Exhibits.pdf
Mary Rose Birch, Petitioner V Township Of Peaine, Respondent · 26-000228-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
Exhibits:
A. Petition to Appeal Principal Residence Exemption Denial
B. Notice of Denial of Principal Residence Exemption dated 2/28/26
C. Petition to the Board of Review completed in person on Beaver island 3/12/26
D. Proof of Ownership – 31153 Camp 3 Trl Beaver Island, MI PIN 15-012-129-005-50
E. Proof of Ownership – 31061 Camp 3 Trl Beaver Island, MI PIN 15-012-129-005-60
F. Proof of Contiguous Parcels – Certificate of Boundary Survey Parcel 3 & Parcel 4
G. Proof of Contiguous Parcels – Parcel Search & Mapping dated 2/18/2026
H. Property tax Statements showing prior 100% PRE when combined
a. Tax Bill Winter 2021
b. Tax Bill Winter 2023
c. Email from Treasurer Vicki Smith forwarding tax bill combined
I. Timeline of Request to Split/combine parcel (July 2024)/(April 2025) 4 pages
J. Charlevoix County Equalization Request to Split Platted Lots Form
K. Photo of Principal Residence – 31061 Camp 3 Trl Beaver Island, MI 49782
L. Principal Residence Parcel # 15-012-129-005-60 Purchase appraisal document
M. Photo of structure on 31153 Camp 3 Trl not occupied by tenants or separate
household
N. Occupancy and Ownership Proof – Homeowner’s insurance lists both parcels on
one policy {6 pages}
O. Occupancy proof – Auto policy
P. Occupancy Evidence – Great lakes Energy Bills
a. 31061 Camp 3 Trl Principal Residence
b. 31153 Camp 3 Trl