner contiguous or adjolning?
IN| Yes
[J No
[&4 Not Appicabie
If not, list which parcels adjoin one another,Page 44
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON |. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Section 4: Explain Your Answer studies to provide proof o value nip, a - sales Section 5: Jurisdictional Issues IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE TRUE CASH AND/OR TAXABLE VALUES Did Petitioner protest the assessment at a Board of Review (BOR)? [4 Yes [J No If yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: March O July O December If no, was the Notice of Assessment properly sent to Petitioner prior to the March BOR? Od Yes O No *Submit a copy of the Notice of Assessment with the Answer, If the July or December BOR revised the assessment(s) at issue, did it have authority? J Yes O No If yes, cite the Board's authority. Was the assessment(s) at issue established as the result of a clerical error or mutual mistake of fact? [J Yes No If yes, explain Is Petitioner appealing from a State Tax Commission Order? Od Yes [4 No If so, what is the issue date? IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE UNCAPPING OF TAXABLE VALUE
Page 45
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
MARLON |. BROWN, DPA
GOVERNOR
LANSING
DIRECTOR
Did Petitioner request a Poverty Exemption ata BOR? [J Yes
[JNo
If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended; [| March
O July
J December
List the date the BOR denied Petitioner's Poverty Exemption:
IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE DENIAL OF AN EXEMPTION
OTHER THAN POVERTY, PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE, OR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL EXEMPTIONS
Did Petitioner request the exemption at a BOR? J Yes
[i] No
If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: [| March
[J July
[] December
Tax Year(s) denied:
List the date the exemption was denied:
What statutory section did Petitioner request the subject property be exempt?
IF PETITIONER [S APPEALING THE CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY
What do you believe ihe classification should be:
Reat
Personal
{check one)
i]
Agricultural
Commercial
Industrial
Residential
Timber-Cutover
Developmental
Utility
(check one}
Section 6: Valuation Information suse the muttipte parce! form for additional, contiguous parcels.
Parcel Identification Number:
74-11-470-0031-000
Classification of Property:
Real
Personal
(check one)
4
Agricultural
Commercial
Industrial
Residential
Timber-Cutover
Developmentat
Utility
(check one)
Current Assessed Value (also known as State Equalized Value) as established by the BOR:
379,500
Current Taxable Value as established by the BOR:
. [879,500
What do you believe is the fair market value (also known as True Cash Value)?
758,902
Multiply the True Cash Value by .§ and enter here, This is your contention of Assessed Value.
379,500
If you befieve the Taxable Value differs from your contention of Assessed Value, enter your contention of Taxable Value.
379,500Page 46
005'755$ 000'0Z$- | 000°0TS 1000%TTS- i 0000Z$- | 000's$- | 005°88TS- 000°0S (5727) (ea z +) (iT€-) (anoxyjem-) | (yreq T-) | (ibs #5.) ( ST SIA | TE /SL SIA SAA 2 ¥S.- / 00%E IN } 14°05 052 | NT3 AD1¥9 06t'525$ 000'9T$- |000°0TS 9E1'697S$- |000°SS- |000°02$- |000°SS- | 8/8°€TS- 000°00 (eaz-) (dea z+) (9s) | (day 1-) [(ano jem) [(yieq 1-) | (bs ps) ( | 4 LNO ¥TIYM ¥5-/004T IN [4 S3K SIA 95-/00T | SIA S3A 14 "L408 £52% JY 976'6€5$ 000'v2$- | D00°0TS 000°0Z2s- 000°0Z$ | 0000S 976°€6TS (eog-) | (e274) (.557) (wawsseq +)/ (yieq z +) (bs 9v0'T+) € SIA SS-/66 SAA TMV) I 9v0‘T+/009T | IN 1408 182$ JY €5T'T+/ £651 ITVS SIH 904 INIT NO NGILVINYOINI 135 OL 318VNN| "1d ‘DS 90€$ | JU 789°v£T$ | 000'0T$- 000'9T$- SIA |000°2ETS- 000'0Z$- | 000'0TS- 8IETOVS- | (sauniesy anoge-)| (pune z-) (199) 85-) (anoxjem-) | (yzeq z-) | (bs ¥58°1-) I aaHs | S3A | 85-/ TOT LNOXTYM S ¥S8°T-/ 00SY SAS YIADINIYLS [4 [4 i SAA 1408 L128 FHO vdS Q3IHOVLIA SA | S3A rv 1 SIA € 997 Ww z ; "1408 "887% FUO 4vD ¥3d | ¥vd Yad 1004 43d 304d ISYHI¥ 000'8% | 000°s$ |TIVM 0007S | 000°S$ 000'S$ : Pid SIINIVIE | GIHOVLLY [FHOVLLI( vas |DIVI| HIQIM | DVId |ININGSVE HIVE "1370S s IOVYVD | IDVHYD 101 ERIE]
Page 47
00Y'S8YS$ |000°0Z$- |000°TES- |000°0TS 000%Z$- |0000T$- |000°02$- 000'0TS- |009°807S- (3n0av) | (uvovr) | (wvoz+) (z) (z) (008°T-) 14 SIA | SIA] 9-/o0s € Q3HSINIA S 008°T-/ Oty IN SAS NOILYORNI JOVHYD | I9VHVD, TVA ~ Vid | LNoNTYM Hlvg| 14'0S/Lze$| N13 vdS v a VIS |DIVI HLM 101 34 INIW3ISvE anL 10H INFINISNIAV NV 404 1S3nD3F AW ININMI3a 01 disn ANY JT19VIVAINOD AYIA, SV SSTHAAV SIHL *M3IATY 40 QUV09 ¥70C IHL H04 43SN | LVYHL SSTYAAV 3 IN YILVM NO ION| “ISIN IN “ YAIVM NO ION| JUO
Page 48
8308 LAKESHORE RD, LAKEPORT, MI 48059 Sold: $975,000 . Sold on 02/04/2022 Type:SingleFamily e Year built:1929 o Heating:Forced air, Gas e Cooling:Central e Parking:4 Parking spaces Lot:1.46 Acres Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms e Bedrooms: 5 e Bathrooms: 5 o Full bathrooms: 4 e 1/2 bathrooms: 1 Basement o Basement: Yes Flooring o Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood Heating
Page 49
Total interior livable area: 4,500 sqft Fireplace: Yes Property Parking Property Lot Total spaces: 4 Parking features: Garage - Attached, Garage - Detached Spa included: Yes Lot size: 1.46 Acres Other property information Parcel number: 74111900028000 Construction Type & style Condition Home type: SingleFamily Year built: 1929 Community & neighborhood Location Other Region: Lakeport Other facts 6 6 * © Property Type: Residential Appliances: Dryer, Washer, Disposal, Dishwasher, Microwave, Double-Oven, Bar Fridge Fireplace: One, Gas, Wood Flooring: Carpet, Wood Heat: Forced Air, Gas, Other
Page 50
Breakfast Room Level: Entry Kitchen Level: Entry Library Level: Entry Living Room Level: Entry Laundry Room Level: Entry Dining Room Level: Entry Dining Room _2: 13x13 Basement: Yes Basement Type: Full, Walkout, Partially Finished Garage Features: Attached, Door Opener, Electric, Detached, Second Garage, Workshop Water Type: Public Garage: Yes Sewer Type: Septic Misc. Features: Kennel Water Facilities: All Sports, Lake Frontage, Water Front, Private Frontage, Direct Frontage, Beach Front Style/Architecture: Tudor Frontage: 102 Feet
Page 51
' 8484 LAKESHORE RD, LAKEPORT, MI 48059 Sold: $427,500 Sold on 9/14/2022 71 acre lot 2 Beds 2 Baths 1,393 Sq Ft $419/Sq Ft Est. Value Type:SingleFamily e Heating:No Data e Cooling:No Data e Parking:No Data o © Lot:No Data Property Other property information e Parcel number: 74111900052000
Page 52
' 8014 LAKESHORE RD, FORT GRATIOT, MI 48059 Sold: $450,000. Sold on 11/07/2022 4 Beds 1 Bath 1,600 Sq Ft Single-family Built in 1948 1.38 acres 3 garage spaces Burtchville Twp Property details for 8014 Lakeshore Rd Parking Garage Information o Has Garage o Garage Size: 3 Car o Garage Features: Attached Interior Bathroom Information o # of Baths (Full): 1
Page 53
Kitchen Room Level: Entry Room Length: 10 Room Width: 10 Room 2 Information Bedroom Room Level: Entry Room Length: 10 Room Width: 10 Room 3 Information Bedroom Room Level: Entry Room Length: 10 Room Width: 10 ¢ © © eo Room 4 Information Bedroom Room Level: Second Room Length: 9 Room Width: 9 Room 5 Information Master Bedroom Room Level: Entry Room Length: 11 Room Width: 10 Room 6 Information « Bathroom (Full) + Room Level: Entry Exterior Building Information 2 Story
Page 54
Public facts Beds: — Baths: — Sq. Ft.: — Stories: — Lot Size: 1.03 acres Style: Single Family Residential Year Built: — Year Renovated: — County: St. Clair County APN: 11-320-0019-000 e © 6 © 0 © eo © © Home facts updated by county records on Oct 4, 2024 Other Listing Data Information Close Date: 2022-11-07 DOM: 6 RDOM: 6 CDOM: 6 Listing Information » Originating MLS: RealComp ¢ Close Price: $450,000
Page 55
' 6500 LAKESHORE RD, BURTCHVILLE, MI 48059 Sold : $695,000 Sold 2022 ®e © oo eo Type: Single Family Residence Year built: 1950 Heating: Hot water/Forced Air Cooling: Central Air Parking:2.5 Attached Garage Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms Bedrooms: 3 Bathrooms: 4 Full bathrooms: 3 V2 bathrooms: 1 Basement Walk out Finished Heating Heating features: Hot water/Forced Air, Natural Gas Cooling features: Center Air Interior features
Page 56
° Waterbody name: Lake Huron e Lake Length: 100 Lot o Lot size: 100° Wide Other property information o Parcel number: 11-470-0033-000 Construction Type & style o Home type: Single Family e Architectural style: Traditional * Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence Material information e Construction materials: Vinyl Siding o Foundation: Basement Condition e Year Built:1950 Utilities & green energy Utility e Sewer information: Septic Tank eo Water information: Public
Page 57
' 6026 WILDROSE LN, BURTCHVILLE, MI 48059 CLE (Af p= Sold $850,000 Sold on 7/14/2022 e Single Family Residence e o Year built:1950 e o Heating:Forced Air, Natural Gas e o Cooling:Central Air o o Parking:2 Attached Garage spaces o Lot:0.34 Acres ~ 75 ft lake frontage Interior Bedrooms & bathrooms o Bedrooms: 3 o Bathrooms: 4 o Full bathrooms: 3 o 1/2 bathrooms: 1 Basement e Area: 1608 Basement o Has basement: Yes o Basement: Unfinished Heating
Page 58
' Other interior features e Total structure area: 5,008 » Total interior livable area: 3,400 sqft « Finished area above ground: 3,400 Property Parking Total spaces: 2.5 Parking features: Electricity, Garage Door Opener, Attached Garage spaces: 2.5 Covered spaces: 2.5 Property Levels: Two Stories: 2 Entry location: Ground Level Exterior features: Gutter Guard System Waterfront features: All Sports Lake, Beach Front, Lake Front, Waterfront Waterbody name: Lake Huron Frontage length: Frontage: 75', Water Frontage: 75.00" Lot Lot size: 0.34 Acres Lot size dimensions: 75 x 230 e Other property information e Parcel number: 74117200007000 » Special conditions: Short Sale - No Construction Type & style « Home type: SingleFamily » Architectural style: Colonial o Property subType: Single Family Residence Material information « Construction materials: Brick, Vinyl
Page 59
PETITIONER: Judy L. Gentner MTT DOCKET NO: 24-003589 STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON |. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Judy L. Gentner , MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL Petitioner(s) v MTT Docket No. 24-003589 Township of Burtchville, Mi , Respondent(s) PROOF OF SERVICE Judy L. Gentner states that on April 17, 2025 he/she [Name of person serving/mailing petition] [date of service] served a copy of the comparisons,evidence,research relative to the above-captioned matter upon: [Provide name and address of the party/people being served] Township of Burtchville Burtchville Township 4000 Burtch Road Burtchville, MI 48059 Qudy sf Quid [Sighatde of pefdon who is serving/mailing copy] Judy L. Gentner [Print/type name of person serving/mailing copy]
Page 60
GENT" | 1 iy A toneffilfyttf bell I" UR CERTIFIED WA LU TL ER | CPT LER (HA Bl Loa oNoRes na, Buatehville, M1 #8059 7021 1970 000% 9215 | | Bi Michigan GW i" O+ TO. Box [poging