24-003862.pdf
Holiday Village Tc & 1950 Investments Tic LLC, Petitioner V Township Of East Bay, Respondent · 24-003862-TT
Text extracted from the reviewed PDF, organized by page. OCR and reading order may contain errors; confirm details in the PDF below.
Page 1
RECEIVED 0CT 202025 wr AD. MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL STATE OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING & REGULATORY AFFAIRS MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION Holiday Village TC & 1950 Investments TIC LLC, Pai Shitiouess, MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Vv East Bay Charter Township, Respondent. —— — i / S. Douglas Tour J Ryan Porte Touma, Whaling, Coury, Grout, Georgia & Director Of Assessing Kamidoi, PC East Bay Charter Township Attorneys for Petitioners Representatives for Respondent 316 McMorran Blvd. 1965 N. Three Mile Rd. Port Huron, MI 48060 Traverse City, MI 49696 (810) 987-7700 x105 (231) 947-8647 x4 sdtouma(@tweslaw.com rporte@eastbaytwp.org / Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment 1 The parcels are located in Grand Traverse County. 2: The case is pending in the __ Entire Tribunal OR X Small Claims Division. 3: Property Parcel No. — multiple — see Attachment. 4. The values for the property identified above as established by Respondent’s Board of Review are: See Attachment.
Page 2
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment 6. If stipulation addresses tax years other than the tax year originally appealed or tax years added through motions to amend that have been granted by the Tribunal, list the separate facts upon which the parties rely to invoke the Tribunal’s authority over those tax year or years (attach additional page if necessary): 7. List separately any special terms or conditions being proposed by the parties that would affect the execution of this Consent Judgment including, but not limited to, the joint payment of the refund, the waiver of interest, etc.: IT IS FURTHER ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that refunds shall be made payable to Holiday Village TC, LLC and sent to Petitioners C/O Russell Franchi, 174 Watercolor Way, Ste 103, #355, Santa Rosa Beach, FIL 32459. Calculations of the refund amount also be shall sent to Petitioners at the same address, All interest due on any refund is waived if, and only if, all refunds otherwise due are paid within 42 days of the entry of the comsent judgment, however, otherwise interest shall be paid as provided in the Tax Tribunal Act, including MCL 205.737. Touma, Whaling, Coury, Grout, Georgia & Kamidoi, PC Aittomeys for Petitioners Ss. Douglas Touma NN - 316 McMorran Blvd. Port Huron, MI 48060 (810) 987-7700 x105 sdtoumafifitweslaw.com Dated: October??, 2025 East Bay Charter Township Representative for Respondent Director Of Assessing 1965 N. Three Mile Rd. Traverse City, MI 4969 (231) 947-8647 x4 rporte(@eastbaytwp.org Dated: Octobera?, 2025 6 RI
Page 3
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment STATE OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF LICENSING & REGULATORY AFFAIRS MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL SMALL CLAIMS DIVISION Holiday Village TC & 1950 Investments TIC LLC, Petitioners, MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Vv East Bay Charter Township, Respondent. S. Douglas Touma | EEN Ryan Porte Touma, Whaling, Coury, Grout, Georgia & Director Of Assessing Kamidoi, PC East Bay Charter Township Attorneys for Petitioners Representatives for Respondent 316 McMorran Blvd. 1965 N. Three Mile Rd. Port Huron, MI 48060 Traverse City, MI 49696 (810) 987-7700 x105 (231) 947-8647 x4 sdtouma(@tweslaw.com rporte@eastbaytwp.org Multiple Parcel Attachment to Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment I. The values for the property identified herein as established by Respondent’s Board of Review are: | Year | Parcel No. True Cash Value | Assessed Value | Taxable Value 2024 | 03-502-002-00 $196,400 | $98,200 $98,200 2024 | 03-502-003-00 | ~~ $196,400 $98,200 $98,200 2024 | 03-502-004-00_ $196,400 $98,200 $98,200 2024 | 03-502-005-00 $196,400 $98,200 $98,200 2024 | 03-502-006-00 $196,400 $98,200 $98,200
Page 4
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment Year | Parcel No. "| True Cash Value | Assessed Value | Taxable Value | | 2024 | 03-503-003-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-004-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-005-00 | $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 | 2024 | 03-503-006-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 | 2024 | 03-503-007-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-008-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 | 2024 | 03-503-009-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-010-00 $203,400 $101,700 $101,700 2024 | 03-503-011-00 $203,600 $101,800 | $101,800 | 2024 | 03-503-012-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-013-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-014-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-015-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-016-00 | $203,600 $101,800 $101,800 2024 | 03-503-017-00 $203,400 $101,700 $101,700 | 2024 | 03-503-018-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-019-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-020-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-021-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-022-00 | ~~ $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-023-00 | ~~ $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 | 2024 | 03-503-024-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-025-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-026-00 $203,400 $101,700 $101,700 2024 | 03-503-027-00 $205,400 $102,700 $102,700 2024 | 03-503-028-00 $197,200 $98,600 $98,600 2024 | 03-503-029-00 | ~~ $197,200 $98,600 $98,600 2024 | 03-503-030-00 | $197,200 $98,600 $98,600 2024 | 03-503-031-00 $197,200 $98,600 $98,600 2024 | 03-503-032-00 $197,200 $98,600 $98,600 2024 | 03-503-033-00 $193,200 $96,600 $96,600 2024 | 03-503-034-00 | $205,400 $102,700 | $102,700 2024 | 03-503-035-00 | $205,400 $102,700 $102,700
Page 5
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment Year | Parcel No. True Cash Value | Assessed Value | Taxable Value 2024 | 03-503-041-00 $197,200 $98,600 $98,600 | 2024 | 03-503-042-00 $205,400 $102,700 $102,700 2024 | 03-503-043-00 $205,200 $102,600 $102,600 2024 | 03-503-044-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-045-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-046-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-047-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-048-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-049-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-050-00 $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-051-00 | $197,000 $98,500 $98,500 2024 | 03-503-052-00 $205,200 $102,600 $102,600 | 2024 | 03-503-053-00 $203,400 $101,700 $101,700 | 2024 | 03-503-054-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-055-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-056-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-057-00 | $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-058-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-059-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-060-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-061-00 $195,400 $97,700 $97,700 2024 | 03-503-062-00 $203,400 $101,700 $101,700 2025 | 03-502-002-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-003-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-004-00 $212,800 $106,400 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-005-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-006-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-007-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-008-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-502-009-00 $212,600 $106,300 $101,244 2025 | 03-503-001-00 $224,600 $112,300 $103,924 2025 | 03-503-002-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-003-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728
Page 6
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment Year | Parcel No. | True Cash Value | Assessed Value Taxable Value 2025 | 03-503-009-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-010-00 $224,600 $112,300 $104,852 2025 | 03-503-011-00 $224,600 $112,300 $104,955 2025 | 03-503-012-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-013-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-014-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-015-00 | $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-016-00 | $224,600 $112,300 $104,955 2025 | 03-503-017-00 $224,600 $112,300 $104,852 2025 | 03-503-018-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-019-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-020-00 $216,200 $108,100 | $100,728 | 2025 | 03-503-021-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-022-00 | $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 | 2025 | 03-503-023-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-024-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-025-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-026-00 $224,600 $112,300 $104,852 2025 | 03-503-027-00 $228,200 $114,100 $105,883 2025 | 03-503-028-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-029-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-030-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-031-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-032-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-033-00 $219,800 | $109,900 | $101,656 | 2025 | 03-503-034-00 $228,200 $114,100 $105,883 2025 | 03-503-035-00 $228,200 $114,100 $105,883 2025 | 03-503-036-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-037-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-038-00 $219,800 $109,900 | $101,656 2025 | 03-503-039-00 | ~~ $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 | 2025 | 03-503-040-00 | $219,800 $109,900 $101,656 2025 | 03-503-041-00 $219,800 $109,900 $101,656
Page 7
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment Year | Parcel No. | True Cash Value | Assessed Value Taxable Value | 2025 | 03-503-047-00 | $219,600 $109,800 $101,553 2025 | 03-503-048-00 $219,600 $109,800 $101,553 2025 | 03-503-049-00 $219,600 $109,800 $101,553 2025 | 03-503-050-00 $219,600 $109,800 $101,553 2025 | 03-503-051-00 | $219,600 $109,800 $101,553 | 2025 | 03-503-052-00 $228,000 $114,000 $105,780 2025 | 03-503-053-00 $224,600 $112,300 $104,852 2025 | 03-503-054-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-055-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-056-00 | $216,200 $108,100 | $100,728 2025 | 03-503-057-00 | $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-058-00 | $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-059-00 $218,000 $109,000 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-060-00 $216,200 $108,100 $100,728 2025 | 03-503-061-00 $216,200 $108,100 | $100,728 | 2025 | 03-503-062-00 $224,600 $112,300 $104,852 | 2. The values for the property identified herein as stipulated by the parties for settlement purposes are: True Cash Assessed/State Taxable Year | ParcelNo. | Value Equalized Value Value 2024 | 03-502-002-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-502-003-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-502-004-00 $155,000 $77,500 $77,500 2024 | 03-502-005-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-502-006-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-502-007-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-502-008-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-502-009-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-001-00 $158,800 $79,400 $79,400 2024 | 03-503-002-00 $154,200 $77,100 | $77,100 2024 | 03-503-003-00 _$154200 | $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-004-00. $154,200 $77,100 $77,100
Page 8
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment True Cash Assessed/State Taxable Year | Parcel No. Value Equalized Value | Value 2024 | 03-503-011-00 $160,000 $80,000 | $80,000 2024 | 03-503-012-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-013-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 12024 | 03-503-014-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-015-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 ~] 2024 | 03-503-016-00 $160,000 $80,000 $80,000 2024 | 03-503-017-00 | $160,000 $80,000 $80,000 2024 | 03-503-018-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-019-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-020-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-021-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-022-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-023-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-024-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-025-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 | 2024 | 03-503-026-00 $160,000 $80,000 $80,000 2024 | 03-503-027-00 $161,200 $80,600 $80,600 2024 | 03-503-028-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-029-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 12024 | 03-503-030-00 | $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-031-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-032-00 $155,200 | $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-033-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-034-00 $161,200 $80,600 $80,600 | | 2024 | 03-503-035-00 | $161,200 $80,600 $80,600 2024 | 03-503-036-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-037-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-038-00 $155,200 $77,600 | $77,600 2024 | 03-503-039-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-040-00 | $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-041-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-042-00 $161,200 $80,600 $80,600 2024 | 03-503-043-00 $161,000 $80,500 $80,500 2024 | 03-503-044-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-045-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-046-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600 2024 | 03-503-047-00 $155,200 $77,600 $77,600
Page 9
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment True Cash Assessed/State Taxable Year | Parcel No. Value Equalized Value Value 2024 | 03-503-053-00 | $160,000 $80,000 $80,000 2024 | 03-503-054-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-055-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 | 2024 | 03-503-056-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-057-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-058-00 $154,200 $717,100 | $77,100 2024 | 03-503-059-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-060-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-061-00 $154,200 $77,100 $77,100 2024 | 03-503-062-00 $160,000 $80,000 $80,000 2025 | 03-502-002-00 $167,600 $83,800 | $80,005 12025 | 03-502-003-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 | 2025 | 03-502-004-00 $167,400 $83,700 $79,902 2025 | 03-502-005-00 | $167,600 IL $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-502-006-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-502-007-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-502-008-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-502-009-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-001-00 | $171,600 $85,800 $81,861 2025 | 03-503-002-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-003-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-004-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-005-00 | $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-006-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 | 2025 | 03-503-007-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-008-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-009-00 | $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-010-00 | $172,800 _ $86,400 $82,480 2025 | 03-503-011-00 $172,800 $86,400 $82,480 | 2025 | 03-503-012-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-013-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-014-00 | $166,600 $83,300 | $79,490 2025 | 03-503-015-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-016-00 $172,800 $86,400 $82,480 2025 | 03-503-017-00 $172,800 $86,400 $82,480 2025 | 03-503-018-00 $166,600 $83,300 | $79,490 2025 | 03-503-019-00 | $166,600 $83,300 $79,490
Page 10
MTT Docket No. 24-003862 Stipulation for Entry of Consent Judgment True Cash Assessed/State Taxable Year | Parcel No. Value | Equalized Value Value 2025 | 03-503-025-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-026-00 $172,800 $86,400 | $82,480 2025 | 03-503-027-00 $174,000 $87,000 $83,098 2025 | 03-503-028-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-029-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 | 2025 | 03-503-030-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-031-00 | $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-032-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-033-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-034-00 $174,000 $87,000 $83,098 2025 | 03-503-035-00 $174,000 $87,000 | $83,098 2025 | 03-503-036-00 | $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-037-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-038-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 | 2025 | 03-503-039-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-040-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-041-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-042-00 $174,000 } $87,000 $83,008 | 2025 | 03-503-043-00 $173,800 $86,900 $82,995 2025 | 03-503-044-00 | $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-045-00 | $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 | 2025 | 03-503-046-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-047-00 $167,600 | $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-048-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-049-00 | $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-050-00 $167,600 $83,800 $80,005 | 2025 | 03-503-051-00 $167,600 | $83,800 $80,005 2025 | 03-503-052-00 $173,800 | $86,900 $82,995 | 2025 | 03-503-053-00 $172,800 $86,400 $82,480 2025 | 03-503-054-00 | $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-055-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-056-00 $166,600 | $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-057-00 | $166,600 $83,300 | $79,490 2025 | 03-503-058-00 | $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 2025 | 03-503-059-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 | 2025 | 03-503-060-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490 | 2025 | 03-503-061-00 $166,600 $83,300 $79,490
Page 11
FloNIGMAN LLIF COSTS ADVANCED ACCOUNT Invoice Date Invoice Number Invoice Narrative 10/20/25 21074678.1 040662 280540/568787/SLM Filing Fee for Stip for CJ (MTT 24- 003862) Payment Amount FxEE5(0,00%** RECEIVED 0CT 20 2025 MICHIGAN TAX TRIBUNAL