Urbain 321 Oak Way South Haven MI 2026 Comps Tax Tribunal.pdf
Donna & Peter C/O Ipts Urbain Petitioner V City Of South Haven Respondent · 26-002870-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
Property: 321 Oak Way, South Haven MI Parcel: 80-53-890-015-00 2026 Subject Yr Built Land SQ FT Living Area Total MV Total MV PSF 321 Oak Way, South Haven 1995 6,534 1,430 $ 555,400 $ 388.39 Sales Comps Yr Built Land SQ FT Living Area Purchase Price Purchase PSF Purchase Date 1 742 Green Street, South Haven 1940 6,600 1,544 $ 314,000 $ 203.37 2/21/2025 2 324 South Haven St, South Haven 1900 6,316 1,536 $ 435,000 $ 283.20 2/21/2025 3 620 Bailey Ave, South Haven 1910 6,534 1,478 $ 255,000 $ 172.53 12/23/2025 4 840 Superior Street, South Haven 1920 10,469 1,385 $ 365,000 $ 263.54 8/7/2025 $ 230.66 Estimated Requested Market Value 329,844 Estimated Requested Assessed Value 164,922 Subject Yr Built Land SQ FT Living Area Total MV Total MV PSF 321 Oak Way, South Haven 1995 6,534 1,430 $ 555,400 $ 388.39 2026 Value 321 Oak Way, South Haven 1995 6,534 1,430 $ 522,400 $ 365.31 2025 Value Assessment Comps 2025 Yr Built Land SQ FT Living Area Total MV Total MV PSF 320 Oak Way, South Haven 1996 5,140 1,520 $ 495,600 $ 326.05 521 Woodbridge Circle, South Haven 1998 19,863 1,848 $ 583,200 $ 315.58 253 Oak Street, South Haven 2005 6,011 1,732 $ 630,800 $ 364.20 $ 335.28
Page 2
SALE COMP #1 742 Green St, South Haven, MI 49090 Back South Haven, MI Fŷy around 1/21 How much home can you afford? Off Market 3 bed 1.5 bath 1,544 sqft 6,660 sqft ŷot 742 Green St, South Haven, MI 49090 View on Map Singŷe Famiŷy 1940 Property type Year buiŷt $314K in 2025 $203 Last soŷd Price per sqft View as owner Share Get Up To 4 Free Moving Quotes Interested in seŷŷing 742 Green St? Estimated vaŷue* $331,200 *Estimation is caŷcuŷated based on tax assessment records, recent saŷe prices of comparabŷe properties, and other factors. See your offers Compare agents with ReaŷChoice TM Seŷŷing, Ŝnd a trusted expert View proposaŷ, no commitment See reaŷ reviews and ratings Ryan Green Green Towne Coastaŷ Reaŷty #6501325481 68 23 years Soŷd Experience View proposaŷ Featured DOUG KLAASEN, Broker Associate
Page 3
Keŷŷer Wiŷŷiams Reaŷty Hoŷŷand - Broker #6502354195 20 29 years $300K - $900K 742 Green St, South Haven, MI 49090 Soŷd Experience Price range View proposaŷ I've served in the U.S. miŷitary No Yes Property detaiŷs Interior Bedrooms Bedrooms: 3 Bedrooms On Main Leveŷ: 1 Bedrooms On Upper Leveŷ: 2 Bathrooms Totaŷ Bathrooms: 1.5 Show more Find out more about this property. Contact agent Locaŷ Home Services Advertisement Moving Need a Mover? Get Free Moving Quotes and a Cost Estimate Presented By GET MOVING QUOTES Home vaŷue ReaŷEstimateႩ Chart Tabŷe
Page 4
742 Green St, South Haven, MI 49090 March 2026 Vaŷuation provider Estimate Coŷŷateraŷ Anaŷytics - CoreLogic® $332,099 Quantarium $314,072 Is this your home? Start tracking home vaŷue with monthŷy updates and tips to maximize your investment. I own this home The estimate(s) shown, which come from one or more automated vaŷuation modeŷ providers independent of Reaŷtor.com®, represent information that may provide a heŷpfuŷ starting point for discussions with a reaŷ estate agent. Contact agent Tap into your home’s equity Connect with a ŷender to expŷore a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) to access Ɓexibŷe funding for home remodeŷing projects, debt consoŷidation, or other Ŝnanciaŷ needs. A HELOC aŷŷows you to borrow against your home's equity, often at ŷower interest rates than other ŷoan options, giving you the abiŷity to draw funds as needed. Connect with a ŷender Latest home equity rates South Haven market trends A city in Van Buren, MI Listing price median List price/sqft median $539,999 $369 Soŷd price median Days on market $510,000 61 $571.3K$571.3K$571.3K$571.3K$571.3K$571.3K$571.3K$571.3K$571.3K Layers
Page 5
742 Green St, South Haven, MI 49090 $348.8K$348.8K$348.8K$348.8K$348.8K$348.8K$348.8K$348.8K$348.8K $227.9K$227.9K$227.9K$227.9K$227.9K$227.9K$227.9K$227.9K$227.9K $331.2K$331.2K$331.2K$331.2K$331.2K$331.2K$331.2K$331.2K$331.2K $332.4K$332.4K$332.4K$332.4K$332.4K$332.4K$332.4K$332.4K$332.4K $406K$406K$406K$406K$406K$406K$406K$406K$406K $330.4K$330.4K$330.4K$330.4K$330.4K$330.4K$330.4K$330.4K$330.4K $382.3K$382.3K$382.3K$382.3K$382.3K$382.3K$382.3K$382.3K$382.3K $317.7K$317.7K$317.7K$317.7K$317.7K$317.7K$317.7K$317.7K$317.7K $295.1K$295.1K$295.1K$295.1K$295.1K$295.1K$295.1K$295.1K$295.1K $305.1K$305.1K$305.1K$305.1K$305.1K$305.1K$305.1K$305.1K$305.1K Nearby Schooŷs Neighborhoods Sateŷŷite $353.1K$353.1K$353.1K$353.1K$353.1K$353.1K$353.1K$353.1K$353.1K Map data ©2026 Nearby home vaŷues Address ReaŷEstimateႩ Bed Bath Sqft Lot (sqft) This home : ƉƆƄ Green St Ƹƅƅƃ,ƄƂƂ ƅ ƃ.Ƈ ƃ,ƇƆƆ ƈ,ƈƈƂ ƉƆƊ Green St, South Haven, MI ƆƋƂƋƂ ƸƅƅƄ,ƆƂƂ Ƈ Ƅ ƃ,ƅƂƂ Ɗ,ƉƃƄ ƉƄƉ Lee St, South Haven, MI ƆƋƂƋƂ ƸƅƊƄ,ƅƂƂ Ƅ ƃ ƃ,ƄƉƄ Ɗ,ƉƃƄ ƉƅƄ Green St, South Haven, MI ƆƋƂƋƂ ƸƅƆƂ,ƇƉƂ Ƅ ƃ ƉƇƊ ƃƂ,ƂƃƋ See more Property history $314,000 $4,184 Last soŷd in 2025 2025 taxes 5 permits 86 years oŷd Recorded since 2005 Buiŷt in 1940 Price history 2025 SoŷdFeb Ƅƃ, ƄƂƄƇ ƸƅƃƆ,ƂƂƂ ƸƄƂƅ/sqft MichRic 2021
Page 6
Soŷd 742 Green St, South Haven, MI 49090ƸƄƇƈ,ƂƂƂAug Ƅƅ, ƄƂƄƃ Ƹƃƈƈ/sqft MichRic LJƈƇ.ƉƂ% Show more Tax History Year Taxes Totaŷ assessment Land Additions ƄƂƄƇ ƸƆ,ƃƊƆ ƸƃƅƇ,ƈƂƂ ƿ - LJ - ƄƂƄƆ ƸƇ,ƄƆƉ ƸƃƅƇ,ƈƂƂ ƿ - LJ - ƄƂƄƅ ƸƆ,ƋƈƇ ƸƋƇ,ƅƂƂ ƿ - LJ - ƄƂƄƄ ƸƆ,ƉƃƆ ƸƉƉ,ƆƂƂ ƿ - LJ - ƄƂƄƃ Ƹƅ,ƄƇƃ ƸƈƋ,ƄƂƂ ƿ - LJ - ƄƂƄƂ Ƹƅ,ƄƆƂ ƸƉƈ,ƉƂƂ ƿ - LJ - ƄƂƃƋ Ƹƅ,ƃƄƋ ƸƈƇ,ƆƂƂ ƿ - LJ - Show more The price and tax history data dispŷayed is obtained from pubŷic records and/or MLS feeds from the ŷocaŷ jurisdiction. Contact your REALTOR® directŷy in order to obtain the most up-to- date information avaiŷabŷe. Want to get comps? Contact agent Permit history Date Type of work Project type Project name Status Aug ƃƉ, ƄƂƃƊ Buiŷding •• Residentiaŷ - Finaŷa •• RooŜng Unŷock permit history data Oct ƃƉ, ƄƂƂƊ Eŷectricaŷ •• Eŷectricaŷ work - Issuedue Access pubŷic buiŷding permits for this property, aŷŷ in one pŷace. May ƄƊ, ƄƂƂƊ Buiŷding •• RooŜng - Issuedue Sign up to unŷock Sep ƃƅ, ƄƂƂƇ Pŷmg, s-a: singŷe famiŷy aŷteration •• Residentiaŷ - Finaŷa Aŷready have an account? Login Show more The permit history dispŷayed is obtained from pubŷic records and provided for informationaŷ purposes onŷy. It may not represent the compŷete permit history for the property. Accuracy is not guaranteed. Home improvements Learn which renovations may increase your property vaŷue with our renovation tooŷ. Things to consider
Page 7
SALE COMP #2 City, Address, School, Agent, ZIP Buy ᶟ Rent ᶟ Sell ᶟ Mortgage ᶟ Real Estate Agents ᶟ Feed Join / Sign in Search Overview Sale & tax history Property details Neighborhood Climate Favorite Edit Facts OFF MARKET Street View Redesign 41 photos
Page 8
OFF MARKET— SOLD FEB 2025 FOR $435,000 Estimated sale price $498,020 Est. refi payment $1,185/mo—See my rate $474,000 – $573,000 3 bd • 2 ba • 1,536 sq ft Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Plus, you’ll save $4,980 in324 South Haven St, South Haven, MI 49090 fees. Schedule a selling consultation Claim home Claim home to manage this property View dashboard Edit facts Manage photos Get an in-depth report about your home value and the South Haven market. About this home Charming and spacious, this home is just 4 short blocks to Kids Corner and South Beach Request a free analysis access via the Blue Stairs! And close to downtown South Haven! Enter this home through the enclosed front porch! There is a main floor bedroom with direct access to the newer large deck and hot tub. Huge dining room and living room for family gatherings. Many windows allow natural light throughout. There is a side drive for off street parking. Furnishings are negotiable. Single-family 1900 6,300 sq ft Property Type Year Built Lot Size $324 Est. Price/Sq.Ft. Listed by Debbie Ehrlich • Greenridge Realty South Haven Bought with Amy O'Sullivan • Jaqua REALTORS Redfin checked: a minute ago • Source: SW Michigan MLS #25001641 Redfin Estimate $498,020 $63K since sold in February 2025 $9,000 since February Recently sold homes Estimate history Homes for sale SOLD JAN 9, 2026 SOLD DEC 23, 2025 SOLD OCT 30, 2025 $520,000 A $255,000 B $325,500 C 3 beds 2.5 baths 1,724 sq ft 3 beds 2.5 baths 1,478 sq ft 3 beds 2 baths 1,123 sq ft 325 Superior St, South Have… 620 Bailey Ave, South Haven,… 310 Van Buren St, South… E FF CACDAD B
Page 9
B Claim this home to receive a free report every month with I own 324 South Haven Stinsights on the changing estimate. Estimated sale earnings Desired selling price $498,020 Remaining mortgage -$342,000 Est. closing costs: -$35,651 Sell with a Redfin agent +$4,980 Estimated profit $125,349 Market trends in 49090, MI Last updated February 2026 Buyer's Seller's -- Median sale price Market Market -- Avg. days on market Recently sold homes Balanced market -- -- New listings for sale NEW 24 HRS AGO OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM $565,000 $325,000 $599,000 2 beds 2 baths 1,084 sq ft 2 beds 2.5 baths 1,950 sq ft 2 beds 2 baths 1,762 sq ft 516 Williams St #10, South Haven,… 234 Bailey Ave, South Haven, MI… 800 North Shore Dr #1, South… Estimated earnings Rental estimate Est. $1,144 per month, based on comparable rentals S l hi t f 324 S th H St
Page 10
Sale history for 324 South Haven St
Date Event Price
SW Michigan MLS #25001641
Feb 21, 2025 Sold $435,000
$283/sq ft
Feb 20, 2025 Pending —
Jan 16, 2025 Contingent —
Jan 11, 2025 Listed $429,000
$279/sq ft
MiRealSource-MiMLS #70448301
Feb 21, 2025 Sold $435,000
$283/sq ft
Feb 20, 2025 Pending —
Jan 16, 2025 Contingent —
Show more
Tax history for 324 South Haven St
b
Year Property tax Land + Additions = Assessment*
2025 $4,195b( 20.3%)
2024 $5,266b(+5.7%)
2023 $4,983b(+5.2%)
2022 $4,735b(+4.0%)
2021 $4,552b(+0.7%)
2020 $4,520b(+3.6%)
2019 $4 365 (+2 3%)
Show more
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and
does not affect market price.
Property details
Interior
Bathroom Information Interior Features
# of Full Bathrooms: 2 Interior Features: Hot Tub Spa
# of Rooms Total: 6
Heating & Cooling Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Range,
Has Heating Refrigerator, Washer
Has Cooling
Room InformationPage 11
SALE COMP #3 City, Address, School, Agent, ZIP Buy ᶟ Rent ᶟ Sell ᶟ Mortgage ᶟ Real Estate Agents ᶟ Feed Join / Sign in Search Overview Sale & tax history Property details Neighborhood Climate Favorite Edit Facts SOLD DEC 23, 2025 Street View Redesign 14 photos
Page 12
SOLD ON DEC 23, 2025 Estimated sale price $255,000 Sold Price $317,000 – $384,000 3 bd • 2.5 ba • 1,478 sq ft Reach more buyers when you sell with 620 Bailey Ave, South Haven, MI 49090 Redfin. Plus, you’ll save $3,332 in fees. Is this your home? Schedule a selling consultation I own 620 Bailey Ave Track this home’s value and nearby sales activity About this home Cute 3 bedroom home on a beautiful corner lot in the City of South Haven. Easy walking distance to South Haven Beaches, Black River and Downtown restaurants and shopping. Great starter home or investment property. Remodeled and updated kitchen, additional bath and shower in basement, fenced deck area. Great home and a great price! Single-family 1910 6,534 sq ft Property Type Year Built Lot Size $173 Price/Sq.Ft. Listed by Gale Realty Gale • Gale Realty, LLC Bought with Matthias DeJongh • Greenridge Realty South Haven Redfin checked: a few seconds ago • Source: SW Michigan MLS #25057562 Redfin Estimate $333,219 $78K since sold in December 2025 $68K since February Recently sold homes Estimate history Homes for sale SOLD JAN 9, 2026 SOLD NOV 19, 2025 SOLD AUG 7, 2025 $520,000 A $369,000 B $365,000 C 3 beds 2.5 baths 1,724 sq ft 3 beds 2 baths 1,651 sq ft 3 beds 2 baths 1,385 sq ft 325 Superior St, South Have… 727 Wilson St, South Haven, … 840 Superior St, South Have… F B DD AA CC E
Page 13
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with I own 620 Bailey Aveinsights on the changing estimate. Market trends in 49090, MI Last updated February 2026 Buyer's Seller's -- Median sale price Market Market -- Avg. days on market Recently sold homes Balanced market -- -- New listings for sale NEW 23 HRS AGO OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM $565,000 $325,000 $599,000 2 beds 2 baths 1,084 sq ft 2 beds 2.5 baths 1,950 sq ft 2 beds 2 baths 1,762 sq ft 516 Williams St #10, South Haven,… 234 Bailey Ave, South Haven, MI… 800 North Shore Dr #1, South… Homeowner tools View owner dashboard Track your estimate and nearby sale activity Edit home facts Review property details and add renovations Manage photos Update home photos or make them private Home sale earnings Est. $109K when you sell with Redfin Rental estimate Est. $934 per month, based on comparable rentals Sale and tax history for 620 Bailey Ave Sale History Tax History Date Event Price REALCOMP #69025057562
Page 14
Dec 23, 2025 Sold $255,000 $173/sq ft Nov 15, 2025 Pending — Nov 10, 2025 Listed $249,900 $169/sq ft SW Michigan MLS #25057562 Dec 23, 2025 Sold $255,000 $173/sq ft Nov 15 2025 Pending Show more Property details Interior Bathroom Information Room 2 Information # of Full Bathrooms: 2 Room Type: Living Room # of Half Bathrooms: 1 Room 3 Information Heating & Cooling Room Type: Dining Room Has Heating Room 4 Information Cooling: Window Unit(s) Has Cooling Room Type: Bathroom 1 Heating: Forced Air Room 5 Information Interior Features Room Type: Primary Bedroom # of Rooms Total: 6 Room 6 Information Room Information Room Type: Bathroom 2 Basement: Michigan Basement Room 7 Information Room 1 Information Room Type: Bedroom 2 Room Type: Kitchen Room 8 Information Room Type: Bedroom 3 E t i Show all property details Around this home 51/100 Somewhat Walkable 45/100 Somewhat bikeable Schools Places Transit Lincoln Elementary 5/10 Public PreK-3 • Assigned • 0.6mi WAY South Haven Public 9-12 • Assigned • 1.4mi Show nearby schools
Page 15
SALE COMP #4 City, Address, School, Agent, ZIP Buy ᶟ Rent ᶟ Sell ᶟ Mortgage ᶟ Real Estate Agents ᶟ Feed Join / Sign in Search Overview Sale & tax history Property details Neighborhood Climate Favorite Edit Facts SOLD AUG 7, 2025 Street View Redesign 36 photos
Page 16
OFF MARKET— SOLD AUG 2025 FOR $365,000 Estimated sale price $434,313 Est. refi payment $2,326/mo—See my rate $413,000 – $500,000 3 bd • 2 ba • 1,385 sq ft Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Plus, you’ll save $4,343 in840 Superior St, South Haven, MI 49090 fees. Schedule a selling consultation Claim home Claim home to manage this property View dashboard Edit facts Manage photos Get an in-depth report about your home value and the South Haven market. About this home **Prepare to fall in love.** Nestled in the heart of South Haven and just a short stroll to Request a free analysis the iconic Blue Steps and sandy shores of Lake Michigan, 840 Superior Street is the kind of home that rarely comes along. Bursting with character, filled with natural light, and surrounded by beautifully maintained landscaping, this storybook bungalow blends historic charm with everyday comfort—offering the perfect setting for your next chapter Show more Single-family 1920 10,469 sq ft Property Type Year Built Lot Size $314 Est. Price/Sq.Ft. Listed by Sarah Wellman • Five Star Real Estate-Douglas Bought with Ron Seiler • Coldwell Banker Woodland Schmidt Redfin checked: 3 minutes ago • Source: SW Michigan MLS #25033920 Redfin Estimate $434,313 $69K since sold in August 2025 $4,000 since February Recently sold homes Estimate history Homes for sale SOLD DEC 23, 2025 SOLD NOV 19, 2025 SOLD SEP 22, 2025 $255,000 A $369,000 B $491,500 C 3 beds 2.5 baths 1,478 sq ft 3 beds 2 baths 1,651 sq ft 3 beds 2 baths 1,380 sq ft 620 Bailey Ave, South Haven,… 727 Wilson St, South Haven, … 601 Kalamazoo St, South… BE F
Page 17
DC A Claim this home to receive a free report every month with I own 840 Superior Stinsights on the changing estimate. Estimated sale earnings Desired selling price $434,313 Remaining mortgage -$289,000 Est. closing costs: -$31,357 Sell with a Redfin agent +$4,343 Estimated profit $118,299 Market trends in 49090, MI Last updated February 2026 Buyer's Seller's -- Median sale price Market Market -- Avg. days on market Recently sold homes Balanced market -- -- New listings for sale NEW 23 HRS AGO OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM $565,000 $325,000 $599,000 2 beds 2 baths 1,084 sq ft 2 beds 2.5 baths 1,950 sq ft 2 beds 2 baths 1,762 sq ft 516 Williams St #10, South Haven,… 234 Bailey Ave, South Haven, MI… 800 North Shore Dr #1, South… Estimated earnings Rental estimate Est. $1,175 per month, based on comparable rentals
Page 18
Sale history for 840 Superior St
Date Event Price
SW Michigan MLS #25033920
Aug 7, 2025 Sold $365,000
$264/sq ft
Jul 11, 2025 Pending —
Jul 10, 2025 Listed $359,999
$260/sq ft
MiRealSource-MiMLS #70480571
Aug 7, 2025 Sold $365,000
$264/sq ft
Jul 11, 2025 Pending —
Jul 10, 2025 Listed $359,999
$260/sq ft
Show more
Tax history for 840 Superior St
b
Year Property tax Land + Additions = Assessment*
2025 $5,791b( 20.2%)
2024 $7,261b(+5.7%)
2023 $6,871b(+5.3%)
2022 $6,525b(+4.0%)
2021 $6,273b( 7.3%)
2020 $6,764b(+77.7%)
2019 $3 807 (+56 0%)
Show more
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and
does not affect market price.
Property details
Interior
Virtual Tour Room 3 Information
Virtual Tour URL Unbranded: Virtual Tour Room Width: 15
(External Link) Room Type: Dining Room
Room Length: 12
Bathroom Information