St. Clair Haven Dredge Project Property Signature Analysis Revised.pdf
Jeffrey Kovacik Petitioner V Township Of Harrison Respondent · 26-000850-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
Dredge Project Property List Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-15-377-001 RAPP, KEVIN Vacant Lot 48045 Single + 60' Yes 12-15-377-002 MULDER, KENNETH 39488 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-15-377-003 MARSACK, KEN & JANICE 39482 ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' No 12-15-377-004 MARSACK, KEN & JANICE Vacant Lot 48045 Single + 75' No 12-15-377-005 KING. MATTHEW 39468 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 108' Yes 12-15-377-006 CLEMENS. CHRISTOFFER 39456 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. + 129' No 12-15-377-007 VAN LUVEN. CHARLES 39450 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 78' No 12-15-377-008 SALO. JEFF 39442 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-377-009 TANCES. ROXANNE 39438 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-377-010 NEIDELMAN. MICHAEL & SHEILA 39432 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-15-377-015 STIEBER. RICHARD & JEANNE 39380 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-377-016 DRELLICK. PETER & SUE 39364 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-377-017 RUMOHR. DAVID W & LESLIE-DALE 39352 ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 99' Yes*/ invalid Does not have signature from all owners. Township Clerk later responded owner's spouse was deceased and they had proof of obituary. (No proof or timeframe of when this happened provided.) 12-15-377-032 WINKLER. MARK W. 39426 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-15-377-034 PAPSDORF. JOHN F. 39400 ARCHER E 48045 Dbl. 99' Yes 12-15-377-036 WINKLER. MARK & CARRIE Vacant Lot 48045 Single 42' No
Page 2
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-15-377-037 HINEBAUGH. FREDERICK & WIGGINS- HINEBAUGH. SUZANNE 39406 E.ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-15-377-038 ELLISON. GEORGE & HEATHER 39340 E. ARCHER 48045 Single * 42' No Has adjacent vacant lot next door that is not listed in procject 12-15-377- 019. Township Clerk later responded the two lots were combined as one after petition. According to application to combine lots issued by the township, no combination of lots can be assessed as such until the following tax year. (No proof or timeframe of when this happened provided.) 12-15-377-020 BECKETT. GENE A & SUSAN A 39316 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-15-377-021 SMIGIEL. JOHN G 39300 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-15-377-022 BOUTIN. DEREK 39282 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-15-377-023 BOZIMOWSKI. KAREN 39280 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-15-377-024 RENTSCHLER. JEFFREY 39270 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-15-377-025 SWIFT. CHRISTOPHER & STEPHANIE 39260 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 96' Yes 12-15-377-026 GAYHART. EUGENE & NICHOL 39240 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 96' Yes 12-15-377-027 UNGER. WILLIAM & JACQUELINE J 39220 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 96' Yes 12-15-377-028 HARDER. CATHLEEN M 39206 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 96' Yes 12-15-377-029 MCMONIGLE. MICHAEL & MARY 39184 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-377-030 SMITH. MATTHEW L 39170 E. ARCHER 48045 Single -42 Yes 12-15-377-031 ROBINSON. MATTHEW 39154 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-378-001 ANDRION. ALEXANDER J 39641 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-378-002 HARRELL. JOEY & KAREN HAPANOWICZ. PAULA A 39631 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No Page 2 of 8
Page 3
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-15-378-003 JACKSON. TODD & STARLITA 39621 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-004 DIAMOND. NICHOLAS & MICHELLE 39611 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-005 DRITSAS. ELIZABETH ANN & GEORGE 9601 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-006 KOPYTEK. MARCIA SMITH. MARIE & MURAWSKI. ERICA 39591 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-007 TRUDELL. JESSE 39581 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-008 PRZYWARA. MITCHELL & BEATA 39577 LAKESHORE DRIVE 48045 Single 54' No 12-15-378-009 PIETKA. GERARD & GINGER 39565 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-010 DOWKER. PETER A 39533 LAKESHORE DRIVE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-011 GLATZ. MARCEL 39517 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-012 DELEON. MARGO 39501 LAKESHORE DR 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-013 POLAN. MARY- ANNE 39475 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' Yes 12-15-378-014 JOLLY. PAMELA A & JEFFREY M 39457 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' No 12-15-378-015 CURTIS. THOMAS F 39441 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-378-016 FRANKENSTEIN. NICHOLAS P 39431 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-15-378-019 SHEA. ROBERT JAY 39401 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-020 KAY. ANDREW & ANDRA L 39387 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-021 KENNEDY. GEORGENE F & KENNEDY. ROBERT K 39375 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-022 VARNAS. GARY 39363 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-023 COOK. MIKE & GATTERI. GIGIA 39351 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No Page 3 of 8
Page 4
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-15-378-026 LENTINI. JACOB 39303 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-027 BASILE. NINO V 39283 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-028 LIPINSKI. REBECCA 39267 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-029 ALLAR. ANNASOFIA 39245 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' No 12-15-378-030 PRYBULA. ZENON 39207 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' No 12-15-378-031 ANGLIN. WENDY A & MOMAMY. MICHAEL W 39191 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes*/ invalid Does not have signature from all owners. 12-15-378-032 JOHNSON. KRISTYN 39173 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' No 12-15-378-033 RUNSTADLER. KEITH & CRAIG RUNSTADLER. JEANNE 39155 LAKESHORE 48045 Single + 75' No 12-15-378-034 KASPER. MARLENE M 39135 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' No 12-15-378-035 STEYAERT.TERRE NCE J 39125 LAKESHORE 48045 Single + 63' No 12-15-378-036 FLATT. BILLY W & ZAPPITELL. MOLLY 39115 LAKESHORE 48045 Single + 75' No 12-15-378-037 PILETTE. RUSSELL 39105 LAKESHORE 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-15-378-041 ATLESKI. VOJO & SUSAN 39095 LAKESHORE 48045 Single + 72' No 12-15-378-042 ROARTY. PATRICK & STOPPA. BRIDGID ROARTY 39085 LAKESHORE 48045 Single + 78' Yes 12-15-378-043 AMOROSO. MICHAEL & KATHLEEN 39339 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' No 12-15-378-044 GRAUSTEIN. KEITH & ANDREA 39321 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 46' Yes 12-15-378-045 SHEA. ROBERT J & JACQUELINE 39411 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' No 12-22-103-035 CASEY. WILLIAM D & HAPANOWICZ 39084 E. ARCHER 48045 Dbl. 99' No Page 4 of 8
Page 5
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-22-103-001 RUMOHR. DAVID W & LESLIE-DALE Vacant Lot 48045 Single 50' Yes*/ invalid Does not have signature from all owners.Township Clerk later responded owner's spouse was deceased and they had proof of obituary. (No proof or timeframe of when this happened provided.) 12-22-103-002 RUMOHR. DAVID W & LESLIE-DALE 39116 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 50' Yes*/ invalid Does not have signature from all owners.Township Clerk later responded owner's spouse was deceased and they had proof of obituary. (No proof or timeframe of when this happened provided.) 12-22-103-003 FEKIN. DAVID 39100 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-006 BAKER. RICHARD A 39056 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-007 EHLERT. ELMER N Vacant Lot 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-008 WALLEMAN. LINDA R Vacant Lot 48045 Single + 60' No 12-22-103-009 WALLEMAN. LINDA R 39014 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 72' No 12-22-103-010 ALLMACHER. CHERYL 38994 E. ARCHER 48045 Single + 75' Yes 12-22-103-011 RIZZO. GAETANO S 38986 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-012 CROFT. GLENN A & MIECHELLE P 38978 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-103-013 MORRIS. DAVID R 38970 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-014 GUARNIERI. SUSAN R 38960 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-103-015 BUSSELMAN. ALAN L 38950 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-103-016 KENBEEK. JAMES & DORIS 38946 E. ARCHER 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-103-036 WOODWARD. ADAM J 38922 E. ARCHER 48045 Triple 126' No 12-22-103-019 ROBINSON. DANNY & CARMEN 38906 E. PARDEE 48045 Dbl. 84' Yes*/ invalid Spoke w/son J. Robinson who is power of Att. Does not want and dispite father being pressuered into signing, peition is invalid as wife Carmen did not sign. Township Clerk indicated they dropped this "YES" note as it was confirmed invalid. Page 5 of 8
Page 6
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-22-103-020 KOVACIK. JEFFREY & CINDY Vacant Lot 48045 Single 42' No* Resident was pressured and harrassed to sign for fear of having to pay for 2 lots if we did not concede to letting contractor use adjacent property as project work site. 12-22-103-021 KOVACIK, CINDY L. 38886 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' No* Resident was pressured and harrassed to sign for fear of having to pay for 2 lots if we did not concede to letting contractor use adjacent property as project work site. 12-22-103-034 BURNS. HWA CHA BURNS. WILLIAM D 38874 PARDEE 48045 Dbl. 90' No 12-22-103-024 SKIRPAN. PETER L 38862 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-025 CISLO. BRENDEN 38850 PARDEE 48045 Dbl. 99' Yes 12-22-103-026 BOLTON. GARRETT A 38840 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-103-027 AUNE. ALLEN & SANDRA 38830 PARDEE 48045 Single 49' Yes* Resident was pressured and harrassed to sign for fear of having to pay for 2 lots if she did not concede to letting contractor use adjacent property as project work site. 12-22-103-028 AUNE. ALLEN & SANDRA Vacant Lot 48045 Single 49' Yes* 12-22-103-029 LATOWSKI. JESSICA 38810 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' Yes * Name on pettittion does not appear to match owner name.. 12-22-103-030 CASTRONOVA, ANTHONY 38800 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-103-031 DANNA. ANDRE & HERRON. ANTOINETTE 38790 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' Yes */ invalid Does not have signature from all owners. 12-22-103-032 MOLDAVSKY. STANISLAV 38780 PARDEE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-103-033 KITCHEN. GREG & CHERYL 38762 PARDEE 48045 Quad 204' No 12-22-126-001 LAKESHORE DRIVE PROPERTY LLC 39071 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. + 126' No Business Agent: RAYMOND A. CONFER 12-22-126-002 PELKEY. MICHAEL R & PAMALA 39055 LAKESHORE 480465 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-003 ASHBROOK. THOMAS & SUZANNE 39041 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' No 12-22-126-006 JOZWIAK. DANIEL & GRIFFITH. KATHLEEN 39005 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 78' Yes Page 6 of 8
Page 7
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-22-126-007 BARNHARD. MICHAEL 38995 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 78' Yes 12-22-126-008 HINES. MICHAEL 38985 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-009 WILHELM. STEVEN & ROBIN D 38979 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-010 RATZA. JAMES & LINDA 38971 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-011 MERTZ. CARL W 38963 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 52' Yes 12-22-126-012 DUFFY. JOHN P & JEANNE M 38955 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-013 BARTLETT. THOMAS & BONNIE SUE 38947 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 60' No 12-22-126-014 MULLICA. SCOTT & CARRIE Vacant Lot 48045 Single 60' No 12-22-126-015 FOURNIER. THOMAS & JENNIFER 38921 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 60' Yes 12-22-126-016 LIGHTFOOT. BENJAMIN 38909 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 60' No 12-22-126-017 ELSEY. MARK 38895 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 60' Yes 12-22-126-018 MACE. GINO 38883 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 60' Yes 12-22-126-019 KROLCZYK. SHAWN & CYNTHIA 38871 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 57' No 12-22-126-020 WALLER. KEITH G & KIM A 38861 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-021 BOLF. MICHAEL 38853 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-022 LACKEY. RYAN V 38845 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-126-023 LOSICKI. ROBI & MICHELLE 38839 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-126-024 BERGER. JEFFREY & TRACEY Vacant Lot 48045 Single 54' Yes 12-22-126-025 BERGER. JEFFREY & TRACEY 38823 LAKESHORE DR 48045 Single 42' Yes 12-22-126-026 WAGNER. LEE & KANDY 38815 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' No 12-22-126-027 KARPOWITSCH. NIKOLAJ ELGIN & KARPOWITSCH. SHANA DAWN 38807 LAKESHORE 48045 Single 42' No Page 7 of 8
Page 8
Parcel ID # Property Owner(s) Address Postal code Lot Size Canal Frontage Signed Petition Notes 12-22-126-028 HUETTER. WILLIAM & KAREN Vacant Lot 48045 Single 48' No 12-22-126-029 HUETTER. WILLIAM & KAREN Vacant Lot 48045 Single 48' No 12-22-126-031 MCCARTHY. NADIA & JOSHUA 39015 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. 102' Yes 12-22-126-032 HUETTER. WILLIAM & KAREN 38777 LAKESHORE 48045 Dbl. / Quad 100' + 149'=249' No 12-22-176-005 JACKSON. JASON 32101 RIVERDALE 48045 Dbl. 96' No Property was dropped from project during March 9th meeting to achieve Township's 51% signature claims. 12-22-176-009 METCALF. KENT & ANDREA 32127 RIVERDALE 48045 Single + 69' No Property was dropped from project during March 9th meeting to achieve Township's 51% signature claims. 12-22-176-010 CLARK. JAMES R & IRMA 32175 RIVERDALE 48045 Quad 200' 204' No Property was dropped from project during March 9th meeting to achieve Township's 51% signature claims. 12-15-377-019 ELLISON. GEORGE & HEATHER Vacant Lot 48045 Single 50' 42' Yes Not on list of properties. Vacant lot adjacent to 39340 ARCHER.Township Clerk later responded the two lots were combined as one after petition. According to application to combine lots issued by the township, no combination of lots can be assessed as such until the following tax year. (No proof or timeframe of when this happened provided.) Total # of project properties involved: 131 Total # of Valid "Yes" votes on petition: 62 Total # of "No" votes on petition: 59 Total # of invalid signature votes on petition: 6 Yes to No & Invalid Signatures is 62 to 65 making it only 47.3% of total property owner votes that are Valid. Total Canal Frontage of Valid "Yes" votes on petition: 3,653' Total Canal Frontage of "No" votes on petition: 4,188' Total Canal Frontage of invalid signature votes on petition: 367' Total Canal Frontage of Yes vs. No & Invalid Signatures is 3,653' vs. 4,555' of total lots involved making it only 44.5% Page 8 of 8