24-003666.pdf
Charles Fogleson, Amanda Fogleson, Petitioners V Township Of Egelston, Respondent · 24-003666-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
RECEIVED NOV 182.4 MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL November 12,2024 Charles and Amanda Fogleson 4405 Krystallee Dr Muskegon, MI 4442 RE: MOAHR Docket No. 24-003666 - Answer Form Dear Mr. and Mrs. Fogleson: Enclosed are copies of the Property Tax Appeal Answer Form and required documentation that our office prepared for your tribunal case. . Property Tax Appeal Answer Form . Copy of Assessment Notice . Copy of Board of Review Notice . Property Record Card and sketches . Proof of Service These documents are filed in compliance with the Notice of Docket Number issued by the MTT on October 7%, 2024. If you have any questions, please contact me at 231-724-3475. Sincerely, Muskegon County Equalization Egelston Township Assessing CN Cp Shree sp Michelle Ercole MAAO, PPE Senior Appraiser
Page 2
November 12% 2024
Michigan Tax Tribunal
611 W. Ottawa St.
Lansing, Michigan 48933
RE: MOAHR DOCKET #24-003666 — Answer Form
Dear Tribunal:
Please see the enclosed documentation for the Small Claims case mentioned
above:
Property Tax Appeal Answer Form
Copy of Assessment Notice
Copy of March Board of Review Notice
Property Record Card and sketches
Proof of Service
These documents are filed in compliance with the Notice of Docket Number
issued by the MTT on October 7%, 2024.
If you have any questions, please
contact me at 231-724-3475.
Sincerely,
Muskegon County Equalization
Egelston Township
{Yh eine
Ro Cee ols
Michelle L. Ercole MAAO, PPE
Senior AppraiserPage 3
5
8
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
MARLON I. BROWN, DPA
GOVERNOR
LANSING
DIRECTOR
PROPERTY TAX APPEAL ANSWER FORM
VALUATION / EXEMPTION / CLASSIFICATION APPEAL
MTT DOCKET NO. 24-003666
Section 1: Respondent’s Contact Information
First Name:
M.L:
Last Name/Company Name/Unit of Government:
Township of Egelston
Home Address {No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route}:
County:
5428 E Apple Ave
Muskegon
City or Town:
State:
ZIP Code:
Muskegon
Ml
149442
Telephone Number:
Fax Number:
231-788-2308
E-mail Address {do not enter unless you want MTT fo send all correspondence via email):
Section 2: Respondent's Attorney/Authorized Representative’s Contact Information
First Name:
Last Name:
Michelle
L
Ercole
mr Muskegon County Equalization Department
Address (No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route):
173 E Apple Ave., Ste. 201
City or Town:
State:
ZIP Code:
Muskegon
MI
[49442
Telephone Number:
Fax Number:
231-724-3475
E-mail Address {do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email):
ercolemi@co.muskegon.mi.us
Section 3: Subject Property Information
Does the subject property have a Principal Residence Exemption of 50% or more?
[re] Yes
[m} No
Are the parcels listed by Petitioner contiguous or adjoining?
If not, list which parcels adjoin one another.
[MN] Yes
Mm
No
[1%] Not
ApplicablePage 4
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON I. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Section 4: Explain Your Answer to this Appeal The True Cash Value for parcel 61-11-161-000-0019-00 is $306,000, Assessed Value of $153,000 and Taxable Value of $143,115 as established by the 2024 March Board of Review. A more detailed valuation disclosure will be submitted at a later time. Section 5: Jurisdictional Issues IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE TRUE CASH AND/OR TAXABLE VALUES Did Petitioner protest the assessment at a Board of Review (BOR)? Yes I] No if yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: March [I] July O December if no, was the Notice of Assessment properly sent to Petitioner prior to the March BOR? [I Yes [] No *Submit a copy of the Notice of Assessment with the Answer. If the July or December BOR revised the assessment(s) at issue, did it have authority? [mn] Yes [mn] No If yes, cite the Board's authority. Was the assessment(s) at issue established as the result of a clerical error or mutual mistake of fact? [Mi] Yes No if yes, explain Is Petitioner appealing from a State Tax Commission Order? [] Yes [ No If so, what is the issue date?
Page 5
Gd
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
MARLON I. BROWN, DPA
GOVERNOR
LANSING
DIRECTOR
Did Petitioner request a Poverty Exemption at a BOR? Il Yes
No
If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: [] March
1 July
[| December
List the date the BOR denied Petitioner's Poverty Exemption:
IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE DENIAL OF AN EXEMPTION
OTHER THAN POVERTY, PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE, OR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL EXEMPTIONS
Did Petitioner request the exemption at a BOR? [i] Yes
[a] No
If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: O March
[Wm] July
0 December
Tax Year(s) denied:
List the date the exemption was denied:
What statutory section did Petitioner request the subject property be exempt?
{F PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY
What do you believe the classification should be:
Real
Personal
{check one)
Agricultural
Commercial
Industrial
Residential
Timber-Cutover
Developmental
Utility
(check one}
Iv
Section 6: Valuation Information *use the multiple parcel form for additional, contiguous parcels.
Parcel identification Number:
61-11-161-000-0019-00
Classification of Property:
Real
Personal
({checkone)
7]
Agricultural
Cormmercial
Industrial
Residential
Timber-Cutover
Developmentai
Utility
(check one)
Current Assessed Value (also known as State Equalized Value) as established by the BOR:
$153,000
Current Taxable Value as established by the BOR:
$143,115
What do you believe is the fair market value (also known as True Gash Value)?
$306,000
Muitiply the True Cash Value by .5 and enter here. This is your contention of Assessed Value.
$153,000
if you belleve the Taxable Value differs from your contention of Assessed Value, enter your contention of Taxable Value.Page 6
STATE OF MICHIGAN
GRETCHEN WHITMER
DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS
MARLON I. BROWN, DPA
GOVERNOR
LANSING
DIRECTOR
Charles and Amanda Foglesom
,
MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL
Petitioner(s)
v
MTT Docket No.24-003666
Township of Egleston
A
Respondent(s)
PROGCFE OF SERVICE
Michelle Ercole
states that on November 12th, 2024
he/she
[Name of person serving/mailing petition]
[date of service]
served a copy of the Mshigan
Tax Tribunal Answer For
relative to the above-captioned matter upon:
[Provide name and address of the party/people being served]
Michigan Tax Tribunal
611 W. Ottawa St.
Lansing, MI 48933
on
(Miele
Cnee
[Signature of person who is serving/mailing copy]
{ny Neg,
Ex Cove
[Print/type name of person serving/mailing copy]Page 7
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON |, BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Charles and Amanda Foglesom , MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL Petitioner(s) v MTT Docket No.24-003666 Township of Egleston Respondent(s) PROOF OF SERVICE Michelle Ercole states that on November 12th, 2024 he/she [Name of person serving/mailing petition] [date of service] served a copy of the Mihigan Tax Trisunal Answer Fomn relative to the above-captioned matter upon: [Provide name and address of the party/people being served) Charles and Amanda Fogleson 4405 Krystallee Dr Muskegon, MI 49442 NN clade Caemie [Signature of person who is serving/mailing copy] (MN Chelle Eveole [Print/type name of person serving/mailing copy]
Page 8
11/12/2024 01:56 PM 2024 BOARD OF REVIEW DECISION FROM .EGELSTON TOWNSHIP MUSKEGON COUNTY EQUALIZATION 173 E APPLE AVE STE 201 MUSKEGON MI 49442 NAME AND ADDRESS OF OWNER OR PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION: (Parcel Code required. Property address and legal description optional.): 11-161-000-0019-00 FOGLESON CHARLES/AMANDA 4405 KRYSTALLEE DR 4405 KRYSTALLEE DR MUSKEGON MI 49442 THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED 401 (RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED) Thank you for attending this years March Board of Review. The Board has reviewed the information you supplied and the data necessary to compute your assessment and taxable value. The Board has completed their review of parcel number 11-161-000-0019-00 They have made the following determination based on the information you supplied. Board of Review Comments ADJUSTED ASSESSED VALUE DUE TO COMPARABLES [2024 ORIGINAL ASSESSED VALUE 159,000 | 2024 "BOARD OF REVIEW" ASSESSED VALUE 153,000 | (If the above amounts are the same, no revisions have occured) 2024 ORIGINAL TAXABLE VALUE 143,115 2024 "BOARD OF REVIEW" TAXABLE VALUE 143,115 2024 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION/QUALIFIED AG 100.0000 Please feel free to contact the assessor at the address listed above or call if you have any questions, 231-724-3475 If you disagree with the decision of the Board of Review, further appeal may be made to the Michigan Tax Tribunal by May 31 for Commercial Real, Industrial Real, Developmental Real, Commercial Personal, Industrial Personal and Utility Personal Property by July 31 for Agricultural Real, Residential Real, Timber - Cut Over Real, and Agricultural Personal Property. Effective March 1, 2013 the Tribunal is no longer able to accept Small Claims letter appeals. Rather, you are required to file a petition to initiate a new appeal. Petition forms are
Page 9
Michigan Depatnnt of Treasury THIS IS NOT A TAX BILL L-4400 Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification This form is issued under the authority of P.A. 206 of 1883, Sec. 211.24 (c) and Sec.211.34¢, as amended. This is a mode) assessment notice to be used by the local assessor. FROM EGELSTON TOWNSHIP PARCEL IDENTIFICATION MUSKEGON COUNTY EQUALIZATION PARGEL NUMBER: 11-161-000-0019-00 173 E APPLE AVE STE 201 MUSKEGON Mi 49442 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 4405 KRYSTALLEE DR MUSKEGON, Mi 49442 OWNER'S NAME & ADDRESS/PERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION OGLESON CHARLES/AMANDA % Exempt As "Homeowners Principal Residence": 100.00% F SO % Exempt As "Qualified Agricultural Property": 00% 4405 KRYSTALLEE DR % Exempt As "MBT Industrial Personal™: 00% a . bl 0 MUSKEGON MI 49442 y ; i % Exempt As "MBT Commercial Personal”: .00% Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property": 1 Yes No Exempt As "Development Property”: [1 Yes No LEGAL DESCRIPTION: EGELSTON TOWNSHIP LOT 19 BELLE OAKS PARK #1 ACCORDING TO MCL 211.34c THIS PROPERTY IS CLASSIFIED AS: 401 (RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED) PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION: 401 (RESIDENTIAL-IMPROVED) The change in taxable value will increase/decrease your tax bill for the 2024 PRIOR AMOUNT CURRENT TENTATIVE CHANGE FROM year by approximately: $221 YEAR: 2023 AMOUNT YEAR: 0 PRIOR YEAR To 1. TAXABLE VALUE: 136,300 143,115 6,815 2. ASSESSED VALUE: 136,300 159,000 22,700 3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR: 1.000 : 4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV): 136,300 153,000 22,700 5. There WAS or WAS NOT a transfer of ownership on this property in2023 WAS NOT 6. Assessor Change Reason(s): Market Adjustment The 2024 Infiation rate Multiplier is: 1.05 Questions regarding the Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification may be directed to the Following: Name: Phone: Email Address: DONNA VANDERVRIES (231) 724-3475 ERCOLEMI@CO.MUSKEGON.MLUS March Board of Review Appeal Information:
Page 10
sxxPO93URIEND JOU ING STYRT 08T0°18 005‘€8 006°SL l0o00‘s 1202 0169 ‘€8 007 ‘16 00% ‘es 0008 [440k S00€ ‘9¢€T 00€‘9¢€T 0og’szt 0008 €20¢C HEIN ¥I¥A 0T0Z/62/L0 WAY YHEINF ¥I¥d TT0Z/ST/Z0 €¥D ATATY ¥SEA ZZ0Z/ET/SO REAE FE UBBTYOTH "6002 - OSTT’E¥T W000 ‘EST 000‘6ST 002°0ST 0088 vz0e IBUM uaym snTeA aTqexe] T3430 /Teunqrag maTARY J0 paeog snreA passassy anTea butprTng snTep puet IEBSX VIVO IIV/ONITTEMA JS ZEET 1L66T/0T/T0 PenSSI ‘ITT0-6TWE 3TWred x0y uoT3dIIosad iIom O/¥ EOVTIdEY :6T0Z/0T/G0 PonssI ‘9T9¢€ 3ITWISg I07 uoT3adTIAOSSQ fIOM UTBTd POOTd puerism suta®y Juoxzasjey puog papooy duremg padeospueT ubTH MOT buttronw T9487 oum 2 8371S Jo Aydexbodoyg, *STT3N punoxbrspun SSTITTTIN PIepuels SIUBTT 399138 qand ses| x ¥LT'9 = 9NTBA USED oni] sjuswasorxdwI pueT PO3eWT3ISH TeIOL | oTIy08TE| X S8€E Ly 821 0v°9 318I0U0D GE :d/M/Q | Tomas 68L'S LS L8ST 079 ®38I0U0D GE ::d/M/Q Ie3epm enTeA ysed Poon g 3zT§ a3ey uot3drIosaqg ERI ATeMIPTS S83PWTISH 350) JusweAoxdul puet FSNoF MAGE PROY: DOARE| X 009°LT = onTep pueT °"3s¥ TEIOL ~~ §9IOY TeIOL €8°0 ‘399 IUOIZ Ten3dy 0GT Gi pss 009 LT 00T 009LT IDYUYT YEIXE <d SUTBA S3TS> S antTeA uosesy -[pyg @3ey vyadsq 3uoxi yidsq obejuoxd uoTadTIosaq s3juswaaoxduy x SI030BI « oTTqnd TYIINEAISEY TYEENED 60° TN" 60° Td SIRI PUBRT IO S9JPWTISH SnTBA pue] Jueoes] | paaoxdur T - - ; 6°9%2 ¥L/ADL £90‘8TE ADL ISH 7202 | | 00-6TO-SET-TT :# WW FIFTINOD| 9T9€| L66T/0T/2Z0 SONILOOI 2202/22/70 $00T "d"¥'d HLITINOD TITO0-6TWd| 6T0Z/0T/S0O TYOINVHOHAN STOOUDS OTTAnd SBPTIYRO :TOOUDS sn3eas TaqumN s3eq (s)aTwzeg burping Td :HUTUOZ| OWAWI-TYIINEAISHY :SSBTD 0°0 | agEd 96T/E06€E ¥EHIO/JESN ION-TZ am] 1102/90/50 0 | vorwmWv #0 sEIVIS T 0°00T | YEASNVML AI¥Ed0¥d €SL/LT6E MEHIO/AESA ION-TIZ u10| 2102/90/90 000‘8L T XET 0°00T | wmasnwaz AL¥IJ0dd 8ES/¥BTIV HIONIAT S.,WI¥-£0 am| 6102/S2/€0 [000 771 YHINYWYS/MEIHLIVN T 0°00T | ¥HASNVEL AI¥EI0¥d 069/68Z% HIONAT §.¥Y-€0 an zzoz/81/20 00§‘zog YANVWY/SETIVHO N ssueig, . Kg sbeg » odAg a3eq ®0Tad | | *quoxg PITITISA I9qTT 8TEBS JO swIaj “3sur aTes sTesS | yzoz/eT/1t uo pajuTIg NODEMSAW :4A3unod dTHSNMOL NOLSTIDHE 1UOTIOTPSTANL
Page 11
7202/21/11 Uo PolUTIA ———— $0°3'41"E 240.00 00'0ST M 95 LE LBS 1/W oe gg” JLIS I “ON Jlied s)eQ ajjog. 61 107 ,00°08T 3.95 LE oL8 N ~1q 29fje1sAy xxxPOV3URIENS JOU Ing START N O° 3' 41" W 240.00" obeul puer
Page 12
£xxDODIURIENS
J0U ING STYRT
7
{
rus
682767
ADD <= 00€°T (TVIINGATSTY TYHENED) 303
i
iswelT mg dum
rs9j30N
|
=
jroddng
9Le‘9ze
£08°2LZ
isTe30L
gis 152 0002)
gy
53000
OEY
TES
T
Fauedo x00Q
:
1=0
000T)
1
as
9vL 1
951 2-
T
TTeM
T :TTeM uowwoD
ITom TS3EM
11
(@)
sz00q
I9MRG
OTTANG
S06791
9LE’0T
828
380) esey
zoqey OTTAN
Is
(P9USTUTIUA)
YOUI
81
:UOTIBPUNOZ BUTPTS
:JIOTISIXE
O
:SSBTD
:
AS
~~ uoT
sobeies
Tamag/xe%en
($1)
YSTUTI
*
99Z'v
8€S’Y
07e
boos peaesay
ued
3USA
S00TI
12°20 | sa0DTY GNI DTWRIRD
Li9~
98
88
MOTTEUS :UOTIPPUNOA
| sutem o1TI oTwesen
poem
SLE'T
8EV‘T
88
(Az038
TI)
400
TOOTH TTL OTwWeIs)
-5uo
seuvIod
T3m0Ys s3eredeg
¥o0
vI1°2
019 ‘2
1
388%
0G
‘TToM I9jem
JUTS BIE
T
828°¢
9zZL'y
1
o1ades TED 000T
19TTOL BIIXT
IoMaS/ 19M
putqunta
oN
87.
£26
T
UTS ©IIXE
qeey Tajey IeTOS
0°0
:S3STO
989°¢
YIS‘Y
1
Yirg SINIXTI
€
TenueH
‘Isus3iyos
4
buteumTg
oqny
‘zouslIOS
"3'
€18'%€
SEO ‘LE
£901
vOIY BUTATT juswesey
yleg oInixTd
7
“d°S
BE
$3usWISTLPY/SUOTITPPY 29430
UiPg SIMIXTA
£)
T
TOT
797091
POT '86T
1TR3I0N
{s})sxnixTy aberoay
8871
Jusussed
butpts
Azo3s
1
Ps
3500
-adeqg
MBN 1500
°2ZTS§
uoTjepUnCd
IOTISIXT
$9TI01S
-
UTM
(£1)
T8/00T/00T/00T/T8=P00Y
& *CqUOD/UCDE/OuUNI/Ayd
q¥/Aua
|
.
0
88ZT
= ©3IY X00Td
AS
8821
= ©9IY pPUNOIH
;
$391300
2218 3°
ON
TOOD
3 3BSH P8oIod
:welsAg butiesy
(TT)
|
PFOIX
TEE
L66T 3Td
§
D
STD
Xd0LS
T
ATTwed ofburs
T
:HpTE
"69Y I0F
"ISH
3ISOD|
$eInIXTA
JO
-TEUD/ ON
+ zoo
we3sdg A3ranosg
sorazag
sdug|{p0T
resxy 3z0dTED
682/V6Z ADL DOIRWTISE
ron0eduon
eens
STa30eTE
(21)
00E"T
X
9.£792Z
:31s0p ade
Te3OL
7
—
:oberen juwsd|
-g-5-g
£08°7LT
:
MeN ssed TeloL
5
Funes
SOBUINL POOM|
Lg.
¥X |D
6877
teexy xoors
°SPUTY UESID ITs
ITY [RIIUBD|
-
0
110073
"DUO ON
.
61
roby 081%
sbury paepuel§
BUTTO0D,/BUTIESH
ON
i
0
:eaxy aberols
:
6+
Dp
issETH
2ABMOIDTH
amg
aesy
s3
0
ipood
3
ea
TOOD
»
3¥3H POI
TT
826
1e9Iy
:
29 PIIUSA-308ITA
qng-Tdex Tzznoee
soRUINI T00Td/TTEM
UTW|
|
0
:sI00Q
"UDSK
£
84038 poop
qni tzznoep
T
:sIc0Q
‘oany
UlIeoy posed
wWoOISIUT
Jesy a
uoyae
1¢
PSYSTUTI
I0J3RTNOITD
JESH
POOH pelusa
(zooTI-w
JueTpEd
537
poom
ysuI
8
:UOTILPUNOF
Az03g
7
qezeaa
POOH p23jusaun
JjueTpey
‘1T8)
‘08TF
xe3serd!
Trem
T
:TTeM uowmod
£xo3g
1 gegsag
ang 30H
pIEOqRSRY OT1300TE|
0
-UBA QUOI
Az0ag
7
IOTIDIXET
weg USA
Toven Rom peoIod
0
usp YoTad
T0128
T
XOTABIXF
IP3ESH yard
lH
BUTPTS
:XOTISIXT
poom peesIiiorz
POPTS om
Tescedstq
obeqresn
morn
iid Poorod]
bueyzs
J
ISSBID
(AI03S
1)
dooigs
joel
|UWRG/PUZ
IYSEMUS TQ
a
rr
bueyzs
:Ratoede)
xen
A1018
7 zOTISIUT
dor %o0D
ipoom
uo
37T0ng ISR
adAriesav | Azo3s
1
z0TISIUL
*MOTTY @ouetTddy
{
{sen
¥
ybn
obexey
(LT)
| s3oeg/ssydIod
(971)
ssoerdeatd
(ST)
sut-37Tng
(g1)
|
Burroop/buriesH
(TI)
(-3uo
7202/21/11
uc p2UTIF
00~6700-000-1T9T-1T
:Idqumy ToDIBGPage 13
sxxPO93URIRBNS JOU INQ STURT 2 E 5 8 g = (91225 03 uMRIG 20N 203) 51861 .5°€ INOD © momowes = I’ AS J 0 \8 sos © a2 a J g z tS 350°828 H EER) 55 0°921. El LNSE-EFSL af 22 = 200 we “a 2 a ov ~ 150702 0L-2g- n am 0T ¥202/21/11 uo pPI3UTI T BUTPTTNE TeTIUSPTSe™
Page 14
Muskegon County Equalization 173 East Apple Avenue Suite 201 Muskegon, MI 49442 (Michiaan T Ll] Ww Of L-ONSIAS, M