24-003589.pdf

Judy L Gentner, Petitioner V Township Of Burtchville, Respondent · 24-003589-TT

← View full record

Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.

GRETCHEN WHITMER 

GOVERNOR 

STATE OF MICHIGAN 

DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS 

LANSING 

RECEIVED 

OCT 102024 

MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL. 

MARLON 

I. BROWN, DPA 

DIRECTOR 

PROPERTY TAX APPEAL ANSWER FORM 

VALUATION / EXEMPTION / CLASSIFICATION APPEAL 

MTT DOCKET NO. 24-003689-TT 

Section 1: Respondent’s Contact Information 

First Name: 

mi: 

Burtchville Township 

Last Name/Company Name/Unit of Government: 

Home Address {No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route): 

4000 Burtch Rd 

“"3t, Clair 

City or Town: 

State: 

ZIP Code: 

Lakeport 

MI 

148059 

Telephone Number: 

Fax Number: 

(810)385-5577 

(810)385-8551 

sbaumeister@hotmail.com 

E-mail Address {do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via email); 

Section 2: Respondent's Attorney/Authorized Representative’s Contact Information 

First Name: 

Shelly 

M1: 

Last Name: 

Baumeister 

Firm Name (if any): 

Burtchville Township Assessor 

Address (No., Street, P.O. Box or Rural Route): 

4000 Burtch Rd 

City or Town: 

Lakeport 

State: 

MI 

ZIP Code: 

48059 

Tetephone Number: 

(810)385-5577 

Fax Number; 

(810)385-8551 

sbaumeister@hotmail.com 

E-mail Address (do not enter unless you want MTT to send all correspondence via emall): 

Section 3: Subject Property Information 

Yes 

[1 No 

Does the subject property have a Principal Residence Exemption of 50% or more? 

0 Yes 

0 

No 

Not Applicable 

Are the parcels listed by Petitioner contiguous or adjoining? 

If not, list which parcels adjoin one another.

STATE OF MICHIGAN 

GRETCHEN WHITMER 

DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS 

MARLON I, BROWN, DPA 

GOVERNOR 

LANSING 

DIRECTOR 

Section 4: Explain Your Answer to this Appeal 

Property is assessed uniformly within the township, as well as in accordance with the 

sales price. Attached are land values and ECF sales studies to provide proof of value 

and assessment. 

Section 5: Jurisdictional Issues 

IF PETITIONER 1S APPEALING THE TRUE CASH AND/OR TAXABLE VALUES 

Did Petitioner protest the assessment at a Board of Review (BOR)? [4] Yes 

[] No 

If yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended; [i March 

[J July 

[} December 

If no, was the Natice of Assessment properly sent to Petitioner prior to the March BOR? [Hl] Yes 

O No 

*Submit a copy of the Notice of Assessment with the Answer, 

ifthe July or December BOR revised the assessment(s} at issue, did it have authority? [Hm] Yes 

[I] No 

If yes, cite the Board's authority. 

Was the assessment(s) at issue established as the result of a clerical error or mutual mistake of fact? [mi] Yes 

No 

if yes, explain 

Is Petitioner appeallng from a State Tax Commission Order? 

[J Yes 

[4 No 

If so, what Is the issue date? 

IF PETITIONER {8 APPEALING THE UNCAPPING OF TAXABLE VALUE

STATE OF MICHIGAN 

GRETCHEN WHITMER 

DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS 

GOVERNOR 

LANSING 

MARLON 

|. BROWN, DPA 

DIRECTOR 

Did Petitioner request a Poverty Exemption ata BOR? [] Yes 

[J No 

If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: O March 

0 July 

O December 

List the date the BOR denied Petitioner's Poverty Exemption: 

IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE DENIAL OF AN EXEMPTION 

OTHER THAN POVERTY, PRINCIPAL RESIDENCE, OR QUALIFIED AGRICULTURAL EXEMPTIONS 

Did Petitioner request the exemption at a BOR? [| Yes 

O No 

If Yes, check which BOR Petitioner attended: [] March 

[J] July 

[] December 

Tax Year(s) denied: 

List the date the exemption was denied: 

What statutory section did Petitioner request the subject property be exempt? 

IF PETITIONER IS APPEALING THE CLASSIFICATION OF PROPERTY 

What do you believe the classification should be: 

Real 

Personal 

(check one) 

O 

Agricultural 

Commercial 

Industrial 

Residential 

Timber-Cutover 

Developmental 

Utility 

(check one) 

Section 6: Valuation Information *use the multiple parcel form for additional, contiguous parcels, 

Parcel Identification Number: 

74-11-470-0031-000 

Classification of Property: 

Real 

Personal 

(check one) 

rl 

Agricultural 

Commercial 

Industrial 

Residential 

Timber-Cutover 

Developmental 

Utility 

(check one) 

Current Assessed Value (also known as State Equalized Value) as established by the BOR: 

379,500 

Current Taxable Value as established by the BOR: 

379,500 

What do you believe is the fair market value (also known as True Cash Value)? 

758,902 

Multiply the True Cash Value by .5 and enter here. This is your contention of Assessed Value. 

379,500 

If you believe the Taxable Value differs from your contention of Assessed Value, enter your contention of Taxable Value. 

379,500

+xxPP33URIEND J0U ING STURTTS

OT28 702 

: 

_ 

oot’est 

005'88 

120 

EE 

pa 

; 

A 

i 

‘9TTT

0086112 

008 

‘862 

00£°0TZ 

006°88 

zoe) 

"6002 

~ 66

06ST '2ZT 

nN 

000°2Zy¢ 

009°8¥Z 

00% ce 

i 

Eeoz 

: 

S

800S’6LE 

HO0G’6LE 

100G76LE 

008°¢€Le 

00L°SOT 

PZ0Zi 

BUM 

usym 

ouM 

snTeA 

19430 

noTARY 

lenten 

antes 

sntea 

i 

STqeX®L 

/TeungIil 

JO pIeod 

Ipessassy 

burtpTIng 

puet 

E3-TY 

UT®Id Poot 

oe 

er 

mr 

pueTiay 

; 

sutaey 

i 

JUCIIISIBM 

X 

: 

puog 

: 

papoon 

durems 

padeospue] 

ubtH 

no 

buriToy 

X¥ 

n 

} 

T9497 

9318 

} 

Aydeabodog 

“sTT3n punoxbrepun 

; 

- 

SU 

RR 

SeT3TTT3IN PIEPURIS 

: 

SIYBTT 389135 

20L°TT 

= anTeA USED nil sjuswonoIdul pueT pPOILWTIST TEBIOL 

qn 

8EV’'€ 

[44 

0%9 

[42844 

PUBS 

UC OTA 

1d/M/Q 

se 

X 

908°1T 

[44 

096 

$6°8 

832I0UOD GE 

:d/M/Q 

Strood 

X 

906S 

[44 

0v1E 

$578 

838I0U0D GE 

:d/M/Q 

Tomas 

z85 

[#4 

919 

LOY 

butaed 3Teudsy :d/m/q 

zenem 

¥ 

snTea Used 

pPooD 

§ 

SZTS 

FREE] 

uotadraosaq 

ATeMODTS 

re 

$91BWTIST 3500 JuswLAOIdWI pueT 

tomag wrote 

No 

0 

one 

N— 

— 

SR —— 

bm 

pf 

eer 

-" 

° 

gp 

d. 

X 

HOYES 

897/112 

= eunTeA puel 

‘3sF TRIOL 

§2I0Y TeIOL TE'0 

‘3993 3U0II TenIdDY 

7¥ 

P aon aa 

897 TIC 

00T 

O00EP 

€0T6°0 

8LZZ T 007°60€ 

00° %F 

AY 

NO 

INO¥I 

x 

Fm 

antTeA 

uosesy 

-Cpyy 

saey 

yideg 

2uozg 

yideg 

abriuoad 

uotidrIossq 

i 

syuswesoxduy 

» 

SIONORA 

x 

| 

2T1qng 

IVTd HOYEE ONVIEMYT 0LPP 0LPp ©TQRl PURT IOI S9JBWIISH BNTRA PUR 

Jueoes 

paaoxdur: 

x 

! 

ym 

—— 

N 

VAL/ADL 

; 

AnL 

asE 

I 

I 

18°98Z 

* 

ADL 

2068S. ADL 

¥202 

3 

em 

ees 

glgy 

If dd 

¥202/L2/20 

%00T 

"@ 4-4 

_ 

6802. 

0007/81/71 

) 

butpTIng 

1SIO TOOHOS VENY NOWAH INOd :TOOUdS 

snaeas 

Ze0umy 

23eq 

(s)ryuxsg BuypTing. ¥I¥, 

:BUTUOZ: OMAWI-TYIINZGISEY 

07001 

- 

Jatciclet 

HIONET S,W8Y-E£0. 

aM 

666T/.0/90 

10 

_.. TIANYS/HAATO 

00 io QFE 

6V8/09¢v. WAHIO/QESN ION-TZ 

00: 

2102/92/10 To 

; ISOM YEANYS/HJATO 

0°00T 

| 

agag 

ZEE/9L9S 

HIONET 

S NY-€0) 

aM; 

€20Z/0€/TT_000°0SL | 

ENNAT XQOC 

“M

-sueLl 

Ag 

obed 

» 

2dKT 

a3eq 

tentad 

Squoag 

POTITIOA 

I8qEY 

2TRS 

JO Swill 

“3sur 

ates 

eTES 

9

5202/80/01 

uo pejurTig 

¥IVID 1S 

:Ajunod 

ATHSNMOL FTITAHOL¥NE 

(UOTIOTPSTIAND 

0

(L¥1d 

HOVAE ONVIEMYT 

OL¥) 

sxspoOFuUEIENS 

J0U ANY STYRTIT

v20Z/80/0T 

Uo 

po1uTig 

000-TE00-0LP-TTHL 

tIaqumy 

TSoIed 

2ELSES 

PADI 

<= 002° 1 

a8 

a. 

—— 

[320-327 

86L°6LG 

tsTe30L 

‘ 

sswenT umg dum 

956 °L1 

zee 

4 

£3038 

¢ ToTIS3XE 

219405 199 0002 

er 3E0ddns 

saoeTdeatd 

| 

Stade 

es 

TF) 

TI60q 

‘ 

vz 

171 

sberes z8a0 HRIOLS 

PIERS TED 000T 

T° 

4g 

r0

688°T 

£S 

TToM Iolem 

i 

019722 

v9£°62 

v8Y 

3s0p ssed 

Tomes Stand 

(a) 

szo0q 

(PRUSTUTIUN) 

UYOUI 8 

:UOTIRPUNOI BUTPTS 

:IOTISIXF DE SSB | 

iorem orrang. 

1 

IS 

sabezeg 

| 

: 

L' 

3g 

uorj

‘ 

‘ 

xemag/xsxem 

(pT) 

| TT

eel 

IE 

poll 

= 

; 

: 

ysTutTg 

j

S2UDIOZ 

sao 

urd usa 

I00TJ 3

AODTY QNI JTWeIad 

2991 

8sT'e 

I 

Ie3eM OTTANE 

| sutem STTL OTWRISD 

Poon 

p68 

95€ 9 

T 

5713deS Te 0001 

| TooTd TTI OTWRISH 

. 

IeMBG/IB%RN 

| 

18M0yg oneaRdeg) 

ouel 

S16°¢ 

7917s 

T 

yjeg SIMIXTI 

7 

| 

Juts eax 

0078 

Z€6°G 

POLL 

T 

y3eg SANIXTI 

€ 

187101 

eXaXT 

J

But 

: 

: 

a 

TqQumig 

putquUTd 

ON 

| 

S3uUsMWISNLPY/SUOTITOPY I2U30 | 

 jesy i91eM TBTOS 

{00 

:s3sTop

601 '8LE 

Z50‘T6¥ 

tTe30l 

Tenuey 

‘Isusijos: 

‘d'

0Z 

juswsseg 

}oTIg 

Axoas 

1 

ony 

‘I3uUs130S 

ds 

9z 

Jususseg 

3otag 

£1038 

1 

y3eg exnixTd 

Zz: 

1. 

4°S _T6YL

09 

Juswesey 

Notre 

AX01S 

6271 

san9xT, 

oe 

Iuewsseg 

Yorra 

 Aroas og T 

Je Ee 

_mOT

9601 

Jusuesedg 

ota 

K1038 

7 

3sop 

-xde@ 

map 3S0D 

22TS 

uoTIePUNOg 

IOTIDIXT 

$3TI0S 

I _burqunta (1) i. 

ses1y HUTpIINg 

ARS 

Aue 

LL/00T/00T/00T/LL=PO0OD 

§ ~quOD/UODE/DuUnd/Aud 

"qv/Aud 

s397IN0 00TH FO 

con. 

TT

“IS 9597 

= ®RIY I0OTE 

JS Z6BT 

= B9IY PUNOID 

BL 

Au 

| 

s

I93°M 10H P8dIod 

:welisAs buriesy 

(11) 

UIK 

“B10 

“XE 

X 

_I00Z 

318 

og 

S10 

R80IS 

7 

AtTureg 

eTbuts 

T 

bp1e 

'Sey 

TOF 

"38d 3500 

$2IN3¥TI4 

JO 

-“Tend/ 

oN 

LS

— 

een 

a 

SS 

pogad

: 300% 

wo3shs Aazanoss 

....29TATes 

SAY 0 

poompae

unnoes 

TEIUS 

em 

teary 3z0dIRD: 

ZEL'GES ADIL POIBWTISH 

zonmaduon aver 

_ »Ta30eTd 

tzu) 

prm———— 

gape 

yg 

€pp‘9yy 

:3s0D adeq TEIOL 

eunes 

Csomuzng pooy 

TTT 

saferen juwsg 

-g-o- 

‘ 

HE 

el 

nO DR TBD JUWSE] 

gD 

F 

86L sus 

i non 

ove fee 

obey wesTy FTOS 

ty Tesiuen 

SCH 

JBT

Yr 

ena 

sberoas pe 

£7 

toby 0933 

Soue 

hrepanas 

BUTTO0D/BUTIRRH ON 

rreus. px

: 

x 

: 

F 

di 

0 :poos 

3 

sad 

anc 

1005 

3 

ean oneal. S395

78y 

1eIAV: 

© POIUBA-IVDITA! 

qnr- dex 

Tzznoep 

soBUING 

100TJ/TTEM 

UTH 

0 

:1SI00Q 

"UODW 

24015 

POON! 

qnl 

Tzznoep 

zo3e8H 

200d 

HT

0 

:sIoOQE 

-OInY. 

YIIBSH 

POsSTeRY| 

WODISJUL 

Je8H 

TTEM DTI109TH 

.....JOTIBI

ii pausTUTd 

FOIBINIITO FBSH 

POOH paausa 

(100TF-uT) 

IURTPRR 

53] pooM, 

YouI 

§1 

:UOTIEPUNOF| 

Kxo01s 

7 qeyexd 

pooy paiusaun 

Juetpey 

Tres oT 

18358 

SUPRISq 

TTEM UoumoD: 

Axo3g 

T geyeId 

ani 10H 

pIrogeseg oTI1091F 

0 

‘udp SUOIS; 

A1035 

7 T0TI2IXA: 

Z 

uel usp 

zee 10H peoIoE 

Rome 

0 usp FoTIg 

KI103s 

T 

IOTI9IXET 

T97©9H yieq 

$3000 

Jn ITY peoIod. 

BUTPTS 

:IOTIIIRT! 

sa0i9¢ 

PIPTS 

omMl 

TesodsTg 

abeqres 

saomg 

O/mM 

ITY POSIT 

bueyzaap

29 

:SSeTD; 

J je 

XDB1S 

BWERS/pUy 

I2YSEBAUS TQ 

bueyxsag

:A3roede) 

TBD 

rere L200 RIO3E 

7 IOTISUL 

dor 

300) 

wealsg 

20D 

i 

poop! 

uoT

: 

1 

p 

_:31Tng Te8x! 

°dAg eoIy | A035 

T I0TIUI 

“moTTY douetrddy 

oer 

sea 

i 

ybnox

obexes 

(LT) 

| 

oxona, soupTod 

(971) 

saoerdarty 

(ST) 

sur-37Ing 

{ST} 

burroop/butiesy 

(11) 

~ 

(r3uo2)

xxxPP23ueIENb 

JOU 

INQ STULIT

wpa 

ot fq omg 

ll bab 

H 

» 

fre] 

: 

: 

Kd 

of 

Log 

a 

st Lic ise 

Ae 

a 

Kh 

la 

As 

bi 

" 

i 

ks 

. 

BL 

i 

sah y 

ied 

$Z02/80/0T 

Uo peiutig 

1 burpiTng TETIUSPTSSY

Fo ku fives EOF 

58°C 

<="A3Q "PIS 

LEY 

<= ojzey "oes 

000'v99°TS 

 00S°00£°€S 

005'00L°€S 

s{eoL 

£TT 

006'€LS$ 

000'SLT$ 

HIDNITSWEV-€0 

aM 000'SLTS 

 TZ/0T/TT 

1S INIVEHO1

v8'6¢ 

7000158 

000°82T$ 

HIDNI1SWEV-€0 

OM -000°82L$ 

| 

zg/vife0 

ay JUOHSHIVT

PLE 

008TLES 

000°058$ 

HIONITSNEY-E0 

~ OM" 000'058$ 

 TZ/vi/L0 

N13SOY:QTIM

60 

00T°CTES 

000'569% 

HIONITSNYY-E0 

AM 000°569S 

 TT/T0/90 

GY FJHOHSINV

£L'Ly 

008VTTS 

000°05t$ 

HIDNITSNYV-€0 

QM 0000SPS 

 TT/80/TT 

 QY JYOHSINVI

6LLy 

-00€P02S 

008'LTrS 

HIONITSNYV-E0" 

AM 00S'LThS 

 TZ/0€/80° 

- QY FYOHSINVI

£LvY 

00T9¢YS 

000'56$ 

HIONITSINYV-E0 

. AM 000'SZ65 

72/81/10 

. 

OY IWOHSIIV

i bos 

TEBYOSEET'S 

\JOIUBDIYBO) 

QTES'Y 

 <=IDUBLIEA "BAY 

] 

8YZTT 

<='4073 ‘any 

LETB0°0 

 <=UONEIN3( "PIS 

S971 

<=°403 

SPLIT 

86°€ETS 

9TTZTLTS 

[424 E154 

HONVY 

ZTTZ'9T 

0ELY 

8TGYIS 

800°T 

T180'T 

99%'SETS 

GEV VTS 

1

THONYY: £9420 

08Lw 

94'58$ 

CYCLE 

UUISET 

B0T0LS 

TL 

SESURS 

YL 

A

-AHOIS 7: OVES® 7 

0TLY 

LO09TS 

ii 

TeSLE 

9EE'T 

CTTOSYS 

“10L°T09S 

66

AYOLS ¥/TT T8YLOT 

(Ja 

9T6ETS 

004°C 

9SE€'T 

SLELLTS 

600°9/€$ 

T

AYOIS¥/TT 

9€00°€ 

ogov 

8€'06$ 

L297 

8LTT 

E€VO'STTS 

woLYTS 

8

HONVY: T9887 

0S0V 

© 

LL°8EIS 

PE6ET 

6TZT- 7P§'8STS 

SOE‘E6TS 

S

AMOISY/ET 8p9TE 

0€0Y 

LEBLIS 

ZEPPE 

STITT 

£ST'S0SS 

£TTYT9S 

L

SIN

pS 

11474 

Tov 

ov 

oP 

Tov 

1X4)74 

110i 

191d ANV

Yd GNY

JO HOY38 N

d HOV38 AN

$ Sd0¥d INO

-'$$d0Ud IN

Ajuo s356dINd JoUOROWIONT] -14/00S

7 S$-91

00£‘ps=91eYy JuoLaleM H20T 

00€Y 

S$ 

11V 40 Say 

009 

$ 

0S 

000°0€C 

$ 020T/8

009°¢ 

$ 

0S 

000081 

S$ 

810T7/

09€°€ 

$ 

0S 

000891 

S$ LT0T/E

Ajuo

00Z's 

$ 

001 

000°0Z5 

S$ €202/0

BINQ gEET—5 §¢ 

660'S2T—5 ETOT/S

K[Uio

008c$=a1eY JU0ILIBIEM £202 

0sL'y 

$ 

44 43d Say 

00°08LY 

$ 

001 

000°5LYy 

$ 1z0t/6

1004 JU0.14 134 diag 

1994 1U044 

ao11d sajes 

a

€2/0E/€-12/1/v 

pod soles 

J)

LC 

7 YA 

F930 7£2'% 

re TYIT 7 IHD. 

VAT Ls TU 17 Vio 7A 

/ 

L/ H 

i

BURTCHVILLE TOWNSHIP 

4000 BURTCH ROAD 

BURTCHVILLE, MI 48059 

ws HeprinnR 

esos

← View full record