Smith.pdf
Anita T Smith, Petitioner V Township Of Eaton Rapids, Respondent · 25-002644-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
RECEIVED JUN 04 2025 MICHIGAN Tax STATE OF MICHIGAN TRIBUNAL GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON |. BROWN, DPA SENRENIR LANSING DIRECTOR PROPERTY TAX APPEAL ANSWER FORM VALUATION / EXEMPTION / CLASSIFICATION APPEAL MTT DOCKET NO. Section 1: Respondent’s Contact Information First Name M.I. Last N, e . | C Vi thn Mailing Address (No., Street, P.Q, Box or Rural Route) ) [1828 5. Waverly City or Town State ZIP Code Loton Rapids mIl 49837 Telephone Number 301- (079-230 Email Address (do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email) Anaemia 33D womall- com Section 2: Respondent’s Attorney/Authorized Representative’s Contact Information First Name M.I Last Name Firm Name (if any) Mailing Address (No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route) City or Town State ZIP Code Telephone Number Email Address (do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email) Section 3: Subject Property Information Does the subject property have a Principal Residence Exemption of 50% or more? Iq ves O No Are the parcels listed by Petitioner contiguous or adjoining? If not, list which parcels adjoin one another. J Yes WK ve [J Not Applicable
Page 2
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON I. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Section 4: Explain Your Answer to this Appeal We have enced 2 Compavable properties, and +Hhese are @omparable Ho subject property Also enclosed 1S the most recent appredsal. Based on buywng our home ohite low inventory and Tow intevest rates, (We Peel Jheve 1S” evidence that proves hat we overpaid. Section 5: Jurisdictional Issues IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE TRUE CASH AND/OR TAXABLE VALUES 4 Did Petitioner protest the assessment at a Board of Review (BOR)? Pal Yes O No If yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: J March [| July [| December If no, was the Notice of Assessment properly sent to Petitioner prior to the March BOR? a Yes O No *Submit a copy of the Notice of Assessment with the Answer. I If the July or December BOR revised the assessment(s) at issue, did it have authority? [ml] Yes Bno If yes, cite the Board's authority. \_/ Was the assessment(s) at issue established as the result of a clerical error or mutual mistake of fact? O Yes Do If yes, explain Is Petitiongr appealing from a State Tax Commission Order? [J ves vo If so, what is the issue date?
Page 3
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON I. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Did Petitioner request a Poverty Exemption at a BOR? O Yes O No If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: O March Od July Od December List the date the BOR denied Petitioner’s Poverty Exemption: IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE DENIAL OF AN EXEMPTION OTHER THAN POVERTY, PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE, OR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL EXEMPTIONS Did Petitioner request the exemption at a BOR? [] Yes [0] No If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: [] March Od July O December Tax Year(s) denied: List the date the exemption was denied: What statutory section did Petitioner request the subject property be exempt? IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY What do you believe the classification should be: Real Personal (check one) a Agricultural Commercial Industrial Residential Timber-Cutover Developmental Utility (check one) Section 6: Valuation Information *use the multiple parcel form for additional, contiguous parcels. Parcel Identification Number: [30-045 -400-00]-13 Classification of Property: eal Personal (check one) Agricultural Commercial Industrial Resjdential Timber-Cutover Developmental Utility (check one) Current Assessed Value (also known as State Equalized Value) as established by the BOR: PASO, 500.00 Current Taxable Value as established by the BOR: $950, 500. OO What do you believe is the fair market value (also known as True Cash Value)? 3415,000 .00 Multiply the True Cash Value by .5 and enter here. This is your contention of Assessed Value. $ 42D, 000. OO Ifyou believe the Taxable Value differs from your contention of Assessed Value, enter your contention of Taxable Value. 4 H20, veo. 0 af a ape
Page 4
STATE OF MICHIGAN GRETCHEN WHITMER DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS MARLON |. BROWN, DPA GOVERNOR LANSING DIRECTOR Fee Information Does the subject property have a Principal Residence Exemption of at least 50% as of the date of the filing of this petition? Yes O No Are you appealing ONLY the denial of a Poverty Exemption or Disabled Veterans Exemption? ves O No If you answered yes to either or both of the above questions, you are not required to pay any filing fees. The filing fee is based on the greater of the State Equalized Value or Taxable Value In contention. If you are appealing more than one parcel, the parcel with the highest State Equalized Value or Taxable Value in contention will be used to determine your filing fee, plus $25.00 will be added for each additional parcel being appealed, not to exceed a total filing fee of $1,000. If your property is residential property (see MCL 205.762) and the State Equalized Value or Taxable Value in contention is: Filing Fee is: $100,000.00 and under $125.00 $100,000.01 to $500,000.00 $200.00 $Over $500,000.00 $300.00 If your property is NOT residential property (see MCL 205.762) and the State Equalized Value or Taxable Value in contention is: Filing Fee is: $100,000.00 and under $250.00 * Plus $25.00 for each additional parcel, as indicated above. If your property is NOT residential property and the State Equalized Value or Taxable Value in contention is $100,000.01 or greater the appeal does not qualify for Small Claims. Therefore, an Entire Tribunal petition must be filed. Signature *gequired _ bf ADF). THE FIT] 1 Ged
Page 5
May 26, 2025 To: Michigan Tax Tribunal RE: 1838S. Waverly Rd., Eaton Rapids MI To Whom It May Concern, | am writing on behalf of Chris and Anita Smith. They purchased their home at 1838 S.Waverly Rd. in Eaton Rapids at a time when there was little inventory and interest rates were low. | believe these facts caused them to overpay for this home. In researching the current value, | found homes with more features and square footage for considerably less than they paid when they closed on their home. | have been a real estate broker for over 40 years in the greater Lansing area. | do, however work primarily in the Eaton Rapids area. If | can be of any further assistance please to call me. Sincerely, 4 Z p 4 go cf Ly n Ball, Broker Afrowhead Realty (517) 202-6489
Page 6
Michigan Department of Treasury
Form 618, Page 2
FOR BOARD OF REVIEW USE ONLY
INSTRUCTIONS: Incorporate a copy of this form and the assigned number in the Board of Review minutes.
Parcel Code
Petition Number
i
120-025-400-001-13
1. ASSESSED VALUE
Disposition by Board of Rexjew. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below.
[7]
penied
Assessed Value Changed From;
ENT)
ro:
|
A850, 500
Record of Vote - Board or three member. committee of board
=n No TRE.
Member:
Bl
oves
[Jno DIM pember:
ves
[1 NaS
Chairperson;
YES
ha
p
n =
initials
initials
Reason for Board Action:
Due
79
REE
OF
1HaTn&
It you disagree with the decision of ihe Board of Review regarding tentative assessed value, you may appeal that decision by filing a petition with the Michigan Tax Tribunal at
£.0.1ox 30232, Lansing, Mi. 48809. Commercial Real, Industrial Real, Developmental. Real, Commercial Persanal, industria Personal and Wiility Personal Property may be
appealed by May 31. Agricultural Real, Residentiat Real, Timber - Cut Over Real, and Agricultural Personal Property may be appealed by July 31. ‘The petition must be filed on
2 Mictigan Tax Tribunal for-or a form approved by the Michigan Tax Tribunal. Michigan Tax Yribunal forms are available at www.rnichigan.govitaxtfib.
2. TENTATIVE TAXABLE VALUE
Disposition by Board of Review. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below.
[1
Denied
=
Tentative Taxable Value Changed From:
T1600
oo;
Record of Vote
- Board or three member committee of board,
2450, boo
Member:
PJ ves
[7]
no 011
Member.
[3 ves
[7] nose
\
Chairperson:
ves
{1
no
lia
Reason for Board Action:
DUE
To
RELE
OF
Homme
If you disagree with the decision of the Board of Review regarding fentative taxable value, you may appeal that decision by filing a petition with the Michigan Tax Tribunal at
P.O. Box 30232, Lansing, Mi. 48909. Commercial Real. Industrial Real, Developmental Real, Commerclat Personal, Industrial Personal and Utility Personal Property may be
appealed by May 31. Agricultural Real, Residential Reat, Timber
- Cut Over Real, and Agricultural Personal Property may be appealed by July 31. ‘The petition must be filed
on a Michigan Tax Tribunal for or a form approved by the Michigan Tax Tribunal. Michigan Tax Tribunal forms are avaiable at www.michigan.govitaxirib.
3. CLASSIFICATION
Disposition by Board of Review. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action below.
OJ
Denied
[|
Classification Changed From:
401
To:
Record. of Vote - Board or three member committee of board.
Chairperson:
[1 YES
[J Noms
Member:
(J ves
[J
NO
“fis
Member:
[1
ves
[1
No wis
Reason for Board Action:
\f you disagree with tho dacision of the Board of Review regarding classification, appeal is made by sending Form 2167 to the State Tax Commission, .0. Box 30471, Lansing, Mi 48903 by June 30.
4. QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL PROPERTY EXEMPTION
Disposition by Board of Review. The Board of Review must state the reason for its action befow.
I!
Exemption Request Denied
In
Exemption percent modified from
% To:
%
Record of Vote - Board or three member committee of board.
] NO—____Page 7
eT THIS IS NOT A TAX BILL L-4400 Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification This form Is issued under the authority of P.A. 206 of 193, Sen. 214,24 (c) and $50.241.34¢, sb arnanded. This is a mode} essassment notics to ba used by the local assessor, FROM EATON RAPIDS TOWNSHIP ASSESSOR PARCEL IDENTIFICATION DIANE DOWLER PH 810 635 9596 . y .001- 11238 REID RD PARCEL NUMBER: 120-025-400-001-13 SWARTZ CREEK, MI! 48473-8516 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1838 S WAVERLY RD EATON RAPIDS, Mt 48827 PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE EXEMPTION GWNER'S NAME & ADDRESSIPERSON NAMED ON ASSESSMENT ROLL: SMITH, ANITA THERESA/ CHRISTOPHER A % Exempt As "Homeowners Principal Residence”: 100.00% 1838 8 WAVERLY RD % Bom As "Qualified aut Property’: 00% EATON RAPIDS Mi 48827 % Exempt As "MBT Industria Personal” 00% % Exempt As "MBY Commercial Personal”: 00% Exempt As "Qualified Forest Property": [J Yes No Exempt As "Development Property”: [J Yes [X] No LEGAL DESCRIPTION: COM E 1/4 COR SEC 25; S0°0933'€ 871.88 FT TO POB; S0°09'33'E 210 FT; $89°38"14"W 440.17 FT; NO°09" 33'W 210 FT; N89°39'14"E 440.17 FT TO POB, SUBJ TO ALL EASEMENTS & RESTRICTIONS IF ANY. SEC 25, T2N,R3W, EATON RAPIDS TWP. 1 7-05 (ADJUSTMENT) ACCORDING TO MCL 211,34c THIS PROPERTY 1S CLASSIFIED AS: 401 Residential PRIOR YEAR'S CLASSIFICATION: 401 Residential The change in taxable vatue will increase/decrease your tax bill for the 2025 PRIOR AMOUNT CURRENT CHANGE FROM ; TENTATIVE AMOUNT TH year by approximately: $144 YEAR: 2024 YEAR: 2026 JAA 1. TAXABLE VALUE: 272,800 277,600 4,800 2, ASSESSED VALUE: 272,800 277,600 4,800 3. TENTATIVE EQUALIZATION FACTOR: 1.000 =v 4. STATE EQUALIZED VALUE (SEV): 272,800 277,800 4,800 5, There WAS or WAS NOT a transfer of ownership on-this property in2024 WAS NOT 6. Assessor Change Reason: Market Adjustment The 2025 Inflation rate Muitiplier Is: 1.031 Questions regarding the Notice of Assessment, Taxable Valuation, and Property Classification may be directed to the Following: Name! Phone: Ema! Address: DIANE DOWLER (810) 635-9596 DDE5YE@ YAHOO.COM
Page 8
8608 Katelin Drive, Eaton Rapids, MI 48827 261669 Residential Closed $4do0,b00 Zh a AF County: Eaton Lot Acres: | whip - ys City: Eaton Rapids Lot Size undefinedxundefined Key: combo Dimensions: y Township/Tax Hamilton Twp School District: Eaton Rapids Authority: Subdivision: None Property Sub- Single Family Home Warranty: No Type: Residence Reserved Items: No Entry Level: 1 Year Built: ( Entry Location: Front Door Occupancy: \ / | List Price: $430,000 Building Area 4,496 / Baths Full - Total: 2 Total SqFt: | Baths Half - Total: 0 Total Livable 2,248 | Baths - Total: 2 Area: | Bedrooms Total: 4 Association Fee Annually £ Pool Private: Yes Frequency: Association Fee/Yr: 8608 Katelin Drive Directions: Spicerville to Durfee to Katelin, Home is at the dead end Legal: COM N 1/4 COR SEC 9; S01(DEGREES)53'54"W 660 FT ALONG N-S 1/4 LINE TO POB; S87(DEGREES)38'17"E 330 FT; S39(DEGREES)24'06"E 392.88 FT, S01(DEGREES)51'19"W 105 FT, S87(DEGREES)46'31"W 80.2 FT; SO01(DEGREES)51'19"W 261 FT, N87(DEGREES)36'23"W 509.59 FT; NO1(DEGREES)53'54"E 665.19 FT TO POB. SUBJ TO ALL EASEMENTS & RESTRICTIONS. SEC 9, T1N,R3W, HAMLIN TWP. 10-3-05 (ADJUSTMENT) Parcel #: 23-160-009-200-010-13 Tax Year: 2023 State Eq Value: $175,200 Taxable Value: $175,200 Taxes: $4,198 Zoning: Residential #Full Baths Level 3: 0 #Full Baths Level 2: 0 #Full Baths Level 1: 2 #Full Baths Level B: 0 #Half Baths Level 3: 0 #Half Baths Level 2: 0 #Half Baths Level 1: 0 #Half Baths Level B: 0 Level 1 Finished Area: Level 2 Finished Area: 0 Level 3 Finished Area: 0 Below Grade Finished Area: 0 Above Grade Finished Area: 2,248 SqFt - Basement: 2,248 Room Name Level Dimensions Room Remarks Room Name Level Dimensions Room Remarks Features Features Primary First 15x15 Bedroom2 First 13.9x 13.4 Bedroom Bedroom3 First 10x10 LivingRoom First 20x 16 Bedroom4 First 11x 10.9 Dining Room First 11x11 _ Kitchen First 22x 8 0 Assocation Amenities: Maintenance Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Electric Oven; Electric Range; Electric Water Heater; Stainless Steel Appliance(s); Water Heater Basement: Concrete; Full Current Financing: Conventional Cooling: Central Air DPR: DPR Eligible: No Electric: 100 Amp Service Exterior: Brick; Vinyl Siding Flooring: Carpet; Ceramic Tile; Hardwood; Vinyl Fencing: Back Yard; Chain Link Fireplace Features: Fireplace Total: 1; Bedroom; Family Room; Gas Heating: Forced Air; Natural Gas F JO Wall ust vile [ 0,000 Land & Ps— 5+ thru 10 Ata Lot Features: Agricultural; Back Yard; Front Yard; Landscaped; Many Trees; Private; Secluded; Wooded Laundry Features: Laundry Room; Main Level Levels: One Other Structure: s), S Parking Features: Gal ces: riveway Patio & Porch Features: Deck; Porch Pool Features: Above Ground Property Use: Primary Roof: Shingle Road Frontage Type: Private Road Showing Requirements: Occupied Road Surface Type: Paved Sewer: Septic Tank Terms: Cash; Conventional; FHA; FMHA - Rural Housing Loan; MSHDA,; VA Loan Architectural Style: Ranch Utilities: Cable Available; Natural Gas Available; Sewer Connected PD “>
Page 9
4951 Ferris Road, Onondaga, MI 49264
280929
Residential Closed
$431,200
| County:
Ingham
Lot Acres:
A
{ City:
Onondaga
Lot Size Dimensions: 331x1331
Key:
open
School District:
Eaton
Township/Tax
Onondaga
Rapids
Authority:
Subdivision:
None
i Property Sub-Type:
Single Family
Home Warranty:
Ye!
Residence
Reserved Items:
oo
List Price:
$444,900
Year Built:
§l
Baths Full - Total:
~~
3
Occupancy:
Baths Half - Total:
0
Building Area Total
4,532
Baths - Total:
3
SqFt:
Bedrooms Total:
5
Total Livable Area:
3,399
Association FeelYr:
Directions: Aurelius Rd. West on Ferris, On North
side oh oad
:
Legal:
© 3-5W
1/2 of W 1/2 SW 1/4 SEC
3,
Sd
abr Loa FA EER
3
:
6,
es
CoH
(oh
4951 Ferris Road
FM
Parcel #:
33-13-13-03-100-008
Tax Year:
2023
Taxes:
/ 119.64
State Eq Value: $187.900
Taxable Value: $119,587
Zoning: Residential
#Full Baths Level 3:
0
#Half Baths Level 3:
0
Level 1 Finished Area: =e
#Full Baths Level 2:
0
#Half Baths Level 2:
0
Level 2 Finished Area:
0
#Full Baths Level 1:
2
#Half Baths Level 1:
0
Level 3 Finished Area:
0
#Full Baths Level B:
1
#Half Baths Level B: 0
Below Grade Finished Area: 1,133
Above Grade Finished Area: 2.266
SqFt - Basement:
2.266
Room Name Level Dimensions Room
Remarks
Room Name
Level
Dimensions Room
Remarks
Features
Features
Primary
First
18.42 x
Bedroom 2
First
11.42 x
Bedroom
16.58
12.17
Living Room
First
13.58 x
Bedroom 3
First
11.42 x
16.42
10.67
Dining Room
First
9.9x 12.5
Bedroom 4
Basement 11.42 x
Laundry
First
12.42x 558
14.67
Bedroom 5
Basement13.75x
14.67
Kitchen
First
11.42 x
16.83
Other
First
11.42 x 8.83
Breakfast Nook
Other
Basement38.9 x 14.67
Rec Room
Appliances: Disposal; Electric Range; Gas Water Heater; Ice Maker;
Land & Acreage: Up to 1/4 Acre; 1/4+ thru 1/2 Acre; 1/2+ thru
1 Acre;
Microwave; Plumbed For Ice Maker; Range; Range Hood;
1+ thru 2 Acres; 2+ thru 5 Acres; 5+ thru 10 Acres
Religerstor Self Cleaning Oven; Stainless Steel Appliance(s); Vented
Lot Features: Back Yard; Front Yard; Many Trees; Private
Heater; Water Softener Owned
Laundry Features: Laundry Room; Main
Level; Sink
Basement; Corcrgl
le; Egress Windows; Exterior Ef
Finished; Full/
Levels: One
oe
ces:
.
Other Structures: Kennel/Dog Rurf;
Pole Barn
Cooling: Central Air
Parking Features: Garage Spaces: Bs
©, Garage Door Opener;
+
“Eligible: No
.
Garage Faces Front
Exterior Features: Dock; Kennel; Lighting; Rain Gutters
Patio & Porch Features: Deck; Front Porch; Patio
Electric: 200+ Amp Service; 220 Volts in Workshop; Circuit Breakers
Property Use: Primary
Exterior: Vinyl Siding
Roof: Shingle
Flooring: Carpet; Laminate; Tile
Sewer: Septic Tank
Foundation Details: See Remarks
Terms: Cash; Conventional
Heating: Forced Air; Propane
Utilities: Electricity Connected; High Speed Internet Available; High
Interior Features: Cathedral Ceiling(s); Crown Molding; High Ceilings; Speed Internet Connected; Natural Gas Connected; Phone Available;
Laminate Counters; Natural Woodwork; Pantry; Recessed Lighting;
Phone Connected; Propane; Sewer Connected; Underground Utilities;Page 10
11490 Wilbur Highway, Eaton Rapids, MI 48827
219058
Residential Closed
$485,000
County:
Eaton
Lot Acres:
EP
Ls
City:
Eaton Rapids
Lot Size Dimensi
:
£5
i
Key:
combo
Frontage Length:
313
d
o So
1
,
Township/Tax
Eaton Rapids Twp
Waterfront:
No
|
i
»
—
‘
_, Authority:
School District:
Eaton
Vi
apo
Property Sub-Type:
Single Family
Rapids
ail
TTT
Residence
Elementary School
Eaton
i, dd sl [+]
Entry Level:
1
District:
Rapids
;
List Price:
$479,900
Subdivision:
None
Pos
Baths Full - Total:
~~ 3
Section #:
1
Baths Half - Total:
1
Home Warranty:
Yes
Baths - Total:
4
Reserved Items:
ro
Bedrooms Total:
3
Year Built:
19
Yan
Sil
Pool Private:
No
Occupancy:
@close
11490 Wilbur Highway
Spa:
No
Building Area Total
4,240
Cross Street:
Waverly
SqFt:
Total Livable Area:
3,710
Association FeelYr:
Directions: From M99- East on Wilbur, house on south side of street
Legal: COM. AT N 1/4 POST, S ON N&S 1/4 LINE 1403.2 FEET, WLY 313.5
FEET, N 1404.2 FEET PARALLEL WITH 1/4 LINE TO N SEC. LINE, E 313.5
FEET TO BEG. SEC. 1, T2N R3W, EATON RAPIDS TOWNSHIP
Parcel #:
23-120-001-100-035-00
Tax Year:
2022
Taxes:
$4,200
State Eq Value: $206,800
Taxable Value: $157,516
Zoning: Residential
~
N\
#Full Baths Level 3:
0
#Half Baths Level 3:
0
Level 1 Finished Area: thle”
#Full Baths Level 2:
0
#Half Baths Level 2:
0
Level 2 Finished Area:
#Full Baths Level 1:
2
#Half Baths Level 1:
1
Level 3 Finished Area:
[¢]
#Full Baths Level B:
1
#Half Baths Level B: 0
Below Grade Finished Area: 1,590
Above Grade Finished Area: 2,120
SqFt - Basement:
2,120
Room Name
Level
Dimensions Room
Remarks
Room Name Level
DimensionsRoom
Remarks
Features
Features
Primary
First
11.9x 16.4
Bedroom 2
First
12.4% 12.9
Bedroom
Bedroom 3
Basement12.6 x 10.7
Living Room
First
12.9% 20.6
Family Room First
23.4x20
Dining Room
First
11.5x 15.4
Kitchen
First
22x11
Other
Basement14.8 x 24.6
Appliances: Dishwasher; Microwave; Oven; Range; Refrigerator;
Land & Acreage: 10+ thru 20 Acres
Washer/Dryer; Water S
Lot Features: Back Yard; Front Yard; Landscaped; Many Trees;
Basement: Bath{Stubtbed; Crawl Space; Egress Windows; Finished;
Private; Wooded
Full; Sump Pump;
Walk-Out Access
Laundry Features: Laundry Closet; Main Level
Cooling: Central
Ai
Levels: One
DPR: DPR Eligible: No
Other Structures: Barn
Exterior Features: Private Yard; Rain Gutters
Parking Features:
e;
Electric: 150 Amp Service
Garage Faces Fron
Exterior: Brick
Patio & Porch Features: Deck Clss-Enslosed™
Flooring: Brick; Carpet; Slate; Tile; Wood
Pool Features: None
Fencing: None
Property Use: Primary
Foundation Details: Block
Roof: Shingle
Fireplace Features: Fireplace Total: 2; Basement; Gas; Living Room;
Road Frontage Type: County Road
Wood Burning
Security Features: Smoke Detector(s)
Heating: Forced Air; Natural Gas
Special Listing Cond: Trust
Interior Features: Beamed Ceilings; Chandelier; Crown Molding; Eat-
Spa Features: None
in Kitchen; High Speed Internet; Natural Woodwork; Pantry
Road Surface Type: Dirt
Improvements: Three Seasons Room
Sewer: Septic Tank
Terms: Cash; Conventional; FHA; FMHA - Rural Housing Loan; VAPage 11
Sold Price: $485,000 Sold Price/SqFt: 22877 Arrowhead Realty Arrowhead Reaity 108 S Main St. Suite C Eaton Rapids, MI 48827 517-202-6489 517-202-6489 Information is deemed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed. © 2025 and : . Prepared by Arrowhead Realty on Monday, May 19, 2025 9:30 AM. The information on this sheet has been made available by the MLS and may not be the listing of the provider.
Page 12
11815 Valdo Drive, Eaton Rapids, MI 48827 273584 Residential Closed $385,000 County: Eaton Lot Acres: 1.86 City: Eaton Rapids Lot Size Irreg Township/Tax Eaton Rapids Twp Dimensions: Authority: School Eaton Rapids Property Single Family District: Sub-Type: Residence Subdivision: None | Association Saratoga Woods Reserved No # Name: Private Road Assoc. Items: and Maint. Agmt Year Built: 2008 ist Price: $385,000 Occupancy: 60 | Baths Full - 2 Building 4,072 otal: Area Total aths Half - 1 SqFt: | Total: Total Livable 3,088 Baths - Total: 3 Area: — : Bedrooms 4 Association Saratoga Woods Private = a Total: Name: Road Assoc. and Maint. 41815 Valdo Drive Agmt Association $500 Fee: Association Annually Fee Frequency: Association Fee/Yr: Front Door: Southeast Directions: S Waverly Road to Valdo Drive Legal: COM E 1/4 COR SEC 25; $89 44'53"W 1321.51 FT; SO 11°26"E 1063.42 FT, N89 48'34"E 75.94 FT, N52 49' 32'E 51.31 FT TO POB; NO 09'24"W 435.89 FT N89 50'36"E 184.65 FT; S65 43'40"E 162.33 FT, $38 31' 44"E 54.5 FT, 851 2816"W 109 FT, N38 31'44"W 33 FT, 851 28'16"W 125.29 FT, $36 29'068"W 239.31 FT, $52 49'32"W 24.16 FT TO POB. SUBJ TO ALL EASEMENTS & RESTRICTIONS IF ANY. SEC 25, T2N,R3W, EATON RAPIDS TWP. 4-11-03 (APPROVED PARCEL 10) Parcel #: 23-120-025-400-001-10 Tax Year; 2022 Taxes: $4,004.8 State Eq Value: $198,400 Taxable Value: $146,267 Zoning: Agricultural #F ull Baths Level 3: 0 #Half Baths Level 3: 0 Level 1 Finished Area: 2,036 #Full Baths Level 2: 0 #Half Baths Level 2: 0 Level 2 Finished Area: 0 #Full Baths Level 1: 1 #Half Baths Level 1: 1 Level 3 Finished Area: 0 Below Grade Finished Area; 1,052 Above Grade Finished Area: 2,036 #Full Baths Level B: 1 #Half Baths Level B: 0 SqFt - Basement: 2,036 Room Level DimensionsRoom Remarks Room Name Level Dimensions Room Remarks Name Features Features Primary First 13.1 x 18.6 Bedroom 2 First 159x112 Bedroom Bedroom 3 Basement13.2 x 12 Living Room First 19x 16.3 Bedroom 4 Basement 13.2 x 12 Dining First 15.6% 12.8 Bathroom 1 First 13.6x7 Room Bathroom 2 First 7x41 Half Bath Laundry First 8.6x7.1 Bathroom 3 Basement13.2x 6.1 Workshop Basement17.4x 11.8 Kitchen First 134x9.8 Office First 13.6x8.1 Other First 1x8 Dinette Other First 136x738 Walk in Closet Other Basement23.9 x 17.1 Recreation Room Other Basement30.9x 17.8 Storage Other Basement10.2x7.8 Under First Floor Dinette
Page 13
Water Heater, Water Softener; Water Softener Owned; Other Basement: Daylight, Egress Windows; Finished; Full; Partially Finished: Walk-Out Access; Walk-Up Access Community Features: None Current Financing: None Cooling: Central Air; Electric; Heat Pump DPR: DPR Eligible: No Exterior Features: Lighting; Private Yard; Rain Gutters; Other Electric: 200+ Amp Service; 220 Volts; 220 Volts in Garage; 220 Volts in Kitchen; 220 Volts in Laundry; Circuit Breakers; Generator, Underground Exterior: Brick; Vinyl Siding Flooring: Carpet; Ceramic Tile; Laminate, Linoleum; Simutated Wood, Tile; Varies; Vinyl; Wood Fencing: None Foundation Details: Other; See Remarks Fireplace Features: Factory Built; Glass Doors; Living Room; Metal Green Building Verification: Body: Great Lakes Home Performance; Metric: 54; Rating: Energy Star, 5 Stars; Source: See Remarks; URL: www.eehmidwest.com; Year: 2,008 Green Energy Efficient: Appliances; Construction; Doors; HVAC; Insulation; Lighting; Thermostat; Water Heater; Windows Green Indoor Air Quality: Moisture Control; Ventilation Heating: Central; ENERGY STAR Qualified Equipment; Fireplace(s); Forced Air; Humidity Control, Natural Gas Interior Features: Built-in Features; Ceiling Fan(s); Chandelier; Double Closet; Double Vanity; Eat-in Kitchen; High Ceilings; In-Law Floorplan; Kitchen Island; Laminate Counters; Pantry; Recessed Lighting; Solar Tube(s); Storage; Walk-in Closet(s) Patio & Porch Features: Covered; Deck; Front Porch; Porch; Rear Porch; Screened Property Use: Primary Roof: Shingle Road Frontage Type: Private Road Security Features: Carbon Monoxide Detector(s); Fire Alarm; Prewired; Security System Owned; Smoke Detector(s) Road Surface Type: Asphalt; Chip And Seal; Paved Sewer: Septic Tank Terms: Cash; Conventional; FHA; VA Loan Architectural Style: Traditional Utilities: Cable Not Available; Electricity Available; Electricity Connected; High Speed Internet Not Available, Natural Gas Available; Natural Gas Connected; Phone Available; Sewer Not Available; Underground Utilities; Water Not Available View: Forest; Pond; Trees/Woods; Water Window Features: Blinds; Double Pane Windows; Drapes; Low Emissivity Windows; Skylight(s); Window Treatments Water Source: Well Public Remarks: Welcome to your peaceful paradise! setting, surrounded by nature's beauty. This stunning 4 bedroom, With a full finished walkout basement, there's plenty of space to spread out and enjoy all the comforts 2 1/2 bath home is perfectly situated in a serene country of home. Relax and unwind in the screened sunroom, the perfect spot to take in the tranquil views of the pond and all the wildlife that calls it home. The dishwasher, refrigerator/freezer, and tankless hot-water heater are Energy Star qualified, and this home has a § Star Home Energy Rating Certificate. The basement walls are factory manufactured precast concrete by Superior Walls and there is a chimney installed suitable for a wood or pellet burning stove. The fireplace has gas piped in for future instaltion of gas logs and there Sold Date: 07/12/2023 Sold Price: $385,000 Sold Price/SqFt: 189.1 Arrowhead Realty Arrowhead Realty 109 S Main St. Suite C Eaton Rapids, MI 48827 517-202-6489 517-202-6489 llynn33@gmait.com Information is deemed to be reliable, but is not information on this sheet has been made availa aranised. © 2025 MLS and FBS. Prepared by Arrowhead Realty on Sunday, May 18, 2025 8:41 PM. The le by the MLS and may not be the listing of the provider.
Page 14
<5 Lod 1838 S'Waverly Road, Eaton Rapids, MI 48827 = AQ BZ $465,000 Zr2908 Residential Closed : 1 County: Eaton Lot Acres: | City: Eaton Rapids Lot Size Dimensions: 210x440. 17 | Key: Combo Frontage Length: 210 | Township/Tax Eaton Rapids Twp School District: Eaton Rapids Authority: Elementary School Eaton Rapids Property Sub- Single Family District: Type: Residence Subdivision: None Entry Level: 1 Section #: 25 Entry Location: Front Door Home Warranty: Yes List Price: $475,000 Reserved Items: No Baths Full - Total: 2 Year Built: Baths Half - Total: 0 Builder Name: Aarowhead * Baths - Total: 2 Homes Bedrooms Total: 3 Occupancy: TBD Pool Private: No Building Area Total 4,280 ay y Spa: No SqFt: = = Ll Cross Street: Barnes Road Total Livable Area: ~~ 3,240 1838 S Waverly Road Association Fee/Yr: Front Door: "East Directions: Columbia Road to S. on Waverly Road, House on west side of Waverly Legal: COM E 1/4 COR SEC 25; S0 09'33"E 871.88 FT TO POB; S0 09'33"E 210 FT, S89 39'14"W 440.17 FT, NO 09' 33"W 210 FT; N89 39'14"E 440.17 FT TO POB. SUBJ TO ALL EASEMENTS & RESTRICTIONS IF ANY. SEC 25, T2N,R3W, EATON RAPIDS TWP. 1-7-05 (ADJUSTMENT) Parcel #: 23-120-025-400-001-13 Tax Year: 2021 Taxes: $4,392.7 N State Eq Value: $255,000 Taxable Value: $166,933 Zoning: Residential #Full Baths Level 3: 0 #Half Baths Level 3: 0 Level 1 Finished Area: 8 #Full Baths Level 2: 0 #Half Baths Level 2: 0 Level 2 Finished Area: ~.0 #Full Baths Level 1: 2 #Half Baths Level 1: 0 Level 3 Finished Area: i #Full Baths Level B: 0 #Half Baths Level B: 0 Below Grade Finished Area: 1,100 Above Grade Finished Area: 2,140 SqFt - Basement: 2,140 Room Level DimensionsRoom Remarks Room Name Level Dimensions Room Remarks Name Features Features Primary First 224 x 16.2 Carpet Bedroom 2 First 12.9 x 10.11 Carpet Floor Bedroom Floor Bedroom 3 First 12.8 x 12.7 Carpet Floor Office Primary First 13.8 x 10.3 Tile Floor Bedroom 4 Basement 15x 9.3 Carpet Floor Bathroom Bathroom 2 First 10.11 x 4.1 Tile Floor Living First 21x 18.4 Hardwood Family Room Basement22.5x 20.2 Carpet Floor Room Floor Kitchen First 19.1x13 Hardwood Dining First 14.5x 13.3 Tile Floor Floor Room Other Basement27.11 x 13.3 Laminate Billiards Room; laminate Landry: First 8. 1 x7 Vinyl Floor Floor wood Appliances: r—— [— Dryer; Electric Ov: ven, Elect Land & Acreage: 2+ thru 5 Acres Range; Gas Water Heater; Humidifier; Microwave; -Range; Lot Features: Back Yard; Front Yard; Landscaped; Many Trees; Refrigerator; Washer; Water Softener Private; Secluded; Wooded Basement: Bath/Stubbed; Egress Windows; Finish d; Full; Walk-Out \ Laundry Features: Laundry Room; Main Level; Sink Access Levels: One Cooling: Central Air Other Equipment: Generator DPR: DPR Eligible: No “Parking Features: Garage Spaces: 3; Driveway; Garage; Garage Exterior Features: Rain Gutters Door Opener; Garage Faces Side Electric: 200+ Amp Service Patio & Porch Features: Deck; Front Porch; Patio; Porch Exterior: Stone; Vinyl Siding Property Use: Primary Flooring: Carpet; Ceramic Tile; Laminate; Simulated Wood; Tile; Vinyl Roof: Shingle Foundation Details: Concrete Perimeter Road Frontage Type: County Road Fireplace Features: Living Room; Wood Burning Road Surface Type: Asphalt
Page 15
nasement includes 1 bedroom and additional living room with a sliding door out to the patio. Sold Date: 07/21/2023 Sold Price: $465,000 Sold Price/SqFt: 217.29 Arrowhead Realty Arrowhead Realty 109 S Main St Suite C Eaton Rapids, M| 48827 517-202-6489 517-202-6489 llynn33@gmait.com Information is deemed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed. © 2025 MLS and FBS. Prepared by Arrowhead Realty on Monday, May 19, 2025 9:24 AM. The information on this sheet has been made available by the MLS and may not be the fisting of the provider.
Page 16
APPRAISAL OF REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT: 1838 8 Waverly Rd See attached addenda. Eaton Rapids, MI 48827 FOR: United Wholesale Mortgage 585 S Blvd E Pontiac, MI 48341 AS OF: 0711012023
Page 17
Appraisals by Joanna Moray
f
:
n
202307-768
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report
Fle 1838 § Waverly Ro
The
59
of this summer
rélsal
report
is to
provide the lenidor/chent wih an accurate,
and
edequatel
red,
opinion
of the market valu
of the
st
Property
Ardress
erly Rd
City Eaton Rapids
Stats
Mi
ZpCods 48827
Bamower_Anfia & Chiistopher Smith
Qunet
of Public Resoxd
Anderson Family Living Trust
County Eaton
Legal
Description
See attached
addenda
Assessors Parcel #
120-025-400-001-13
Tax Year 2020
RE. Taxss$
4.393
hborhood Name
Ea
api
Map Relorence
28620
Gengus Tract 022
Occupant
BG Owner
|] Tenant
{| Vacam
Special Assosemenis$
QO
[1PUD _ HOAS ©
[por year
por month
Pioperty Rights Appraised
BY] Fes Simple
Leasshold
[3 Other (describe)
Assignment
Typ
1D) Purchase Transaction
Refinance Transaction
|
| Othet (describe)
Lendat/Chlalt
United Wholesale Mortgage
Address
_ 585 S Blvd E, Pontiac,
Mi 48341
Is the subjoct property curently oflerod for sala of has if been offered for sata in the twelve months prior to the affective dats of this appralsai?
Dives
[No
Report data source(s) used, oerlng price(s), end deaf).
DOM 33:Sublect property was offered for sale. Latest Price $475,000, atest Date
06/13/2023; Criginal Price
$480,000;0riginal Dale
05/10/2023;
Real
#630000272908
1 DG dd
[] cid not analyze the contract for sale for the subject purchase transaction. Ex
ites
of
says of the corti
or slo vy Bs anes is nt
formed.
Arm:
h
sate;l
have al
Col
for
Sale
and
the contract
price
appears
to
be the a
uy
al
estate,
nly
without any
other
valuable considerations
or conditions,
Contract Price $465,000
Dato of Gontradt 06/43/2023 _ Is hw property saber tho awner of public record?
DL Yes
[
[Mo
Dela Soures(s)
Assessor
Ts thet any financlal assistance (oan charges, sale concessions, ft or downpayment assistance, ele.) to bo paid by any party on behalf
of the borrasver?
[Yes
5 [0
If Yas, report tha total dollar amount and describe the lems to be paid,
30;
Note; Race and the raclal composition of the neighborhood are not eppralsal factors,
Nelghborhood Charsoteristios
Orie-Untt Housing Trends
One-Unft Housing
Present Land Use %
Location
_[_] Urban
Suburban
Rugal
Property Vales
|] Increasing
Stable
[] Dechiing
PRICE
AGE
| Ono-Unit
55%
BuitUp
[] Over 76%
25-76%
__[] Under 26%
|Domand/Supply
{| Shortage
In Balance
|] Over Sugply | $ (000)
yrs}
{2-4 Unit
1%
Growth
[] Rapid
Stable
Show
Marketing ime
Underdmths
[ }36mths
[J OverBmths | 385
Low
1
|MatiFemiy
1%
Nelghbiorhood Boundaries
The subject's neighborhood boundaries are [96 to the north, U$-127 to the
550
High
93
|Commerclal
3%
east, Bellevue Hwy to the south, and 1-69 to the wast.
.
389
Pred.
23
[Other
40%:
Ne
De
See attached addendum. The subject
is
located in the Eaton Rapids Public School District. The "other
present land use
refers to
vacant land, The
subject Is localed in an
a
ith
a mixture of home sfvies, ages. sizes, condition, and quality.
Market Conditions (inoluding support for tha sbove conchustons)
The subject is part of the Lansing regional market. General marketing time Is 0-3 months.
Diversions 210’ x 439°
hea 212 ac
Tape Rectangular
VW B.Res Woods
Spocific Zoning Classification
LA
Zoning Description
Limited Agricuffural
Zoning Compliance
D) Legal
[ ] Legal Noniconforming (Grandfathoved Use}
[] No Zosing [
] Hegel (describe)
Is the highest
ard bast uss of subjoct property as improved (oe &3 proposed por plang and specifications)
the present sa?
Xi Yes
[]No_HNo dmorde
See attached
addenda.
Utllitles
Public
Other (deacribe}
Public
Other (describe)
Off-aits brprovemsnts - Typs
Put
Private
Eloaricty
Water
DX Private Well
Strest Paved
Gag
Santry Sowst_[_]
I)
Private
Septic
Ney
None
FEMA Special Rood Hazard
Ares
Yes
Ho FEMA Rood Zona
FEMA Map #
FEMA Map Dato
11/26/2010
Ave the utilties and off-atta lprovaments typical for the market ares?
BC Yes
[No
if No, dessribe
Are thor any advasa sito conditions or extemal factors (easements, encroachments, environments) conditions, land ixses, tc)?
[Ye
No_
Hf Yes, deseilhe
There
were
no enicroa:
its
or adv
conditions
evident,
|
easements
for
public
utilities.
The subject
Is
located on a roal
xper
arate traffic thre
ut
thie ds
e
if
ol
rketabil
8
refle
in the location adjustments.
General Desorption
Foundation
Exterior Desorption
‘materials /condition | interior
materisls/oondiion
Units (38 Ons [| Ong wih Accessory
Unt
Concrete Stab
Grad Space
[Foundation Walls
Poured Concrete/Av_
Firs
Tile/HWIGrotAvg
# of Storias
1
& Ful Bagoment
Partial Basomond
{Exterior Walls
Viny[EriodAverade
Was
DrywalyAverage
|
Typo [3 Det. [1 Att
S-Det/End Unt _1Basement Area
2,039 seit
q
Avera
Exiting | Propossd |] Urder Const.
| Basement Fal
55%
Deg
a)
Quisida
Entry/Bxtt
Sump
P
Voor Built
2008
Evidenco of
[] Infestefon
None
Storm Seid
Thome Panciieg
Hfoclive
Aga (Yrs)
§
[1 Dampness
Settlement
Sarsons
lon/Avg
DQ rivoway
__# of Gary
1
Alle
Nome
Heating DQ FA
HWBB {| Radiant [Amenites
Woodstova(s)
#
©
j0rivawey Scface
Gravel
Drop Stat
[Stairs
Other
[Fost Gas
Fireplaces) #
1]
Fence Noy
Guge
#oi0us
3
Flaor
Souttie
Cooling
Central Alr CondiBoning
PatioDack _PT/0K X Porch Entry
Caport
~~ # of Garg
0
Finished
Hogted
Individual
[J Other
Pool None
Othe_None
At
Det.
Buift-in
Agplances |] Refigurtor
[7] Range/Oves_
BQ Dishwasher
_ DG) Disposal
8) Microwave
[| WasherDyer
_[] Dir (describ)
Fiolshed area above grado contains:
7_
Rooms.
2
Bedrooms
20
Bans)
2,039
Square Feat
of Gross Living Area Above Grate
Adgitiopal features {spell encegy efcknl Rems, ele).
No value fs aiven to personal property. See below for property detalls,Page 18
202307-766
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report
Fie# 1838 § Waverly Rd
Thetagte
5
comparable properties currently offered for sae in the sublect neighborhood ranging
In price from $
385.000
o§
515000
Thors ars
0
comparable galas in the subject neighborhood within
the past twelve months gig
J sh pk. fon
385,00
fof 549,900
FEATURE
SUBJEGT
COMPARABLE SAE # 1
PARABLE BALE #
COMPARABLE SALE #3
Address
1838 S Waverly Rd
1906 S Royston Rd
401 William Durfee Dr
8807 Bradford Rd
ide,
Mi 486827
Eaton Rapids, M} 48827
|Eaton Rapids, MI 48827
Eaton Rapids,
M1.48827
Proximity
to Sisbject
6.05 miles W.
4.87 rolles SW
4.77 miles SW
Salo Price
$
465.000)
$
400.000]
$
549.900
$
450,000]
Salo Prica/Gross Liv. Area
$
_22805%0f18
29510 saft
$281.36 sqft
5
176.06 sat
Data Source(s}
RCMLS#630000273014:D0M 4
IRCMLS#630000272679:D0M 42 |RCMLS#830000260268:D0M 151
Verification Source(s)
RC MLS / Assessor Records
Realcomp MLS/ Tax Data
RC
MLS /
Assessor R
S
VALUE ADJUSTMENTS
DESCRIPTION
DESCRIPTION
+{}$ Adjustment
DESCRIPTION
+()§ Adjustment
DESCRIPTION
+{) $ Adjustment
Sales of Financing
AmmiLth
Ami ih
ArmLth
Concessions
Cash
Conv:
VAD,
Date of Sale/ Tire
$06/23;605/23
806/23:c05/23
$03/23:¢01/23
Location
A:Res:BsyRd.__IN;Res:
-3.000{B:Res Stream
-5.000|N.Res:
3.000,
Leagehold/Feg Simple
Fee Simple
[Fes Simple
Fee Simple
Fee Simple
Sita
2.12.80
5.01a¢
-5,780[13.14 ac
-22,040/6.23 ac
-8,220
Vow
BRes:Woods
_|B:Res:Woods
B:Res:Woods
BResPstr
0
Design
(Style
DT1:Ranch
DTZ. Tradifional
0I0T1.5:Bunaam
Q{DT1:Ranch
Qualky of Construction
Q4
Q4
Q4
Q4
Actual Ago
17
24
0130
028
[)
Condition
C3
C3
C3
-20.000C3
420,000
Above Grado
Total
{Bdrms. | Bas | Totar
|Bams. | Baths
Tot) [Boms. | Baths
Tote
{Boms. | Baty
Roam Count
ti
2120]
7]
3
12%
-20000
7
| 3
130
4000:
8
|
3
[24
-2,000
Grass Living Area
2,039 sad.
1.777. 48
+0,170]
2.104 soft.
9
2.556 san.
18,095
Basement & finished
2039s11121sfwo | 1095610stwo
011504sf1504sfwo
0(2384sf1773sfwo
0
Rooms Bolow Grade
2 1bt0.0balo
11,240; 100br{ Obalo
3,830: 170br1.0bato,
6,620)
Functional Uiity
2 Bedroom
Average
-2,000 Average
-2.000{ Average
2.000
Fe] Hoating Cooling
FWAICA
FWAICA
FWACA
FWA/CA
PY enon font toms
ins/Win
tnsWin
TnsfWin
Insvin
fy Garage/Carpoit
3gatdw
2gaidw
45,000] 2ga2dw
+5,000|20a1dw
+5,000
[ag Porch/Patio/Dack
CvdPc, Dk CvPa {Pe Dk CvP EnP
-2.000|CvdPo Dk.CvPa
CvP. Dk Bal Cub
1.000]
[I
1E/P
EP
1EP
1 F/R
[4
Othe
None
Pole Bam
-10,000{None
None
a
ge] vet Acpstment (ota)
+
(1-8
goo
[J+
DO-
Is
52870]
[J+
-
I$
15.835
a Adjusted Sale Price
Not Adj.
02%
Net Adj.
06%
Nat Adj.
35%
I] of Comparables
Gross
Ad,
125%
1%
400,600]Gross Ad.
11.4% 8
497 030]6ross Ad).
14.8%($
434 165,
@
1
ad
| did not research the sale or transfer history of the subject property and comparable sakes. if nof, explain
My resowph
[] old
[3 did not reveal any prior sas or transfers of the subject property for th thes years prior
ta the effective dele of this appraisal.
Data Source(s)
__Realoomp MLS
/ PRD
My rosoarch
|) did
[3] did not reveal any prios sales of transfers of the comparable sales for the year prior to the date of sele of the comparable sala.
Dia Soute(s)
_Realcomp MLS / PRD.
Report
tha results of the research and analysis of the prior
sat or transfer history
of the subject property and comparable sales {repost additional prior sales on page 3).
EM
SUBJECT
COMPARABLE SALE #1
COMPARABLE SALE #2
COMPARABLE SALE #3
Date of Prior Sale/Fransfor
Price of Prior Sal/Transter
Data Source(s)
Realcomp MLS / Tax Data
[RC MLS / PRD
Realcomp MLS / Tax Datla
[RC MLS {PRD
Effoctivo Dats of Bata Source(s)
07/10/2023
07/10/2023
07/10/2023
07/10/2023
Analysts of prior sala or transfor fistory of the subject proporty and comparablo seks
The appraiser could not locate any prior sales or transfers within the
past 38 months for the sublect prior to the dale of inspection or 12 months prior to the date of sale for any comparable properties, unless listed
above.
Summary of Seles Comparison Approach
See attached addenda.Page 19
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report
Filo # 10.8 waverly Rd
LITIES
All of the utilities
were on and appeared
to be
in
working
order
at the
time
of the inspection,
UBL
WER AND WATER
Public
sewer
and water
are
not
currently avaifable
af the sublect properly per the
township, Well
and septic are common for the area
and
this
has
no effect on the
sublect's
markets
‘COSY APPROACH TO VALUE (not required by Fannie Mae)
Provide adequate knformation for the lender/cliait to repticate the below cost figures and calculations.
Sapport for the opinion of site value (sumenary of comparable land sales of other methods for estimating site value)
See attached atidenda.
EJESTMATED
[| REPRODUCTION OR
_[) REPLACEMENT COST NEW
OPINION OF SITE VALUE
20,000
poy Soros of cost data
DWELLING
pif usally rating from cost service
Effoctiva dite of cost data
b= Comments on Cost Apprasch (gross living ares caictdations, depraciaton, ete.)
Gajape/Camport
Soft @$
Total Estimate of Cost-Now
Loss
Physical
Femetional
Extemat
Depreciation
Depraclated Gost of Improvements
"As-ls" Value of Sits Improvements
ST
[ES
» Esfimated Remalning Ecosomic Life (HUD and VA only)
Years (INDICATED VALUE BY COST APPROACH
»
INCOME APPROACH YO VALUE (not required by Fannie Hae)
$3 Estimatod Monthly Maskot Ront
§
X Gross Rent Multiplier
=$
Indicated Value by Incoms Approach
b§ Sunmary
of Income Approach ((neluding support for market rent and GR
The
income approach was considered but not developed due
to
the lack of
B sutiiclent
reliable ingome
date
{o derive
a gross
rent
muttiplie
PROJECT INFORMATION FOR PUDS (if applicable)
Is the developerbulider In control of the Homeowners’ Association (HOA)?
[TYes
[No
Unittype(s)
[J Deteched
[| Attached
Provide
tha following Information for PDs ONLY H the developer/bulider 1s in control of the HOA and the subject propecty is an attached dwelling nit.Page 20
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report
Fed Tons Snir Rd
This
report
fom
ls
designed
to
report
an
appraisal
of
a
one-unit
property
or
a
one-unit
property
with
an
accessory
unh;
including
a
unit
In
a
planned
unit
development
(PUD).
This
mport
form
is
not
designed
to
report
an
appraisal
of
a
manufactured
home
or
a
unit
In
a
condomintum
or
cooperative
project,
This
appraisal
report
Is
subject
to
the
following
scope
of
work,
Intended
use,
Intended
user,
definition
of
market
valus,
statement
of
assumptions
and
fimiing
conditions,
and
certifications.
Modilcations,
additions,
or
delstions
to
the
[ntendsd
use,
inendad
user,
deflntion
of
market
value,
or assumptions
and
limiting
conditions
are
not
permitted.
The
appralser
may
expand
the
scope
of
work fo
Include
any
additional
research
or
analysis
necessary
based
on
the
complexity
of
thls
appraisal
assignment.
Modifications
or
deletions
to
the
certifications
are
also
not
permitted.
However,
addifional
certifloations
that
do
not
constitute
material
alterations
to
this
appraisal
report,
such
as those
required
by
law
or those
volated
to
the
appraiser's
cordinuing
education
or
membership
in
an
appraisal
organization,
are
permitted.
SCOPE OF WORK:
The
scope
of work
for this appraisal
is
defined
by the
complexity
of
this
appraisal assignment
and
the
reporting
requirements
of
this
appraisal
report
form,
including
the
following
defintion
of
market
value,
statement
of
assumptions
and
limiting
conditions,
and
certifications.
The
appralser
must,
at
a
minimum:
(1)
parform
a
complete
visual
inspection
of
the
interior
and
exterior areas
of
the
subject property,
(2)
inspect the
neighborhend,
(3)
Inspect each
of
ihe
comparable
sales
from
at
least
the
street,
(4)
research,
verify,
and
analyze
data
from
rellable
public
and/or
private
sources,
and
(6)
report
fis
or her analysls,
opinions,
and conclusions
in
this appraisal
report,
INTENDED USE:
The
Intended
use
of thls
appralsal
report
is
for the
lender/olient
to
evaluate the
propery
that
Is the
subject
of
this
appralsal
for
a morgage
finance transaction.
INTENDED USER:
The intended
user
of this appraisal report
is the lender/clent.
DEFINITION OF MARKET VALUE:
The
most
probable
price
which
a
property
should
bring
In
a
competitive
and
open
market
under
all
conditions
requisite
to
a
fair
sale,
the
buyer
and
seller,
each
acting
prudently,
knowledgeably
and
assuming
the price
is not afacted by undue stimulus.
Implicit
in this definition
1s the consummation
of
a sale
as
of
a specified
date and
the
passing
of
title
from
seller
to
buyer
under
conditions
whereby:
(1)
buyer and
seller
are
typically
motivated;
(2)
both
parties
are
well Informed
or wefl advised,
and each
acting
In what he
or she considers
his
or her own best
Interest;
(3)
a
reasonable time
Is allowed
for exposure
In the open markel;
(4) payment
is made
In terms
of cash
in
U.
S.
dollars
or
in terms
of
financial
amangements
comparable
thersto;
and
(56)
the
prico
represents
the
normal
consideration
for
the
property
sold
unaffected
by
special
or
creative
financing
or
sales
conpessions®
granted
by
anyone
assaslated
with
the
safe.
*Adjustments
to
the
comparables
must
be
made
for
special
or
ciestive
financing
or
sales
concessions.
No
adjustments
are
necessary
for those costs which
are
normally
pald
by
sellers
as
a
result
of tradition
or
law
In
a
markel
area;
thess
costs
are
readlly
Identiffable
since
the
seller pays
these
costs
In
viiually
aif
sales
transactions.
Special
or
creative
financing
adjustments
can
be
made
to
the
comparable
property
by
comparisons
to
financing
terms
offered
by
a
third
pary
insttutional
lender
that
Is
not
already
Involved
in
the
property
or
transaction.
Any
adjustment
should
not
be
calculated
on
a
mechanical
dofiar
far
doffar
cost
of
the
financing
or
concession
but
the
doar
amount
of
any
adjustment
should
approximate
the
market's
reaction
to
the
financing
or
concessions
based
on
the
appraiser's
judgment.
STATEMENT
OF ASSUMPTIONS AND LIMITING CONDITIONS:
The
appralser's
certification
in
this
repost
is
subject
to
the
following
assumptions
and
Imiting
conditions:
1.
The
appraiser
will
not
be
responsible
for
matters
of
a
legal
mature
that
affect
either the
property
being
appraised
or the
tlite
to
ft,
except
for
information
that
he
or
she
bsoame
aware
of
during
the
research
involved
in
performing
this
appraisal.
The
appraiser assumes
that
the
title
Is
good
and
marketable
and
wilt
not
render
any
opinfons
about
the
title.
2.
The
appraiser
has
provided
a
sketch
in
this
appraisal
report
to
show
the
approximate
dimensions
of
the
Improvements.
The
sketch
Is
Included
only
to
assist
the
reader
In
visualizing
the
property
and
understanding
the
appralser's
determination
of fs size.
3.
The
appraiser
has
examined
the
avaliable
flood
maps
that
are
provided
by
the
Federal
Emergency
Management
Agency
{or
other
data
sources)
and
has
noted
In
this
appraisal
report
whether any
portion
of
the
subjost
site
is
located
in
an
identified
Speclal
Flood
Hazard
Area.
Because
the
appraiser
is
not
a
surveyor,
he
or
she
makes
no
guaramtess,
express
or
implied,
regarding
this
determination.
4.
The
appraiser
wlll
not
give testimony
or appear
In
court because
he
or she
made
an
appraisal
of
the
property
in
question,
unless
specific
arrangements
to
do
so
have
been
made
beforehand,
or
as
otherwise
required
by
law.
6.
The
appraiser
has
noted
In
this
appraisal
report
any
adverse
condilons
{such
as
nesded
repalis,
deterioration,
the
prosonce
of
hazardous
wastes,
toxic
substances,
etc.)
observed
during
the
Inspection
of
the
subject
property
or that
he
or
she
became
aware
of
during
the
research
involved
In
performing
the
appraisal.
Unless
otherwise
stated
In
this
appraisal
report,
the
appraiser
has
no
knowledge
of
any
hidden
or
unapparent
physical
deficiencies
or
adverse
conditions
of
the
property
(such
as,
but
not
fimited
to,
needed
repairs,
deterforation,
the
presence
of
hazardous
wastes,
toxic
substances,Page 21
.
.
N
.
202307-766
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report
Fis # 1838
§ Waverly Rd
APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION:
~~ The Appraiser certifies and agress
that
1.
1
have,
at
a minimum,
developed
and
reported
this
appraisal
In accordance
with
the
scope
of work requirements
stated
in
this
appraisal
report.
2.
1
performed
a
complete
visual
Inspection
of
the
tnterfor
and
exterior
areas
of
the
subject
property.
1
reported
the
condition
of
the
Improvements
In
factual,
specific
terms.
|
identitied
and
reported
the
physical
deficiencies
nat
could
affect
the
fivablity,
soundness,
or
structural
integrity
of
the
property.
3.
|
performed
this
appraisal
In
accordance
with
the
requirememts
of
the
Uniform
Standards
of
Professional
Appraisat
Practice
that
were
adopted
and
promulgated
by
the
Appraisal
Standards
Board
of
The
Appraisal
Foundation
and
that
were
in
place
at
the
time
thls
appraisal
report was
prepared.
4.
|
developed
my opinton
of
the
market
value
of
the
real
property that
Is
the
subject
of
this
report based
on the
sales
comparison
approach
to
value.
|
have
adequate
comparable
market
data
to
develop
a
reliable
sales
comparison
approach
for
this
appraisal
assignment.
|
further
certify
that
|
considered
the
cost
and
income
approaches
fo
values
but
did
not
develop
them,
unless
otherwise
Indicated
in
this
report.
6.
|
researched,
varified,
analyzed,
and
reported
on
any
current
agreement
for
sale
for
the
subject
propery,
any
offering
for
salo
of the subject property
in the twelve months
prior to the
effective
date
of
this
appraisal,
and
the
prior
safes
of the subject
property
for
a
minimum
of thre
years
prior
to
the
effective
date
of
this
appraisal,
unless
otherwise
indicated
In
this
report.
6.
|
researched,
verified,
analyzed,
and
reported
on
the
prior
sales
of
the
comparable
sales
for
a
minimum
of
one year
prior
fo the
date
of
sale
of the comparable
sals,
unless
otherwise
Indicated
in
this
report,
7.
|
selected and used comparable
sales that
are
locationally,
physically,
and functionally the
most
stmilar to the subject property.
8.
| have not used comparable sales that were the result of combining a land sale with the contract purchase price
of a home that
fias been bullt or will be bulft on the land,
9.
|
have
reported
adjustments
to
the comparable
sales
that
reflect
the
market's
reaction
to
the
differences betwaen
the
subject
properly
and
the
comparable
sales.
10.
| verified, from
a disinferested source,
ail information
In this
report that was provided by parties who have
a financlal
Interest
In
the
sale
or financing
of
the
subject
propery.
11.
1
have
knowledge
and
experience
In
appraising
this
type
of
property
In
this
market
area.
12.
1 am aware
of,
and have access
to,
the necessary and appropriate
public and private data sources,
such
as
multiple
listing
services,
tax assessment
records,
public
land
records
and other such
data
sources
for the
area
in
which
the
property
Is
located.
13.
|
obtained
the
Information,
estimates,
and
opinions
furnished
by
other
parifes
and
expressed
In
this
appralsal
report
from
rellable
sources
that
|
believe
to
be
true
and
correct.
14.
|
have
taken
into
consideration
the
factors
that
have
an
impact
on
value
with
respect
to
the
subject
neighborhood,
subject
property,
and the
proximity
of
the
subject
property
to
adverse
Infiusnces
in the development
of my
opinjon
of
market
vaiue.
|
have
noted
in
this
appraisal
report
any
adverse
conditions
(such
as,
but
not
IimHed
fo,
needed
repalrs,
deterioration,
the
presence
of
hazardous
wastes,
toxic
substances,
adverse
environmemtal
conditions,
etc.)
observed
durng
the
inspection
of
the
subject
property
or
that
|
became
aware
of
during
the
research
Involved
In
performing
hls
appraisal.
|
have
considered
these
adverse
conditions
in my
analysis
of the propery
valus,
and have reported
on the
effect
of the conditions
on the
valus
and
marketability
of
the
sublact
property,
15.
| have
not knowingly withheld
any significant Information from
this appraisal
report
and,
to the
best
of my knowlsdge,
all
statements
and
Information
In
this
appraisal
report
are
true
and
coract.
16.
|
stated
In
this
appraisal
report
my own
personal,
unblased,
and
professional
analysis,
opinions,
and
conclusions,
which
are subject only to the assumptions and Hmiting conditions
In this appraisal report.
17.
| fave
no present or prospective
interest
in the praperty that
is the subject of this report,
and
! have
no present
or
prospective
personal imersst
or
bias
with respact
to the participants
In the ransaction.
|
did
not
base,
either partially
or
completely,
my
analysis
and/or opinfon
of
market
value
In
thls appraisal
report
on the
race,
color,
religion,
sex,
age,
marital
status,
handloap,
famillal
status,
or
national
origin
of
either the prospective owners
or occupants
of the
subject property
or
of
the
present ownsrs
or occupants
of
the properties
in the vicinity
of the subject property
or on
any other basis prohibited
by law.
18.
My
employment
and/or
compensation
for
performing
thls
appraisal
or
any
future
or
anticipated
appralsals
was
not
conditioned
on
any
agreement
or
understanding,
written
or
otherwise,
that
|
would
report
{or
present
analysis
supporting)
a
predetermined
specific
value,
a
predetermined
minimum
value,
a
rangs
or
direotion
In
value,
a
valus
that
favors
the
cause
of
any
party,
or
the
attainment
of
a
specific
result
or occurence
of
a
specific
subsequent
event
(such
as
approval
of
a
pendingPage 22
202307-766
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report
Flo# 1838 § Waverly Rd
21.
The
lendat/ollent
may
disclose
or
distribute
this
appraisal
report
to:
the
bomower,
another lender
at
the
request
of
the
borrower,
the
mortgagee
or
its
successors
and
assigns,
maorigage
insurers;
government
sponsored
erterprises;
other
secondary
market
parlolpants;
data
collection
or
reporting
services;
professional
appraisal
organizations;
any
department,
agency,
or instrumentality
of the
United
States;
and
any
state,
the
District
of
Golumbla,
or other jurisdictions;
without
having
to
obtaln
the
appraiser's
or
supervisoty
appraiser's
(ff
applicable)
consent.
Such
consent
must
be
obtained
hefore
this
appralsal
port may be disclosed
or distributed
to
any other party
(including,
but
rot
limited
to, the
public through
adveitising,
public
relations,
news,
sales,
or
other
media).
22.
1 am aware that
any disolosure
or distribution
of
this appraisal
report
by me
or the
lender/client may
be
subject
to
certain
laws
and
regulations.
Further,
|
am
also
subject
to
the
provisions
of
the
Uniform
Standards
of
Professional
Appraisal
Practice
that
pertain
to disclosure
or distribution
by
me.
23.
The
borrower,
another
lander
at
the
request
of
the
borrower,
the morigagee
or
Hs successors
and
assigns,
morgage
Insurers,
government
sponsored
enterprises,
and
other
secondary
market
participants
may
rely
on
this
appralsal
report
as
part
of
any morigage finance transaction that
Invoives
any
one
or more
of theses
parties.
24.
If
this
appraisal
report
was
transmitted
as
an
“electronic
record”
contalning
my
‘“sfectronic
signature,”
as
those
terms
are
defined
in
applicable
federal
and/or
state
laws
(excluding
audlo
and
video
recordings),
or
a
facsimile transmission
of
this
appralsal
report
containing
a
copy
or
representation
of
my
signature,
the
appraisal
report
shalt
be
as
effective,
enforceable
and
valid
as
#
a
paper version
of
this
appralsal
report
were
dellverad
containing
my
original
hand
wiltlen
signature.
25,
Any
Intentional
or
negligent
misrépresentation(s)
cortalned
in
this
appraisal
report
may
result
In
civil
lability
and/or
criminal
penalties
including,
but
not
Hmited
to,
fine
or
Imprisonment
or
both
under
the
provisions
of
Title
18,
United
States
Codes,
Section
1001,
et
seq.
or
similar
state
laws.
SUPERVISORY APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION:
~~ The
Supervisory
Appraiser cenlles
and
agress that
1.
|
directly
supervised
the
appraiser
for
this
appraisal
assignment,
have
read tho
appraisal
report,
and
agres
with
the
appraiser's
analysis,
opinions,
statements,
conclusions,
and
the
appraiser's
certification.
2.
| accept
full responsibifty for the contents
of this appraisal report Including,
but not limited to,
the appraisers analysts, opinlons,
statements,
conclusions,
and
the
appraiser's
certification.
3.
The appraiser
Identified
{n
this
appraisal
report
is ether
a sub-contractor
or
an employee
of the supervisory appraiser
(or the
appraisal firm),
is
qualifted
to perform
this
appraisal,
and
Is acceptable
to
perform
this
appraisal
under the
applicable
state
faw,
4.
This
appraisal
roport
complies
with
the
Uniform
Standards
of
Professional
Appraisal
Practice
that
were
adopted
and
promulgated
by
the
Appraisal
Standards
Board
of
The
Appralsal Foundation
and
that
were
[n
place
at
the
time
this
appraisal
repoit
was
prepared.
5.
if this
appraisal
report was transmitted
as
an
“electronic
record”
containing
my
“electronic
signature,
as
thosa terms
are
defined
in
applicable
federal
and/or
state
laws
(excluding
audlo
and
video
recordings),
or
a
facsimile
transmission
of
this
appraisal
report containing
a
copy
or representation
of my
signature,
the appraisal
report
shall
be
as
effective,
enforceshle and
valid
as
ff
a
paper
version
of
this
appraisal
report
were
dolivered
containing
my
original
hand
written
slgnature.
APPRAISER
;
yo
§ |
i
SUPERVISORY APPRAISER (ONLY IF REQUIRED)
OA
Signature
j
!
Ld
Signature
Name
Joanna A Morey
Name
Company Name
Sage Appraisals, LLC
Company Name
Gompany Address
PO Box 93
Company Address
Telephone Number
~~ (517) 861-8454
Telephone Number
Emall Address
fmoreyappraiser@amail.com
Emall Address
Date of Signature and Report
011202023
Date of Signature
Effective Date of Appraisal
07/10/2023
State Certifcation #
State Certification # I
ar State License #
or State License #
State
or Other (describe)
Stata #
Expiration Date of Certification or License
State
MI
Expiration Date of Certification or License
07/31/2024
SUBJECT PROPERTY
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY APPRAISED
[J Did not nspact subjaot propanty
1838 S Waverly Rd
{J Did inspaot exterior
of subJact property from steoetPage 23
SMTi EATon RaPibs, MT, 4E927 Micwigan T AL Floor M 2407 N. GR LANSING,